15 ms·
Yelp Fired Manager After He Didn't Take Calls, Check Email 24/7, Lawsuit Claims
- nythrowaway 8y agoIn nyc there are Orthodox Jews who work in medicine and finance and law who will not answer the phone or work on the sabbath. These are people who can make millions a year and are otherwise slaves to their jobs working 80 hour+ weeks. They have backups during the day they are off. The jobs they do are much more intense then tech work
- ergothus 8y agoTL;DR: lawsuit claims dude's boss had unreasonable-but-believable demands on availability, yelp denies it. No real information is given as to the up-front understanding of expectation, nor evidence for either side. I'd be interested in the details once everything is decided, but as it stands there just isn't much to do other than speculate....or crack jokes about reviewing Yelp.
- excalibur 8y ago> as it stands there just isn't much to do other than speculate....or crack jokes about reviewing Yelp. Or we could debate the merits of managers and/or company policies requiring "24/7/365" availability, even without enough evidence to make an informed judgment in this particular case. I personally think it's bullshit.
- ergothus 8y agoSure...but is there really a debate? I'm willing to accept a sliver of jobs that require that availability, if they involve saving lives or huge sums of money AND are explicitly agreed to by both parties. Other than some quibbles about if money qualifies and if so how much, I don't really expect a lot of argument - even the jerks demanding such availability without caveats tend to only demand it when they are the boss involved. Edit: Based on the other comments on the story so far...I may be wrong.
- roywiggins 8y agoJust rotate on-call hours around several employees. Putting "lives or huge sums of money" onto one singular employee who must be in contact at all times is a recipe for disaster.
- ergothus 8y agoI was thinking of things like a personal accountant for a mega-millionaire or a doctor on a crisis case...but even then you're right. Even with my qualifier of "sliver" and that I was mentally thinking in time-spans of less than 365 days...yeah. No call.
- jhall1468 8y ago> I'd be interested in the details once everything is decided I'll give you a preview: This is going to settle very quickly. Yelp probably wins the court case, but there's no way they are letting this type of story stay in the press forever.
- doktrin 8y agoAssuming things went down more or less as described, I wouldn't put much stock in Yelps chances should this end up in front of a jury.
- jhall1468 8y agoThey 100% win this. They didn't treat him differently because he's religious, they made him work despite being religious. That's perfectly legal in the US.
- klodolph 8y ago> That's perfectly legal in the US. This is incorrect. This behavior is illegal according to title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It is not enough to treat people “equally”, because it is trivially easy to come up with “equal” but discriminatory requirements. Instead, companies are required to reasonably accommodate the religious observations of their employees, unless there is some compelling reason otherwise.
- jhall1468 8y agoReasonable accommodation doesn't mean the day off and it certainly doesn't mean the day off without requesting it in advance. To be clear, I'm not defending Yelp requiring people to be on email/phone 24/7, but his statement makes it very clear that he never made a request for this. Should he have to? No it's a weekend. But legally they aren't required to. Had he requested, in advance, that he not be contacted on Sunday for religious observation you can bet that would absolutely be public. It'd be a slam dunk case. So yes, it is perfectly legal to email someone on a religious holiday and expect an answer if they didn't request accommodations ahead of time. There's no court in the country that wouldn't call that unreasonable.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tschwimmer 8y agoThe headline is at least somewhat misleading. The plaintiff did not work in software, they seemed to have worked in physical security. It sucks that there was work to be done on a major religious holiday, but it seems reasonable to me that there's an expectation you are 'on-call' outside of normal work hours for a role like that. I'd really like to know what the job expectation was going in.
- reaperducer 8y agoit seems reasonable to me that there's an expectation you are 'on-call' outside of normal work hours 24/7/365 isn't considered "reasonable" outside of the SV bubble. If you need that kind of coverage, you have two or three people available, sometimes on rotation. Even doctors — people who save lives, not tally reviews — aren't on call 24/7/365. No company should have a single employee that essential. Will Yelp shut down if he gets hit by a bus?
- anth_anm 8y agoThat's not reasonable, hire a second person. Unless you're paying the person 24/7. Even then, it's absurd.
- crescentfresh 8y agoAre there certain fields where people are implicitly required to be "on call"? As a software dev (in an oncall rotation) even when I'm not on call I still am expected to check in on things and be available during non-business hours. Same with the IT folk in my company. However, does the CFO have this same requirement? Couldn't there be some financial-related mishap in the middle of the night? HR? What if an employee, say, assaults some other employee off-site in the middle of the night? Sales guys? ie, one of their customers is irate off-hours. The president? I've never bothered to ask.
- michaelt 8y agoit seems reasonable to me that there's an expectation you are 'on-call' outside of normal work hours for a role like that If that's the case, I'm sure the job advert will have said it explicitly and this will be a slam-dunk for Yelp. If it didn't? Well, if the job advert writer didn't know about it, it's hardly reasonable to think applicants would know.
- NoblePublius 8y agoWho would have thought that the company that extorts businesses to bury negative reviews isn’t very nice to work at?
- onemoresoop 8y agoYelp is terrible. They actually extort business to show good reviews as well
- toss1 8y agoIndeed!! Yelp specifically makes me glad that I'm in a B2B sort of business and not subject to their extortionate behavior.
- albertshin 8y agoI always see this claim in Reddit and sensationalist news articles, but I have never seen actual evidence of this. One would think that given the (supposed) frequency of this, an email or phone transcript that lines with this allegation would have leaked or passed on to some media outlet by now?
- time0ut 8y agoThe article says he claims he was fired based on his religion, but it doesn't sound like it was related to religion. It just so happened it was a religious holiday. Maybe there is more to the story, but it sounds like he could just as well have been golfing. Either way, Yelp sounds absolutely toxic if they required him to be available like that. Expecting anyone to be available 24/7/365 is absurd. Set up an on-call rotation. Establish escalation chains. Designate backups. These are basic procedures. If this guy was so critical that there was no-one else in the company that could do whatever it was, hire someone else.
- reaperducer 8y agoit doesn't sound like it was related to religion "Lee also told Weathers, who is pursuing a degree in ministry leadership and has a severely autistic son, that he didn’t care about Weathers’ religious holidays or children, the suit claimed."
- Spivak 8y agoThat's how you wind up with zero sympathy from a potential jury.
- zbentley 8y agoWorkplace discrimination suits are vanishingly unlikely to end up before any sort of jury, at least in the US.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- robbrown451 8y agoBut what a jury would do can still be relevant.
- akerl_ 8y agoDiscrimination would be saying “I’m making you work this weekend because it’s a religious holiday for you”. Saying “I don’t care about your religion and personal circumstances, I demand you work or ill fire you” isn’t discriminating, it’s just shitty.
- azinman2 8y agoMy question is what were the expectations? Did he agree to be on call then? Or did he inform that he wouldn't be available? There's a lot of context missing here...
- root_axis 8y agoIs it really religious discrimination though? It's pretty clear that the plaintiff's boss didn't care why he was incommunicado, only that he was. It doesn't appear that he displayed any religious hostility or intolerance, the outcome would have been the same if the employee was an atheist who decided to spend time with his family on a Sunday.
- Arzh 8y agoYeah I don't think it will get anywhere but that seems to be the only way they can see to fight since (I'm guessing) requiring someone to be on all call at all hours isn't illegal.
- lgeorget 8y agoAs a matter of fact, it is in various countries: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_disconnect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_disconnect. In France it exists since 2001 and had been reinforced by the last labour law. I'm not sure about the actual consequences.
- Arzh 8y agoYeah but this is in America where those laws don't exist, though I wish they did
- aeturnum 8y agoYes, it is. You're correct that any employee who decided to not answer their phone for a period might attract the same displeasure, but we have laws in the US that protect people who are observing religious holidays and he was, in fact, observing one. I guess Yelp could argue that his observation was unreasonably extreme, but that seems unlikely to pass muster.
- everdev 8y ago> we have laws in the US that protect people who are observing religious holidays Do we? From: https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/FAQ_Holidays.htm https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/FAQ_Holidays.htm > California law does not require that an employer provide its employees with paid holidays, that it close its business on any holiday, or that employees be given the day off for any particular holiday
- frankwiles 8y agoWe ALL need to be against 24/7/365 “on call”. I did it for 10 years. It not only sucks, but I’m confident hurt my overall productivity. If it’s not important enough to hire a backup or two, it’s simply not important.
- ams6110 8y agoOne of the advantages of getting older is that you develop some perspective on crap like this. I never check work email at night or on weekends anymore. And I just tell people "no" when they ask me to do work stuff on a weekend. The world continues to turn.
- randycupertino 8y agoI think this is why companies often have a bias towards hiring naive younger workers- they're more likely to be cool with being exploited and haven't established any healthy work/life boundaries yet. I worked somewhere that "specialized" in hiring younger newish grads from the midwest. They'd bring them out to the Bay Area, pay them way under market. The people would put in a year to two years at $75k working 70 hour weeks before they realized it was an intolerable and nonsustainable situation. The younger people were more excited over the free lunch and pingpong tables to care about comp, let alone making rent.
- falcor84 8y ago> The people would put in a year to two years at $75k working 70 hour weeks before they realized it was an intolerable and nonsustainable situation. Indeed unsustainable, but getting that experience and Bay Area connections might quite likely be a rational career choice for these grads
- gnu8 8y agoNegative, those things are external to any employment position and not something an employer is entitled to discount salary against.
- avar 8y agoNo comment on the merits of the case, but the headline is really hiding the ball. Instead of "Manager" they should say "Man Tasked With Granting Out-Of-Hours-Access to Office". I.e. this wasn't just some random manager, but evidently someone they needed to be available to grant out of hours access to their offices.
- barbecue_sauce 8y agoIs there no one to delegate this task to when the employee is unavailable?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- doktrin 8y agoUnless that was his only job function (unlikely), I dont see why the headline should be that granular.
- avar 8y agoBecause it means one of two things. One, Yelp is incompetent enough to make it someone's literal job to open the office in a timely manner at all hours without thinking to have a conversation first that establishes an SLA for that. Two, they did have such an agreement, but the employee is claiming a religious exception supersedes any such agreement. Both would be interesting to discuss, but the article doesn't have any details.
- michaelt 8y agoIf there was an important function that relied on the availability of a single employee, with no bus factor, that rather implies Yelp is incompetent to me.
- doktrin 8y agoarticle != headline I don't disagree that more information is often better than less, but you haven't really made the case for overstuffing the headline. Imagine a potential developer equivalent - "man-tasked-for approving-pull-request" : reads to me like an absurd amount of detail for the title of a general audience news article... even if failing to merge in a PR is 100% the reason said developer was contacted beyond standard office hours in the first place.
- CaliforniaKarl 8y agohttps://outline.com/pHSqZN https://outline.com/pHSqZN
- epx 8y agoMy guess is that religion thing was added to make the case more robust. Unfortunately the meat of the case (having to be on call 247) might be considered "less outrageous" these days :(
- rdtsc 8y agoWhat did his job description say? Did it clearly specify having to be on call 24/7/365. That would be key especially for a position that seems to require that kind of response. Otherwise this is a bit like "unlimited vacation". Yes you can take it, but you never know when they'll come back and say "looks like you're not applying your full potential, so we're gonna go ahead an put you on probation". > Lee also told Weathers [...] that he didn’t care about Weathers’ religious holidays or children, the suit claimed. I think this is mostly about naming and shaming. As the lawsuit could involve a discovery phase, Yelp might want to settle to avoid revealing to the whole world their management "culture".
- titanix2 8y agoEven if it is written on a contract isn't being on call at every seconds of your life against human rights? It seems to be near slavery condition.
- minikites 8y agoWe can thank labor unions for the concept of weekends and the 8-hour workday. The decline in labor union participation tracks with the erosion of the benefits our predecessors fought so hard for.
- cdoxsey 8y agoBeing a backend engineer with occasional on-call responsibilities, this is an unfortunate reality I've had to deal with. My religious tradition (reformed evangelical christian) takes the sabbath pretty seriously, as stated in the Westminster Confession of Faith: > VIII. This Sabbath is to be kept holy unto the Lord when men, after a due preparing of their hearts, and ordering of their common affairs beforehand, do not only observe an holy rest all the day from their own works, words, and thoughts about their worldly employments and recreations, but also are taken up the whole time in the public and private exercises of his worship, and in the duties of necessity and mercy. Notice the last statement makes an allowance for acts of mercy and duties of necessity, which would certainly include things like being a Doctor or a Policeman, but I've always considered my duties as a Software Engineer being on-call to be borderline on whether or not they meet that standard. Certainly my employer(s) have thought they were necessary... But who are we kidding. Most of this stuff isn't life or death and waiting till Monday to get it fixed probably wouldn't be that big of a deal. (I should probably mention that although these are the standards of the Church I attend they're rarely enforced in any meaningful sense - being treated more as a matter of personal conscience than of discipline... and particularly when it comes to the Sabbath) Still I wrestle with it... not having a firm enough conviction to quit a job where I've had to do it, though if it were an every week thing, particularly if I had to regularly miss the Sunday service, I almost certainly would. If I could make one plea, it would be for tolerance and compromise. I realize religious beliefs can be pretty weird in this day and age, but they're often sincerely held, and there's usually a solution available if the company is willing to consider it. (for example I'm just fine being on-call any other day of the week, and a surprising oddity of the reformed tradition, we don't really have religious holidays: https://heidelblog.net/2017/03/the-westminster-divines-on-holy-days/ https://heidelblog.net/2017/03/the-westminster-divines-on-ho...)
- hso1 8y agoI really appreciate people with convictions. I can see that the Sabbath issue is important to you, I'd only like to point out that, if one is to take it seriously, it's important to realize Sabbath is, and always has been, Saturday, the seventh day of the week.
- dev_dull 8y agoThe language from Yelp pretty much spells out their case: > "Yelp respects religious and personal responsibilities and makes reasonable accommodations when requested" (emphasis added) I haven't read any court papers. My guess is their defense will hinge on them trying to prove the plaintiff didn't adequate accommodations. Doesn't pass the smell test if you ask me. If it's important enough to fire somebody over, it's important enough to have a clear escalation strategy in case one person isn't available.
- phonon 8y agoThe case https://imgur.com/a/qp57XAP https://imgur.com/a/qp57XAP COMES NOW PLAINTIFF MARK WEATHERS for causes of action, and alleges as follows: I. ALLEGATIONS 1. Plaintiff Mark Weathers ("Mr. Weathers" or "Plaintiff") resides in California and is a former employee of Defendant Yelp Inc. At all relevant times herein, Mr. Weathers worked for Defendant in San Francisco. 2. Defendant Yelp Inc. ("Yelp" or "Defendant") hosts an online database of user-generated reviews of local businesses and is headquartered in San Francisco, California. 3. The true names and capacities, whether individual, corporate or otherwise, of DOES 1 through 10 are at this time unknown to Plaintiff, who therefore sues* said Defendants by such fictitious names. Plaintiff will ask leave to amend this complaint for damages to reflect their true names and capacities when* the same have been ascertained. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that each of said Defendants is responsible, jointly and severally, for the events and injuries described herein and caused damages thereby as alleged herein. 4. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that at all times mentioned herein each and every co-Defendant was and is the predecessor-in-interest, successor-in-interest, agent, counselor, employee, servant, partner, franchisee and/or joint venturer of each of other co Defendant, and in doing the actions hereinafter mentioned, was and/or is acting within the scope of its authority within such agency, employment, counseling, service, partnership, franchise and/or joint venture or single enterprise, and with the permission and consent of each co-Defendant. Plaintiff alleges that each of said Defendants is responsible, jointly and severally, for the events and injuries described herein and caused damages thereby to Plaintiff as alleged herein. 5. In October of 2016, Yelp offered Mr. Weathers the position of Security Manager starting on November 14, 2016, and reporting to the Head of Security Rick Lee. 6. Mr. Weathers' duties included overseeing several site managers located throughout the country. His compensation included an annual salary, an equity award, a relocation bonus, and a benefits package that included health, dental, vision, life insurance, long term disability, and 401(k). 7. At all times, Mr. Weathers fulfilled the expectations of his . position. In January of 2018, Yelp increased Mr. Weathers' compensation and granted him stock. 8. On Saturday, March 31, 2018, which was Easter weekend, Mr. Lee called Mr. Weathers about an email he had sent the previous night (Good Friday) at 11:49 p.m. Mr. Lee wanted to know why Mr. Weathers had not yet responded to an email. Mr. Weathers indicated that he had not checked his email because it was Easter weekend and he was spending time with his family and attending church services. In fact, Mr. Weathers was attending a church-sponsored event when he answered Mr. Lee's phone call. Mr. Lee was upset that no one, including Mr. Weathers, had responded to an employee's ticket request for after-hours access to Yelp's offices in Phoenix the prior evening after normal business hours. Mr. Lee said Mr. Weathers needed to be responsive, even while he was attending church services. 9. At 12:40 p.m. on Easter Sunday, April 1, while Mr. Weathers was attending church services with his family, Mr. Lee emailed Mr. Weathers and the site managers regarding this situation. He instructed Mr. Weathers to contact each of the site managers to find out what had happened with the ticket request and how to prevent the situation from recurring. He demanded that Mr. Weathers provide an "after action review" to him by the close of business the following day, necessitating that Mr. Weathers contact each of his co-workers on Easter Sunday. In addition, Mr. Lee admonished, "Each leader on this email should make a regular practice of checking email and setting cell phones to take inbound calls 24/7/365 ... so that your phone still rings even if you set it to 'do not disturb' mode." Otherwise, he threatened to "make some changes" if employees could not "commit to being attentive to [their] inbound communiques." 10. On April 2, Mr. Weathers timely provided the information that Mr. Lee had requested. As part of this information, Mr. Weathers explained to Mr. Lee that, "I made a choice to focus on Easter Weekend (Good Friday, Easter Sunday), a very important weekend for me ... I did not check email as I usually would on other weekends." Mr. Lee responded, "You should be checking emails and vmails/inbound calls every day (regardless of weekend or holiday). I understand that church services likely require you to turn off devices. However, a 12-hour gap of non-checking is not acceptable. (Recall that I worked on an incident for 4 hours on Christmas Eve when my personal priority was to be with my family.)" Mr. Lee also verbally told Mr. Weathers, "I don't care about your PTO, religious holidays, your kids or your birthday. I expect a response to my emails." He made this statement despite knowing that Mr. Weathers is a person of faith who is pursuing a degree in ministry leadership and whose son is severely autistic. 11. On April 3, Mr. Weathers approached human resources. He told a human resources representative about the incident that had occurred over Easter weekend, and specifically that Mr. Lee demanded that employees be responsive to work issues even during religious and family commitments. Mr. Weathers also conveyed that his direct reports had expressed concerns about being required to work on Easter Sunday or during paid time off. The human resources representative said she would follow up on this issue. She also suggested that he could include this information as part of his feedback in the manager's survey-a companywide anonymous survey completed by all employees, which he did. 12. On May 15, the day after the manager's survey results were published, Mr. Lee met with Mr. Weathers for their quarterly conversation. During this meeting, for the first time, Mr. Lee was critical of Mr. Weathers performance. He accused Mr. Weathers of needing 'recognition." He said that Mr. Weathers' work on a physical security review the previous month had been disappointing, even though at the time, he commended Mr. Weathers for having done a "great" job. When Mr. Weathers pointed this out, Mr. Lee claimed that his earlier positive feedback had been a "miscommunication." Mr. Lee also said that there had been a "ranking meeting" in February of 2018, and that he and Yelp's CFO had ranked Mr. Weathers as "third or fourth" in ''performance and potential." He never mentioned before that such a meeting had taken place, or that supposedly there were issues with Mr. Weathers' performance or career potential. In fact, Mr. Lee previously had been complimentary of Mr. Weathers' performance and told him that the CFO had praised Mr. Weathers for having a "growth mindset." Finally, Mr. Lee said that he did not like Mr. Weathers' response to the situation that had occurred over Easter Weekend-in which Mr. Weathers stated, "I made a choice to focus on Easter Weekend (Good Friday, Easter Sunday), a very important weekend for me ... I did not check email as I usually would on other weekends"-and reiterated that he was not concerned about Mr. Weathers' ::hurch or family obligations. 13. After this meeting, Mr. Lee all but stopped communicating with VJr. Weathers and sidelined Mr. Weathers from participating in work matters. 14. On May 25, 2018, Mr. Lee and the* human resources *epresentative met with Mr. Weathers. Mr. Lee advised Mr. Weathers that he Nas "not a good fit for this role" and presented him with three options: a performance plan, one month's severance, or termination. Mr. Weathers pointed out that Mr. Lee had previously told Mr. Weathers that "people do not survive [performance plans]." In fact, Mr. Lee said this on numerous occasions about various employees. Mr. Weathers pointed out that, in light of this, a performance improvement plan did not seem like a viable option. 15. On May 29, the human resources representative told Mr. Weathers that the company was "concerned" about how Mr. Lee had managed the situation and, therefore, would be investigating whether there was retaliation. She interviewed Mr. Weathers over the next few days, including about Mr. Lee's statements that Mr. Weathers and other employees are required to work during paid time off and regardless of church or family obligations. 16. On May 31, 2018, the human resources representative told Mr. Weathers that she had "looked into" the situation but supposedly determined that Mr. Lee had not said anything illegal. 17. On June 4, 2018, the human resources representative sent Mr. Weathers a meeting request and said that Mr. Lee wanted to present Mr. Weathers with a list of performance issues. Mr. Weathers asked for a copy of the list in advance, so that he could be prepared for their meeting, but no one provided him with a copy. 18. Instead, on June 5, when Mr. Weathers met with the human resources representative, she told him that given the "toxic environment," "it would be better" for Mr. Weathers to leave his employment at Yelp. Yelp terminated Mr. Weathers from his employment effective June 5, 2018. 19. Plaintiff timely exhausted his administrative remedies by filing a :harge of discrimination with the Department of Fair Employment and Housing and obtaining a right to sue. 20. Defendant's actions were undertaken for improper purposes as alleged above and were willful, oppressive and in conscious disregard of Plaintiff's rights, and were designed and intended to cause and did, in fact, cause Plaintiff to suffer severe emotional distress, pain and suffering, and substantial economic damage and, therefore, justify the awarding of exemplary and punitive damages.
- DevX101 8y agoForgetting the merits of the suit for a minute, if Yelp really needed 24/7 access, why not hire another security manager to work nights? If his job is so mission critical do you really want to risk him not being able to wake up at 3am in the morning from a phonecall?
- sdinsn 8y ago> why not hire another security manager to work nights Money
- meritt 8y agoIf the lawsuit fails he could always create a employer review site, post a bunch of negative reviews of Yelp, and then offer to remove the offending reviews if they purchase an annual subscription.
- randycupertino 8y agoSooo.... Glassdoor?
- badfrog 8y agoIs there evidence of Glassdoor charging companies to get better reviews?
- straw_man 8y agothey absolutely promote positive reviews ahead of negative reviews but i don't know if that's a paid service
- calvinbhai 8y agoI personally know that Glassdoor magically vanished my not so critical review of my past employer (I said nice things about the company and employees, but called out how they mislead/screwed me in immigration matters)
- bsg75 8y ago> On Good Friday last March, Weathers’ boss, head of security Rick Lee, sent him an email about an employee in Yelp’s Phoenix offices seeking after-hours access to a building, the suit said. Expecting employees to respond to non-emergencies off hours is an excellent way to get them to become less responsive. When everything is urgent, nothing is.
- nartz 8y agoI like the yelp service - but working for yelp has always seemed like a terrible idea.
- sjg007 8y agoYelp will lose this lawsuit and this is a PR nightmare.
- wyclif 8y agoYelp seems like a super toxic workplace and essentially a pay-to-play extortion racket.
- stuart78 8y agoPosts like this make me want to remind people that there ARE good places to work. If you’re stuck in this kind of BS, there ARE alternatives. Just like relationships, there are many job fish in the sea, so don’t get discouraged, just find a way out.
- thatoneuser 8y agoThe problem is finding them. The job search sites are trash as far as being a competent mediator to make the hiring process smoother. And companies are way too standoffish to hire quickly. It's a frustrating process.
- kokokokoko 8y agoWe should all spend a moment to really take in the fact that Yelp is a website that has reviews of restaraunts and other services. That this person needed to be on call 24/7 for a review website. Not a hospital. Nothing was burning down. Not even transportation or infrastructure related. A review website. 24/7/365. For a review website.
- mikeash 8y agoIt’s a big site, so any downtime is a lot of lost revenue. I’m sure the cost of 24/7/365 coverage is justified. The trouble is that they apparently don’t want to pay for actual 24/7 coverage with a defined on-call schedule. They just try to declare it into existence.
- jka 8y agoI think you're sending this same message, but just to rephrase it - 24/7 coverage is important to the business due to the continuous traffic they receive, but 24/7 coverage has to be provided by multiple people and/or teams; it shouldn't and can't be an individual responsibility.
- mikeash 8y agoThat is indeed what I was implying, but it’s good to state it explicitly.
- blazespin 8y agoMadness. Hire shift workers. Geezus. And don’t fire, manage them out with a pip. Does it take a long time? Sure! But thats what you get for having stupid policies.
- scarejunba 8y agoThe engineer who wanted access is going to feel like a right idiot.
- jqcoffey 8y agoI am the manager of a decent sized R&D org in a company on the order of Yelp’s size and not only do I find this inexcusable on Yelp’s part, but where I work we would put the firing manager into a training/coaching program to sensitize him to the work life balance needs of his team. If he refused he would probably be removed as a manager and perhaps shown the door. I work for large adtech company in France and out here oncall is paid (even if you’re not called) and we never intrude on personal time unless there is a major disaster, and even then there are almost always enough folks being paid to handle the oncall event to take care of things. We do have R&D offices in the US and I don’t know the specifics of HR policy wrt oncall there, but everyone rolls up to the French HQ so I know it remains human-first.
- SN76477 8y agoAnd companies wonder why their employees try to unionize.
- heelix 8y agoTrue 24/7 can be really disruptive. I've had consulting gigs where some people would rather call me at 3AM then talk with the person next to them in the Ops room. Irritating as all can be, having a sleep schedule disrupted. Same customer ended up having you come in for a normal work day, cater supper, have you do evening deployments/change control/bug fix, then the late night/early AM stuff on prod would start till 5/6AM. You could possibly grab a couple hours of sleep before starting the 'normal' next day - but it was easier to just pound through a 32 hour day and then collapse on the airplane home. Nothing productive happened from those long days. Just like water skiing, more and more mistakes happen the longer a person is at it.
- rpmcmurphy 8y agoI take the approach of telling people to call or text me if something is urgent (my number is in the company directory), because I likely won't notice an email quickly, and will ignore Slack/IM completely so soon as I walk out the door. The only time my phone buzzes is when something is actually on fire. I remember previous jobs where late night emails demanding edits to someone's slide deck were routine (and anything is not urgent, it is editing some product manager's slide deck). That shit can wait until Monday, and if you are throwing it on me because you procrastinated, that's your problem.