5 ms·
Kató Lomb
- 52-6F-62 8y agoHeh. One of her methods for learning a new language sounded very familiar. > Even she was bored with the fabricated dialogues of coursebooks, so her favourite method was to obtain an original novel in a language completely unknown to her, whose topic she personally found interesting (a detective story, a love story, or even a technical description would do), and that was how she deciphered, unravelled the basics of the language: the essence of the grammar and the most important words. She didn't let herself be set back by rare or complicated expressions: she skipped them, saying: what is important will sooner or later emerge again and will explain itself if necessary. Certainly sounds like my experience reading some code. Moreover, the more familiar you are with the language itself, the more transparent different dialects become. (Makes me wonder if she could understand Scots) As well— the growing ability to read and generally understand some code in a language unfamiliar. IE, for a C expert, D or JavaScript is probably intelligible enough to understand what the program is intended to accomplish, even if there are parts of the code or syntax that are less intelligible. I'm sure that's been written about enough by now. edit: grammar
- meddlin 8y agoIt's interesting you draw this parallel; I've pondered the same for a while now. After programming for several years, I wonder how I would fare trying to pick up a second spoken language using similar tactics to learning a programming language.
- kurtisc 8y agoThe only carry-over I've had is a faster understanding of concepts like noun phrases acting similarly to parsing expressions.
- 52-6F-62 8y agoI've wondered that as well but approach the subject with much more apprehension. With programming languages I just get it set up and blow things up until I get something to work, and carry on. Largely out of impatience and moxy. No fear! Then again I don't just hop into writing memory allocators. Similarly I suppose her first experience with a language isn't to attempt to translate at the UN. It's also more fun that way. It sounds like she had a similar attitude with written languages.
- kd5bjo 8y agoI’m in the middle of this process right now, actually. My programming background has helped a lot with the written language— using dictionaries and grammar references to write sentences is very similar to writing code in a new language by referring to its manual. The transfer to speaking and listening is much less pronounced, as my brain hasn’t fully realized that the spoken and written languages are the same.
- scj 8y agoThe barrier I've noticed when switching from reading to listening, is adapting to native accents. I suppose real-time vs. at my own pace is another aspect that comes into play.
- wallflower 8y agoReading is always easier than listening because you can control the rate while reading. With a live conversation partner, you cannot do that yet, until we have accurate, real-time subtitling, perhaps with AR. The hack is to find video material that has exact or near exact subtitles in your target language. By using a short, repeatable video, you will be able to associate sounds with the words, not the other way around. Since spoken language is sounds, you have to start with the sounds. It can be easy to get frustrated as it is a process of repeated listening. For that reason, choose something you like.
- rkapsoro 8y agoThis seems very much consistent with the Input Hypothesis of language acquisition. Here's a good introduction to the idea: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J_EQDtpYSNM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J_EQDtpYSNM Edit: Just realized that the originator of that theory, Stephen Krashen, actually got to meet her. Fascinating!
- Sharlin 8y agoThis immediately brought to mind ”The Atomic Bomb Considered as Hungarian High School Science Fair Project” [1]. Would be interesting to know if Lomb had any Ashkenazi heritage. [1] https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/05/26/the-atomic-bomb-considered-as-hungarian-high-school-science-fair-project/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/05/26/the-atomic-bomb-consid...
- p1esk 8y agoShe also managed to get a phd in chemistry!
- g3ph4z 8y agobojler eladó
- mnyary 8y ago:)
- andrewshadura 8y agomennyibe kerül? :)
- g3ph4z 8y agoegy kormányváltásba
- andrewshadura 8y agonagyon drága
- aries1980 8y agoa létige smafu? ;)
- asteli 8y agoThere's a formula in there that reads: Invested Time x Motivation -------------------------- = Results Inhibition As an engineer without formal education, this rings very true. When people ask "how'd you get into this?" typically my answer includes the phrase "interest times time." The inclusion of inhibition in the formula crystalizes something I've been feeling for a long time.
- miobrien 8y agoThis formula is fascinating. Sums up what I've read on expertise by K. Anders Ericsson. Inhibition is what makes this unique and I think traditional education could benefit from acknowledging the role of inhibition in learning.
- munificent 8y agoThis resonated with me too. In particular, one of the things that's always made software approachable to me is that my failures are hidden on my machine where no one can see them, so I have almost no inhibition. Learning any skill that requires social interaction is much harder for me because then all of my social anxieties and fear of failure kick in. I would love to learn a second language, and this is the main thing holding me back. I think I have the right mental skills to put the time in and wrap my head around it, I just break out in a cold sweat when I imagine horribly mispronouncing something in front of a native speaker.
- jnurmine 8y agoMispronunciation is no big deal! That is just one dimension in a language and one which gets better over time and immersion. If you wish to avoid the social aspects completely, how about starting with practising to only read a language? There are plenty of newspapers and other material to study and it helps to be able to figure out what is said from the context. It will involve some guesswork but it keeps your brain thinking. With context I mean that any big piece of news is likely to appear also in the news written in a language you already know, so you can cross-reference and figure out unknown words.
- lordnacho 8y agoA friend of mine is a translator, and similarly "earns money with" over a dozen languages. Apparently once you've learned a few it gets a lot easier. It's kinda fascinating that someone can learn so many languages. My own experience with it is a it more organic and less deliberate, but I find similar things. Once there's a sort of logic to each language that you've acquired it gets easier to learn stuff, the holes kinda fill themselves. I've never reached full confidence -say enough to do a degree in a non-language course- in all my languages but a couple, but there's enough to build on for most of them, and a lot of everyday stuff is okay. I also don't beat myself up over grammatical issues like keeping loads of gender/subject/etc agreements. On the software side it's maybe similar. You can group languages by various traits like declarative/imperative, GC/manual, static/dynamic types, and a few others. So that allows you to in gross terms translate a program from one language to another, but it's not quite the same as knowing a language inside out so that you fully use all the useful features.
- yesenadam 8y agoI merely speak English and have been learning Spanish. (Enough so that using capital letters for languages seems soo weird to me now!) In doing so, I've learned at least as much about English and Latin. I wish I'd set out to learn the other Romance languages at the same time[0], as learning one sheds so much light on the others. e.g. in French, most words are recognizable as either similar to their English or Spanish/Latin equivalents. And the verb structure (the hardest thing about learning Spanish, although it almost seems natural to me now) is very similar in all Romance languages. ('Je sais' may look very different to 'yo sé', but (in some spanish-speaking regions at least) they're pronounced almost identically. In spanish you usually don't say 'yo' because the verb endings tells you who, but in French enough of the different endings have become the same that you do always have to say who.) Romanian looks crazy with all the words ending in -u, but all those words ending in -o in spanish came from Latin nouns ending in -um; the -m was gradually dropped, and -u became -o. (I can kind of read Portuguese - it's like Spanish with extremely bad spelling - or vice versa.) I made a page a few years ago comparing common words, verbs etc in those languages http://www.adamponting.com/romance-languages/ http://www.adamponting.com/romance-languages/ [0] Well, maybe not - getting on top of one Romance verb system was enough, it seemed soooo weird and complicated in the beginning. Although I'm still a novice at using the subjunctive.