4 ms·
How often do people get promoted on the basis that they will make the team better? Have you ever heard of that? How often do you hear "the IT guys kept things r
by lordnacho 8y ago
How often do people get promoted on the basis that they will make the team better? Have you ever heard of that? How often do you hear "the IT guys kept things running well, enabling the sales people to bring the money in, so they get a piece of that?"
Most of the time people who get stuff are the ones who have been attributed the most output individually.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThat depends on the management and is part of what makes a good manager. I have heard of many accounts of successful and well liked technical managers admitting their job is to be a shield to their team/abstraction layer to allow them ability to focus and explore appropriately while not being buffeted by contradictory direct commands and meetings - all while not ignoring them unduly either. Upper management was perfectly okay with that because they had good release quality and time tables.
- stnmtn 8y agoBut how often do people who do the work that brings in money (in this example, the people coding the project) get a fair share of that profit?
- chooseaname 8y agoDefine "fair". Surely the CEO is worth 800 times what any single coder is.
- vondur 8y agoI think you forgot the sarcasm tags.
- chooseaname 8y agoSometimes it's fun to leave things a little ambiguous. But, yeah, you figured it out.
- tomp 8y agoRight, that's a single company's management system, but our economic system selects for best companies == groups of people. So, no, the point was completely wrong.
- chimprich 8y agoIf you consider the hens in the analogy to be companies (rather than people) I think it holds. We select for companies that can outcompete other companies rather than ones that contribute the most to the system.
- zeveb 8y ago> If you consider the hens in the analogy to be companies (rather than people) I think it holds. If you consider a fern to be an alligator then it's an example of a deadly reptile. > We select for companies that can outcompete other companies rather than ones that contribute the most to the system. I think that the whole point of our system is to ensure that firms which outcompete other firms are the ones which contribute the most total value to the system. Where this isn;t the case (e.g. as with the effects of mass advertising, monopolies &c.) it's a bug, not a feature — and should be adjusted for.
- mirimir 8y agoI've played a minor support role in numerous fraud and antitrust lawsuits. Although experts and counsel said a great deal about economic and social welfare, the key evidence involved what people intended and planned (based on documents, email, etc) and what they did (based on business records). Determining which firms "contribute the most total value to the system" is just too hard to be a useful strategy. Translating that back to the workplace, I'm more inclined to agree with TFA.
- zeveb 8y ago> Determining which firms "contribute the most total value to the system" is just too hard to be a useful strategy. Yes, it is — which is why we have a free market instead of a central authority trying to determine who contributes the most. Wisdom of crowds & all that.
- FakeComments 8y agoMy point was not that this happens as often as it should, but rather that the system we use now is built around the recognition that it’s important to do so, and consistently produces the most of that kind of result out of any of our systems. That is, if you look at market based systems against the others, in practice, they have the most people who end up wealthy due to merit — and why McDolands is one of the largest minters of “minority” millionaires ever. This is important, because it implies the solution to our problems with the present is not to throw it out for a system that does worse asymptotically (eg, swap capitalism for socialism), but rather to further optimize and refine capitalism.
- nieve 8y agoThis mindset can spread to higher levels if it's allowed to. At one point during the dot-com bubble the company I worked for was acquired by one where ad sales and biz dev were granted credit for all income and everything else in the company was considered a loss. This was a _financial media_ company and without fresh content the entire thing would have keeled over immediately, but via appearing to hold the purse things had slid to the point that ads and business development had power over almost all decisions. They bought us because they were trying to move into premium subscription products like we did, but we didn't know how bad it was until we found out that every dollar we brought in was attributed to the business development group and on paper our entire subsidiary was a money hole. From individual employees up to the C-level divisions they judged everything solely on what was easiest to put into a spreadsheet and it destroyed them in less than a year. Sad to say my hope they were unique was wildly optimistic.