13 ms·
20th Century Fox Uses ML to Predict a Movie Audience
- everdev 8y ago> The top audiences for Logan were actually a combination of superhero (which we already knew) and “rugged male action lead” (which we didn’t know with certainty). This can be better seen by noting that key “rugged male action lead” predictions like The Magnificent Seven (in blue above), John Wick (in green above) and Terminator Genisys (in blue above) were also present in the top 20 list of actual audiences. This result is a win-win because the new audience “adds” to the core superhero audience, and can potentially be used to extend the reach of the movie beyond that core audience. I wish they'd include saturation and release dates as factors as I'm sure releasing a new rugged make lead superhero movie every week would have diminishing returns at some point.
- msla 8y ago> I wish they'd include saturation and release dates as factors as I'm sure releasing a new rugged make lead superhero movie every week would have diminishing returns at some point. Hollywood has seemed... constrained from noticing this.
- sametmax 8y agoNope, it just financially works so why do otherwise. People still pay no mater how many bad movies they got fed with.
- duado 8y agoThose diminishing returns haven’t seemed to happen yet. What is it this year... Avengers vs. Batman?
- setr 8y agoThose aren’t “rugged” male leads
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 8y agoI guess the ML doesn't read the news, as there was a recent release stating that movies with strong female leads make more money [0]. Seems like the ML would figure that out, and lean heavily against 'rugged male action lead' dominate movies. [0]https://www.bbc.com/news/business-46539473 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-46539473
- hmate9 8y agoOne of the reasons why there are so many sequels and less unoriginal movies from big studios. Big franchise names almost always perform according to expectations, even if the movie is bad.
- basch 8y agoIt's actually fairly rare for an animated sequel to outperform the original. https://filmrust.com/2019/02/12/where-lego-2-went-wrong-an-50-movie-analysis-of-the-best-and-worst-times-to-make-an-animated-sequel/ https://filmrust.com/2019/02/12/where-lego-2-went-wrong-an-5... Incredibles 2, Shrek 2, Spongebob 2, and Despicable Me 2 were really the only ones worth making, vs gambling on a new property.
- michaelt 8y agoA moderately successful sequel to a highly successful original could underperform that original, but still outperform the average original. If "Kung Fu Panda 1" makes $273 million and "Kung Fu Panda 2" makes $187 million that's lower - but higher than "Pokemon: The First Movie" which only made $153 million.
- madebylaw 8y agoMaybe domestically? Toy Story 2, Monsters University, and I'm sure others outperformed the original when you compare their global box office numbers. https://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?id=monstersinc2.htm https://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?id=monstersinc2.htm (nb foreign BO is 64% of the haul).
- rexreed 8y agoThere was a great AI Today Podcast interview with 20th Century Fox CTO Hanno Basse on how AI is being used quite intensely in the entertainment industry: https://www.cognilytica.com/2018/11/07/ai-today-podcast-62-ai-in-the-entertainment-industry-interview-with-hanno-basse-cto-20th-century-fox/ https://www.cognilytica.com/2018/11/07/ai-today-podcast-62-a...
- yborg 8y ago> When combined with historical customer data, sequencing analysis can be used to create predictions of customer behavior. When not combined with sequencing analysis, historical customer data can be used to create predictions of customer behavior. It watches movies and does classification which all studios do anyway for decades on everything they and their competitors produce. I'm not really seeing the value add here apart from having a "data science" team to excuse your flops.
- freediver 8y ago"Success in the movie industry relies on a studio’s ability to attract moviegoers—but that’s sometimes easier said than done" No it isn't. Just make a good movie. Forrest Gump didn't need any machine learning. The only reason someone might use this is when your strategy is "spray and pray", create crappy movies that insult everyone's intelligence and you need to figure out is it worth launching at all.
- yodon 8y agoAs with most simple recipies "just make a good movie" is unfortunately neither sufficient nor always the best path. Word of mouth on movies is far more likely to have a negative impact on theater going decisions than positive impact (if your friend says it sucks, you are far more likely to switch from go to no go than you would be to switch from no go to go if the same friend said it was awesome). In practice, what this means is that because positive word of mouth is so minimally impactful studios need to focus on high marketing value films rather than high story value films, because high marketing value films cause potential audience members to see a trailer or an ad and say "I'll totally go see that!" Yes, negative word of mouth can and will reduce the number who actually go see it, but final viewership is higher if you start with a huge population saying "I'll totally see that" than if you start with a "meh" response to the initial ads and try to grow viewership through word of mouth about how awesome your film is. Given these observations, Hollywood has made the rationally and financially correct but unfortunate for audiences decision to focus on marketability over enjoyability. These economics are quite different for entertainment as a service providers like HBO and Netflix, with the obvious results in quality of output.
- smichel17 8y agoThe alternative is to build up a reputation, so when a new $studio film comes out, people are excited about it because $studio has a history of making good films. I think Pixar is/was a good example of this.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoEvery studio that has focus on children is smart marketing. Children > parents. If you are a parent, don't you go to a child friendly restaurant that is reasonable good instead of one that is very good but not child-friendly.
- selflesssieve 8y agoI bet this is one example of many on how they use ML. This is probably their least capable predictor- but a good example to signal that 20th Century Fox has entered the 21st Century.
- qntty 8y agoI guess 20th Century Fox Uses Statistics to Predict a Movie Audience doesn't have the same ring to it.
- natalyarostova 8y agoLol. Well, you see, there are so many complex non-linearities here that it wasn't possible until they could use a 20 layer deep neural net /s
- dylan604 8y agoBut I bet the 21st Century Fox could do it better.
- neves 8y agoNow every 20th Century Fox movie will be full of violence and sex. Ops, It looks like the ML is already in production!
- JackFr 8y agoHere's an orthogonal idea which would make a great project - scrape IMDB for all creative roles in the credits - actors, directors, writers, set designers, make up, music, etc. -- all of them. Regress them against budget, revenue, margin and revenue/budget. Importantly it would allow for groundbreaking and genre bending movies to be assessed. See who's adding value and who's not. And see how well that predicts your outcome.
- selflesssieve 8y agoWith enough orthogonal ideas you'll have a well rounded approach. Why would 20th Century Fox advertise their best idea?
- Krasnol 8y agoSo now we get even more of the same but machine certified?
- yodon 8y agoFor those interested in the economic factors driving media production and distribution, Matthew Ball [0] is a great analyst to follow. [0] https://redef.com/author/56d1e0f14f16158e36008235 https://redef.com/author/56d1e0f14f16158e36008235
- nimbius 8y agoSix terminators, Seven transformers, eleven Madea films, and nine aliens films. If the strategy is to waterboard us with progressively more pointless sequels, no ML in the world is going to improve the outcome when the writers have clearly checked out.
- dylan604 8y agoWhy the need for a writer? The ML should be able to produce scripts of equal quality.
- zuck9 8y agoI would love to feed GPT2 with movie scripts when it's completely open source.
- thedoctor79 8y agoWhy the need for actors? The ML could be trained on millions of hours of existing movies and produce fake, convincing personas. Why the need for spectators? The ML could analyse the movies and produce fake, convincing reviews.
- sametmax 8y agoThey'll make money anyway. People will pay to watch those, so they have no incentive to do otherwise. Like with every product that people refuse to go without no matter the quality.
- Phenomenit 8y agoYeah, it feels like a little kick of novelty is way better than not going to the movies at all.
- dudul 8y agoAt least these are "sequels". Reboots are even worse in my book.
- 8y ago
- duxup 8y agoI'm a bit disappointed they didn't use some old movie terms ... maybe it's in the code such as a "LEGS quotient". They used to ask if a movie "had legs" because legs puts butts in seats.
- fuddle 8y agoJJ Espinoza goes into detail about the system on the twimlai podcast - https://twimlai.com/twiml-talk-220-building-a-recommender-system-from-scratch-at-20th-century-fox-with-jj-espinoza/ https://twimlai.com/twiml-talk-220-building-a-recommender-sy...
- gerardnll 8y agoTired that (machine learning) suggestions in Amazon, Youtube, Instagram and other sites mean showing me more of the same. Is this the fabulous AI revolution? Yes, I like photos of food, but I can also enjoy other types of photos and until I don't start searching for them, Instagram (or whatever service) doesn't list them. What a great AI! This is like that article that talked about increasing extremist political videos being recommended depending on your views habits (Youtube). I understand, no data can create predictions. But tastes are so depending of the context you grow up in that it is normal not to be able to predict that. And that uniqueness is what makes a person great.
- crooked-v 8y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/kibblesmith/status/724817086309142529 https://mobile.twitter.com/kibblesmith/status/72481708630914...
- chrismaltby 8y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/chethaase/status/925715289244819458?lang=en https://mobile.twitter.com/chethaase/status/9257152892448194...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- borroka 8y agoNetflix is doing this at scale for all the content that it is on its platform, where the audience is the number of Netflix member that have watched (or will watch) a tv show, movie etc. There are limits of predictions that are reached quite fast. For example, how much money you spend on the production for an original show is the best predictor of the audience (more money spent means more promising plot and actors and directors, more marketing and so on). All the fancy AI, Deep whatever are largely irrelevant and a waste of time and money, but can be sold very well internally and externally, at least for a few more years.
- josteink 8y agoI know I’m not the average movie-goer, but I strongly prefer to see movies at either end of the spectrum: really bad or really good. Those are usually experiences I can fully immerse into and enjoy. Anything in between (I.e. mediocre) does nothing for me, no matter how well produced or marketed it is or how many hundred millions it cost to make. It’s just gonna be a dud. Most movies made to please the most people end up here: high budget, great looking, but mediocre, predictable and utterly boring. To me, using ML to optimize movie audience targets sounds like something which will make a bad situation even worse. I guess cinema as an art form is truly dead. Edit: This news seems to confirm a claim made by screenwriter Max Landis[1] in a RLM podcast: Hollywood used to have a recipe for making “successful” (i.e. profitable) movies, but these days none of the recipes work anymore and they are desperate, feeling blinded, and as a result being even more risk-averse in their productions. This definitely sounds like a desperate move. [1] https://youtu.be/DR-Dry8Qb4A https://youtu.be/DR-Dry8Qb4A
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Phenomenit 8y agoAgreed, every movie I've been to for the last 2-3 years have been boring not terrible, just utterly boring and a waste of time and money. Compared to other mainstream art forms, movies have a higher barrier of entry and that translates in to smaller influx of new and interesting concepts.
- Stunting 8y agoThen you are going to the wrong movies friend. Which is to say, you are victim to assuming the mega complex Movie Theater, powered by the mega complex of Studios pumping out advertisements are the only option available to you. If cinema is a desirable experience to you, seek out film colleges, independent theaters, movie rental spots, and YouTube/Vimeo/reddit. You’ll find a bunch of crap, for sure, but it will be new and interesting crap. You’ll explore your own mind trying to define why you don’t like it. Eventually you’ll see something truly moving and that will be amazing! Or, If you justly say “I don’t have time or energy for something I’m not that passionate about,” continue to go to the AMCs. Just recognize, much like McDonald’s they (and the studios) have massive overhead and massive interest in not losing money. No one takes the person complaining that McD’s isn’t gourmet very seriously. (The most moving zombie movie I ever saw was 15mins on YouTube and had 3 zombies in it..)
- blibble 8y agogoogle built the awesom-o 4000? we're going to be getting a lot more adam sandler movies
- jedberg 8y agoNetflix has been doing this for years. It's one of the inputs into how much to pay to license a film or TV shows (but to be clear not the only input, at the end of the day it's the buyer's gut instincts that determine what to buy at what price, but the AI is a tool to help them make that decision).
- bluetwo 8y agoWhy wait for a movie to be produced before running ML on it to predict audience? Why not just run it on SCRIPTS to see which to produce? :-)
- danmg 8y agoThis is the reason 90% of their budget goes to comic book franchise movies. I guess it also helps that the simple-formulaic plots translate easy and rarely delve into any social issues that foreign (e.g., PRC) censors would find objectionable.
- moocowtruck 8y agois this why everyone makes shitty movies these days?
- dschuetz 8y agoAnd this is going to ruin the current movie industry if it gets any traction. Now that technology is highly available to everyone, this is going to cause two major streams of movie making - industrial/predicted and independent/auteur. Those exist already of course, but indie is a niche. Guess who is going to remain in business if the movie industry collapses?
- wolco 8y agoThe indie lives if the industry dies. The industry will not die but it may evolve.
- TrevorAustin 8y agoA data science consultancy I used to work at did box office predictions for a major movie studio, and the fanciest techniques you could dream up gave only a slight lift over the https://www.hsx.com/ https://www.hsx.com/ prediction market, which provided the overwhelming majority of the model's predictive power.
- commandlinefan 8y agoThis strikes me as being classically anti-inductive: if they figure out the "formula" for a successful movie, the formula will become useless as soon as they try to apply it.
- opportune 8y agoif you apply machine learning to a creative effort you will only continue to imitate what has already been done
- anth_anm 8y agoUsing ML to speed up the process of making bland blockbusters!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dewaine 8y agoWow I didn't know you needed ML to decide to copy what disney and marvel are doing
- tokyodude 8y agoMaybe someone here remembers the name but I read a short SciFi story about someone who edited a mediocre movie into an amazing movie, posted it online, got tons of hits, was offered a job by the movie company. When she arrived it turned out they wanted her to be part of an audience of people with good taste. Some AI made the movies, they'd play them to the audience with tracking equipment on their heads. The AI would use the info to adjust the movie. Their memories of having watched the movie would then be erased. Repeat several thousand times until all readings are high. Release movie.