7 ms·
My Underground Warfare Wish List
- justtopost 8y agoHalf of these seem poorly thought out, and this seems poorly written for someone of that position. For instance, #3 blinding lights, is easily mitigated by #2 non-ambient/thermal vision. #4, sound weapons are going to effect everyone in the tunnel, so offense is limited. #10 foam grenades, are less effective for concealment, and ineffective as cover, most outgas toxic and flamable vocs. Existing procedure of collapsing tunnel has neither downside and accomplished with existing, legacy, and improvised tech. I won't even touch on headlamps, and insisting on an actual live canary.
- regularfry 8y agoThe underlying assumption is presumably that if you're on the side with non-ambient vision gear, you're also the only side with the blinding lights.
- zeveb 8y ago> For instance, #3 blinding lights, is easily mitigated by #2 non-ambient/thermal vision. No, because you need to use your susceptible-to-blinding eyes to use the thermal-vision system. Also, of course, the fact that I have blinding & thermal-vision systems doesn't mean that my foe does. > #4, sound weapons are going to effect everyone in the tunnel, so offense is limited. That's true in general of acoustic weapons. Presumably if they can be made directional above-ground they might be made directional below-ground — or they could be treated as acoustic 'grenades,' in that they are deployed prior to ingress. > #10 foam grenades, are less effective for concealment, and ineffective as cover, most outgas toxic and flamable vocs. Existing procedure of collapsing tunnel has neither downside and accomplished with existing, legacy, and improvised tech. A small amount of slightly-carcinogenic gas beats getting shot. Sealing off a tunnel connected to the one I'm in seems far preferable to collapsing it and possibly my own. It also could make rescuing civilians who've taken shelter in the tunnel system more possible. > I won't even touch on headlamps, and insisting on an actual live canary. I'd trust an actual live animal a lot more than I would some lowest-bidder system.
- potta_coffee 8y agoFoam grenade would be small, how much foam could such a grenade conceivable deliver? Probably not enough to do anything.
- emj 8y agoTo fill a door with foam you would need at least 20 liters of ABfoam liquid, not an impossible concept.
- arcaster 8y agoIR reflective rope / tag-line seems novel enough. Also seems like a ballistic foam "munition" could also likely work. Some of these ideas are half-baked but interesting nonetheless.
- AtlasBarfed 8y agoI CANNOT believe this list does not include automapping via AR or other means.
- jspencer508 8y agoFor sure one of the biggest needs. I did link to the DARPA project working on that now. I just didn't add it to my list because it is being worked on so aggressively.
- Junk_Collector 8y agoNearly everything on your list already exists and much is in limited use by the military already. I think you missed the biggest item you missed is good hearing protection and sound suppression. In enclosed spaces all the normal issues with loud noises (i.e. guns and explosives) are massively magnified. In fact, it would be terrible to bring a dog much less a canary into this environment.
- Opportunity007 8y agoCan confirm, we were always told to keep our mouths slightly open when setting off charged explosives or grenades. We were told that the overpressure could rupture our eardrums if we didn’t. Good hearing pro is a must
- simonh 8y agoThat would be nice, but AR needs precise positioning information, and GPS doesn’t work very well underground. It’s also likely to need good long range communications, and ditto.
- shove 8y agoLove to fantasize about even more war toys which will of course only be used to “spread democracy” etc etc and obviously will never make their way into the hands of racist domestic police forces to use on activists once they’re on sale as military surplus. Very legal and very cool.
- lainga 8y agoWell, I'm not sure why you're bringing up their legality. Are you talking about the Geneva Conventions? with respect to the blinding lights?
- Tronno 8y agoHe is ironically quoting the POTUS: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/very-legal-and-very-cool https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/very-legal-and-very-cool
- lainga 8y agoWell, please, don't do that, or assume bad faith, it's counter-guidelines. On the actual topic at hand, even assuming this technology finds its way into the hands of police forces (racism or not), what's the use case? People hiding in sewers and drainage pipes? Natural cave systems? Underground mall networks in urban environments? The item with the most potential for invasion of privacy in the article is the ground-penetrating radar (when pointed sideways at houses), but that has already been around for a few years, and there is both literature and case law on police using radar in that capacity.
- shove 8y agoIt’ll be used to clear homeless out of underground / tight urban spaces just for starters
- shove 8y agoThere’s also the matter of police militarization being an end run around constitutional protections re: domestically deployed armed forces. I’m not arguing in bad faith. I’m offering a legitimate (if unpopular) critique.
- dmckeon 8y agoAs a wish list and an idea-sparking exploration, this is quite interesting. I would add some sort of return-path and side-passage marking system, perhaps with paint or ink that is only visible in some combinations of illumination and goggles, that is more resistant to being cut or redirected than IR cord or rope. Batteries and LED bulbs have come a long way in the last 30 years, and the community of civilian cavers would be a good source for suggestions about durable equipment. Ask people in Huntsville, AL - the home of an Army base, rocket scientists, karst topography, and the NSS <https://caves.org> https://caves.org>.
- smacktoward 8y agoWith AR you wouldn't even need a physical marking, the system could keep track of where everyone's been and show breadcrumbs in everyone else's display/goggles/whatever. (Of course this assumes some kind of connectivity between the headsets of the various members of the fire team, which could itself be vulnerable in various ways. Painting the walls does have the virtue of simplicity, which counts for a lot in these scenarios.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cwmma 8y agoyou'd need to measure against something, since you probably won't have GPS and dead reckoning probably work very long
- MR4D 8y agoInertial guidance on a cellphone was written up last year. It's clearly a work in progress, but it's a good start. HN link to it is here [0]. I'd bet that if this continues (and I presume the military would want to ensure it continues if only for redundancy purposes), that we'll have accurate inertial guidance on our phones in a decade. [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19203494 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19203494
- shove 8y agoLove to downvote anyone suggesting that technology has consequences
- goda90 8y agoSeveral of these ideas could be combined into a remote controlled robot that can go in front of soldiers and around corners while keeping an eye in every direction. If it encounters an enemy combatant the operator could deploy some of the blinding light/sound nonlethals directly on the robot before the soldiers move in.
- jmrobertson 8y agoSounds like a lot of power reqs, and therefore a lot of AA/AAA batteries. For many of the more tech-forward piece of equip the Army produces, there is a heavy dependency on batteries to the tune of 10xAAA for ~2hrs of consistent use, for example. That sort of burn rate turns into massive, massive, MASSIVE battery requirements for even 24 hr operations. There simply is not enough ruck space. That's all to say, these ideas sound great. But the odds that the Army has a combat-loaded Soldier + ruck try to carry whatever comes out of this before fielding it all to the force are rather low. Or, solve power source first.
- chrisseaton 8y agoWhat's a 'ruck'? The US term for a pack carried on your back? They keep suggesting ideas like a single battery pack and a power distribution system integrated into your vest. But I think that'll end up very much like '14 competing standards... now 15 competing standards.' You already have systems needing AA, AAA, and CR123A. You can never balance how many you need as well so you're wasting and running out of AAA when you have tons of AA still left. I also feel terrible when I get back from just a couple of days on the ground and have to recycle (no idea how they recycle them, let's be pessimistic and calling it really throwing away) a KG or more of batteries.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Jtsummers 8y agoA rucksack is a backpack. The term has become more common in civilian use but was primarily from military use. According to Wikipedia it's from German, not sure how it entered the US/UK military lingo.
- chrisseaton 8y agoAh - I had heard the term 'rucking' now I think about it. > not sure how it entered the US/UK military lingo 'Ruck' is definitely not UK military lingo! Talking about a 'rucksack' sounds extremely civilian to my British ears. The UK military term is 'bergen' or 'daysack' or something smaller.
- Bucephalus355 8y agoThe author talks about the importance of tunnel warfare. About halfway between Dallas and Austin is Ft. Hood, the Army’s largest base. After WWII, so only a few years after it had been set up in the first place, the Army dynamited a series of caves in the very sparse western section of the base to carve out a massive underground structure for nuclear weapons. The Army doesn’t use / maintain nuclear weapons anymore, but the bunker has been repurposed into a basically one-of-a-kind underground training environment. Units from all over the world train there. Pretty cool stuff. https://www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/texas/article/Little-known-underground-Texas-nuclear-bunker-5252582.php https://www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/texas/article/Littl...
- a3n 8y agoCreating your own tunnels and safe spaces sounds like Minecraft. Maybe they should adapt Minecraft for training the mindset.
- ICE_9 8y agoI want ICE 9.