10 ms·
I took 50k images of the night sky to make an 81 Megapixel image of the moon
- gppk 8y ago~~I obviously don't know enough about images... Why would you store this as a jpg and not a LOSELESS format?~~ The full resolution image is in the comments, it's uploaded small because of Reddit https://drive.google.com/file/d/1lGDV6jOHc0v5UdkxcqYShqhKBz_UijPl/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/1lGDV6jOHc0v5UdkxcqYShqhKBz_...
- sureaboutthis 8y ago> LOSELESS Lossless
- wongarsu 8y agoyou lose less with a lossless codec
- sureaboutthis 8y agoI'm glad you didn't write "loose less".
- Asooka 8y agoWell, a lossless codec loses less information and so it's less loose with the pixel data :)
- aerophilic 8y agoAssuming “lossless”, the main reason is you don’t want to “lose” information. For example, if someone wanted to actually use this picture to geo-reference (or would it be Lunar-reference =p) a particular reference a particular feature, you would want it to be accurate. Specific use case: you found some ice, and want to know exactly where it was, as well as composition. If you didn’t use a lossless format, you wouldn’t have confidence it wasn’t as artifact of the compression. Edit: misstated Leo instead of lunar, Leo is low earth orbit
- halvdan 8y agoBeautiful picture! Author's comment about how it was made https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/arer0k/i_took_nearly_50000_images_of_the_night_sky_to/egmo9s8 https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/arer0k/i_took_nearly...
- gus_massa 8y agoMore details from another user https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/arer0k/i_took_nearly_50000_images_of_the_night_sky_to/egn6mbz/ https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/arer0k/i_took_nearly...
- nwellinghoff 8y agoVery nice!
- ourmandave 8y agoThe image is 9000 x 9000 pixels. Future proofing for my own-it-someday 8K monitor background.
- Tomte 8y agoBy then your eyesight might have deteriorated. ;-)
- Waterluvian 8y agoIs it just me or are 4k monitors running in 1080p worse than straight 1080p monitors?
- billyc74 8y agodepends on the density - if both monitors are the same physical size, there should be no difference.
- systemcluster 8y agoYes, since neither GPU drivers nor most displays currently support integer scaling. See http://tanalin.com/en/articles/lossless-scaling/ http://tanalin.com/en/articles/lossless-scaling/ for more a more in-depth explanation.
- andy_ppp 8y agoI mean would the display need to know - just GPU drivers should be able to send a 4k signal that has 4px squares each of one colour? Interesting though.
- tpolzer 8y agoIt doesn't need to, but it would suffice in case your GPU doesn't manage.
- Waterluvian 8y agoFascinating. I assumed that an even multiple is all you need to ensure crispness.
- ptero 8y agoThis is great; as another pointer, http://clarkvision.com http://clarkvision.com is my go-to source for beautiful astrophotography with technical explanations. Look for astro gallery and tutorials if interested
- KnightOfWords 8y agoA quick word of caution. For anyone who might be interested in astrophotography I really wouldn't recommend any of the tutorials on the clark-vision site. This is what the co-author of an astronomical image processing program had to say about them: http://forum.startools.org/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=912 http://forum.startools.org/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=912 "The "articles" exhibit a litany of errors, nonsense and misunderstandings of how some basic algorithms and mathematical concepts work in image processing, including (but sadly not limited to) light pollution removal, deconvolution, the commutative property in mathematics, stacking, linearity vs non-linearity of data, basic physics and color theory. After politely inquiring why he thought any of this was good practice or scientifically accurate and getting nowhere, even after demonstrating the mathematics and writing code to disprove some of his more fanciful claims and pointing out errors and untruths. The fact that I'm having to put this warning up, gives you an indication that that didn't go very well."
- ptero 8y agoThis can definitely be true and I personally find that the writing style of Clark's tutorials could use some polish -- his random switches between scientific and colloquial styles within a single tutorial can annoy both engineers and artists. I also heard that he does not like debate that he deems repetitive and is not be the friendliest opponent to his critics. That said, the criticism above is very scarce on details. What exactly is the nonsense about mathematical concepts that he is objecting to? Roger's data describe his metrics, methodology, data and conclusions (not to the level required to publish in Nature, but better than most websites on the topic). One can argue with either or all of those, but such arguments should include the rigor at least to the level used on Clark's site. That way we can understand what are some reasonable simplifications that are OK even if not strictly correct (e.g., when we tell middle school kids that equation x^2 = -1 has no solutions without into complex numbers or axioms of R) and which are genuine, major errors. But the strongest argument going for Clark, IMO, is his stunning pictures. If his methods describe how he produced them, I am interested in reading more. My 2c, corrections welcome.
- prickledpear 8y agoThis comment explains some of the technical details: https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/arer0k/i_took_nearly_50000_images_of_the_night_sky_to/egn6mbz/ https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/arer0k/i_took_nearly...
- aboutruby 8y agoPretty much every download link is down, but the torrent is working: magnet:?xt=urn:btih:j6ixrzpitvpmkx5tgroy6utcpqr5hhhj&dn=updated%20mosaic.png&xl=304863698&fc=1
- k4r1 8y agoAll the download links are down at the moment. Here's a torrent link: magnet:?xt=urn:btih:j6ixrzpitvpmkx5tgroy6utcpqr5hhhj&dn=updated%20mosaic.png&xl=304863698&fc=1
- HenryBemis 8y agoThis link works now. File is 291 MB https://drive.google.com/uc?id=1lGDV6jOHc0v5UdkxcqYShqhKBz_UijPl&export=download https://drive.google.com/uc?id=1lGDV6jOHc0v5UdkxcqYShqhKBz_U...
- nbeleski 8y agothanks for this! It is probably a smarter way to share the pic given the number o dead links...
- nakedrobot2 8y agobittorrent is the smartest way to share any file that's being viewed by lots of people at the same time. I am continually amazed why it's not used more often. edit: i a word
- stronglikedan 8y agoPossibly the lack of adoption for native browser support.
- throwawaymath 8y agoAside from the nontrivial security mechanisms that would be required to implement it safely, is there another reason why native browser support for torrenting doesn't exist yet?
- leetcrew 8y agoI suspect it just doesn't look good from a PR perspective. who wants to be first to get slammed in the press for enabling piracy?
- diegoperini 8y agoWindows Photos is having a hard time despite my strong specs. Any alternative to use aside from browsers?
- cmpb 8y agoIrfanview seems to handle it decently well
- Avamander 8y agoAnyone knows of a GPU accelerated Linux image viewer?
- bratch 8y agoGLiv [1]. Firefox and GLiv both take ~5 seconds to load the image for me, although whilst Firefox takes another ~5 seconds to re-render after zooming in to 100 %, GLiv is instant. [1] http://guichaz.free.fr/gliv/ http://guichaz.free.fr/gliv/
- grezql 8y agoits opens with Paint.net and i have really bad cpu
- geolgau 8y agoThis makes me lose my shit every time I want to see a simple jpg image in Windows 10. WHY?? Even my 14 year old linux laptop can open 100+ MB images faster than W10.
- sevensor 8y agoViewnior barely breaks a sweat on my (powerful by 2014 standards) machine %CPU %MEM VSZ RSS TTY STAT TIME COMMAND 2.8 1.6 823764 277528 pts/6 Sl+ 0:06 viewnior updated mosaic.png That's about 804 megabytes allocated, 271 megabytes resident. Took about 2 seconds to read and render the file.
- AmVess 8y ago
- phront 8y agoGreat! It is interesting, why Google or anybody else have not made a map of Moon just like Googlemap of Earth. Are there some technical problems?
- stetrain 8y agohttps://www.google.com/moon/ https://www.google.com/moon/
- raphaelj 8y agoThey did: https://www.google.com/moon/ https://www.google.com/moon/ Last time I used it, Google Earth provided a 3D view of the Moon and of Mars.
- jessriedel 8y agoIt's too bad they haven't updated this to act like the modern version of Google Maps. It's like going back in time to the old HTML version.
- Nitramp 8y agoAlso, zero road data or local shops. It's like Apple Maps outside the Bay Area...
- mrep 8y agoThat's because you aren't using the maps version: https://www.google.com/maps/space/moon/ https://www.google.com/maps/space/moon/
- jessriedel 8y agoOh thank goodness.
- Ajedi32 8y agoThe UI in that link looks really old. If you want the more modern, 3D view, I'd recommend going to maps.google.com, switching to satellite view, and zooming out.
- idoco 8y agoThat's no moon... it's a space station.
- squarefoot 8y agoThis is so beautiful, thanks! I'll cut some pieces to be used as desktop backgrounds. The southern part of the moon and surrounding space if turned upside down would make a really nice one. BTW, I spent some time zooming around the stars and objects and some of them look rather interesting, at least to a completely astronomy illiterate like me, such as the closest objects to the moon at roughly 2 o' clock.
- faitswulff 8y agoAnyone have a mirror of the full-size lossless image? All the download links are dead atm.
- neddeadstark 8y agoSeem to be up now, I just downloaded
- Theodores 8y agoIf anyone wants to look at this image properly then you need OpenSeadragon and VIPS. OpenSeadragon enables you to view this image at full resolution without your device keeling over, VIPS enables you to make the image tiles required to get OpenSeadragon to work. OpenSeadragon has only ever made it to the academic world, in this age of Instagram people want average resolution selfies that take three seconds to look at. OpenSeadragon enables a deeper look. If anyone has ten minutes spare: https://openseadragon.github.io/ https://openseadragon.github.io/ On linux just apt-get install vips and then: vips dzsave massive.jpg massive And you are then good to go. Now where was that torrent link...?
- enriquto 8y agoFor images of a moderate size such as this one, viewing it on a regular image viewer is less of a hassle.
- Theodores 8y agoSuch as? I didn't see any example of that in the comment threads.
- planteen 8y agoFirefox works great, as others have mentioned.
- Theodores 8y agoHave you tried OpenSeadragon? I feel like I have been casting pearls at swines here.
- enriquto 8y agoOpenseadragon may make sense for huge images, not for merely large ones as this one, that fits comfortably in memory. Besides, not everyone is keen on using "web-based" programs just because.
- honestoHeminway 8y agoImagine what a massive camera earth could be if a certain part of humanity pointed its cellphone at the sky at night..
- omilu 8y agoIs the haze around the moon sun light scattering because of moon dust?
- mankyd 8y agoNot sure, but that's unlikely. Remember, the moon has no atmosphere, so there's nothing really to either kick-up nor suspend the dust in. Any dust that did get kicked up (by meteorites?) would settle back down relatively quickly.
- jcurbo 8y agoNo, it's partially artistic, partially light scattering in the Earth's atmosphere from the moonlight and the exposure settings he used. The moon does have a very tenuous atmosphere but nothing thick enough to cause this effect.
- autokad 8y ago> "it's partially artistic" When I view the moon with my telescope, I see the same haze. I think its earths atmosphere, not the moon that causes it.
- Sharlin 8y agoNo. This photo (well, photos) is taken from the bottom of an air sea, which is where the scattering happens.
- jannes 8y agoAre you referring to Earth's atmosphere as an air sea? Is that an actual term being used? I couldn't find anything about this term in a quick ddg search.
- icebraining 8y agoI think "ocean of air" is more common.
- 8y ago
- vectorEQ 8y agothat doesn't look like cheese at all :S
- fergie 8y agoIs the resolution high enough to see any man made stuff?
- MrEldritch 8y agoNot even close. (81 megapixels is 9000 by 9000, and the moon only takes up about the middle 1/9th of the image, so it's about 3000 pixels across. So that's over a km per pixel at the very front of the moon, and even worse at the edges where the surface is at an oblique angle to our view)
- bradenb 8y agoAlso, I can't remember the source (maybe it was a "What If?"), but I seem to recall that it's actually to create a lens that allows us to focus a point on the moon to allow us to make out current man-made items on the surface of the moon.
- KangLi 8y agoAwesome picture. Well done :D
- senorgomez 8y agoA couple of 1920x1080 versions for desktop, I like the one on the right so there is space for icons on left: https://imgur.com/a/I62aGZ2 https://imgur.com/a/I62aGZ2
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- m-p-3 8y agoBecausr the full-res version links went down often yesterday, I'm hosting it on my IPFS node, here's the link (for those on IPFS, if you can afford the bandwidth please pin it to spread the load :) ) https://ipfs.io/ipfs/QmVLTMHtLRhnft3QspDx4qTJeXY6hiib1j77UfQmY54CGe/mosaic.png https://ipfs.io/ipfs/QmVLTMHtLRhnft3QspDx4qTJeXY6hiib1j77UfQ... Also made it available in torrent form (with the IPFS URL as a web seed) http://www.urlhash.com/124410/mosaic.png.torrent http://www.urlhash.com/124410/mosaic.png.torrent
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sneak 8y agoalso works, thanks to the generosity of cloudflare: https://cloudflare-ipfs.com/ipfs/QmVLTMHtLRhnft3QspDx4qTJeXY6hiib1j77UfQmY54CGe/mosaic.png https://cloudflare-ipfs.com/ipfs/QmVLTMHtLRhnft3QspDx4qTJeXY...
- jjcm 8y agoI've got plenty of bandwidth on my server - http://files.jjcm.org/mosaic.png http://files.jjcm.org/mosaic.png if anyone needs a non-ipfs / magnet link :) Alternatively, if you have a slower connection I made a lossless webp here which should result in the same output at about 1/10th the size: http://files.jjcm.org/mosaic.webp http://files.jjcm.org/mosaic.webp
- steelframe 8y agoLoading this image brings me back to the days of my 2400 BAUD modem.
- canada_dry 8y agoyoutu.be/ckc6XSSh52w?t=44
- geostyx 8y agoHere's another mirror, hosted on B2 + Cloudflare: https://i-cdn.jacobhands.com/lwd3q/mosaic.png https://i-cdn.jacobhands.com/lwd3q/mosaic.png
- Rooster61 8y agoAs an amateur astronomer who has looked directly at the moon through a telescope hundreds of times, this photo looks strange and artificial, though I know it's not. I pondered why this was for a bit, and came to the conclusion that its otherworldly quality is actually due to being superior to what one can see directly. At any one moment, direct observation will have artifacts of the air moving between you and the target object. This picture quashes all of that at once, lending an "uncanny valley" feeling I think spurred by the fact that my brain just isn't used to that level of fidelity looking at a real object. This work is fantastic.
- madaxe_again 8y agoNo no, it is strange and artificial. The stars are comped in from something else, and the moonglow looks like a gaussian blur. Still, it's pretty, and has hopefully inspired people to go stare at the moon. To be fair, most astrophotography is "enhanced" one way or another - I can spend hours screwing around with a single DSO shot after stacking. Here's a quick and dirty 30 second reconstruction using a shot of the moon from last summer, acquired in much the same way as OP - except using an EdgeHD 14 with an EOS 7D in video mode. It's pretty crap as last year was my first foray into planetary imaging - I usually do DSOs. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1hYLJeb_pO9z2qNFwtux0q5Jix9DZ5MFT/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1hYLJeb_pO9z2qNFwtux0q5Jix9D...
- jcurbo 8y agoAmateur astronomer here as well that has also done a bit of lunar photography. (envious of your EdgeHD 14...) I made a similar comment about the moonglow, but thinking a bit I think it's a combination of: - Higher dynamic range than the human eye (combination of stars, moonglow, and high contrast lunar surface both in shadow and in sunlight) - High resolution imaging, and the digital signal processing aspect (noise reduction, deconvolution, etc.) They combine to make something that looks kinda like reality but is really a mix, and maybe triggers a little bit of the uncanny valley effect.
- jordache 8y agomajority of the 81 megapixels are not of the moon though..
- scarejunba 8y agoWhat’s the glow over the lit part? There shouldn’t be any dust or air to provide it there, right?
- philcarbo 8y agoThis is amazing! Definitely my new wallpaper... on all my computers. :)