11 ms·
Disinformation and ‘fake news’: Final Report published
- Anon84 8y agoPDF of the report https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmcumeds/1791/1791.pdf https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmcu...
- dsl 8y agoCalls for: Social media companies obliged to take down known sources of harmful content, including proven sources of disinformation It will be interesting to see how Reddit addresses The_Donald or 8chan deals with the QAnon nonsense in the wake of this. Edit: Feel free to disagree with the law, but you don't do that with a downvote.
- sarcasmOrTears 8y agoHow do you prove something is disinformation? Time for a ministry of truth? I can imagine already imagine for example which version of the Convington kids case would be considered official and information.
- docdeek 8y agoThis is exactly right. Trusting a government to determine what is true and what is not, and enforcing that version of truth via shutting down certain speech and penalising those who speak it, is a bad idea. I’ve no problem with a government announcing that they believe something is true or false, but I have a big problem with them restricting the speech of people who happen to disagree.
- fzeroracer 8y agoInstead we have a ministry of truth being perpetuated by sites such as Youtube, with incredibly harmful information being disseminated and treated as truth resulting in disease outbreaks and outright denial of history. In your idealistic world of free speech, the innocent pay the price for the freedom to spread lies and deceit. At what point do we accept that it has to be fixed, or are we OK with diseases previously eradicated coming back in full force?
- colordrops 8y agoThe difference is that there is also an overwhelming force of true speech to counter the lies and deceit. Once you start banning speech, only "official" lies will be allowed. See China. Where the hell did you get the idea that free speech is only OK until people start to lie? You can take my free speech from my cold, dead mouth.
- pjc50 8y agoWe're in the era when automated propaganda means the lies can far more easily overwhelm the truth. And just as with guns, the lies end up with the deaths of innocent bystanders.
- colordrops 8y agoWhereas before, manual propaganda ended up with deaths of innocent bystanders. Can you point to any source that indicates that deaths have gone up due to AI/social media bots? And even if there was a study, it's not necessarily a case for censorship. Pretty much every basic right Americans have are trade-offs rather than 100% positive.
- NeedMoreTea 8y ago> The difference is that there is also an overwhelming force of true speech to counter the lies and deceit That doesn't seem to be hugely helping as far as climate change goes. For anything where money is involved deepest pockets counts far more than the "overwhelming force" of true speech. It has become depressingly common to see topics being astroturfed or an "Independent Health Research Institute" set up by the guilty corporate or a trade body, and SEO'd and adworded to page 1. Like Soviet Bloc use of "democratic", use of "independent" in an information site has almost become proof it's not. :) We need to dream up some life changing consequences for lies and misinformation, serious enough that it stops being standard policy of every medium size enterprise.
- fzeroracer 8y agoIf that overwhelming force of true speech worked, then why hasn't climate change denial, anti-vaccine nonsense etc been eradicated from the public sphere yet? In fact, why are those movements growing?
- nightfly 8y agoEspecially in an era where our president refers to every negative article about him as "fake news".
- CM30 8y agoEspecially as you have no idea when a government hostile to you or your beliefs may take power, and if they do, well then it could means news and things you believe in get censored or banned. Anyone who believes governments should have the ability to decide what 'fake news' is should remember who's in the White House about now, or who runs the FCC at the moment. And who might be in the White House in a few years/run the FCC in a few years, etc.
- pjc50 8y agoCourt cases? Ultimately that's where Sandy Hook has ended up. More seriously, if you believe that it's impossible for courts to establish truth or that they are the same thing as Party members of the elected government, you've already given up on the possibility of rule of law and arguably democracy as a whole.
- A2017U1 8y agoCan I take the dozens of news outlets in the Western world to court for lying about Iraq's weapons of mass destruction? It was their coverage which arguably resulted in public support with billions of tax dollars spent on a lie Or were they simply reporting what they were told without proof? It's a very slippery slope.
- pjc50 8y agoI think any effective, honest campaign against lying in public life has to take both newspapers and politicians into account somehow. UK press regulation is absent but at the same time we have onerous libel law. Having "accurately reporting what the government minister said" still open press to liability is .. interesting, especially when considering how to report Trump.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Can I take the dozens of news outlets in the Western world to court for lying about Iraq's weapons of mass destruction? Which specific ones?
- creato 8y ago> Can I take the dozens of news outlets in the Western world to court for lying about Iraq's weapons of mass destruction? It was their coverage which arguably resulted in public support with billions of tax dollars spent on a lie The "dozens of news outlets" were not, as far as they knew, lying. They were reporting what their sources, many/most of them public, told them. If you want to punish someone for this lie, it should be the Bush administration.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y ago
- abainbridge 8y agoThe report recommends, "tech companies assume legal liability for content identified as harmful after it has been posted by users". If they do that, the existing laws and court system would be used decide what is disinformation, in the same they are currently applied to traditionally published media.
- beaner 8y agoIf this were being applied to the media, where the links come from, we wouldn't need to apply it to tech sites, where the links are shared. This doesn't cover all cases but it's offloading the responsibility from "journalists" to tech. If the media were honest at all they'd acknowledge that they're most of the problem.
- AstralStorm 8y agoAnd then everything is frozen. No discourse allowed because moderators become the police and they cannot accept any liability. This law cannot be allowed to pass in such a broad form. Obviously it is convenient to status quo.
- res0nat0r 8y agoReddit-wise I doubt nothing honestly. That subreddit has been a hateful cesspool for years now, but the community and the money/traffic it bring in for the site due to the sheer amount of traffic, and backlash from big name rightwing nutters that use it for their propaganda launchpoint is more than reddit management wants to deal with, thus it's not going anywhere.
- mikeq101101 8y agoWho decides what is a "proven source of disinformation"? The media that are currently paraded as trustworthy were all in on things like "babies out of incubators", "weapons of mass destruction", Libya, etc. And everyone who tried to go against them was smeared as conspiracy theorist. I can not trust the media that was integral in lying about and manufacturing consent for endless wars, when they have not learned from their mistakes and are still beating their drums. Giving the elites power to decide what is a "proven source of disinformation" sounds like a really bad idea.
- lisper 8y ago> Who decides what is a "proven source of disinformation"? That question doesn't get nearly enough attention among those decrying the rise of fake news. Even the NYT occasionally gets it wrong. Does that make them a "proven source of disinformation"? The answer is not to throw your hands in the air and concede to factual relativism. But the first step to solving this problem is to recognize that it is a very, very difficult problem.
- asdff 8y agoIt is not a difficult problem, ban the bots from St. Petersburg, not the god damn NYT.
- lisper 8y agoWhat you are effectively saying is that the answer to "who decides" is you. I can see why you would think that is a satisfactory answer, but can you see how a reasonable person might disagree?
- Retra 8y agoIf reasonable people are disagreeing, then they have reasons to disagree. If reasons can drive a discussion, they can decide issues like this. So your question is misleading. It's not "who decides", but "what decides", and how to we ensure the "what" remains reasons that reasonable people would support. Otherwise, you're just asking how people make decisions. "Who decided murder should be illegal" is just a poor (rather conspiratorial) way to ask what reasons are used to argue that it should be illegal and how we determined that those reasons were sufficient. Presumably, in a democracy, the answer to "who determines what the government does" is "the people."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Pimpus 8y agoWhile the rest of Reddit was lying about Hillary's favorability, only The Donald was posting accurate polls. They've continued to be more accurate than the other subreddits, most recently with the Jussie Smolett thing. I think at this point people are willfully ignoring reality, though it's getting harder (the Russia collusion conspiracy theory is no longer cresible).
- somebadguy 8y agoAww you poor stupid asshole. Why didn’t your mother follow her gut and have you aborted?
- caconym_ 8y agor/T_D is completely fucking unhinged. The most memorable thing I saw there was a spree of posts explicitly praising Pinochet for the atrocities he committed, and calling for the same treatment for their political enemies; this stuff was upvoted to the top of the subreddit. I do not disagree that there is misinformation and biased content everywhere, but if you're turning to r/T_D as a general source of truths, you should take a step back.
- beaner 8y agoFor every piece of fake news in the_donald, it legitimately calls out five examples from liberal sources. It's a combination of meme factory and watchdog group. It's a little crazy because it has to be. When you can't speak about your views reasonably and publicly because you'll be ostracised no matter what you say or how accurate it is, what else can you do? How else do you respond? The maga DC kid literally just stood there and was called a racist and bigot with calls for his face to be punched in and for him to be doxxed. Imagine if he opened his mouth to say something? That's the world people in the_donald live in. Fear to speak. And that story turned out to be fake news anyway. For people using it, the_donald played an important role of being a place where much of the truth of that situation was surfaced. I don't think you can really blame people for saying fuck it, if nobody's going to hear me out, I may as well be fun and funny and extreme while I do it. Plus, everybody knows that the real danger isn't that it promotes a lot of fake news, but that the real news that it does surface might be convincing. Between the memes, the_donald is part of a well-rounded news feed if your goal is to actually understand US politics and the viewpoints of many conservative thinkers, and not just blindly desire people to conform to something else. It obviously should not be your only news source.
- fzeroracer 8y agoConsidering the amount of damage anti-vaccine hysteria and disinformation has caused, I can't say I disagree with their conclusions. If debating them with facts and logic actually worked, then we should've seen the movement fade away years ago. It's not, and it's growing as a result of faulty search algorithms being used by people to spread conspiracy theories and fake nonsense. It's exactly why flat earth nonsense is spreading as well [1]. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/feb/17/study-blames-youtube-for-rise-in-number-of-flat-earthers https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/feb/17/study-blames...
- alexis_fr 8y agoThe media has its own disinformation. For example the wage gap « at equal work » is the biggest statistical error ever made (never were basic criteria taken into account), thousands of researchers voiced that the way the media presented it made people think women were paid less for the same work... ...and yet researchers couldn’t get their voice to be heard. Given the number of unfair laws and bylaws that were passed on the understanding that women were paid less, the wage gap has been a lie at a huge scale.
- cm2187 8y agoOr Cohen being told to lie to congress. Or the Covington kids. Etc. One could make a pretty convincing case against pretty much every major newspaper and TV station. Fake news is really the news published by the other side.
- robbick 8y agoI regularly quote said statistic - can you link me some reliable sources supporting your claim?
- alexis_fr 8y agoThe proof is in the charge of the accusers. They accuse that there is a wage gap. Can they show a study that is properly peer-reviewed and includes all basic criteria together? Each time we have this discussion, it derives into « Ok women are not paid less because of their gender, but because they work less. But they’re prevented from working, by social prejudices! » Which proves my point, and sidesteps the question onto social prejudices. Concerning the question of social prejudices, it’s again a blanket accusation, and each argument has been repealed, but it’s a long discussion. In each discussion what we can easily prove is that: - Women work less as soon as they marry a man. When they marry a woman, they earn more. When they are single, they earn more. When they have kids with a lesbian, they work more. The only case they work less is when there’s a husband, and that’s valid even before the first birth!!! All of it points to social expectations that women are not expected to work when they are in couple. Sorry for the « social construct » ideology, but the man is vastly made a slave of the woman in marriage, which would explain all of the above, including the wage-gap-because-they-work-less. - All in all, girls are treated better at school, better marked for the same copy (measured with anonymization, not just because they’re better), taken careof when they fail and even when « feel unsure » (see the whole debat about « women don’t dare asking for raises »– they got help from everyone on that case - while men don’t even get help when they plan to commit suicide), - Which results in better, both easier and healthier employment for women, and in average women before children earn 117% of men the same age in USA. I don’t even claim it’s infair that women earn more, I’m just tired of feminists being bigoted about male problems: for every feminist figure there is an inequality m that kills 50x more men and has 100x to 1000x smaller budget (see: beaten women, suicide, workplace deaths, in all of the western world). Again, the burden of proof falls on those who claim there is an inequality. All we can prove is that every single feminist study was reliably proven false on the topic of wage-gap-for-same-work.
- cinquemb 8y agoSnippets from 2014 CFR discussion: "…So the question I'm asking myself is can we figure out a way to accelerate the second curve of human response in a fashion -- in -- in -- in identical ways to the way DARPA accelerates the first curve of technological challenges." "… What about Facebook? What about Twitter? I have no idea what Twitter is good for. But if it flips out every tyrant in the Middle East, I'm interested." Funny how tools work…
- JackPoach 8y agoYeah, because politicians always tell the truth, I totally believe this report.
- frereubu 8y agoThis sound like straight-up nihilism. I'd get if it you were reserving judgement, but I'll bet you haven't even tried to read the report.
- Theodores 8y agoBut do you have the measure of British MPs? Right now there is this thing called Brexit. There is the 'no-deal', Theresa May 'deal' and 'remain' to consider. However, the truth is that democracy really was subverted by outside interests that funded the Brexiteers. None of that was legitimate spending, it went against the rules. The Brexit debate should not be about 'leave' or 'remain' when there is this matter of whether democracy can be bought. There is a corruption scandal and addressing that should matter regardless of whether you hate or love Brussels. But none of the British MPs care about this fundamental issue, they are playing politics, stuck with their respective party lines to tow. They have had plenty of time to cotton on to what has gone on and they have not. There may be some 'great work' done by back bench committees in Parliament, however, I would not mock anyone that has suspicions regarding the state of British politics in this era. The MPs know that the internet poses a threat to them because concerned citizens can express views online that are outside the narrow frame that is permitted within the political establishment.
- frereubu 8y ago"Right now there is this thing called Brexit." I'm British, so I'm all too aware of Brexit. The comment I responded to didn't sound like someone who had legitimate suspicions regarding the state of British politics, it sounded like a fatuous, offhand dismissal of people who were taking a serious interest the effect of social media on democracy. I'm interested in thoughtful criticism of the report, but this wasn't that.
- 8y ago
- sbhn 8y agoFake news is new media. It must be really important if google news has a special section dedicated to it on the right column where you can see it without needing to scroll down the page. The uk has the bbc to spread its agenda, mostly in favour of further colonisation and to protect its weapons supply network across the middle east , and doesnt want the competition. Fake news is actually competition that makes the ‘real’ news try harder.
- growlist 8y ago> further colonisation What? UK has been de-colonising for decades. Other former colonial powers held on much harder, e.g. France.
- MaysonL 8y agoMedical disinformation often rises to the top of search results: https://www.wired.com/story/the-complexity-of-simply-searching-for-medical-advice/ https://www.wired.com/story/the-complexity-of-simply-searchi...
- hamilyon2 8y agoI found something like this when searched for antibiotic resistance in russian. Mainstream, 70-years old boring truth is not the top result. Top result is fringe controversial study, that is reported all over recent news. This is so frustrating.
- Const-me 8y agoWhat did you expect? Antibiotic resistance is a new phenomenon. There's no science in modern Russia, and good sources on the subject like "The Lancet" and NIH's pubmed are in English.
- tim333 8y agoI guess you'd expect that but it could in theory be fixed with better search algorithms. Perhaps AI that could distinguish The Lancet and crank stuff.
- Const-me 8y agoThere’s no Russian version of The Lancet, nor Russian translation. Nothing to distinguish crank stuff from. People can distinguish if they speak other languages and search global Internet. Maybe I’m underestimating AI but I don’t think AI can do that currently, nor will be able in foreseeable future.
- BorRagnarok 8y agoI think censoring the "fake news" is far more dangerous than to just let it exist and have people think for themselves about what's true or false.
- stuartaxelowen 8y agoWhy?
- AstralStorm 8y agoFake news is known only after the fact. (After verification.) If you can accept only really verifiably sourced news, things become really inconvenient for both journalists and political opposition. And where do you put the bar? No interpretation allowed dry facts? Court rulings?
- rjtavares 8y agoNews that turn out to be false are not fake news. News deliberately known to be false are fake news. Example from the last US presidential election: * The Pope endorses Bernie Sanders -> this is fake news * The Pope endorses Trump -> this is fake news * The Pope endorses Clinton -> this is fake news All three spread on facebook, btw (https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/pope-francis-shocks-world-endorses-hillary-clinton-for-president/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/pope-francis-shocks-world-...) Also, anonymous sources are not fake news, they're anonymous sources. If labelled as such, the are fine.
- arethuza 8y agoTurkey joining the EU was another example from the Brexit campaign - it was clearly nonsense (Turkey might want to join the EU but the chances of that happening any time soon is pretty much zero): https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/unfounded-claim-turkey-swing-brexit-referendum/ https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/unfounded-claim-tu...
- 8y ago
- templain 8y agoThe UK is one of the most cucked countries known to the history of mankind so this report is not to be taken seriously. Also nice try redefining fake news. Fake news AREN'T some badly written wannabe news items targeting soccer moms on facebook written by underpaid Macedonian hackers, but Fake news ARE what we get when all mainstream journalists live in their metropolitan leftist bubbles and just see the same 27 colleagues retweet the same stuff for years.
- tempestn 8y agoI certainly agree that a segment of the political spectrum, which you appear to inhabit, has attempted to redefine fake news as 'any news I don't like'. Of course, much like fake news itself, that doesn't make it true.
- templain 8y agoYou'd be very surprised about the segment of the political spectrum I inhabit. Even people like Slavoj Zizek would agree 100% with my comment and he is a Stalin nostalgic.
- drawkbox 8y agoThe truth is the internet is teaching the biggest lesson ever in critical thinking and getting your information from many sources across spectrums, countries, divides and more to find out what is really going on. People must think about why they are hearing about something and the layers and goals that are behind it and drive it. Let's hope that people see these disinformation and misinformation efforts as a lesson and not somewhere they can bask in their confirmation bias all day, or make decisions based on fear, in those cases the populace is easy to manipulate, divide and conquer. When something it too salacious or fits a narrative too perfectly, someone/group is marketing you in a direction and has you possibly in an active measure.
- frereubu 8y ago"People must think about why they are hearing about something and the layers and goals that are behind it and drive it." But do they or will they? The proliferation of flat earth videos on YouTube suggests otherwise. In a perfect world everyone would critically examine what they hear, but a lot of people just feed their existing biases. (To be clear, I'm not suggesting that flat earth videos are banned because they seem harmless, if stupid. Anti-vaccine content, on the other hand, needs some additional context at the very minimum.)
- drawkbox 8y agoIt is a hard problem. The answer is it will never fully be solved but if there is enough competing information and facts are out there, you might just get most of the people to hold down the fort. There will always be people fooled by disinformation/misinformation and everyone probably has been fooled by some, even highly skilled intel agents that purposefully look for it and have access to more info. As long as most people can differentiate fake/real fact/fiction/bias then we are good. I do think it is better to have this information out to be fought, when you hide it, critical thinking skills aren't improved over time, and we become more susceptible to it. We need to solve it before AI and neural networks target and learn about each one of us, and where we are gullible or biased. Some of the disinformation/misinformation/fake news out there is already algorithm driven and when it can be tuned to each individual's psychology that is when it gets scary. Already these networks are grouping people in smaller and smaller target groups and the result is highly effective. Education and critical thinking is the only way, people need to challenge all authority and all information, especially after emergencies/disasters/shock/attacks as that is when the hoards emerge the most.
- chvid 8y agoThe truth is that there has always been misinformation, lies, and manipulation through media in politics. Just look at the history of TV and radio regulation in the US and Europe. Look at how so many future leaders moved from media careers into politics. The problem is that this time it didn't work as usual and the process had the wrong outcome (Brexit and mr. Trump). So now "we" are looking for excuses and reasons to expand government power.
- willyt 8y agoDo we need a trust system of some kind? Maybe journalists should be held accountable in the same way that doctors, structural engineers, architects etc. An article should be cryptographically signed by the journalist. If a journalist publishes incorrect information, report it to their professional body. Factual inaccuracies should be corrected in the reported article or the journalist should withdraw their certificate from it. Several egregious uncorrected factual innacuracies, as judged by a jury of their peers and lay people, causes a journalist to be struck off and their certificate revoked forever lableing everything they have written as questionable. Protect the word ‘News’ in law so that you can’t use it without having certified journalists writing the copy. People can still publish and read anything they want just like you are free to go to a homeopath if you want, but there would be a trust structure in place.
- buboard 8y agoa blockchain trust system for reporters (i think the profession of journalist has come full circle and it's time to retire the label)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- buboard 8y agois it me or does the committee seem lazy? their report is basically a collage of NYtimes articles, which they quote as evidence , even when it is speculative their facebook emails 'evidence' isn t particularly related to their conclusions either. i mean facebook has been treating its small publishers unfairly since the age of zynga, just search facebook's forum to find developers actively calling them out. it's not really related to disinformation. i would expect a little more work based on their own secret services about the extent of russian trolling in their own referendum.most of all i would expect at least some evidence that these campaigns can change people's opinion. not liking an electoral outcome cannot be used as evidence that they were effective that said, i do hope they ban political advertising to death, because the ones who benefit from it are the politicians who write this report themselves. however, regulating the truth? i thought george orwell was british
- pjc50 8y ago> basically a collage of NYtimes articles This is such an inaccurate statement that I'm tempted to joke about it being fake news. This report is about as serious as it gets in terms of professional investigations. There's almost 100 pieces of written evidence and they called a number of witnesses to give primary evidence (famously including Zuckerberg who refused to show up). Where they have referred to the NYT, it is properly cited in the footnotes. Eight of the 349 footnotes refer to the NYT. Care to retract your accusation of laziness? > ban political advertising to death It largely is, in the UK. Certainly by American standards of "free speech". There's one huge exception: Facebook adverts were unregulated...
- buboard 8y agoi was actually expecting something more related to the UK and brexit. Particularly, evidence that misinformation can change or has changed the minds of people regarding the EU, or brexit in general . Instead this seems to be a hodgepodge of well know information about facebook and cambridge analytiuca and the US elections. they use some very speculative quotes from nytimes such as this > allegedly to spread anti-semitic information about George Soros and his campaigning activities, afer Mr Soros called Facebook “a menace to society” in early 2018. and some very spurious data such as this > is interesting to note that, as of 30 November 2018, the online Government response to our Report received a total of 1,290 unique page views and the PDF has been visited 396 unique times from the website.265 In the month following its publication, over 63% of views of the report online were from foreign IP addresses (whereas, on average, 80% of viewers of Reports are UK-based), and of these, over half were from Russia in which they seem to be downgrading russian interference to spam bots. Their own conclusion with regards to interference in UK elections is that "Te Government should be conducting analysis to understand the extent of Russian targeting of voters during elections". i.e. "we don't know" that said i m not disputing the accuracy of what is stated. it's just not enough, and not surprising at all
- lbj 8y ago> Compulsory Code of Ethics for tech companies overseen by independent regulator I would have loved to see strong moves in favor of critical thinking, rational argumentation, scientific analysis/study. The suggested actions will leave us with a government that dictates what it believes is good ethics and penalizes everyone who does not agree - Not quite the opposite of what I'd hope for, but its scarily close.
- raxxorrax 8y agoAs a European I would be strongly in favor of the UK leaving the union as fast as possible if anything of that kind gets implemented.
- yunruse 8y agoThe problem is and always will be that truth is tricky to define, and “blocking fake news” is immensely easy to exploit for nefarious purposes. Perhaps the better solution here is not to try to block the flood but to manipulate it by using market incentives. Notice how high-quality journalism tends (again, quite subjective) towards subscriptions and sponsorships, as users will actively want to participate whereas lower-effort content has to lean heavily on black-box advertising networks. This could be solved with a few changes: tax advertising a lot more, and use these funds to subsidise subscriptions and sponsorships in media.
- rangeban 8y agoJFC, HN. You’re really pretty useless, aren’t you? Recent events are not the result of mass hysteria rooted in subversive brainwashing. Then what’s the real cause of the problem, you ask? The reality is that one needs not the correct answer, to realize a supposed idea is deeply flawed. In the void of any obvious truth, a dubious narrative takes shape. All in all, this is mostly an aftershock of some of the horrendous decision making surrounding “terrorism” and refugees from The Global War On Terror. But the cognitive realities of such a proposition are to difficult for some to digest. No buzz words for clean, succinct headlines. Too bad about that.
- AlexTWithBeard 8y agoThe problem is not fake news. The problem is extremely biased news. Is everything Trump does is great? Hell, no. Is everything Trump does is stupid? Probably not either. But will hardly ever hear from CNN that "actually, Trump's idea here was good, let's give him a credit". Same goes the other way round.