5 ms·
As long as SIP can be disabled I don't mind this outcome. However, that's a very big and important condition.
by Wowfunhappy 8y ago
As long as SIP can be disabled I don't mind this outcome. However, that's a very big and important condition.
- 1over137 8y agoSIP is useful though. It would be better that we could have SIP enabled and still be able to install whatever we want without going through App Store.
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> SIP is useful though I am very skeptical on this point. macOS, like all Unix systems, already limits privileges for non-root users. What do you accomplish by placing limits on root as well? If a malicious application gets root, you are very screwed. The app can encrypt most of your hard drive, monitor most keystrokes, do nasty things with your hosts file, and steal most of your personal data. It won't be able to directly inject itself into other processes and certain critical OS files we protected, but how relevant is that? As I see it, SIP's main purpose is to (1) prevent non-technical users from (completely) hosing their systems by copying and pasting terminal commands from the internet, and (2) to protect TCC.db so that apps can't bypass Apple's privacy system. If you're able to turn off SIP, you have enough technical knowledge than #1 isn't necessary. I suppose #2 may have some limited value, but not much. If I am completely off base on this, feel free to educate me—but in my several years of research I have not come across any plausible scenarios for when SIP's protection would be helpful. ------ Edit: One other relevant note: Apple lets you selectively disable and enable parts of SIP. So you'd likely be able to turn off sideload-blocking (or whatever it is) without disabling SIP completely, if you want to for whatever reason.
- pvg 8y agoIf a malicious application gets root, you are very screwed. SIP is a piece of design intended to make you less screwed when that happens.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoYes, but how meaningful is that? If a thief breaks into my house, I don't particularly care if he can access the drawer where I keep pencils.
- pvg 8y agoI'm not sure I understand this but if you prefer it in terms of strange analogies - you're walking past a construction site where they're building a highrise and see they're hammering a giant steel pylon into the ground. You smirk and say 'that won't keep the rain out!'.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoMy analogy was somewhat stupid and I apologize. Stated better: it appears to me that the consequence of a malicious app getting root is already so incredibly catastrophic, that at that point it makes little difference whether or not SIP is enabled.
- pvg 8y agoRight, and I'm trying (and seemingly failing, sorry) to convince you you are looking at it backwards. SIP is not there to magically save you in a system where an all-powerful administrative account is compromised. The goal is to come up with a system that doesn't have something like an all-powerful administrative account, among other security improvements. It's only part of an effort to retrofit an existing consumer desktop OS to be more resilient to adversarial software - a long and arduous one that all makers of consumer OS'es are engaged in and have been for years.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoPut another way, you’re saying macOS’s admin account is currently too powerful? Even if Apple is able to eventually change that—and it would take a while—it doesn’t make SIP useful for security as of right now. Edit: Also, security be damned, I don’t want to use an OS without a proper root account! So while not entirely relevent to the discussion, I know that I would either continue to turn off SIP or move to another platform.
- sascha_sl 8y agoIt's more of a "prevent app developers from asking you to do it". A normal user that has to disable SIP is a lot more of a barrier than a normal user typing in the root password. Normal users need UX to save them from owning themselves.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoExactly! But if you're an even slightly advanced user, this isn't necessary. I'm a little frustrated by all the FUD I've seen spread in Apple enthusiast communities about how SIP is this super important security feature that should never be turned off. My opinion is that if you have a reason to disable SIP, go ahead and do so with a clear conscious. You will continue to be protected by the privilege system that's in place for (basically) all UNIX's.
- Hackbraten 8y ago> Apple lets you selectively disable and enable parts of SIP. Can you cite a source for that?
- pvg 8y agohttps://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/17452 https://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/17452
- Hackbraten 8y ago> I suppose #2 may have some limited value, but not much. Didn’t stop apps from trying exactly that anyway. https://daringfireball.net/linked/2016/09/20/dropbox-macos-security https://daringfireball.net/linked/2016/09/20/dropbox-macos-s...
- IshKebab 8y agoThe issue is that normal users will not (and should not) disable SIP because it is complicated and scary. Therefore it will become unviable for 99% of apps to be distributed outside the app store, so they won't. I distribute an app outside the app store. It's free and open source, but not meant to be for technical users (it's art-related). I like people being able to use it, because I am a nice guy, but I also don't want to pay Apple $100/year and go through the hassle of putting it in the app store, if that would even work. My users are not going to disable SIP so if Apple continues in this way I really will be forced to put it in the app store (or more likely, abandon OSX).