3 ms·
> Good recruiters focus on building relationships versus solving an immediate need. The problem is they get paid only when immediate needs are met. A placement
by lordnacho 8y ago
> Good recruiters focus on building relationships versus solving an immediate need.
The problem is they get paid only when immediate needs are met. A placement is hard to do, but results in 25% of an annual salary when done. This results in two kinds of strategy:
1) Spammers. I get this all the time on both sides (as a hiring manager and as a potential hire). The worst is when I get forwarded someone's actual CV out of the blue. It's happened a couple of times recently: a guy who works at Google or Amazon at a high level has his CV sent to me by a recruiter who's never spoken to me. In both cases I found the person on LinkedIn and told them, much to their surprise. Of course there was never a conversation on the other side either. Normally it's not as egregious as this, but it's still not a way to do business.
2) Relationship people. These guys will actually take the time to meet with me and talk about what kind of stuff I do. Both as a hiring manager and a potential hire, there's no sense that they are bucketing me in either, we can potentially do either business. There's no sense of urgency either, just two people discussing the market. I've made business contacts through recruiters this way, nothing expected in return, no hard sell. I've told them we're not even using recruiters, and they still check in for a coffee now and again. I do try to throw something their way, esp when it comes to giving them candidates.
The big problem for the good guys is they somehow have to get paid while maintaining all these low probability relationships. Not only that, they actually need to speak intelligently about every technology and business in the market. They need to know what kind of thing c++ is, how it's different from JS, and what kind of function it might be useful for. This is no easy task.
You can easily see how someone needing to feed themselves could get desperate and go for some version of spamming.
- leerob 8y ago> The big problem for the good guys is they somehow have to get paid while maintaining all these low probability relationships. Not only that, they actually need to speak intelligently about every technology and business in the market. They need to know what kind of thing c++ is, how it's different from JS, and what kind of function it might be useful for. This is no easy task. Very good point. I have a few friends who are recruiters (with no technical experience before starting) and I had to give them the 101 on programming languages and how they differ ("No, C and C++ are not the same thing. There's also C#"). I can imagine a recruiter in today's landscape probably spends a decent amount of time learning about the tech industry just to keep up. I'm not sure I have a solution for monetizing the good relationships, though.
- scarface74 8y agoFor #2. I’ve had a recruiter that I first spoke to in 2012 after I was laid off. We kept in touch over the years and he didn’t get a chance to place me until 2018. I think the $30K he made off of me was worth the few emails he sent over the years. You only need about 6-10 placements a year to make a decent income.
- komali2 8y agoCorporate doesn't let you stop. Even if you hit the 2 placement a month kpi, your other ones don't go away (candidate calls, manager calls, cold resume sends). And I'd you hit all the kpis, they just give you higher ones.
- scarface74 8y agoThis particular recruiter was a partner at a small company where he owned it with another recruiter. I worked with another guy in both sides, from getting a job and hired people through him. He was definitely under corporate pressure. He would routinely send job descriptions with salaries and they were well targeted.
- joeax 8y agoI was actually placed at two different companies by the same recruiter, almost 10 years apart. Between the first and second time, she went from in-house recruiter to running her own successfuly staffing company. Personal relationships do matter.