5 ms·
I don't think anyone's ignoring evidence with vaping. Rather, vaping is (from what we know so far) legitimately a far, far healthier alternative to smoking cig
by crazygringo 8y ago
I don't think anyone's ignoring evidence with vaping.
Rather, vaping is (from what we know so far) legitimately a far, far healthier alternative to smoking cigarettes. The biggest health risk by far isn't the nicotine, it's the smoke, which vaping doesn't have.
It's been framed as a public health question since the very beginning: do the population-wide large health benefits of smokers who can't quit then switching to vaping, outweigh the (as currently understood) much smaller potential health problems with vaping, but which may be taken up by many people who otherwise wouldn't smoke at all? It's a balance of harms.
What I've heard about Juul addiction among college-age kids sounds a little scary. (But then in my generation it was scary binge drinking, and that's fallen significantly over the past 10 years.)
But at the same time, I've seen friends finally be able to give up smoking for vaping, which can only be a good thing given what we know right now.
- tantalor 8y agoVaping causes nicotine addiction which has the secondary risk using of tobacco products later in life. In other words ecigs is a gateway to smoking. Youth Who Use Vaping Products Are More Likely to Smoke Cigarettes, Increase Use of Both Over Time https://www.rand.org/news/press/2018/10/02.html https://www.rand.org/news/press/2018/10/02.html
- zeta0134 8y agoSpecifically, vaping with nicotine causes the nicotine addiction. But there's a really awesome alternative: you can vape nicotine free. Any decent vape shop will let you pick out the strength that you like, and 0% is an option. One of my roommates did just that, because he liked the social benefits: getting to pretend he was a dragon, hanging out with his other friends during their smoke breaks, etc. Of course this doesn't solve any potential other problems with the practice (the popcorn lung scare from a while back comes to mind) but in theory, if you simply must smoke, it's possible to do so without any nicotine at all.
- treebeard901 8y agoThe real long term danger here might be to get an entire generation hooked on vaping as a safer alternative, then remove vape devices from the market. That's a whole lot of potential new customers (nicotine addicts) for traditional cigarette companies.
- kgwxd 8y agoIf vaping is ever removed, I would think cigarettes would go with them.
- solarkraft 8y agoIn what world would vaping devices not be sold, but cigarettes?
- treebeard901 8y agoRecent comments about regulation lead me to believe it is possible. The government has already pushed to remove Juul from gas stations while leaving cigarettes. Maybe it is far fetched to say this approach could be expanded but I’m not so sure anymore.
- capitalsigma 8y agoVaping is illegal in Thailand, but cigarettes aren't
- moltar 8y agoVaping is banned in Thailand. And guess why? Right, because cigarette companies were threatened and they lobbied the government.
- madaxe_again 8y agoCorrelation, causation. That link provides nothing to say that vaping leads to smoking apart from the say-so of their analyst. It’s equally possible that their smoking leads to vaping.
- porphyrogene 8y agoThis is what ignoring evidence looks like. The study is very clear on how they gathered their data and how it was analyzed.
- capitalsigma 8y agoVaping among former smokers is clearly different from vaping among the tobacco niave: I know what cigarettes are like and I don't want to go back.
- madaxe_again 8y agoThis is what dogmatism looks like. The study is very clear that the behavioural flow goes both ways, and that this is a cohort rather than individual effect: “Models revealed robust reciprocal associations between EC and cigarette use, such that more frequent EC use at one time predicted more frequent cigarette use at the subsequent time, and vice versa. Between-person analyses showed associations between shared risk factors and both EC and cigarette use. However, shared risk factors did not predict frequency of subsequent EC and cigarette use in within-person analyses.” Please, show me where they say it is clearly causative.
- porphyrogene 8y ago> Please, show me where they say it is clearly causative. You are either being intentionally obtuse or you misunderstand the purpose of a study. This is a published study, not a Fox News article.
- madaxe_again 8y agoAh, resorting to ad hominem attacks because you can’t. Alright, then.
- dmm 8y ago> vaping is (from what we know so far) legitimately a far, far healthier alternative to smoking cigarettes. Cigarettes kill 50% of long-term users. It's reasonable to use that as the comparison if you're discussing smokers switching to vaping but it's crazy to use that as the basis of comparison for new vapers.
- astazangasta 8y agoI am having trouble believing this figure. Lung cancer incidence for heavy smokers is 20%. Where do the other 30% of deaths come from?
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoPerhaps emphysema and heart disease?
- dmm 8y agoIt's mostly cardiovascular disease. The CDC has a breakdown of yearly smoking deaths[0]. And the 50% number comes from the WHO[1]. [0] https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/health_effects/tobacco_related_mortality/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/heal... [1] https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/tobacco https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/tobacco
- mturmon 8y agoRespiratory diseases under the umbrella term COPD (which includes emphysema) are another large category represented in that table. And alas, in my family.
- GarrisonPrime 8y agoThe highest risk of death from smoking is due to coronary artery disease. The chemicals irritate the vessels, causing atherosclerosis.
- 8y ago
- sjackson1 8y agoFunny how people want to insist that vaping is not good but “less bad than smoking.” You know what’s even better than vaping? Not vaping. Cutting off your finger is not as bad as cutting off your arm. But I prefer not cutting off my finger.
- posterboy 8y agoThe vapor is a lot of water. Water in the lungs is never good. You have, from what you "know so far", no idea what you are talking about, with all due respect, Dr. crazygringo. Nicotine is still a nervous agent. How about that? "Smoking is far healthier than snorting laced crack cocaine" is a paradoxical thing to say. It's just the wrong choice of words.
- scythe 8y agoIt’s not water. It’s a mix of glycerol and propylene glycol. Before you tell someone they have “no idea what [they] are talking about”, maybe learn the most basic facts about the subject.
- posterboy 8y agoThat stuff may have 10 to 20 % distilled water added to lower the boiling point. Depending on the use pattern, that is a lot. Propylene glycol binds oxygen, when degrading. Glycerol is downright toxic. I didn't say that I had a clue. I said that you didn't. That's a fine difference.
- trevyn 8y ago>Water in the lungs is never good. Should I stop showering and going in steam rooms too?
- lowercased 8y agohow much water do you get in your lungs from showering?
- ryanlol 8y agoMuch, much more than you would get from vaping.
- porphyrogene 8y ago> vaping is (from what we know so far) legitimately a far, far healthier alternative to smoking cigarettes > given what we know right now You are making assumptions and drawing conclusions based on what you don't know. That's exactly what doctors used to do when they smoked in hospitals and what vocalists did when they claimed that smoking gave their voice a rich, deep sound.