4 ms·
> produced by a nation state Why do people always say ‘nation state’ in these situations? It’s not a fancy word for ‘major country’ - it means something specif
by chrisseaton 8y ago
> produced by a nation state
Why do people always say ‘nation state’ in these situations? It’s not a fancy word for ‘major country’ - it means something specific. For example the UK is definitely not a nation state. The US is arguably not a nation state either, due to its cultural and lingual heterogeneity and tribal sovereignty.
- ljcn 8y agoIt sounds fancier than "state"? Which is what was meant I think.
- kkarakk 8y ago"nation state" Dictionary result for nation state noun a sovereign state of which most of the citizens or subjects are united also by factors which define a nation, such as language or common descent. so you can call anything a nation state as long as that thing issues a passport i guess?
- chrisseaton 8y ago> so you can call anything a nation state as long as that thing issues a passport i guess? What? No - you just gave the argument against that! > are united also by factors which define a nation, such as language or common descent This means the UK isn't a nation state - we have four nations in the UK, with different cultures, descents, and in some areas even languages. It also means that the US is not a nation state - the people there have very distinct descents. Today Americans literally still say they're 'Italian' rather than 'American'. Many Americans don't speak English. The US literally describes tribal lands as 'dependent nations', so it isn't one nation even by their own federal definition. Examples of nation states are places like Iceland and Portugal. These are the major military players that the original comment was trying to refer to.
- dannypgh 8y agoIt's possible for a person to be a member of multiple nations. In the eyes of many Americans (USian), American most certainly is a nation. MAGA-style nationalism is quite popular and powerful at the moment...
- chrisseaton 8y agoYes establishing your own nation as a state is a goal for many nationalists. And you can see some nationalists pointing at Japan (a nation-state) and saying that they'd prefer their state to be more homogenous like Japan.
- Symmetry 8y agoKorea is one nation divided into two different states. And the Soviet Union was one state comprised of several nations which later split apart.
- United857 8y agoEspecially in American English, the term nation state is often used to disambugiate from a 'state' at the sub national level -- eg one of the 50 US ones.
- SCHiM 8y agoThe uk and us are definitely referred to as nation states in cyber Warfare lingo. I think the meaning is close to: group with lots of resources and strategic goal directed in that context.
- chrisseaton 8y agoThat's the same mistaken meaning that the original commenter is using. A nation state is a nation that is also a state. The UK clearly is a union of four nations into one kingdom. I mean - the clue's in the name.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoIt's 3 kingdoms, they are "united".
- chrisseaton 8y agoThey're nations. Why do you think Wales has a 'national' assembly if it isn't a nation? Why do you think they have their own 'national' bodies for things such as sports? Why do you think they compete separately in competitions like the 'six nations'?
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoWales is a curious one, I've tried to establish when it became a "nation" best I can do is some time in the last 100 years or so. Unless you're going to separate out historic county kingdoms (Wessex, Sussex, Kent, Gwent, etc.) then England annexed the counties that compromise the region we now call Wales as lands of the English Crown. The UK was initially formed by the Union of two kingdoms, England and Scotland at which time all the parts of Great Britain were under the same Monarch. Your contention doesn't necessarily disagree with this historical fact.
- jstanley 8y agoIt is 1 kingdom, which is united. It's "the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland", not the "United Kingdoms of Great Britain, Northern Ireland, and whatever 3rd one you have in mind"
- ForHackernews 8y agoFine, substitute "state actor" or whatever pedantic term you prefer. Jargon nitpicking is my second-least-favourite kind of HN nitpicking, coming in close ahead of "Boy there was an advert on that article!/Why U no adblock?" nitpicking.