4 ms·
I have trouble what to make of the article. Mainly because it itself points out the central hypocrisy. The US is just as interested in spreading its values by m
by Barrin92 8y ago
I have trouble what to make of the article. Mainly because it itself points out the central hypocrisy. The US is just as interested in spreading its values by means of entertainment media as any other country on the world, it just had more money in recent history than anyone else.
And with countries like China or India having a larger market, what does America want to do? Not let them invest in the US, accepting that different viewpoints will be expressed? Declare them invalid?
One of the positions that Americans broadly have always held is that when ideas are exchanged, the people overall can figure out what the good ideas are and what the bad ideas are, that's in fact the basic assumption behind liberal democracy. So if these Chinese cultural exports are just propaganda and all around awful, surely Americans will figure it out.
If there's something to them, and they're genuinely valuable and give a different perspective, then it would be bad to try to suppress them.
So by liberal democracies own standards, I find myself puzzled by the flat-out fear of foreign cultural imports.
- tivert 8y ago> So by liberal democracies own standards, I find myself puzzled by the flat-out fear of foreign cultural imports. The fear isn't so much about "cultural imports," but foreign control of cultural institutions. That control can be used to export different kinds of government censorship and other illiberal practices.
- door5 8y agoThe United States has done this for decades. Why do you think China blocks Google, Facebook, et al? The exact same reason. The difference is the US is substantially richer and more powerful than China is.
- newen 8y agoI don't think "Americans will figure out that something is propaganda" is a reasonable position to take. After all Russian propaganda via the internet was very effective, look at the 2016 election, and native American military propaganda is hugely effective.
- reallydude 8y ago> After all Russian propaganda via the internet was very effective That's a narrative, not a conclusion. It certainly wasn't effective in painting Putin as anything than the brutal dictator he is. I think you mean anti-Hillary propaganda, which there is evidence of...although it was so incidental (in spend and trend) that I'm not sure how this is still a news item. I guess it's just a red-scare-orangeman-bad proxy fight. Russia is not a friend of the US, but Putin and Trump are co-narcissists, dancing around each other.
- newen 8y agoStill, Americans are vulnerable to propaganda just like all populations are. And pretending that people can't be affected by propaganda because they'll think their way out of it is a dumb position to take.
- reallydude 8y ago> pretending that people can't be affected by propaganda because they'll think their way out of it is a dumb position to take Who is that addressed to? Who would pretend? Just the phrasing of that statement seems strange. It implies an understanding that propaganda serves a function. It always has, that's why the term exists. I didn't imply or assert that a population would "think its way out of it".
- defertoreptar 8y agoIt's not so much fear of cultural imports as it is about political influence from a foreign government. The article makes a good point about how "Seven Years in Tibet" came out before Chinese money started flowing into Hollywood, and how perhaps that movie might not be so easily made these days. There's something you didn't mention when you talked about how "USA wants to spread its values too." American companies that invest in Hollywood and sites like Reddit generally aren't partially owned by the government, and certainly aren't subject to as much government control.
- rdiddly 8y ago"Seven Years in Tibet" was made without Chinese money, so why couldn't the same movie be made today without Chinese money? It's harder because everyone else is taking Chinese money? I don't buy it.
- theNJR 8y agoCensorship by omission is a tricky thing to quantify. If a Studio gets, lets say, $5b a year from their Chinese investments, do you think they'd make a Seven Years style movie (even without the Chinese money directly funding it)? To personalize it, I had plenty of conversations with Chinese VCs back when I was raising for my VR company. I was incredibly aware of the meta implications of this article while writing it. Had I received Chinese investment, I'm not sure I would have written it at all.
- deogeo 8y ago"Make this movie, and you won't get any more investments from us. We've said the same to your distributor and producer. And we'll make sure every corporate board we have influence over will shun you."
- luckylion 8y agoAnd then the next producer will make it, enjoy the financial super hit and get super rich by doing it. That's how markets work, supposedly. If one company doesn't want to do something that is in demand, others will.
- deogeo 8y ago> So by liberal democracies own standards Given how easily wars on foreign soil are sold to the American public, you should be well aware that the US does not meet those standards. Few countries do.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI think as Westerners we are used to being dominant. I am German (now in US) and I wouldn't think twice if I heard that a German company bought a company in China but a chinese company buying a German company gives me slight discomfort. I guess I just have to get used to it. The world power balance has changed.
- gotocake 8y agoIt’s a contest, is that really a surprise? The hypocrisy is just the marketing spin on the contest for people who can’t accept that it is a competiton. If the honest question isn’t about right and wrong, but about winners and losers, the hypocrisy disappears.
- Aeolun 8y ago> So if these Chinese cultural exports are just propaganda and all around awful, surely Americans will figure it out. Hah! Yeah, no. I’m not falling for that one again. People will happily run themselves off a cliff if someone appeals to them enough, and damn logic.