3 ms·
I'm glad they won, and I applaud them for fighting for the good of everyone else. Thank you Cloudflare. Unfortunately by not going to trial, they didn't set a
by jedberg 8y ago
I'm glad they won, and I applaud them for fighting for the good of everyone else. Thank you Cloudflare.
Unfortunately by not going to trial, they didn't set any precedent, and sadly I don't think they did much damage to the patent troll system. Hopefully I'm wrong. :(
- Someone1234 8y ago> Unfortunately by not going to trial, they didn't set any precedent The article says: > We’re happy to report that on Wednesday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued an opinion affirming a lower court decision dismissing the case brought by Blackbird Tech.
- jedberg 8y agoThat's not a precedent. That's just affirming a summary judgment and saying, "Yep, they're right, we're not gonna hear the case either."
- Someone1234 8y agoThe lower court can set a precedent too.
- jedberg 8y agoIt can, but it made a summary judgment. My understanding is that precedent isn't set with a summary judgement.
- Someone1234 8y agoThe upper court's opinion was a summary judgement the lower court wasn't: https://blog.cloudflare.com/bye-bye-blackbird/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/bye-bye-blackbird/
- jmalicki 8y agoThe lower court dismissed the case following a preliminary motion before trial... How is that not considered a summary judgement? Edit: a dismissal is even less precedential than a summary judgement, as summary judgements come after discovery, unlike dismissals.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dharmab 8y agoThe lower court decided not to hear the case because the specific patent was unenforceable. That won't impact any future cases on other patents.
- tyingq 8y agoProbably creates a freebie template of sorts for suits using that specific patent. Supposedly Blackbird has many more though.
- matt4077 8y agoI’m not sure what your preferred outcome would be? A court ruling patents in general unenforceable is rather unlikely. “Patent trolling” obviously isn’t a legal concept, and would be hard to define. Any definition would actually just loop back to patentability, with exactly the result of this lawsuit.
- save_ferris 8y agoIANAL; how would a precedent help future cases like this? They make it sounds like the slow and expensive process of just participating in the legal system is what enables trolling, not the actual prior opinions of courts.
- jedberg 8y agoIAalsoNAL, but my understanding is if there were a bunch of opinions overturning claims of trolls, it would change the calculus of settlement and therefore make it too expensive to be a troll because of the high risk of loss. Yes, the long trial lengths are also a problem, and maybe an easier one to fix, by adding expedited hearings just for these things. But at the end of the day the trolls troll because the reward is greater than the risk.
- URSpider94 8y agoFirst of all, it’s not clear that they could have taken this to trial, as the judge didn’t see a basis for argument (that’s what summary judgment means). Second, there is no legal theory or precedent that I’m aware of that would factor in the troll-ish nature of the plaintiff in a patent ruling. Patent trolls lose because they are usually stretching to apply vague patent claims to a large number of targets. Finally, trolls have a heavily uneven playing field. Most troll farms have in-house counsel, so they have very low litigation costs. Also, they typically segregate every patent or patent family into a separate corporate entity so that any fee or damage awards won’t claw back overall winnings.
- pseudolus 8y agoThis particular case is explicitly non-precedential as is indicated on the top of the first page. The decision was made under Rule 36 of the Rules of Practice of the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit which allows the Court to enter a judgment without an opinion. The case might be precedential in the business logic sense in that potential trolls will have to alter their calculus to take into account that companies will no longer roll over and pay token amounts simply to exit litigation. Also complicating their calculus is an earlier decision from the Supreme Court (Octane Fitness, LLC v. Icon Health & Fitness) which effectively made it substantially easier for a prevailing party to recoup their legal fees in patent related matters.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- monochromatic 8y agoedit: I just noticed that the CAFC opinion is designated nonprecedential > The court’s ruling comes in response to a preliminary motion filed by Cloudflare under Section 101 of the U.S. Patent Act. That section defines what sort of things can be patented. Such motions are generally referred to as “Alice” motions because the U.S. Supreme Court held in a 2014 case (Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank Int’l) that a two-part test could be used to determine patent eligibility based on whether something is more than merely an abstract idea or at least creates an inventive use for an abstract principle. The Alice test helps to determine whether something is patentable subject matter or an unpatentable fundamental concept. Judge Chhabria found that Blackbird’s ‘355 patent was too abstract to be patentable subject matter. (https://blog.cloudflare.com/bye-bye-blackbird/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/bye-bye-blackbird/) This ruling was then affirmed by the CAFC. In what way is it non precedential? I sure wouldn't want to be Blackbird trying to assert that patent in a new litigation...
- howard941 8y agoDo you have a link to the Fed Circuit's opinion?
- apendleton 8y agoThe whole opinion, such as it is, is right there at the bottom of the blog post. It just says "Affirmed."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- apendleton 8y agoThe patent wasn't revoked. Blackbird can continue to collect from parties it has already sued who settled, and can sue new parties if it so chooses. The courts who hear those cases aren't required to respect the previous judgments -- the appeals court ruling even says "Note: This disposition is nonprecedential" right at the top. And even if courts would potentially find the previous ruling at least persuasive, respondents would still have to undergo significant court costs just to mount a defense, and many will still choose not to do so and instead to settle, which Blackbird knows.
- mamurphy 8y agoSummary Judgment is persuasive precedent. A higher court affirming Summary Judgment is controlling precedent for that circuit and highly persuasive precedent for other circuits. The ruling here is limited and narrow as to the particular patent in question, but it is precedent. Your hopes of being wrong are fulfilled.
- ceejayoz 8y agoThe ruling's first line is: NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential.
- imglorp 8y agoAlso Blackbird holds at least 73 other patents [1], some notably shitty, with which to sue the next poor sap. The sap doesn't even need to require buttock lift support [2] (I am NOT making this up!), for example, in order to be sued and perhaps pay the extortion fee out of court to be rid of it. The system is broken. 1. https://www.cloudflare.com/blackbirdpatents 2. https://patents.google.com/patent/US7081036
- pnw_hazor 8y agoThe patent was invalidated on common/conventional grounds. There is no new precedent here.