8 ms·
Opportunity's and Spirit's original missions were planned to last 90 Martian days each. They ended up lasting over 8,000 combined. That is almost as impressiv
by slg 8y ago
Opportunity's and Spirit's original missions were planned to last 90 Martian days each. They ended up lasting over 8,000 combined. That is almost as impressive as getting the rovers to Mars in the first place.
- hart_russell 8y agoIt's a testament to the engineering excellence happening at NASA.
- Will_Parker 8y agoAlso a testament to the value of under-promising. :)
- sizzzzlerz 8y agoThen that was the mother of all under-promises!
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoIf they make it over 9000 days, they can state the just did a error on the exponent
- Simon_says 8y agoThen the units would be time squared. That doesn’t make any sense!
- mattkrause 8y agoNah, just use scientific notation: 9e1 vs 9e3 days.
- Simon_says 8y agoOh, OK
- felipemnoa 8y agoIf I remember correctly the reason they did not expect the mission to last longer than that was because they expected the solar panels to get covered with dust and thus render them useless. I don't think they had banked on martial winds to regularly clean them.
- classicsnoot 8y agoYour recollection is correct. Consider too the dust accumulation predictions for the moon landing. It would appear that we (as humans) are not very good at dust estimates (dustimates?). This is reinforced by the continuing struggle/inability to manufacture dirt. As an avid composter with a ton (lol sorry) of experience, I can make you hummus for days. I can turn 90% of your organic household waste into growth medium, bokashi tea, or pre-dirt in anywhere from 6 months to 2 years. But if you want me to make dirt? I'll need a decade to get you a production level process that requires raw stocks, pre-processing, vermiculture, aquaculture, and many rounds of late stage funding. Dirt production stymies every modern industrial process because as it stands, you cannot reduce the time necessary for conversion from hummus to dirt. I find it beautifully tragic that terraforming Mars will require mass dirt transfer from earth (consider this tonnage conundrum and revel in the irony). Don't take my word for it. Go out and try to make earth yourself. If you can reinvent this fundamental, elementary process, you will join Jonas Salk and Fritz Haber, and very few others, in changing The Game in a fundamental way.
- mos_basik 8y agoKim Stanley Robinson's Mars trilogy talks a lot about the "can't make dirt fast" problem, and I was surprised and impressed at how fascinating such a mundane-appearing problem could be. I had never thought about it before. Note: I think you mean humus. Hummus is "a Levantine dip or spread made from cooked, mashed chickpeas... blended with tahini, olive oil, lemon juice, salt and garlic."
- classicsnoot 8y agoAutocorrect has outed me as a desirer of dips and spreads more so than an urban farmer. The shame and ignominy is overwhelming.
- Consultant32452 8y agoJust a humorous take... This is SOP for government projects. "No worries, it'll be complete in 90 days." 8,000 days later....
- Retric 8y agoThat story is very much over sold. They defiantly designed the things with a longer lifespan in mind. NASA simply had more reasonable minimum specks so if they died on day 220 nobody would call the program a failure.
- omegaworks 8y agoUnderpromise and over deliver :)
- commonsense1234 8y agounderpromise and way over deliver. This is unheard of.
- jacquesm 8y agoExpectation management is sometimes as important as the actual delivery.
- NL807 8y agoIt's pretty much what you do in any successful enterprise. Under promise, over deliver.
- goatherders 8y agoThat's just startup and sales speak. I've found that delivering exactly as promised is more than enough to keep customers happy.
- NL807 8y ago> That's just startup and sales speak. Nah, it's a method for giving you a lot of wiggle room if you (or your business) fucks up in something.
- slg 8y agoI wasn't just commenting on the physical durability of the rovers themselves although that is a huge part of it. It is also impressive from both a political and an organizational standpoint to keep a program like this running successfully for so much longer than initial plans dictated.
- Ianworld 8y agoI remember talking to a high up on the program at a FIRST robotics event who complained about them running so long. They weren't making any major new discoveries and sucking up resources and mindshare stopping him for kicking off and focusing on new projects. He said nobody would take the PR hit to decide to just end a mission like this so he was stuck.
- jessriedel 8y agoWhat's the limiting factor on just running with reduced staff support? (Honest question.)
- brandonjm 8y agoI had the same question, I don't imagine it takes too many people to decide what it should do and give the robot commands while monitoring it.
- Ianworld 8y agoLooks like according to an old article linked on wikipedia they spent another $100+ million over 5-6 years to keep it going. So not wildly expensive, but not cheap either. https://web.archive.org/web/20120504171453/http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21327647/ https://web.archive.org/web/20120504171453/http://www.msnbc....
- Rebelgecko 8y agoA small handful of people can still easily cost millions of dollars per year. And DSN time to talk to the rovers is expensive, probably in the neighborhood of $2,000 per hour.
- gizmo686 8y agoHow much DSN time do you need. Given the deley, I assume the only use is batch transfers, so cost per bit seems like the more useful metric (along with how much data is involved)
- seppin 8y ago^ this guy drives an accord
- JohnJamesRambo 8y agoI’ve never found it impressive, it’s a horrible padded estimate meant to cover NASA and make them look good. A real estimate needs to be useful and somewhat close to the actual outcome. There’s no way they were this off without it being on purpose. Imagine if your retirement planner or accountant was off by 44X in their number crunches for you. Would you say they were good at estimating?
- crushcrashcrush 8y agoJesus dude, can’t you enjoy a crowning achievement of human and American excellence? You think NASA is overly concerned about public perception to the tune 44x an original estimate?
- ngcc_hk 8y agoCrazy sometimes human could be. But let us celebrate instead.
- JohnJamesRambo 8y agoI celebrate the achievement just fine, it’s the horrible estimate that is shoved in my face constantly I have issues with. It represents a dumbing down of science for the masses that is just getting worse year after year that I resent. The rover isn’t good enough as is, we are told to be impressed by a nearly 50-fold wrong estimate that is all anyone knows about the rover. I knew it would be one of the top comments on this post. As a scientist I appreciate precision and good science, not hero worship and bureaucratic PR estimates.
- pault 8y agoIs it not acceptable that they were conservative in their predictions about the effects of Martian dust? I imagine they didn't have a whole lot of data points to inform their estimate.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- HALtheWise 8y agoJPL wrote a fascinating reflection on what engineering practices allowed this to happen. For any of you who have not experienced the NASA Knowledge Gateway, I would recommend. https://llis.nasa.gov/lesson/1743 https://llis.nasa.gov/lesson/1743
- fma 8y agoNice concise read. I think many lessons are well known but not acknowledged. For a high quality product...Test a lot, experienced people, do things in house. Meanwhile software industry is... Ship to prod ASAP, hire junior devs to reach head count, outsource to overseas and contractors. I realize the risks are different... But management gets pissed when software causes financial lost and wonder why.
- orzig 8y agoOne systemic problem is that the ownership and management of most companies shifts significantly over a 15 year time span, whereas the people designing a new NASA program know that they (or people that they care about) would be picking up the pieces if they are sloppy. I wonder whether family owned companies are closer to NASA in their testing/hiring practices?
- magicalhippo 8y agoThe 90 days was, as mentioned, a lower bound, not an upper bound. They were planned to last at least 90 days. Framed this way it's not entirely surprising they lasted longer, especially given the fortunate turn of events with the martian wind cleaning the solar panels of dust. This of course does not in any way diminish the engineering and ingenuity involved with designing and operating the rovers.