3 ms·
To be clear, this isn't even necessarily about "how Google violated GDPR". This is "why the case didn't go through a country favorable to Google". Aka, Google
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
To be clear, this isn't even necessarily about "how Google violated GDPR". This is "why the case didn't go through a country favorable to Google".
Aka, Google would've still likely been violating GDPR if they had a proper DPO in Ireland, but given how favorable Ireland is to the international companies it harbors the EU legal entities for, it's possible Google would've more successfully evaded punishment, had they been set up to ensure the case got handled in Ireland, rather than France.
- kasey_junk 8y agoFrankly, jurisdiction shopping was one of the big questions surrounding GDPR. You can be sure that legal teams are using this ruling to shore up their own documentation to make sure a random DPA can't bring case against them. Always better to be engaged with an enforcement agency in a country that collects revenue from you.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThe biggest problem with this is that the enforcement agency in the country that collects revenue from you has extremely more incentive to side with you, and not the consumer bringing a complaint against you. It can be a huge challenge to prevent a situation like the Eastern District of Texas and patent lawsuits, and that sort of situation can harm both sides.
- fmajid 8y agoThat's why there is a Court of Justice of the European Union.
- Mirioron 8y agoThe problem with being engaged with these enforcement agencies is that this is probably a significant amount of "bloat." Google would need to engage with all 28 EU governments on this issue. They didn't even allow a bunch of Eastern European countries to sell apps in their play store until a few years ago because they were that's insignificant.