5 ms·
Serious question: almost every economists thinks we shouldn't have corporate taxes. So why can't we just get rid of them and properly tax money as it LEAVES com
by onlyrealcuzzo 8y ago
Serious question: almost every economists thinks we shouldn't have corporate taxes. So why can't we just get rid of them and properly tax money as it LEAVES companies in the form of dividends or imports?
Recently, stock buy-backs are causing people to get around income tax, so we'd have to fix capital gains, too.
Taxing companies seems like a cop-out. It doesn't seem to have any impact at all on inequality. And it just makes American businesses less competitive.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- anonymous5133 8y agoBecause we've already spent those tax dollars by allocating them to some spending program. In other words, we can't stop taxing corporations and based on current sentiments going around....the taxes on businesses are only going higher. I agree it is stupid to tax businesses due to how international our economies are getting. Foreign companies can ship product into the USA but pay no taxes in the USA so they get an economic advantage by being in the lowest taxed country. The only tax they pay is import taxes.
- nightski 8y agoFrom my understanding the government pays for things by printing money. It's literally created on demand. Taxation and bonds/interest rates are partially used to take excess money supply out of the economy and control inflation (which is a highly simplified view of things).
- anth_anm 8y ago> based on current sentiments going around....the taxes on businesses are only going higher They literally just slashed them.
- nradov 8y agoIncome taxes go into the general fund, they aren't allocated to specific spending programs. Obviously any complete elimination of corporate income taxes would have to be coupled with a tax increase on high-income individuals in order to make the change revenue neutral.
- maximente 8y agoexcuse me? "almost every economist"? taxes serve as both revenue and incentive generation. turns out that when you have 0% corporate tax you lose the ability to incentivize corps via taxes. there are externalities e.g. pollution that one can no longer incentivize via taxation. you're also bound to hear the same excuse, can't afford to pay the labor now that their tax rates are higher, guess we'll move somewhere else!
- anonymous5133 8y agoThe pollution issue can be solved by simply regulating polluting businesses or just banning them.
- skookumchuck 8y agoTaxing pollution is a much more economically efficient approach than regulation or banning. You can't really bad pollution anyway. You and I exhale CO2, a greenhouse gas.
- skookumchuck 8y agoTaxing pollution has nothing to do with income taxes. Taxing pollution is "internalizing the externalities", not "they made some money let's take a slice."
- maximente 8y agoit does in the sense that if corporations pay 0% income taxes then there is no money that can be offset from e.g. pollution tax breaks. think about how the mortgage deduction influences homebuying behavior for private individuals.
- tracker1 8y agoWell, if you're charged roughly X per kwH for energy, and Y for each # of waste your company produces, this encourages cutting those costs beyond the costs of those parts alone. This would have a more direct effect than simple income tax incentives and be more direct. There's still an incentive, it's just it's not tethered to income which has MANY ways to work around in other ways with the current structure and the companies wind up not reducing pollution and waste.
- octonion 8y agoWe shouldn't care what economists think, only what they can prove. Evidence-based policy is what is needed.
- 2019ideas 8y ago>HN is very liberal >HN believes in MMT >MMT is unproven Not sure whats going to happen to your post.
- pas 8y agoEconomists prefer models and policies based on models, based on data. Of course economic data is usually statistical in nature, so interpretation leaves a pretty wide margin for personal biases to influence model/policy selection, but that doesn't mean economics is not evidence based. Proving things is only possible withing a model. That's easy. Arguing for and finding the right model is hard.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoIf you have a choice between A and B, and can't "prove" (what?) B is better, that doesn't mean you should choose A.
- tracker1 8y agoMost corporations don't pay taxes... it would be simpler to just remove the taxes as a whole and remove incentives around holding onto underutilized and unutilized capital. That would lead to either an expanding economy or payouts to those who then would be paying taxes.
- smileysteve 8y ago+1 The best rebuttals I've heard are 1. Potentially reduces accounting compliance (but the argument is that public companies have this either way) 2. Less frequent taxation (only when owners have capital gains) 3. Creates a greyer area for business expenses, that businesses might fight 4. Regulatory market that REITs currently enjoy (that effectively have this) The major arguments for it are transparency, simplification, more progressive passive income taxes.
- Felz 8y agoThe implicit argument #5 is that a lot of people would be upset if corporations weren't taxed, because it wouldn't be "fair". I might be wrong, but I think the system is currently structured such that corporate taxes are mostly a sham anyway; when they pay out dividends, those are taxed at a lower rate to make up for the corporate tax. This is probably anti-progressive because poor people aren't incentivized to invest in businesses, as they'd be effectively taxed closer to rich people rates. Really, a surprising amount of screwy and circuitous things in our civilization are a direct result of income taxes.
- clairity 8y agogetting rid of corporate tax would simply increase inequality, because wealthier individuals can employ corporations more effectively to gain even more advantage. if you equalize tax treatment (not just rates, but other things like carryforwards) across people, corporations, and capital, wealthy folks wouldn't be able to game the differences like they do now. international competition can be addressed with tariffs, which is already quite prevalent but are used for petty politics rather than to level the playing field in international trade.
- nightski 8y agoHow would they do that though? You can't take money out of a corporation without it being taxed as income? At some point it's going to be taxed. I agree capital gains rates could use a second look but I don't see this big "wealth loophole".
- a_c_s 8y agoHow about this example: a corporation buys a yacht that the CEO has exclusive use of and lives on. Now the CEO gets full food & board & luxury sea transportation provided. The CEO's salary is $1. The CEO is taking untaxed value out of the corporation but paying no income tax. If the corporation pays no taxes either, then the staff of the yacht will be paying more taxes than the CEO & corporation combined!
- aidenn0 8y agoAside from the fact that this is illegal under the current rules (most perquisites are considered income by the IRS), the yacht is an expense, so reduces the taxes the corporation pays under today's rules.
- seanalltogether 8y agoCorporate car leases, corporate hotel stays, corporate supplied breakfasts and lunches, corporate sponsored day care, corporate tickets to games/performances. There are a lot of lifestyle perks that can be justified as a cost of doing business.
- mr_overalls 8y ago> almost every economists thinks we shouldn't have corporate taxes. My understanding is that this issue is still robustly debated among economists. Do you have a citation for this?
- ileri62 8y agoI bet he means western economists aka lobbyists
- arthurcolle 8y agoI asked the same question and I'm still waiting for a reply. I won't hold my breath
- tivert 8y ago> almost every economists thinks we shouldn't have corporate taxes Name names, please.
- bedhead 8y agoBuybacks don't "get around" income tax since buybacks in no way affect taxable income or tax rate at the corporate level. However, buybacks could (hopefully) boost the value of the stock, in which case shareholders pay more in capital gains taxes when the stock is sold, so indirectly, buybacks are sometimes effectively taxed already. I would also note that no other country in the world taxes buybacks. This whole buyback debate in the last few days is frankly bizarre and just shows how many people are financially illiterate.
- etnos 8y ago> almost every economists thinks we shouldn't have corporate taxes. Almost every economists graduated from harvard or other big profile university, which happens to have heavy corporate sponsorship and ties. Jeeez wonder why!? Listen I hate the expert bashing as much as anyone, but when you give a context of late capitalism corrupting everything, well...
- anth_anm 8y agoCapital gains should be taxed as normal income.
- briandear 8y ago“The tax on capital gains directly affects investment decisions, the mobility and flow risk of capital.. the ease and difficulty experienced by new ventures in obtaining capital, and thereby the strength and potential for growth in the economy.” — President John F. Kennedy, 1963 Myopic egalitarianism on taxes would have ruinous affects on all levels of society. The incentive structures that determine how we allocate capital determine how dynamic our economy is and thus the opportunities for working and middle-class Americans. Lower capital gains taxes encourages skilled investors to reallocate capital to promising projects, ensuring capital goes to the companies most likely to create jobs as they innovate and scale. Better investment of capital literally results in higher wages, superior goods, and a more sustainable tax base. The maximum capital gains tax in the US is already one of the highest in the developed world. It should be zero, like Singapore, Hong Kong, and a dozen other OECD countries. Taxing capital gains as ordinary income would freeze long term investments in place. This is the “lock-in effect.” When capital gains taxes are high, the tax penalty discourages investors from moving their money to potentially better investments. Obama said raising capital gains taxes was “fair.” However, that sounds good to voters that don’t know any better while it would be disastrous in practice. His statement was catnip to the economically ignorant just like “build the wall” is catnip to the right-wing. Both ideas are of questionable benefit while the potential for unintended consequences are somewhat infinite. Of course there are those that actually want the US economy to get worse in order to bolster anti-capitalist arguments. So perhaps the negative effects of taxing capital gains as ordinary income is a desirable outcome for those who suggest it. A bit cynical, however, how else could it be explained: if raising capital gains taxes is bad for the economy as Kennedy and economists say, why would anyone support it? They’re either badly informed or perfectly informed and malicious.
- anth_anm 8y agoIt irks me that you're allowed to effectively call me stupid but any response would get me in trouble. Appealing to the authority of rich white dudes on this topic is not at all convincing.
- ludwig22 8y agoSo corporations are people but without income taxes? How can I declare myself a corporation?
- sdinsn 8y ago> almost every economists thinks we shouldn't have corporate taxes Source?
- candybar 8y agoThis effectively removes income tax entirely for rich people. I can simply create a corporation and never take money out of it. If I need to spend money, I can just borrow (whether directly from the corporation or indirectly). Even if you remove the latter loophole somehow, you're effectively only taxing consumption, which is highly regressive.
- arthurcolle 8y ago> Serious question: almost every economists thinks we shouldn't have corporate taxes. Oh yeah? Got some evidence for that claim?