3 ms·
The resistance of bad designers against codification of design is astonishing. Good designers recognize that there is a language to design, based in culture. Go
by moron4hire 16y ago
The resistance of bad designers against codification of design is astonishing. Good designers recognize that there is a language to design, based in culture. Good design doesn't just happen in a vacuum, radiating fully-formed from betwixt the ears of the design-genius. It has to communicate with the consumer, and that communication has to be effective. It's a similar sort of attitude that we see amongst bad programmers, insisting that day-to-day programming has nothing to do with mathematics.
Example: a bad designer would say that abstract paintings can mean anything. A painting of overlapping dark blue orbs could represent anger, or frustration, or happiness. Such a statement would be not only be completely wrong, but downright troubling as to the artists' culturally insensitivity. In Occidental culture, we often use bright reds to represent anger and frustration, and light blues and pinks make happy feelings.
Another example: in Japanese culture, white is often symbolic of death. If you're designing a hero character, you will either refrain from dressing the character in white, or you will intentionally dress the character in white, knowing that you seek to make the character an anti-hero. But you cannot effectively make that decision unless you understand the visual language of that culture.
The extent to which design cannot be codified by a designer is the extent to which that designer does not understand the culture for which she or he is designing. Every element of design is communicating a piece of information. Every element. That the designer does not understand what a particular element is communicating -- either at all or only on a subconscious level -- does not change the fact that it is there.
Art and science are not mutually exclusive pursuits, they are fundamentally intertwined parts of the creation and understanding process. Even advanced quantum and particle physics requires some level of art in designing experiments. Or did you think that those folk at CERN know exactly how to prove and disprove every hypothesis they come up with?
Even Einstein knew a thing or two about design: "It can scarcely be denied that the supreme goal of all theory is to make the irreducible basic elements as simple and as few as possible without having to surrender the adequate representation of a single datum of experience.", which we often summarize by saying, "make it as simple as possible, but no simpler."
- joe_the_user 16y agoYou know... Can you cite have any example of someone even vaguely within the design world who would say "abstract paintings can mean anything"? Overall, I don't think there are many working professionals in any field who don't believe there is any structure to their work. I would strongly suspect that designers who lean on intuitive processes will still tell you there's a structure to effective expression but that they use their intuition to gain access to it. They may be wrong to rely on their intuition gain access to this structure but you're misrepresenting them if you claim they simply believe there are no rules.