3 ms·
Maybe that. But also the industry is oversaturated with game devs. And for AAA titles they're basically fungible. Need to stop graduating so many.
by Waterluvian 8y ago
Maybe that. But also the industry is oversaturated with game devs. And for AAA titles they're basically fungible. Need to stop graduating so many.
- munk-a 8y agoFor game client programmers I think this is the case, though experienced devs are hard to find and retain. The gaming industry really hits issues when trying to attract non-engine devs, infrastructure and server specifically. Due to the portability of these skills to... much better industry sub-segments a lot of talent here just jumps ship and leaves. As a former server-side game dev I was always supportive of my co-worker's rights (QA & Art in particular have a _terrible_ time) and I think this is where pressure to unionize is likely to originate.
- chrisseaton 8y agoArt has a hard time? That surprises me - if your artist leaves you can’t just hire someone with the same style can you?
- Waterluvian 8y agoFor larger titles you absolutely can. They basically write a "how you do this art style" guide, character design guides, etc.
- munk-a 8y agoAt my company we had an "Art Director" for each title that dictated the style to use, this employee was indeed highly valued (and only the longest/most loyal folks got picked for it), but the actual artists working day-to-day were quite replaceable.
- vonmoltke 8y ago> The gaming industry really hits issues when trying to attract non-engine devs, infrastructure and server specifically. Due to the portability of these skills to... much better industry sub-segments a lot of talent here just jumps ship and leaves. Back when I was actually interested in entering the industry none of the companies I found would even talk to devs without games industry experience, generally major shipped titles, too. That could be part of their problem.
- WAthrowaway 8y agoThe more people that could be even potential union members, the stronger the union's negotiating position is.
- manfredo 8y agoThis is not always the case. If there are a large supply of workers then many will be willing to work for non-union employers. In many cases, unions increase the value of labor by constricting the supply of labor. Unions can often be difficult to join. If there is a overabundance of labor, then the union has little negotiating power.
- yyyymmddhhmmss 8y agoIt’s not that simple at all. Take the film industry. There’s a plethora of young guns who want in on the Cinematographer’s Guild. Millions of them. And a lot of them are skilled as well! The reason unions work in film production is the risk companies would be taking by hiring thos without the proven experience. Tech is prime for unionization because of the way dependability would work. It could minimize hiring processes, minimize management costs, and maximize developer income, and quick! The only thing standing in the way is managers and will power.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> And for AAA titles they're basically fungible. I would have thought it was the opposite, and to produce a AAA title you'd need the very talented people - the experts - and they have more leverage to negotiate.
- pjc50 8y agoAAA is more like the old Hollywood "cast of thousands" films, like Ben Hur. You need a lot of people, but no individual contribution stands out. The overall look is determined by the art director: so you need only a few experts at the top.
- SeanBoocock 8y agoThe reality is a lot more complicated than that. Certain entry-level art roles are pretty fungible, for instance, and most of them are already contract positions or outsourced to other studios (in places like Eastern Europe and Southeast Asia). However, beyond a certain level of experience and in some cases, entire disciplines, there is a dearth of quality candidates. Experienced developers, who have a good reputation, do have leverage but usually not to the extent to equalize comp with what one would see outside the industry. I've seen studios have critical roles go unfilled for the better part of a year for lack of qualified candidates at the budget set aside for them.
- BurningCycles 8y agoAs I understood it, actual developers was the category least impacted by these layoffs at Activision.