8 ms·
I don't think it's a given that it will always be cheaper to avoid emissions. Long-haul air travel, for example, isn't likely to go electric anytime soon, and i
by DennisP 8y ago
I don't think it's a given that it will always be cheaper to avoid emissions. Long-haul air travel, for example, isn't likely to go electric anytime soon, and it could well be that the cheapest option is to absorb their emissions from the air and inject them into the ground, rather than producing carbon-neutral jet fuel.
If this technology really does get down to $94/ton, then a $100/ton price on carbon emissions is likely to give it a role. People can reduce emissions whenever it costs less than $94/ton to do so, and if it costs more, they could pay for absorption instead.
$100/ton CO2 would raise the price of gasoline by a dollar a gallon, which doesn't seem all that unattainable, especially if the collected funds are redistributed as a dividend.
- ebiester 8y agoOr add 100 dollars to the average cost of a NY-London flight, from my quick calculations. Flights would go up 50-200 dollars each way. That's not the end of the world.
- ancientworldnow 8y agoThis figure doesn't take into account radiative forcing which makes that 1 ton figure act more like 3 or 4 tons in actual heating capability. Airline offset programs always ignore this (in addition to way under pricing carbon offsets because that market is mostly scams built around green guilt). Even at $100 a ton, you're talking a few hundred of dollars of price increases to offset damages. This probably reduces the number of people flying which of course raise the per capita damage and therefore cost even more.
- stevesimmons 8y agoHow does it raise the per capita damage? Airlines are only profitable if they fly at high load factors. If price increases reduce the number of passengers flying, the airlines will try to fly fewer planes that are just as full as today. Thus the per passenger cost is the same. (... based on a consulting project I did 20 years ago on airline network economics/route capacity optimization)
- fallingfrog 8y agoBut if you're pulling the CO2 from the air anyway, why not just use the extracted carbon as fuel rather than pull it out of the ground?
- ARandomerDude 8y agoCost. The average American family uses 24 metric tons a year (at least as of 2007, but we're ball-parking here) [1]. The article says it's $500 - $600 to extract 1 metric ton of CO2. (24 metric tons * $550/metric ton) / 12 months = $1,110 per month. That's $1,100 for raw CO2. Once you factor in CO2 => fuel, then transport, delivery, etc. your cost is dramatically higher. Suppose scale could help and the entire process were $1,110 per month. For for most of us, that's still much more than we pay each month in electricity + gas. 1. http://blogs.edf.org/climate411/2007/02/20/picturing-a-ton-of-co2/ http://blogs.edf.org/climate411/2007/02/20/picturing-a-ton-o...
- fallingfrog 8y agoThe parent comment was about airplanes. The argument was that batteries are too heavy and that airplanes will still need to run on hydrocarbon fuel. And the argument the parent made is: you burn the fuel in the airplane engine and then sequester it later. And my response is: ok, but if you're sequestering carbon anyway, then use carbon you just sequestered instead of burning new carbon. You didn't understand my point.
- jdietrich 8y agoAccording to the World Bank, America produced 16.5 tons of CO2 per person in 2014. Germany produced 8.9 tons per person, Britain produced 6.5 tons, France produced 4.6 tons and Switzerland produced 4.3 tons. Can we all agree that 16.5 tons per person is an absurdly large amount of CO2? https://databank.worldbank.org/data/reports.aspx?source=2&series=EN.ATM.CO2E.PC&country= https://databank.worldbank.org/data/reports.aspx?source=2&se...
- snuxoll 8y agoDoesn’t help that so many in the US have no realistic choice for transportation beyond an automobile. I’m a 90 minute walk from the nearest bus station, I work from home luckily (and have no license either) but my wife has to drive literally everywhere. We bought a used 2006 Prius now almost four years ago, so we’ve reduced our emissions as much as is feasible for now - but we still use roughly 300 gallons of fuel a year at 40MPG average.
- nradov 8y agoEventually I expect we'll use renewable power to produce carbon neutral synthetic liquid hydrocarbon fuel for long-range transportation.
- Scarblac 8y ago> $100/ton CO2 would raise the price of gasoline by a dollar a gallon I need to check that number... according to https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/co2-emission-fuels-d_1085.html https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/co2-emission-fuels-d_1085..., there is 9.20 kg CO2 released per gallon gasoline. So a dollar per gallon would be $100 per 920 kgCO2, close enough to a metric ton. OK :-)
- Retric 8y agoCurrently, up to around 50% as much CO2 is produced making and transporting a gallon of gasoline as from burning a gallon of gasoline. Some of that would be mitigated, but it’s probably closer to 1.30$ vs 1$ a gallon.
- thinkcontext 8y agoCalifornia LCFS credits are at around $200/ton, so if $94/ton is achievable they'll make quite a bit of money. https://www.arb.ca.gov/fuels/lcfs/credit/lrtweeklycreditreports.htm https://www.arb.ca.gov/fuels/lcfs/credit/lrtweeklycreditrepo...
- kaybe 8y agoIt still makes a difference when you move the CO2 to the stratosphere, which is what you essentially do here. I'm not sure we've run the models on this (without the rest of the changes), so I don't know at what point it becomes a problem, but we should keep this in mind.
- js8 8y ago> it could well be that the cheapest option is to absorb their emissions from the air and inject them into the ground, rather than producing carbon-neutral jet fuel I am not sure if you want to capture carbon or just CO2. If you want just to capture CO2, that's a different consideration but there is AFAIK no scalable technology that can store CO2 reliably. So what you need to do is to actually break the C-O bonds in CO2, which is very energy expensive. In theory you could burn methane (natural gas) or other hydrocarbon in system (airplane) A, producing more energy than needed by system (factory) B, which would recapture carbon from the air and convert it to pure carbon. That way, you would produce net energy by burning hydrogen into water (methane and carbon, respectively, are the most efficient choices for this). Somebody can calculate it precisely based on the enthalpy, I am sure, but it seems to me that the both systems together would have to be at least 40% efficient (that is the product of their energy efficiencies would have to be that) for this to be energy positive. I don't think anybody has demonstrated this level of efficiency yet, and it might well be impossible (if we also consider the dispersal of CO2 in the atmosphere, as somebody else has noted). Assuming this is possible (unlikely), in practice this would also require the operator of the system A to pay (at least) the cost of energy used by the operator of system B for the recaptured carbon. And this can be a practical problem, because people cheat in various ways and they would probably lobby to pay less at the expense of the environment. It seems much more transparent solution is just to forbid drilling for hydrocarbons outright. That's why one should be careful about using dollars for these calculations. All externalities are rarely counted in costs. It is easy to fool yourself or other humans this way, however, the nature cannot be fooled.
- comex 8y agoIt doesn’t have to be energy positive if the energy used for capture comes from a non-carbon-emitting source.
- DennisP 8y agoIt looks like the most promising idea for sequestering CO2 (rather than C) is injecting it into basalt formations, where it turns into minerals in a year or so. So far it's been tested in Iceland and Washington State, with promising results. Basalt is widespread so this could be very scalable. But it does use a lot of water; I don't know whether salt water would work. https://www.futurity.org/basalt-carbon-storing-conversion-1734812/ https://www.futurity.org/basalt-carbon-storing-conversion-17... https://www.bbc.com/news/world-43789527 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-43789527