4 ms·
There are many people for whom the UI is the only reason they continue to use IE, so I wish MS would just take whatever new rendering engine they now have and g
by userbinator 8y ago
There are many people for whom the UI is the only reason they continue to use IE, so I wish MS would just take whatever new rendering engine they now have and give it the same UI that IE always had --- they would certainly win back a large portion of the userbase who are irritated by the combination of either the familiar and comfortable UI with sites that don't always work, or sites that work but an annoying dumbed-down UI. Edge was from the beginning looking too much like a horrible Chrome clone (which it is sort of turning into now...) Not happy with the browser situation in general these days...
- mxuribe 8y agoI wonder in these cases if an IE-looking/IE-behaving theme for firefox would do the trick; sort of best of both worlds?
- Laforet 8y agoWhen firefox switched to web extensions a lot of the UI modding methods were no longer supported. I doubt this would be a viable route.
- cm2187 8y agoFor me the only use I have for IE is as a .net control to be able to access and manipulate the DOM in .net, for small web scrapping toy projects. I doubt the new Edge will be integrated as well as IE was (if integrated at all), so I will miss that when it is gone.
- mlevental 8y agointeresting. how do you do this?
- cm2187 8y agoAdd a WebBrowser control (which is just a wrapper around IE), navigate to the page of your choice, then you can access the DOM with methods like webBrowser1.Document.GetElementById("someid") you can trigger javascript events or fill a form like: webBrowser1.Document.GetElementById("someid").SetAttribute("value", "login") webBrowser1.Document.GetElementById("someid").InvokeMember("click") There are ways to embed Edge or Chrome in a .net application but you can't access or manipulate the DOM (or you have to inject some javascript, which is not as neat as being to manipulate it directly in .net).
- mlevental 8y agoit's funny i just started learning f# on linux and just last night ran into issues around add webbrowser as form control. thanks though i'll try this on windows
- cheschire 8y agoCheck out Blazor[0], and you can touch the DOM through JS interop. 0: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/aspnet/core/razor-components/javascript-interop?view=aspnetcore-3.0 https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/aspnet/core/razor-component...
- cm2187 8y agoI will certain look at Blazor when it has matured for creating websites, but I am not sure you can use it to scrap a third party website.
- ygra 8y agoFor web-scraping you could (for now) probably also use PowerShell with Invoke-WebRequest which runs the response through MSHTML, giving you fairly convenient access to various parts of the page as well as the complete DOM.
- cheschire 8y agoThere are also many people for whom ActiveX and NPAPI plugins are the only reason they use old browsers like IE. A lot of investment went into niche contracted solutions that are built in Java and Silverlight, and contracting replacements is a huge cost in the face of some abstract cyber security mumbo jumbo. Hell, those guys are screaming about everything all the time anyways, what makes this browser thing any different? /s
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoYou use a sarcasm tag, but your statement is essentially true. Ultimately it is most important to a business that it actually, you know, be able to do stuff, and if those 'cyber security' academics had their way then nobody would ever do anything because there'd be far too much friction involved. They forget that security is not an ends in itself, but exists in the broader context of doing things.
- smadurange 8y ago+1 for the browser situation nowadays. Sad state of affairs really. Even if some young guy looked around on the Internet seeking to build a new browser, all you see is advice on not to do it and use existing libraries, engines. I'm not saying it's untrue but it's not surprising that browser situation ends up here when that's the widely accepted attitude. But then again, wonder what would have happened if Linus Torvalds listened and gave up on Linux.