4 ms·
I think that if you believed in self-determination of people inside Crimea and put it to a vote, there is a decent chance the people would have chosen to be ann
by colechristensen 8y ago
I think that if you believed in self-determination of people inside Crimea and put it to a vote, there is a decent chance the people would have chosen to be annexed making it a justified act (but this is not what happened). This is complicated by extensive propaganda and other manipulation on all sides, and thoughts about the rights of Ukraine as a whole.
What is clear is that Crimea and Ukraine are being used as pawns in a global geopolitical conflict that has little to do with or concern for the people actually there. A significant portion of it is about power and popularity of leaders and parties inside their own state using the international conflict to bolster support.
It is hard to not have a dim view of international politics like this.
Taiwan is completely different situation. It simply does not belong to China. The rest of the world allows China to pretend differently but it is just words.
- cjhopman 8y agoDo you believe that China should be a country ruled by its current government? Or should the ROC control it? If the ROC shouldn't control it, then why should they control Taiwan? Simply because the invaded it 70 years ago and seized control? If China seizes control back today, will you in 50 years argue that the remaining Taiwanese separatists should just get with the times and accept Chinese control of Taiwan?
- colechristensen 8y agoI believe that China, Taiwan, and everywhere really should be ruled by their respective peoples. At least Taiwan seems to be doing a pretty good job of self-rule and nobody has a legitimate claim over that. Any gripes about 70 years ago should be pretty muted because most of the people involved aren't alive any longer.
- cjhopman 8y agoWho is a place's "respective peoples"? How do you feel about Native Americans and their claims to various land in the USA and the policies around reservations? How about native Hawaiian's various issues? Should Mark Zuckerberg be free to erect walls of whatever size he wants around his land and to seize the ancestral land of various native hawaiian's through the courts? How do you feel about the sovereign citizen movement? How do you feel about the state of Israel? I think that your position trivializes the complexities of these situations.
- cjhopman 8y agoIf Russia ships 1,000,000 people into Crimea, and then forces an independence vote where those russians can vote, is that justified? If the ROC flees from mainland China and overwhelms the people of Taiwan and then claims that Taiwan is not part of the PRC, is that justified? Would Russia need to just wait some X number of years after it shipped in the people to force the vote such that it would then be justified?
- Aeolun 8y agoIf those people are properly residents of Crimea? Yes, I’d imagine so. I’d have a hard time arguing against it anyway.