7 ms·
Doesn't matter. I work at a company that releases software there and we have to remove Taiwan as an option for a country when setting up your account or the pro
by gambiting 8y ago
Doesn't matter. I work at a company that releases software there and we have to remove Taiwan as an option for a country when setting up your account or the product simply won't be allowed to be sold in China. Our personal views on the subject don't matter.
- devoply 8y agoWe in the West should not tolerate this sort of behavior. I am sure if we wanted to we could force them not to do this by threatening them with sanctions on certain things.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoThe "West" has priced in a lot of economic growth into its debt. They are in no position to threaten China with sanctions, which could reduce trade. Need to keep those 10%+ returns coming for the underfunded pension funds. It couldn't even do anything about Russia and Crimea, much less China.
- prewett 8y agoThere are things more important than money. Maybe the China market isn't worth sacrificing one's values for. It's not like they want to you to succeed in their market, anyway. And if the company is willing to sacrifice its values, then clearly those weren't its actual values.
- chrischen 8y agoWhat values are those? The value of treating China as the enemy simply because? "The position of PRC is that the ROC and PRC are two different factions in the Chinese Civil War, which never legally ended. Therefore the PRC claims that both factions belong to the same sovereign country—China. Since, as per the PRC, Taiwan's sovereignty belongs to China, the PRC's government and supporters believe that the secession of Taiwan should be agreed upon by all 1.3 billion Chinese citizens instead of just the 23 million residents of Taiwan.[15] Furthermore, the position of PRC is that UN General Assembly Resolution 2758, which states "Recognizing that the representatives of the Government of the People's Republic of China are the only lawful representatives of China to the United Nations", means that the PRC is recognized as having the sovereignty of all of China, including Taiwan." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_status_of_Taiwan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_status_of_Taiwan Basically a bunch of the wealthy class fled to Taiwan, claimed the land, also claimed all of China and Mongolia (to this day), yet denied citizenship to the billions of Chinese people on the mainland (only overseas/wealthy Chinese were allowed Republic of China citizenship).
- Aeolun 8y agoI don’t think the origins of the country really matter. Present day Taiwan is a country in literally everything but name. That is silly in my opinion.
- CogitoCogito 8y agoI agree with you in principle, but I'd go further. The ROC certainly _is_ a country in name as well. It doesn't have relations with all the world's governments, but neither does e.g. the US nor the PRC. The origins aren't really that special anyway. The conflict between the PRC and ROC is really a conflict between two governments over borders. The correct parallel is something like India and Pakistan or North and South Korea. The PRC (mostly...also some people in the ROC) like to act like their case is some mystical historical wrong that must be righted, but it's really not special in any way. The PRC wants to annex its neighbor and uses propaganda in an attempt to make themselves look noble. It's a standard playbook.
- chrischen 8y agolet’s say there was revolution in the US right now because of the anti 1% movement. The 99%, having voting control of congress decide to enact some laws that greatly redistribute wealth from the 1%. Let’s say in order to protect themselves the 1% decide to all move to one city (new york), and take all their wealth with them, and form a new country out of this piece of the USA. Seems like a giant loophole because the 99% are still poor even though they’ve “won” the war for the US, but lost a crucial, albeit tiny, piece of land which contains the majority of US wealth. You can bet the 99% would fight to take back NYC as well as all the wealth sequestered there by the 1%. The fundamental reasoning behind China’s claim to Taiwan is not just the physical land, but also the claim of legacy wealth that was taken from China and moved there, which was why the revolution happened in the first place. A small but meaningful piece of the country cannot simply decide to setup a rogue government to avoid persecution from the law, just like how it would not be tolerated if a bunch of wealthy 1% decided to form their own country within the US (from US land they take) just to avoid being taxed.
- gambiting 8y agoWell, China isn't our only market, far far from it. It's extremely niche in fact - but users have asked us to make a Chinese version of some of our products, so we did. Alternatively, we could have said to those users that we won't provide a localised Chinese version of the product because of political reasons. At the end of the day, I don't make these decisions - I'm just a programmer writing code.
- saiya-jin 8y agoWouldn't it be enough to exclude Taiwan from the interface only for China-based IPs?
- gambiting 8y agoWell, it's a physical product. The version shipped to china is the only one that doesn't have Taiwan in the user creation menu.
- justtopost 8y agoMan, this kind of comment just baits godwins law.
- fipple 8y agoMy values don’t contain anything about Taiwan. I’ll call whatever you want because I don’t think I have nearly enough contextual knowledge to know who is “right” and “wrong” in that conflict.
- jobigoud 8y agoBasically from my understanding: at the fall of the last Chinese dynasty in 1912 a republic was created. Then after the communists took power, that republic exiled to Taiwan, that was in 1949. Current day China is still trying to eradicate that original republic.
- fwsgonzo 8y agoYou have a vast amount of knowledge at your fingertips. There is a difference between a dystopian authoritarian country like China, with "reintegration" camps for Uighurs and "re-education" camps for people who speaks out against the single-party system - and Taiwan, which doesn't. There is no both sides, and saying there is is incredibly disingenuous.
- jstanley 8y agoIt's pretty obvious that the Chinese government is "wrong" on this one. Whether Taiwan is a real country or not, banning references to it is just tyrranical. Imagine if the US banned you from selling software that made reference to the lost city of Atlantis. Clearly wrong.
- chosenbreed37 8y ago> It's pretty obvious that the Chinese government is "wrong" on this one. I don't think it is that obvious. Particularly if you take into account China's long history
- jstanley 8y agoRegardless of any country's history, it is not reasonable to ban people from selling software that acknowledges the existence of a country. Even if that country does not exist. Even if you don't take a stand on whether Taiwan is a real country or not, it is wrong to ban people from selling software that purports that Taiwan is a real country. How is this not obvious?
- oliwarner 8y agoYou don't "have to". You freely forfeited your beliefs for a sale. Certainly lefty idealism but the West has a limited window of influence to improve how China projects its power. 23m Taiwanese people depend on somebody saying no. To ignore the PRCs demands. We've already let 13m Chinese Muslims get sent to concentration camps. We broadly ignored the incorporation of Tibet. Great Firewall, political incarceration, no problem, China, just keep making our stuff and investing. Again, out window of opportunity to do something here is closing. Strong economic sanctions have to come quickly. But we also have to use every bit of defiance to resist behaviour that is clearly wrong.
- anvandare 8y agoPeople will avoid a fight they could easily win until it becomes a fight they will have to win. (By which time it might be too late.) Very roughly, the Western Ideal is to win wars by strength and decisive battles. While the Eastern Ideal is to win wars by endurance and maneuvering and, if possible, avoiding battle altogether. The latter is more realistic. (Permit me the pun: We may one day find ourselves readying for a Marathon, only to discover we've already lost the marathon.)
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> People will avoid a fight they could easily win until it becomes a fight they will have to win. (By which time it might be too late.) There is a good reason for this. There could be a thousand potential fights, all of which you would easily win. But if you had to fight them all, you'd get worn down, and probably lose one of them.
- pjc50 8y ago> the Western Ideal is to win wars by strength and decisive battles. I think a lot of historians would argue with you on this one, not least how the two world wars were both intended to be quick and decisive, but also since the invention of nuclear weapons what it actually means to "win".
- dalbasal 8y ago"the West has a limited window of influence to improve how China projects its power" There's an irony in that statement. The "limited window" is a window to project power, presumably. The current western take on Taiwan is that it's an independent country. That's not even uncontroversial in taiwan. Regardless, the current position evolved from the earlier one: the Taiwanese regime is the legitimate Chinese regime. It's complex and history-ridden.
- sinuhe69 8y agoI thought the solution is simple: just put China in brackets after Taiwan (China) and you should be fine? And don’t list them as “country”, use region instead!
- bloak 8y agoI think that's about right. It's just one of many cases in which you have to be careful with terminology in diplomatic relations. Other countries/regions that need to be named carefully include: Holy See, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Côte d'Ivoire, Socialist People's Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (some of these examples are out of date). In some cases people in the country/region have a strong opinion; in other cases it's people in a different country/region that have a strong opinion. Unless you have a good reason for having your own opinion it's usually best to just go along with these things and save your time and energy for something more important.
- Markoff 8y agoFYROM it's already Northern Macedonia officially and approved by Greece, you should update your map
- Aeolun 8y agoThen you don’t sell in China. Simple!
- Markoff 8y agoi am doing passive aggressive approach, when i see mention of "mainland China" i fix it to "China" since i am not aware of any other China, so word "mainland" it's redundant