5 ms·
(1) Bitcoin has not collapsed because it works well. No, it doesn't. It works only because less than 7 transactions per second worth of people want to use it.
by arcticbull 8y ago
(1) Bitcoin has not collapsed because it works well.
No, it doesn't. It works only because less than 7 transactions per second worth of people want to use it. It works well because it’s collapsed. We saw how it reacted when people did want to use it. inb4 lightning, to open and close a single channel for everyone in the world will take 68 years.
(2) The price is going up! Then...
(3) Stop focusing on the price!
Yes, everyone's got it wrong because in the same breath you tell us the price is going up then not to look at the price. Not to mention all the basic problems with it: the rampant manipulation you can't stamp out by design, the actively user-hostile nature, the massive deflation because everyone keeps losing their keys and all the features people want like chargebacks being stripped out of it. Nobody wants to be their own bank, it’s so hard. Then there’s the economics of it, my lord, ECON 101 level stuff.
Inflation isn’t bad because you’re not supposed to hold cash. You’re supposed to use it to purchase productive assets, like stocks, bonds or real estate which track and exceed inflation. It’s even good for borrowers because debts become cheaper over time. It’s a regular haircut for unproductive capital, the mechanism by which capitalism allocates capital efficiently. Money isn’t supposed to become more valuable by virtue of you just having it. Under your bird bath, of course because it’s not safe anywhere else.
Even the hardcore coiners on reddit have started admitting it’s sole value is hiding your wealth offshore out of reach of the long arm of the tax man. Or for the narcos!
Yes, it's going swimmingly.
- r32a_ 8y agoyour info is pretty old
- arcticbull 8y agoSure don’t provide any new info. “Wrong” doesn’t exactly inspire confidence in your case.
- topmonk 8y ago> Yes, everyone's got it wrong because in the same breath you tell us the price is going up then not to look at the price. You're a lot like a climate change denier. Just like there is a difference between weather and climate, there is a difference between short term volatility vs a long term trend. > Inflation isn’t bad because you’re not supposed to hold cash. You’re supposed to use it to purchase productive assets, like stocks, bonds or real estate which track and exceed inflation. It’s even good for borrowers because debts become cheaper over time. It’s a regular haircut for unproductive capital, the mechanism by which capitalism allocates capital efficiently. Money isn’t supposed to become more valuable by virtue of you just having it. Under your bird bath, of course because it’s not safe anywhere else. There isn't a "supposed to/not supposed to" argument. Cryptocurrency doesn't have to be something that is supposed to be anything. Inflation gives a currency pressure to be traded, yes, and being able to trade it easily makes it more useful, and hence adds to its popularity. But it's not the only reason a currency becomes popular, and the other benefits that cryptocurrency have over little green pieces of paper are IMO enough so it can continue to grow. > Even the hardcore coiners on reddit have started admitting it’s sole value is hiding your wealth offshore out of reach of the long arm of the tax man. Or for the narcos! It can be easily transferred anywhere in the world almost instantly, and ownership very well hidden. These are great benefits, even if they haven't been completely capitalized on yet. I'm not sure if Bitcoin or some other cryptocurrency is going to end up the leader, but I do believe that this industry is going to continue to grow. The cryptocurrency market has crashed and recovered 6 times in the last 8 or 9 years or so. All of your arguments had exactly the same amount of weight as they did the previous 5 crashes, yet the crypto market recovered and greatly surpassed even the weighty highs of the peak before the last crash. Are you really going to tell me that this time is different?
- arcticbull 8y agoI’m no denier, I have facts. The declining hash rate, the declining price, the exchanges going under, the 85% of dApps that don’t have a single daily transaction on average, the miners shutting down, going out of business, steam, Microsoft, Expedia all stopping supporting crypto. And the price too. It takes some serious head in the sandmanship not to notice. I will tell you this time is different in the same way you tell yourself on the way up each time it’ll be different and this time it won’t crash. What’s different this time is there are no new bag holders. They all lost their shirts last time around. The price relies on new bag holders because 1800 new BTC are generated by miners and then sold to pay the electricity bills. That’s $2.4 billion dollars per year in sales pressure. The more the price goes up the more the sales pressure goes up. $20K per bitcoin requires $13B in new bag holder money per year. $100K means $65B in new bag holder money per year. You sidestepped all the issues I pointed out: usability, intentionally built to prevent stopping scams, fraud, illegal activity. How it can’t serve the needs of the public. Nothing. Just more religious/MLM/ponzi sales pitch of hope, pray, moon soon. You even said so where you mentioned it’s a good thing your idle useless capital is increasing in value for NO REASON.
- illumin8 8y ago> The declining hash rate, the declining price, the exchanges going under This has happened every previous cycle. When mining becomes less profitable, the hash rate declines and difficulty declines until it reaches equilibrium. Currently 1800 BTC are being created every day, but when the next "halvening" happens I wouldn't be surprised to see an increase in price as all of a sudden the same amount of demand is competing for half the daily supply (900 BTC). If you look at past cycles, the "halvening" has precipitated many BTC bull runs.
- arcticbull 8y agoAgain you side step. This time side stepped that everyone’s now heard of and been burned by btc which was not true prior to the last run up, that my figures are still astronomical whether halved or not, or quartered, or eighthed. That major companies were burned by it. VCs were burned by it. That people have come down from their hopium high and realized blockchain in and of itself won’t solve literally any problem it’s thrown at better than MySQL will. You side step explaining why you think your money should be magically worth more over time. The question is whether there’s still 2.4 or 1.2 billion in new cash to add every single year until the next “mooning” which if were using your own expectations will be followed by an equally horrific crash. Why would we use that kind of thing as a currency?
- illumin8 8y ago> all the features people want like chargebacks being stripped out of it. Chargebacks were never stripped out because they don't exist. Bitcoin has always had irreversible transactions, and many people view that as a feature. Your argument would carry more weight if you didn't have inaccuracies in it.
- arcticbull 8y agoObviously it never had it that was my point. It was flowery wording for the bitcoin network having evolved from modern finance, in that its modern finance with features ripped out.
- krageon 8y ago"Modern finance" has these features because they are at their core an old boy's network of people saying "yes this is definitely okay". On top of that, it is running on maybe two distinct networks globally, both of which are not immune to just going down. It's then a bit disingenuous to say that it's "modern finance with features ripped out", I would say it's modern finance with a different set of priorities. Two of those priorities are reliability and verifiability, which are two features the current networks have absolutely none of.
- arcticbull 8y agoVisa is not reliable? They successfully processed 99.9995% (5 nines) of the last 319 billion transactions. [1] Marketing suggests they're working to get that to 100%. It's also totally verifiable, as it needs to be audited by the various regulators and industry bodies. It's absolutely both of those. To my knowledge, bitcoin just achieved 4 nines of uptime since the genesis block -- impressive in its own right to be sure. Bitcoin may not be so verifiable itself, right, after all, the longest chain wins and over 50% of hash power is located in the PRC. I'd say a strongly worded memo from Beijing that a new longest chain needs to appear is a bigger weak point than the worlds largest payment network with 5 nines of reliability over the last few decades suddenly decides to stop working, or that they'd stop scribbling down transaction data and avoid getting audited/fined/shuttered. That aside Bitcoin's real issue was never on-chain, but off-chain. Tether and Bitfinex aside, to get a real, truthful, accurate accounting of transactions within the bitcoin ecosystem the weak links by a country mile are the tumblers, the exchanges and so on. Their reporting data is, shall we say, far from tip top. Just ask QuadrigaCX. Old boys network or not, the up and comer needs to be better, not "just different" or "measurably worse." [1] https://www.datacenterknowledge.com/uptime/visa-s-uk-network-outage-what-you-need-know https://www.datacenterknowledge.com/uptime/visa-s-uk-network...
- LAMike 8y ago> We saw how it reacted when people did want to use it. The number of transactions today are as high as January 2018, but the fees never been any lower. If that isn't progress, what is? https://preview.redd.it/khdi0m4pq3f21.png?width=960&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=d658434e3fd77cdb828e93737fa19b57973d823c https://preview.redd.it/khdi0m4pq3f21.png?width=960&crop=sma...
- arcticbull 8y agoCan’t tell if this is sarcasm to be honest. SegWit added a small amount of breathing room without changing block sizes. Not increasing block sizes lead to the split into BCH, then further into BCHABC and BCHSV. The core decided to switch to lightning as the scaling strategy which is still capped at 7 tx/s which still requires 68 years to open and close a single channel for everyone on earth, net new births of course.
- mikekchar 8y agoI probably shouldn't let myself get dragged into this discussion, but I think BCH splitters didn't want lightning and used the excuse of not increasing block sizes to fork. SegWit's initial purpose was to fix the bugs that were stopping lightning. Block size was not increased because BTC devs want people to go towards lightning. They specifically indicated that block size might increase in the future. The fact that current transaction speeds do will not accommodate the entire planet is a bit of a strawman. Nobody needs that capacity right now and I think it remains to be seen if there will ever be the need. Not everybody who thinks BTC is potentially useful thinks that it must be used by the entire planet in order to be useful. Just to be clear, I think it's great to call out the scammers and educate the deluded. I just think that taking a binary stance of either it will work the way the scammers say it will or it's a useless pile of garbage is not a reasonable position. I think there are lots of serious problems with BTC, but as a proof of concept decentralised payment processing system it's actually pretty interesting. I wish the scammers would go away and let people work on it earnestly, though. In that way, I really thought that having the BCH guys go their separate ways was a true blessing.
- 8y ago
- b1r6 8y agoI just have to say, for your first point, it indeed does work... It's just that what it works for isn't what everyone's hyping. For buying things and supporting services that are illegal or culturally resented, it is working just fine, and has been for many years without interruption. :) EDIT: Oh yea, and currencies inspired by BTC like XMR are making such economic activity easier and more anonymous than ever. So it's always going to satisfy this niche...