8 ms·
A growing disconnect between consumers and businesses over use of customer data
- darawk 8y agoWhy exactly is ad customization immoral?
- salawat 8y agoBecause it sets up an incentive structure for advertising businesses to engage in sweeping and intrusive data collection and user surveillance. The technology that results is nigh indispensable from the foundations of a panopticon. Algorithms can end up exacerbating echo chambers, and reinforcing negative biases many people aren't comfortable with. And it's just bloody creepy when you sit down and think about it. That's just what I could think of off the top of my head.
- goldcd 8y agoBut it's no less creepy that Fox News/CNN/your news provider of choice, noting you're a statistical viewer and flogging adverts you're more likely to like, and employing pundits you're more likely to turn off. (and before this your daily newspaper and columnists) "We've 'been the product' from the moment we weren't the sole funder of what we received" Even when we were - "I've become a patron a fine artist, who's got excellent reviews for some Mona-whatsit thing" - he didn't go on to paint your wife ugly. Or even more banal examples - emergency plumber will charge you a callout, same plumber in non-emergency situation will pop around that evening to give you a free quote. Same plumber, same effort - just a different transaction.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoMany TV ads are also immoral. Taking advantage of emotions to trick people into buying things they don't want or need is immoral.
- darawk 8y agoIs that what's actually happening though? Is there any persuasive evidence that people are, en masse, being 'tricked' into buying things they "don't want"? It seems to me that a much more persuasive case can be made that on the margin, some people flip between this product or that for meaningless reasons, but for the most part, advertising informs people of the existence of products that might improve their lives.
- 345gxsagdf 8y agoAh, an ad person. I'm sure you can see this from the inside, the advertising industry has built a large surveillance apparatus in order to sell us thing we don't need. The whole selling things we don't need is already immoral -- but that's a general criticism against advertising and marketing; In this case we have something already dubious turned into a panopticon nightmare. As we grow closer to our technology, this technology is constantly spying on us to order to optimize selling us things we don't need. You can't build trust in technology when that same technology is grassing you out to every huckster who wants to pour junk into your eyeballs.
- darawk 8y ago> Ah, an ad person. I don't work in advertising. > the advertising industry has built a large surveillance apparatus in order to sell us thing we don't need. The whole selling things we don't need is already immoral -- but that's a general criticism against advertising and marketing; In this case we have something already dubious turned into a panopticon nightmare. As we grow closer to our technology, this technology is constantly spying on us to order to optimize selling us things we don't need. That's all a bunch of cute stuff to say, but where's the nightmare? Thinks seem pretty good to me. Do you want to go back 50 years? 100? Which point in history was not a nightmare, to which you'd like to return?
- pmoriarty 8y agoI'd argue that unsolicited advertising in general is immoral, and ad customization (or targeted ads) is even more immoral because it's more effective. The reason I'd argue that unsolicited advertising is immoral is because it's a means of enticing or perhaps even coercing people to buy things that they would not otherwise buy. It's an attempt to control customers to enrich the sellers and marketers. In certain cases, where spending or consuming is actually harmful to the consumer, advertising is even worse. For example, let's say I have an eating disorder and can't resist buying a certain brand and flavor of ice cream. If ads are not targeted and I'm shown ads of, say, motorcycles, I can resist those and not buy them, but if I'm shown ads of my favorite ice cream I'll be tempted to buy it, overindulge, and harm my health. Gambling ads seen by gambling addicts, alcohol ads seen by alcoholics, and so on can similarly be harmful in financial, psychological, and social ways. Solicited ads are more of a gray area, because at least the consumer would be looking to buy whatever it is that's being advertised, and they want to see ads. In that case, the best outcome is that the ads help the consumer make a more informed decision. But the reality of advertising is that ads are often misleading or outright lying, making emotional appeals, or trying to psychologically manipulate consumers in to buying the product or making positive associations with the brand. So even the case of solicited advertising is very problematic.
- darawk 8y ago> I'd argue that unsolicited advertising in general is immoral What does 'unsolicited' mean? Would you argue that human beings are ethically incapable of consenting to being advertised to? If not, what level of consent is required? Nobody forces you to use Google, Facebook, or watch television. > In certain cases, where spending or consuming is actually harmful to the consumer, advertising is even worse. For example, let's say I have an eating disorder and can't resist buying a certain brand and flavor of ice cream. If ads are not targeted and I'm shown ads of, say, motorcycles, I can resist those and not buy them, but if I'm shown ads of my favorite ice cream I'll be tempted to buy it, overindulge, and harm my health. Gambling ads seen by gambling addicts, alcohol ads seen by alcoholics, and so on can similarly be harmful in financial, psychological, and social ways. Sure, some kinds of advertising may be immoral. But I don't see much of an argument here for advertising in general being immoral. Often advertising is quite useful, in that it connects me with products I didn't know about that I might want. Is that kind of advertising immoral? Is it immoral when Dollar Shave Club advertises on podcasts to tell you how much you can save on razors by buying from them instead of the big companies? If so, who's being harmed?
- cuspycode 8y agoIt's immoral if you steal your prospective (non-customer) client data without their consent. Actually it's immoral even when the client actually is a customer, if you steal their data without their consent.
- darawk 8y agoThat is wholly distinct from ad customization. Collecting customer data is sometimes used for ad customization, but there are varying degrees of ethicality in collection.
- crushcrashcrush 8y agoCompletely un-scientific analysis; people don’t mind ad targeting if it’s relevant to them. Example - don’t show me ads for swim suits and beach umbrellas if I live in Montana. What people object to is the detailed, strange and onerous collection and dissemination of this data - eg, the location data controversy...
- goldcd 8y agoHowever if you've been furiously googling for holiday destinations in Maui - maybe I'd slip you some adverts for swimwear, but hold-off on beach umbrellas as you'll never get one on the plane.
- BucketSort 8y agoActually, from my experience, the people that get creeped out by this get creeped out the most when an ad is extremely relevant to them. I would also like to see a baseline of how many people think ads in general are immoral. We find it normal, having grown up with it, but I personally detest the constant psychological manipulation waged by ads in general. It gets even worse when those ads are personalized.
- a1369209993 8y agoI agree with your actual point, but from what I've seen, people get creeped out by ads that: a: are clearly based on personal information ("I just bought a washing machine, now I'm getting ads for washing machines."), and b: are extremely irrelevant to then ("I already bought a washing machine, I don't need another.").
- PavlovsCat 8y agoI'm actively reading ads since puberty or so, that is, I look at what they're saying, what they're trying to imply, compare with the reality, and what they generally are doing to language and communication. I used to consider it just being a smartass prick, a hairsplitting, literally-taking party pooper... but without knowing it, since I can think I tried all I could to innoculate myself against this: > Because we are lied to all the time, in ways so routine they are beneath conscious notice, even the most direct lies are losing their power to shock us. -- Charles Eisenstein, https://charleseisenstein.org/essays/the-ubiquitous-matrix-of-lies/ https://charleseisenstein.org/essays/the-ubiquitous-matrix-o... I take many things into account, but the judgement of those who aren't that active and hostile in their interaction, who just soak in it, is not one of those things. That many people do see a problem makes me think better of them, but it doesn't influence my opinion of the ad landscape, that's something between me and the ads.
- goldcd 8y ago"Do you want to be forced to watch an advert you have no interest in?" "Do you want to pay to have your advert shown to somebody who has no interest in your product?" The same answer to both these questions is why why ad-personalization is "good" - and why TV, printing and all the rest are having their collective arse handed to them by on-line. Now we can move onto discussions around fraud, ethics, leaking, micro-transactions and a million other things - but that study is clearly stupid.
- Tade0 8y agoDo you want to be forced to watch an advert you have no interest in? I wouldn't know until I watched it. As opposed to seeing an ad of something I recently bought. Do you want to pay to have your advert shown to somebody who has no interest in your product? How do we know that? Having no information about a given person is not equal to knowing that that person is not interested. It's not that simple.
- goldcd 8y agoYou're right - it's not that simple. To take an anecdotal example. I was slightly interested in knowing why so many people now took credit cards. Not 'traditional businesses in shops' - but food-carts/stalls, beggars - pretty much everybody. Tiny little calculator things I could tap my card/phone on. Even went so far as to work out which the best ones were, what rates were, reviews of the various companies - I was just interested. I then spent the next few months being bombarded with adverts for them from one company (the best provider, if I wanted this service). I just wished to could click to stop them showing me the advert - I DON'T WANT IT - please spend your limited money on selling to somebody who might. You're seemingly an awesome company and you're wasting your money. Or when I proposed. I worked out that a jewelry-maker usually just adds a fixed % to the costs to come up with the final price. I bought a 'modest' flawless diamond and then got my local jeweler to put it in a beautiful mount, for a fixed price. 6 f'in months over every page I looked at, being covered in diamonds. Each and every one of them wasting their money. Now in perfect data-mining-world, they'd have worked out I'd booked a wedding venue and a ring, so unlikely to need another ring. ...Actually, this gives me quite a good thought. All the tracking we have, is "one-way" - and it's hard to correct the f'ups. If we could maybe accept the tracking and learn to live with it, the trackers could be more upfront and ask us direct questions. Or at the very least have a "was this advert of interest to you" button. A/B test it obviously - as most people will say no to everything, but I'd be on board.
- gammateam 8y agoAnd this is why we have a represenative democracy instead of direct ones Let represenatives and legislative assistants do the real research before passing some emotion based law so often
- Cyclone_ 8y ago17% believe it's moral..but what were the options, e.g. was it something like moral vs. Immoral or was not sure an option? People might have very different impressions of what constitutes ad-targeting, e.g. technically going to a bikes website and showing a bike ad would be a form of targeting, not as invasive as tracking a person around the web. I would like to see a question asked like, should companies keep track of what sites you've visited so they can better advertise to you? IMO that would give a clearer picture of the situation.
- throw2016 8y agoBehavioral targeting which requires stalking people 24/7 and building invasive profiles is not only unethical but creepy, deeply dehumanizing and democratically problematic. As usual many are too blinded by greed to realize this simple fact, focused on 'innovation' and profit but once you dehumanize your fellow citizens its the beginning of the end. The tone of discussion on HN itself on these issues betrays the dehumanization and alienation from the general concerns of privacy, democracy and ethics.
- lapnitnelav 8y agoWould being able to create various anonymous profiles with interests that are only loosely tied to you be considered less creepy? I'm an industry insider and while yes, it's how I make money, I can't deny there are some creepy bits which should be a concern for all. But unless someone comes up with a better revenue model, most of Internet is supported by the Ad money. Be it the big players such as Google or Facebook, or the many modest operations out there. So we have to figure out a way to make it work, something that shouldn't be creepy but can still support the ecosystem.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoSelect ads based on the content/copy, not the individual user. No need to track me across the internet and planet.
- lapnitnelav 8y agoIdeally yeah, that would be the best but the supply and demand might not always match up. Maybe no advertiser is willing to spend some money on the content you're being served because it's very irrelevant to them or because there's simply no advertiser with enough budget to pick up the slack. So you end up with highly valuable spots and then the rest which is at best barely enough to cover the costs of the publisher. I'm not trying to blindly advocate for user targeted ads as the be all end all of online ads but the reality is that a huge swath of the publishers would probably disappear, consolidating the web even more.
- 8y ago
- cookieBaker 8y agoBefore internet became what it is today, Bill Hicks said it best: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GaD8y-CGhMw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GaD8y-CGhMw (2mn clip) /s ...( or is it? ) --edit for context.
- politician 8y agoIf a group is allowed to have sufficient knowledge of an individual through pervasive surveillance, then they can weaponize that by shifting the individual's Overton window through micro-messaging. An altered perspective is the objective of propaganda and targeted advertising and radicalization. Their methods and objectives are the same: make someone believe what we want them to believe without their awareness of the effort. This activity is underhanded and deceptive. It's neither persuasion nor debate, intentionally so.
- tantalor 8y ago> individual's Overton window Overton window is by definition a property of a group, not an individual.
- politician 8y agoAgreed; hence the qualification. The Overton window is the range of ideas tolerated in public discourse; restricting to an individual, it may be considered the range of ideas tolerated in one's private thoughts.
- pnw_hazor 8y ago100% of online advertisers and publishers that use online ad networks believe ad-blockers and tracker blockers are immoral. Online ads are cross-site attacks directed against viewers/users. They are visual or textual hacks that strive to cause targeted users to take actions they might not otherwise take. edit: speaking generally about online ad networks, real-time bidding providers, campaign aggregators, and so on.
- omarchowdhury 8y ago> to take actions they might not otherwise take. This assumes all advertising is coercive.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoOkay only some advertising may be coercive, such as, ads that try to change my mind, ads that try to convince me to buy something I might not have bought otherwise, or ads that try to encourage me to continue to act or feel in certain way.
- omarchowdhury 8y agoIf you don't want to participate in the marketplace then block the ads.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoI do. And, some sites do their best to remind how immoral I am for doing so. If the site is an ad-block denier, I just add them to my blacklist and move on with my life.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoJust like assuming all animals with wings can fly. Yes, there are penguins. But in general, both assumptions are true in 99%+ of cases.
- robbrown451 8y agoI suspect that this is a bit skewed by the fact that targeted ads, as they are typically done, are a horrible experience that has little transparency and that the user has very little control over. Some people are just going to hate all ads no matter what. I'd guess a much larger number (including me) would see them as a reasonable way to support web sites and services that they like, if those ads were to give them much better experience, and that mostly means more control. For one, I suggest that ads have a way you can express, with a couple clicks (and without leaving the page) one of the following: - I already purchased this - I already purchased a competing product - I am not interested in this anymore - I was never interested in this - This ad is too creepy or personal or otherwise makes me uncomfortable - this ad is obnoxious / distracting / ugly / disturbing - I don't want this displayed because it might reveal something private to an onlooker (example: gift purchase for spouse) - I'm not interested in this product but I might be interested in competing products - I'm in the market for ______________ and I don't mind getting ads for them - Thanks for the reminder, not now but maybe later - Ads that track me really annoy me Of course, in addition to collecting this information, it should act on it in a reasonable way. It would also be nice if it was accompanied by an option to pay a small, reasonable amount to remove ads. For whatever reason, ad companies don't seem to want to do this sort of thing. It may take legislation, which I would certainly get behind.
- lapnitnelav 8y agoIt makes a lot of sense and I'm sure advertisers would very much like it as much as you do (in this specific context that is). I mean, there's a reason this infamous quote is still relevant today: “Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is, I don’t know which half.” The real issue is the ad-ecosystem is afraid (and rightly so if I may) that people might try to game the system and would rather not bother. That and realising that out of your X thousands / millions monthly unique visitors, only a small percentage are an adequate audience will pelase neither the publisher nor the ad exchanges. Sure you could fall back to branding adverts but those are usually of lesser value.
- robbrown451 8y agoJust curious, how would you imagine it being gamed? I could certainly imagine advertisers or competitors gaming it one way or another (which is true today), but what about regular people? Do you think there is a rational reason someone would not want to express what they really think?
- spinach 8y agoTargeted ads can become creepy and offensive in lots of circumstances, such as when a woman who was pregnant has a miscarriage and still receives ads about baby items.
- mruts 8y agoI’m sure if you rephrased the question you would get much different results. It’s pretty easy to prime people to answer a certain way, especially by mentioning the word “immoral.” “Do you want to see relevant ads?” “Would you like to see ads for products you would never buy?”
- pnw_hazor 8y agoI have a couple: Would you like to see ads deliberately selected to trigger an emotional response in you to help overcome your rational resistance to buying a product? Do you think designing ads that take advantage of your emotions to sell garbage you don't need is moral?
- mruts 8y agoI mean, those are certainly questions you could ask. I'm just pointing out that you can get people to answer any which way by the phrasing. My wife is a research psychologist who designs studies and comes up with various questions to test a certain hypothesis. It's very difficult to neutralize priming by how questions are phrased. You often need to ask the question in a variety of ways to get unbiased results.
- Hacker_Support 8y agoHAVE YOU LOST YOUR HARD EARNED MONEY TO A BINARY OPTION SCAM?? DO YOU WANT TO RECOVER IT ALL? DO NOT GIVE UP, I HAVE GOOD NEWS FOR YOU!!! First of all, in my opinion, Binary options trading is dead — though few will mourn it, but recovery is 100% possible and many fall for scams other than legit hackers. Dearly beloved readers. We are gathered here today to celebrate the passing of binary options, the much-hated financial instrument. Traded by risk-hungry speculators, binaries brought riches to the few and hefty losses to the many. They inhabited that tantalising grey area between financial investment and gambling, luring us in with promises of mega returns and pictures of people on Twitter with Lamborghinis. Instead, most were left red-faced with empty pockets. Many hundreds of people around the world are targeted each day by disreputable fraudulent brokers. They deliberate target novice investors in contravention of the trading regulations. In many cases the investors who are targeted are completely unfamiliar with the markets and do not recognise that they are dealing with a bogus trading platform. The fraudulent brokers rely on this lack of knowledge to extract as much money as possible before closing down the account, cutting all contact and disappearing. The hapless investor then begins to suspect that they have been scammed. The targeted individuals have frequently lost considerable sums of money and their beginner status means that they have little idea of where to turn for help. Now, investors like you run to an unknown hacker who are secretly scammers to help recorver your fund of which you will be disappointed at the end. We are a group of hackers called HackerOne. We consist of top skilled individual hackers coming together to render services to as many people out there on the common web, we all have operated in the dark web and have carried out classified job so we're bringing our skills here to the common web cause we know how difficult it is to access a service of a real hacker out here. HackerOne has a track record of recovery in relation to financial fraud, with many strategies and tactics to compel the fraudulent broker to restore funds to their former clients, then extract your files and documents, Decrypt your Transaction Details and some Technical Hacking Procedures follows then you have your money recovered in Bitcoins. You Can Also Contact us for other Technical Hacking Services you desire Such as: * WEBSITE HACKING * PHONE HACKING (giving you Unnoticeable access to everything Happening on the Target’s Phone) * LOCATION TRACKING * CLEARING OF CRIMINAL RECORDS * SOCIAL MEDIA ACCOUNTS HACKING etc For further information, please contact us on our Email address bellow: >> hacktech@hackermail.com Cheers!!
- tomlock 8y agoExcuse me, everyone saying that we should enjoy ad targeting because we want to watch "relevant" ads - please consider your own thought process here. I worked in ad tech for a couple years on the targeting tech side specifically, and I can emphatically say that what people buying ads are optimizing for is not relevance, it is reach! Organizations should exclude people that have already purchased products from seeing ads for those products - but they almost unanimously do not. If relevance is what people want, given the data google has about my transport habits, shouldn't I see zero car ads? Or, is perhaps that too creepy? Or maybe, google has no incentive to make advertisers pay less money on useless, irrelevant ads. Or, maybe the marketing manager who paid for the ads doesn't care to optimize their spend because the CMO doesn't care to - both of them want to say they're responsible for the largest budgets and BIGGEST audiences ever (which by the way is the reason TV ad campaigns are still so prevalent, they look good on resumes). Do marketers have time to understand complex ML models with hundreds of variables? No. Biggest audience possible, please and thank you.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoWeird how fast this story is falling off the front page of HN. I wonder how many HN readers, patrons, or sponsors earn big dollars inventing, implementing, or promoting the technology that makes people feel that online advertising as we know it is immoral.