7 ms·
The Era of General Purpose Computers Is Ending
- jostmey 8y agoPerhaps the era of general purpose computing will come to an end. But what I see is a shift away from single CPUs supporting thousands of complex instructions to GPUs with simpler instructions sets capable of running calculations in parallel. It's more of a shift from serial to parallel computing than a shift from general purpose to special purpose computing
- mattnewport 8y agoGPUs typically have instruction sets of similar complexity to many CPUs, plus additional specialized instructions related to their SIMD model, plus a bunch of specialized hardware for particular functionality. I don't really think it's accurate to describe GPUs as having simpler instruction sets than CPUs.
- zdw 8y ago"Special Purpose" can mean so many things that it really depends on the purpose to tell if they're going to be replaced. For example traditional RAID controllers were replaced with software based solutions once there was surplus compute in the multicore era. If your workload can be viewed as "offload the CPU", there's only a matter of time before general purpose CPU cores are more plentiful and the need to offload goes away. Pure compute (be it traditional CPU's or some other vector variant that GPU/TPU offer) or latency sensitive tasks (some network, other FPGA, ASIC, accelerated tasks etc.) are only areas where non-GP can maintain a long term foothold.
- votepaunchy 8y ago> there's only a matter of time before general purpose CPU cores are more plentiful and the need to offload goes away The end of Moore’s Law means no additional transistors and therefore no additional cores without simplifying or otherwise reducing the architecture.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ianai 8y ago“That’s mainly because the cost of developing and manufacturing a custom chip is between $30 and $80 million.” I’ve heard figures an order of magnitude smaller for ARM. If so, the processor market needs to move beyond the Intel/x86 market corner before generalizations about cpu/gpu may be made. One source, not fully vetted: https://www.anandtech.com/show/7112/the-arm-diaries-part-1-how-arms-business-model-works/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/7112/the-arm-diaries-part-1-h...
- swagasaurus-rex 8y agoVery relevant blogpost: https://herbsutter.com/welcome-to-the-jungle/ https://herbsutter.com/welcome-to-the-jungle/
- dahart 8y agoWhile many valid points, they put GPUs in the specialized processor category to seal their argument. It is technically true, however the trend in GPUs is and has always been toward more general computing, and most computers have GPUs in them. I expect to see commercially viable CPUs with SIMD units (Intel tried and bailed, maybe they’ll try again...) as well as GPUs with virtual & shared memory any day now.
- mattnewport 8y agoGPUs already have virtual addressing and the ability to share memory with the CPU and other GPUs in at least some circumstances. What they don't have is automatic page faulting to persistent storage or fully shared memory with the CPU by default but that is for performance reasons. For most applications of GPUs performance is too important to want either behavior by default. All GPUs are basically full of giant SIMD units and the programming models increasingly expose this. They just don't have a common standard ISA.
- dahart 8y agoTotally agreed, automatic page faulting to disk isn't something you want in a GPU application right this second, but with Moore's law dying, I just expect buses to catch up. And you're also right the programming models do expose the SIMD nature, but at the same time they are becoming increasingly easier, and increasingly more flexible and more general purpose. At least I'm thinking of CUDA and NVIDIAs more recent independent thread scheduling; tolerating higher levels of divergence. I'm less familiar with AMD hardware, but I assume the trends are the same. Really, I'm looking at the trend more than any specifics or constraints of today. GPUs used to be only for rendering triangles, and only a small number of gamers and an even smaller number of graphics researchers cared. Today, the applications are way more mainstream, everyone has GPUs, and interest in AI and crypto and general high performance computing is rivaling that of graphics & games.
- mattnewport 8y agoThe thing is GPUs achieve their performance by embracing certain realities that aren't likely to change any time soon. The classic model of memory reflected in conventional CPU architectures tries to keep up the pretense that all memory accesses are equally fast through lots of levels of caches. GPUs have a model that recognizes memory locality as fundamental and treats general memory access more like IO - something asynchronous that you want to issue a request for and then find other work to do while you wait for a response. Fine gained thread context switching with massive parallelism mostly hides that from the programmer and saves them having to write an await on every memory fetch. CPUs also go to heroic lengths to try and make shared memory transparent with complex cache synchronization logic. GPUs allow you to do that to an extent with atomics but have a programming model that discourages it. That's a model that better aligns with the realities of hardware. Moore's Law was always about number of transistors, not clock speed or single thread performance. GPUs have kept it fairly alive in that regard. Even CPUs continue to increase transistor counts quite effectively, they've just stalled out on clock speed increases and ways to use those transistors to increase single thread performance and a lot of software still can't scale well by just adding cores.
- amelius 8y agoGeneral Purpose Computing is ending for another reason: Apple controlling its entire supply chain, and dictating what computing can be used for. If market developments continue along this line and competitors follow suit, then soon buying a PC for your research will cost you a lot more.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- newnewpdro 8y agoIsn't this more appropriately described as "The Era of General Purpose Microprocessors Is Ending"? A general purpose computer is the entire machine, reprogrammable to perform a variety of tasks, hence general-purpose. While I do think it's potentially coming to an end as well, I think it's doing so for entirely different reasons. The general purpose computer has become a somewhat niche device in that the public is increasingly interested in consumer-oriented appliances which just happen to contain microprocessors, like phones and tablets. They're often locked-down and only capable of running a blessed subset of applications available from select suppliers through a walled-garden. That's threatening demise of the general-purpose computer as we know it. I'm genuinely concerned that we may find ourselves one day limited to very expensive niche machines produced in low volumes having general-purpose capabilities targeting STEM-oriented uses. I hope I'm wrong here, but we're already seeing evidence of young people not even learning how to type because they never used a keyboard, it doesn't seem impossible. The linked article is talking about processors, not computers.
- segfaultbuserr 8y agoYes, I agree. I found the title misleading and led me to think about this https://boingboing.net/2011/12/27/the-coming-war-on-general-purp.html https://boingboing.net/2011/12/27/the-coming-war-on-general-... as well.
- tenebrisalietum 8y agoThe general-purpose computer was something most of the public never wanted. It just was that for the a while starting in the mid 90's you needed a computer to use the Internet, "AOL", or email in any way. > I'm genuinely concerned that we may find ourselves one day limited to very expensive niche machines produced in low volumes having general-purpose capabilities targeting STEM-oriented uses. General purpose computers belonged to tech nerds in the 70's and the same plus professionals/creatives through most of the 80's, and it sounds like it's going to go back to them. Honestly I can see benefits to this, it was nice to have dirt cheap hardware for a while but maybe things will get back to being more modular and expandable again. Regarding general purpose processing, I think RISC-V is going to save us here and keep a general purpose microprocessor around as long as anyone wants.
- Animats 8y agoThere are only a few things that parallelize so well that large quantities of special purpose hardware are cost effective. • 3D graphics - hence GPUs. • Fluid dynamics simulations (weather, aerodynamics, nuclear, injection molding - what supercomputers do all day.) • Crypto key testers - from the WWII Bombe to Bitcoin miners • Machine learning inner loops That list grows very slowly. Everything on that list was on it by 1970, if you include the original hardware perceptron.
- p1esk 8y agoThe list might grow slowly, but the last item on it - ML - grows like crazy right now. It's not unreasonable to expect that in 20 years the vast majority of all computation (from tiniest IoT devices to largest supercomputers) will be running ML models (from simplest classifiers to whole brain simulations).
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoIt's pretty unreasonable to expect that if you're aware of what AI winter is, and the fact that we're probably upon the cusp of another one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_winter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_winter Once everyone realizes every practical use of their AI technology is more than adequately met by conventional code, and that there's no grand breakthrough into general artificial intelligence coming anytime soon, the hype cycle will end.
- twtw 8y ago> Once everyone realizes every practical use of their AI technology is more than adequately met by conventional code I'm all for skepticism for the current hyperbole, but there's no need to be hyperbolic in the other direction. There are some applications in which deep learning really does work better than alternatives. The 2018 Gordon bell prize, after all, went to a team that did deep learning on Summit for climate analysis. There is a nontrivial list of applications that you would have a hard time convincing experts that they would be better off with conventional code.
- 8y ago
- deevolution 8y agoit's ending because we're approaching maximum transistor density. The market demands increasingly faster computers, if we're reaching the limits to how many transistors we can cram into a single CPU, ASICs seem to be a logical evolutionary step.
- npx 8y agoBased solely on the title, I assumed this article was going to be about Jeff Bezos. We're entering a brave new world where all compute is rented from Bezos and can only be used for the furtherance of his agenda. The recent tabloid scandal kinda speaks to the underlying problem. When given documentary evidence of a tryst between Bezos and a married woman, these people did the right thing and tried to blackmail him. Bezos somehow managed to turn this into a story about his endless accomplishments and his courage in the face of adversity! Bezos isn't even competing against other companies anymore because that would be too easy. Bezos is actually competing against the rest of humanity now. We're entering the era of Bezos Purpose computing.
- tyingq 8y agoAnother interesting trend is dwindling desktop and laptop sales: https://www.statista.com/statistics/263393/global-pc-shipments-since-1st-quarter-2009-by-vendor/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/263393/global-pc-shipmen... Plus, most non tech people don't need anything high end. So the percentage of Chromebooks, Celerons, etc, goes up. Then, on the server side, a lot of the chip sales are going direct to the FAANG group, rather than to someone like Dell or HP. Those two things do take a lot of wind out of better, generally available, general purpose devices for regular people and companies. A shrinking market doesn't usually improve quality.
- redisman 8y agoFAANG (at least Amazon so far) is also starting to roll out ARM-based servers which is interesting.
- scarface74 8y agoMicrosoft is also moving to ARM servers. https://www.theverge.com/2017/3/9/14867310/arm-servers-microsoft-intel-compute-conference https://www.theverge.com/2017/3/9/14867310/arm-servers-micro... And of course Apple ships 10x more ARM chips than x86 chips.
- peapicker 8y agoThe article says developing the TPU was “very expensive for Google” at tens of millions of dollars. That’s between one one-hundredth and one tenth of one percent of Google’s 2018 revenue. Not expensive in my book at that scale.
- jmount 8y agoEventually the specialized processing units get re-classified as general processing units, covered in "On the Design of Display Processors" http://cva.stanford.edu/classes/cs99s/papers/myer-sutherland-design-of-display-processors.pdf http://cva.stanford.edu/classes/cs99s/papers/myer-sutherland...
- patrickg_zill 8y agoThing is that before Windows this was the case. The sound card had its own Midi and sound effects chips, for example. Now reduced to one chip if that on the AC97 capable motherboard. The modems had their own discrete processor to handle the communication over the phone line. Now again reduced to a WinModem chip and/or a NIC or WiFi chip.