4 ms·
> Network transparency allows you to run an X11 application from any computer on your network and display it on your local computer. This is a rubbish point. R
by IshKebab 8y ago
> Network transparency allows you to run an X11 application from any computer on your network and display it on your local computer.
This is a rubbish point. Remote X may work OKish over a wired LAN, but over anything else it sucks. Not even NX uses the X11 protocol any more.
Honestly the only reason people even use it over a LAN is because VNC is so archaic and nobody has written a modern version. Wayland actually makes that easier though.
The point about crashing compositors is good though. Windows can handle a crash in the graphics driver seamlessly. I don't think any Wayland compositors can come close to that.
- CyberShadow 8y ago> Remote X may work OKish over a wired LAN, but over anything else it sucks. It depends entirely on the software. E.g., Emacs is great (and even kinda usable across the ocean), while Firefox and most Qt/GTK programs are much less so.
- zbuf 8y agoFor the Qt applications, try setting QT_GRAPHICSSYSTEM=native. I did experience Qt applications pushing whole window-sized bitmaps until I discovered this. Now remote $DISPLAY works well again. It seems the functionality is there, just the default setting gives poor performance over the network. I agree, good software works over wireless LAN with no issues. At my workplace this is used extensively.
- welterde 8y agoApplications that use X11 properly don't just work OKish over wired LAN, but work good enough that you can't tell it's not running locally.. One usual workflow is to ssh into a data reduction machine, do some reduction task and inspect the data products without having to copy them to the local machine or use NFS or the likes to access the files.
- j16sdiz 8y agoIt work really well until some time around kde3, when people start using client side compose and font rendering. Try something written in Tk.