4 ms·
Only 1 in 5 people with a penicillin allergy actually had penicillin allergy
- DanBC 8y agoI've submitted this with the title "Only 1 in 5 people with a penicillin allergy actually had a penicillin allergy". The title in the journal is "Implementation of a pharmacist-led penicillin allergy de-labelling service in a public hospital | Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy | Oxford Academic".
- dr_dshiv 8y agoNice. I've always had to fill in penicillin allergy, but have been skeptical. Now, more reasons to be skeptical.
- joshschreuder 8y agoYeah same here. My GP recently told me to check the symptoms with family (I was very young so I didn’t remember) and get administered a dose to test the allergy now if the symptoms were pretty mild. Haven’t got around to it yet but I’m thinking I will soon.
- caymanjim 8y agoI had a terrible reaction to penicillin during a bout of mononucleosis. I've read that it's not uncommon to have a negative reaction to it when you have mono, and that it doesn't indicate an allergy, so I'm not sure I actually have an allergy. I never had a problem with it prior to that. It was such a bad reaction that I don't want to take a chance, though. Every few years, I explain this to a doctor, and when I give them the details, they usually respond along the lines of "yeaaaaah, let's keep avoiding that." One of these days I'd like to get a controlled allergy test for it, but meanwhile, it gets listed as my only allergy to anything.
- detritus 8y agoHuh. Thanks for this - I'm in exactly the same boat! This hasn't really caused me any problem over the past twenty years since I was first 'diagnosed', but it would be handy to resolve in case it's not actually an issue at all. Mind you, I'd prefer to avoid antibiotics, and by the time I get around to taking a proper test, Penicillin may well be completely useless in the face of resistant threats anyway! Oh, happy days...
- firebird84 8y agoAll the doctors I meet are generally VERY risk averse. I explain something similar and they're quite happy to keep avoiding it.
- jazoom 8y agoI'm pretty happy to prescribe a medication if a patient wants to give it a go, as long as the previous reaction wasn't anaphylaxis.
- caymanjim 8y agoI'd be happy to keep avoiding it as well, since there are other antibiotics that are effective, however amoxicillin is still the preferred frontline treatment for a number of things. The one that affects me most is that I've had recurring ear infections over the past few years, and it's putting a real damper on my scuba diving. Anything that can fix me faster would be nice.
- jazoom 8y agoIt's well-known amongst doctors that giving amoxicillin for infectious mononucleosis can lead to a crazy rash. Is this what you are referring to? By the way, infectious mononucleosis is caused by a virus, so any antibiotic would be useless.
- caymanjim 8y agoIn my case it was more than a rash, it was head-to-toe full-body blistering. I still suspect it was due to the mono, which is why I'd like a real allergy test for it. It isn't something I'd willingly subject myself to a full dose of without supervision, though. The original diagnosis, either coincident or simply incorrect, was strep throat, hence the antibiotic.
- jazoom 8y agoYes. That's why antibiotics are erroneously given for infectious mononucleosis. It looks similar to a strep throat.
- assblaster 8y agoWhat's worse is that these false penicillin allergies have precluded the use of similar drugs such as cephalosporins, despite a very low cross reactivity, and worse drugs such as vancomycin were used as substitutes. Thankfully, increased attention will help to decrease overuse.
- mysterypie 8y agoIn case you’re wondering how people get falsely labeled as having a penicillin allergy, I have an anecdote: My grandad with a “penicillin allergy” was recently treated with a high dose of penicillin for 4 days without any problem. The hospital didn’t have access to his medical records and also overlooked what we wrote on the admission forms, and went ahead with penicillin as the best treatment. I asked my grandad about this allergy. He said that 40 years ago he had an upset stomach after taking penicillin and the doctor told him he was allergic. He’s been repeating that information to doctors and pharmacists for 40 years.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoHaving a allergic reaction once - from a disrupted / suppressed immune system - and having an actual allergy are two different conditions. When the majority of the masses falsely believe antibiotics are something you take for a flu or a cold, then educating them on fluctuations in immunity is probably too much to expect.
- jazoom 8y agoWhy would a suppressed immune system increase risk of allergic reaction? I'd have thought it to be the opposite.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI sit corrected. Thanks. The arc of my point was, the immune system isn't static. I should have done better. Again, thanks.
- pessimizer 8y agoThe US and Western Europe are extremely neurotic. All it takes is the mention that an allergy is possible to have for 20% of people to start claiming that they have it.
- mysterypie 8y agoLike the millions of parents who now think their children have peanut allergies for flimsy reasons.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoHuh. 98% of those 'de-labelled' went on to have no adverse reaction to penicillin. So, what about the 2%? Small study - was that just one person? What was the reaction? Did they die? It's important to understand the cost of a 'false negative' here. At the same time understanding that, NOT treating folks mis-labelled with an allergy has a cost as well.
- floatingatoll 8y agoNever summarize as “allergic” to a medical professional; they need the details. I indicate on medical forms that Vicodin gives me waking nightmare hallucinations, because it doesn’t kill me like an allergy, but they should be aware of what they’re in for if they do select it. (This straightforward disclosure has encouraged many years of good decisions by doctors who, I suspect, would rather not have my screams of terror interfering with their work :)
- dTal 8y agoI'm confused, why do they need the details? You would have had the same result (no prescription) if you had simply declared yourself allergic. "Allergic" == "don't prescribe, on pain of death".
- MiddleEndian 8y agoIn his case, the side effects are hallucinations. Perhaps he's OK with them being prescribed if the alternative is worse.
- floatingatoll 8y agoAs a highly intelligent patient, hallucinating nightmares put the hospital risk from me being highly intelligent and hallucinating. This benefits no one to call an allergy.
- unclenoriega 8y agoFor one, nightmares and hallucinations are not allergic reactions, and should not be described as such. And second, true allergic reactions can vary from a mildly annoying rash to life-threatening anaphylaxis. it's important to know the specifics in order to make a proper risk-benefit analysis.
- floatingatoll 8y agoBecause they’re making medical judgements that can kill me if they’re misinformed. If they withhold Tylenol for a fever because “allergic to Vicodin”, and I die from that fever, I will have died because I called it an allergy. It’s bad enough dealing with informed risks without creating uninformed risks too.