3 ms·
I am troubled by the lack of rational discussion of "capitalism" and "socialism" in the society today. Partially, this comes from the complete failure of modern
by dr_dshiv 8y ago
I am troubled by the lack of rational discussion of "capitalism" and "socialism" in the society today. Partially, this comes from the complete failure of modern academic philosophy to make cultural contributions. Part of it is from the weakness of a two party system that both seem to advocate for necessary and insufficient social functions.
The terms capitalism and socialism, on their own, are virtually meaningless, being shorthand for any number of specific policies. For instance: Are monolopolies a failure of capitalism or an inevitable outcome? Is capitalism stronger with or without monopolies? On the socialist side, is social ownership of the means of production necessary for maximizing the distribution of goods? Or are free markets and profit motives appropriate strategies for promoting social value?
Instead, you have the wall street journal treating socialism like idiocy and millennials treating capitalism as an obvious evil.
This is rather practical philosophy... So I'm disappointed things aren't further developed in our polical discourse.
- darepublic 8y agoUnfortunately people in general are not interested in discourse, they want convenience and novelty.
- yyyymmddhhmmss 8y agoThis is, of course, not a problem with “people”, but it is a problem with people in our current capitalist society. Capitalism inspires culture. The abstraction Marx provided for this is the base/superstructure spiral. It is simple and, well, abstract, but it is abstract to a degree that it remains applicable through the ages and more detailed conceptions map onto it, like critical theory and the like. Even post-structural critique really fail to counter Marx on this. I think Frederic Jameson succinctly described the experience of spiraling inevitabilities to result from capitalist/commercial culture with this phrase: All that is solid melts into air.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]