18 ms·
It seems like a lot of people are not reading between the lines of this post. Bezos apparently believes that he was hacked by either the US or Saudi government
by slg 8y ago
It seems like a lot of people are not reading between the lines of this post. Bezos apparently believes that he was hacked by either the US or Saudi government and that now one or both of those governments are using the National Enquirer as an attack dog against him. That accusation is much bigger than any other piece of this story.
EDIT: Here [1] is a reporter from the Washington Post backing that up. The Bezos' camp believes this is a politically motivated attack and the data was acquired by a "government entity" (logically the US or Saudis).
[1] - https://twitter.com/ndrew_lawrence/status/1093715333079318530 https://twitter.com/ndrew_lawrence/status/109371533307931853...
- jonknee 8y agoWhich makes stories like this a lot more interesting: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/mby7kq/malware-to-spy-hack-iphones https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/mby7kq/malware-to... > Saudi Arabia paid $55 million to purchase iPhone malware made by NSO Group, according to a recent report by Israeli newspaper Haaretz The Saudis really disliked the Washington Post digging into their murder of Khashoggi, it doesn't seem too crazy that they set their sights on the boss and ended up stumbling upon some juicy texts and pics. The really interesting part is how they got to AMI. I have to imagine there is a Trump connection somewhere along the way.
- danso 8y agoWorth pointing out that the only mobile device that Bezos has apparently tweeted from (publically) seems to be an iPhone. Doesn’t mean he didn’t have a burner phone for conducting his affairs of course. https://twitter.com/dancow/status/1093732934299856899 https://twitter.com/dancow/status/1093732934299856899
- inopinatus 8y agoGenuinely disappointed that it is not a Fire phone.
- gpderetta 8y agoThat would be his burner phone. ... I'll show myself out.
- eco 8y agoCitizen Lab (who uncovered a lot of NSO Group's work with governments) also recently had what seemed to be an attempt at character assassination targeting them. https://www.apnews.com/9f31fa2aa72946c694555a5074fc9f42 https://www.apnews.com/9f31fa2aa72946c694555a5074fc9f42
- samstave 8y ago>AMI I heard "amazon Machine Image" and thought WTF - are the AMIs compromised....
- ajhurliman 8y agoDifferent sort of image ;)
- jorblumesea 8y agoHouse of Saud, maybe, they are dumb enough to think this would work. Given their inept handling of the Khashoggi I wouldn't be surprised. I doubt anyone in the US intelligence profession would think Bezos would call off the WaPo because of some scandalous photos. "Just blackmail the richest man on the planet, that will totally work!"
- kw04 8y agoDon't underestimate how desperate people in power will get when they feel threatened.
- everdev 8y agoIt was fight or flight and Bezos chose to fight.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- atomical 8y agoCheck out the book The Billionaire's Vinegar. Plenty of rich people are willing to stay silent to avoid embarrassment.
- cm2187 8y ago> "Just blackmail the richest man on the planet, that will totally work!" Given the number of people and media who seem to be convinced without a doubt that Trump is being blackmailed by Russia...
- bredren 8y agoThis is the most salacious and wild hacker news I’ve ever read.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- scarmig 8y agoI wonder how Thiel will react if it turned out Trump directed national spy agencies to attempt to blackmail a rival oligarch to force him to provide favorable political coverage to their ruling coalition. Being the committed anti-tabloid blackmailer he is.
- atomical 8y agoHe would probably file this under "culture wars" and move on to something else.
- kkarakk 8y ago? Thiel targetted only one tabloid(a tabloid that previously openly outed him as gay with who knows what moral authority) by funding a case that another wronged individual cast against that tabloid. gawker was crazy stupid during that timeframe for whatever reason. you can't apply anonymous social media rules to your online publishing business and expect not to be punished.
- opportune 8y agowell last I checked Thiel supports Trump ideologically and the Saudis are large customers of his, plus he wants more defense/spy contracts so since he's so far proven to be a cheap date in terms of business, I think he'll just side with whoever gives him more money
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- blazespin 8y agoOne would wonder if what happened to the WaPo journalist was Saudia Arabia providing indirect payback for Trump. At the very least, that may have been part of the logic. "Oh, it's fine, Trump hates the Washington Post as well"
- joe_the_user 8y agoJamal Khashoggi was much more than a journalist, he was power player in Saudi Arabia. You might have heard of his uncle, Adnan, known as the world's largest arms dealer when he was alive. Over the last six-months-to-a-year, ruling prince MBS has followed the program of whipping the Saudi Ruling class into submission (metaphorically and literally, with electrical chords). Part of the problem is the princes were stealing so much money that the state of this incredibly wealthy, absolutist theocracy was approaching bankruptcy. Khashoggi left the country at that point and was acting as something like external opposition to MBS, clearly something the prince would not brook. None of this is to lessen the final brutal act but rather to explain it. If anything, the Saudis are probably extra pissed at the Post for "harboring" Khashoggi.
- toephu2 8y ago>"hacked" by either the US or Saudi government You think the U.S./Saudi government can remotely grab pics from an iPhone? Apple has disclosed lots of security info saying even they cannot do this. The iPhone/iOS wasn't built in that way. I think the leak likely comes from someone close to Ms. Sanchez, or she fell victim to a phishing attack (or account recovery hack).
- jonny_eh 8y agoA hack is a hack
- toephu2 8y agoForgot password is not a hack.
- jayd16 8y agoJust last week you could group facetime someone and get a audio feed without consent. Their security is not infallible.
- thecatspaw 8y agoRemember the fappening? It doesnt need to be remote grabbing, people just upload their nudes to the icloud. Maybe jeff did as well. While apple says they are end to end encrypted, I also assume they work with the FBI/whoever to catch owners of illegal content, so they probably would have a way to get the unencrypted content.
- gbear605 8y agoThe “fappening” was done by phishing, not a direct hack on iCloud servers.
- fauigerzigerk 8y agoPhotos and files stored in iCloud are not end to end encrypted: https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT202303 https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT202303
- paxys 8y agoPolitically motivated - 100% Government entity accessed them? I'd say it is much more likely that someone got the texts off his mistresses phone (whether willingly or not).
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoI don't understand, isn't a government entity someone who can get the texts off his mistress' phone?
- 420codebro 8y agoThe more likely case is said mistress is a loud-mouth bimbo.
- belorn 8y ago- '
- CloudNetworking 8y agoNobody said they've used sophisticated attacks to get their hands into that data, though. Why would a Government agency risk burning a zero day if they can just pay that lady or blackmail her with something else?
- belorn 8y ago>>> "Bezos apparently believes that he was hacked" Hacking implies a sophisticated attack. Not saying either government didn't do it. Following paxys line of thought I would however agree that hacking is not the most likely explanation in how the private data was taken. Social engineering is sometimes also described as an "hack" but I doubt that is what Bezos implies with the word.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- danhak 8y agoIt really puts this tweet from POTUS last month in a crazy new context: "So sorry to hear the news about Jeff Bozo being taken down by a competitor whose reporting, I understand, is far more accurate than the reporting in his lobbyist newspaper, the Amazon Washington Post. Hopefully the paper will soon be placed in better & more responsible hands!" https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/1084627451983073280?lang=en https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/10846274519830732... Strange times we're living in.
- thisismyusernam 8y agoStrange and terrifying.
- pjc50 8y agoTrump has been making transparent threats on Twitter since before getting elected. Until now they've been pretty empty threats.
- brisance 8y agoHe solicited a hostile foreign power to interfere in the 2016 elections. In many countries this would be equivalent to treason. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/video/2016/jul/27/donald-trump-russia-dnc-email-hack-video https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/video/2016/jul/27/donald...
- Juliate 8y agoI thought it was in the US?
- HillRat 8y agoThe factual and evidentiary bar for treason is quite deliberately high in the US; in this case, if Trump colluded with the Russian government it would represent a violation of campaign laws (and a scandal of historic proportions!) but (Russia not being actively at war with the US) not treason qua treason.
- eruci 8y agoif Mohammed Bone Saw is behind this also, then wow, just wow. His Highness is really dumber than a saw handle.
- sam0x17 8y agoCan't you just picture him being on a call with Trump and casually saying this was something he could do, and Trump being like yes please thus creating yet another Putin-esque blackmail situation. My gut says that's what this is.
- samstave 8y agoIf the CEO and Founder of AWS can be easily hacked by Saudis then what does that mean for the rest of silicon valley in general and 99% of YC funded startups who rely on AWS?
- opportune 8y agowell it's a lot easier to "hack" one person's iCloud account (in reality you just need a well placed personal assistant or employee at apple) than an entire cloud infrastructure without being noticed
- markonen 8y agoOkay, I'll bite: how would a single employee at Apple do this?
- opportune 8y agoIME if you are a part of an org/feature-specific security team at a team at large company you will be made aware of potential security flaws before they are fixed and merged in prod... so if some employee at apple learned "hey, auth tokens are being leaked in the usage data" they could hack basically anybody if they wanted to before the fix was merged and deployed to the public
- michaelt 8y ago1. Receive anti-social-engineering training saying they absolutely shouldn't do X. 2. Do X.
- baybal2 8y ago> If the CEO and Founder of AWS can be easily hacked by Saudis Was he actually hacked? Saudi LEO could've easily got those pics from Apple legally.
- akaij 8y agohow would that work?
- cm2187 8y agoGiven the open rows Trump had with the FBI and the CIA, that these agencies are filled with democrats and even republican sympathisers who think Trump should be impeached, and that an abuse of power is the very raison d’etre of the impeachment procedure, I don’t see how he would get to give such an order without the whole world knowing about it. Doesn’t pass the smell test. Foreign agency, different story. But there are enough people with a smartphone in the US that it doesn’t take a state-backed agency to obtain a compromising picture of a well known public figure.
- greendesk 8y agoReplied to a different comment - but the same question applies here. Are you sure that they are a single entity, where people are of uniform opinion? And every single person follows law to the letter of it? Trump could request this task unofficially from someone as a 'favour' - the agency as a whole might not have access to the request.
- laurentl 8y agoIn the second case, one might hope that those entities will check their audit logs and make sure no-one used the tools of the state for their own end.
- grumdan 8y agoWell, there were documents part of the Snowden leaks that showed how some NSA agents used the agency's tools to spy on (former) romantic partners and such, and I think he said something along the lines of this kind of thing not being prosecuted much. Sure, it's still a different level than a political case like this one, but it does call the internal oversight at the NSA into question.
- michaelt 8y agoIf I was the director of the CIA I'd cover up any internal corruption, to avoid being subject to additional oversight or public criticism. We've already banked the public trust from having audit records exist, actually checking the audit records can only reveal bad news.
- gyaniv 8y agoI really doubt that it was done by a US government entity. Trump is the president and all, but to hack and release (by a third party) the personal information if a citizen (not suspected or related to any crime) seems to me to be something that even Trump or his supporters can't do, the intelligence agencies just wouldn't do it in my opinion. The Saudis seem like a much more likely party to do it in my opinion, mostly because we know they are willing to do a lot worse against people they oppose (or who oppose them). That being said, I also think that playing the "A government hacked my phone" is a much better play on behalf of Bezos then claiming it was done by someone accessing his or Sanchezs phone (for example her brother who is supposedly a Trump supporter, like the link in the end suggests).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- greendesk 8y ago>>Trump is the president and all, but to hack and release (by a third party) the personal information if a citizen (not suspected or related to any crime) seems to me to be something that even Trump or his supporters can't doTrump is the president and all, but to hack and release (by a third party) the personal information if a citizen (not suspected or related to any crime) seems to me to be something that even Trump or his supporters can't do, the intelligence agencies just wouldn't do it in my opinion. For me it checks out - leaking informations sounds like something that Trump or his supporters would do. Why would not they, if they have the option to? Per the intelligence agencies - are you sure that they are a single entity, where people are of uniform opinion? And every single person follows law to the letter of it? There is the example that those services employed Snowden - if the services were so organised as to avoid such hacks, we would not have heard of Snowden. Sure, Sanchez' phone might have had leaks in it... but it is just as plausible as a government officials (US or non-US) accessing his phone.
- gyaniv 8y agoThere's a chance I'm mostly just being hopeful, and you're right in both that Trump would totally support doing something like that, and that the intelligence agencies aren't a single entity. >>For me it checks out - leaking informations sounds like something that Trump or his supporters would do. Why would not they, if they have the option to? Per the intelligence agencies - are you sure that they are a single entity, where people are of uniform opinion? And every single person follows law to the letter of it? There is the example that those services employed Snowden - if the services were so organised as to avoid such hacks, we would not have heard of Snowden. But from my experience in other government entities, I believe that doing something like hacking into someone's phone, would require approval and support from high enough officials in those organizations, and so far it seems that these organization do still seem to remain professional and not involved in political actions by the president. I agree that there might be (and I'm assuming there are) private Trump supporters in those agencies, that for example, would do 'a Snowden' and release classified and private information that they shouldn't. But that information first needs to gathered, and I don't think Jeff Bezos has done something to warrant previous gathering of information about him. (If information about Trump for example is released this way, it would seem more likely to me, because we know they collected that information while thinking he might be a spy). But once again, I hope I'm not just being hopefully optimistic in my trust of 'the system'.
- masonic 8y agoHere [1] is a reporter from the Washington Post backing that up In other words, here is one of Bezos' employees backing him up.
- elmomle 8y agoThere is a conflict of interest between his role as employee and his statements regarding Bezos. But there would be a conflict of interest between his role as reporter and his statements regarding Bezos. You're not wrong per se, but my perception is that there is a very good chance this person is telling the truth, given that in every case I've known of where a reporter for a major newspaper has disagreed with someone on a matter of record, they've been right. (NB that may still be explained by biases on my end and I'd love to be given a more nuanced view).
- c3534l 8y agoI don't think politically motivated is in any way the same thing as state-sponsored attack. That's quite a leap.
- creaghpatr 8y agoIt's a non-falsifiable claim, unless they actually catch and prove whomever did it. If he can get an intel agency (Amazon customers by the way) to say they are reasonably sure it was [insert hostile government], then it becomes gospel and an excuse to declare war or shake down US politicians retroactively for associating with that entity. We saw it happen with Russia in 2016.
- jessaustin 8y agoNot just Amazon customers, but WaPo customers. Every story in that paper with the slightest relation to national security or military spending is vetted and approved by the TLAs. It is exceedingly unlikely that these same TLAs targeted their good friend Jeff Bezos for this sort of abuse. If it hadn't been "dick-pics" [always a good idea, by the way...] but something less salacious we could possibly see it as some sort of convoluted "false flag" op. But Bezos is the good friend of these people. There is no way they would do this to him. If an underling did it without the permission of the top brass, that underling will be destroyed. As observed elsewhere, Ms. Sanchez's phone could have been accessed by any number of parties. It certainly wasn't "inside the firewall". So it could have been the Saudis, and those murderers have incentives to embarrass Bezos. It could have been the Russians. It could have been Amazon short-sellers. It could have been Wal-Mart. It could have been the proverbial fat guy in his mom's basement. At least Guccifer 2.0 hasn't come up. Pecker is a moron though. How could Bezos possibly respond to this in any other way than what we see here? Trump seems to surround himself with morons.
- chillwaves 8y agoRussia got their day in court and lost so I am not sure the equivalence.
- mcintyre1994 8y agoMore interesting context: both David Pecker and AMI have cooperation deals with Mueller, and have admitted to killing stories about Trump during the election.
- TheReveller 8y agoThose agreements are now void if they've broken the law.
- sevensor 8y agoIs that true? I know Manafort's cooperation agreement was nullified, but my understanding is that's because he lied to the special counsel. Which is presumably a crime, but it also violates the spirit of cooperation. I'd assume that in this case the matters are separate. But IANAL, what do I know.
- dwd 8y agoMueller allegedly has a nude selfie filed under seal relating to the indictment of the 13 Russian individuals and three companies. There must have been something more to it to avoid revealing who it was. But we don't know who Mueller's selfie was of. (there was a claim it was some random who was sexting Guccifer 2 but that doesn't seem like something worth filing) Maybe the better question is how or from whom he obtained it. Manafort or Cohen seem most likely sources as Mueller's got all their stuff or maybe the AMI handed it over as part of their cooperation deal. It's all a little weird as attempting to extort Bezos right now seems insane given the legal peril they are in. This may be worse than their part in election contribution violation they were previously on the hook for.
- buboard 8y agoindeed, however the evidence looks too amateurish for a state-sponsored attack.
- preommr 8y agoYea, just look at how well thought out the Khashoggi murder was.
- buboard 8y agootoh , bezos himself is wondering how they got into his phone.
- azeotropic 8y agoWell Kashoggi is dead and MBS got away with it. Moreover, MBS's enemies know know what he's willing to do, and what he can get away with, and may be frightened into compliance. From MBS's perspective this sounds like a success.
- wkearney99 8y agoHas "thus far gotten away with it".
- azeotropic 8y agoPredictions are difficult, particularly about the future
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mc32 8y agoIt's a cruder version of poisoning your turncoats with Pu. While hard to prove, it has an unmistakable signature that says, "anyone lese want to try"?
- 8y ago
- yhoneycomb 8y ago> Here is a reporter from the Washington Post backing that up. You mean, the newspaper that Bezos owns is backing his story? Color me surprised.
- anonu 8y agoWhy Saudis? Why not the Russians in this context?
- dahfizz 8y agoBecause there is no clear connection to Russia here, and there is between AMI and the Saudis? Russia isnt some boogie man, let's use common sense.
- auiya 8y agoKashoggi was an employee of the Washington Post, which Bezos owns. The WaPo have been highly critical of the Saudi response to the Kashoggi murder. It would stand to reason the Saudis are likely using AMI as a proxy for their campaign to blackmail Bezos and silence the WaPo. Trump protecting the Saudis, and Russia protecting Trump would be quite an analytical leap I'd think.
- anonu 8y ago> quite an analytical leap I'd think. Reality can be stranger than fiction. With all the new revelations that come out about all these entities on a regular basis - what is to be believed anymore?
- jessaustin 8y agoNot WaPo, that's for sure. Bezos might be more reliable when writing in his own name...
- wpdev_63 8y agoWhat kind of phone does he use? I am going to guess an iphone...
- lunchables 8y agoI don't think that's the implication at all. He's saying Trump's friends are involved to help him politically.
- Symmetry 8y agoApparently Bezos's mistress's password is in haveibeenpwned.com so this very likely didn't require a government entity. https://blog.erratasec.com/2019/02/how-bezos-dick-pics-mightve-been-exposed.html https://blog.erratasec.com/2019/02/how-bezos-dick-pics-might...
- tyree731 8y agoThese sorts of things are always NP problems. If you know the answer, in hindsight it was obvious, because all the signs line up. But to think to look at the answer, to search the entire space of how to discredit someone, that takes resources.
- HelloNurse 8y agoEverything Bezos tells about seems to have happened very recently, after the divorce announcement, making Lauren Sanchez a very obvious hacking target for which password leaks are a very obvious easy strategy. Taking on Amazon cybersecurity could be a job for the likes of the NSA, but accessing a cracked phone without being caught is almost amateur level hacking.
- jessaustin 8y agoThe spam comment on that post is entertaining.
- auntienomen 8y agoWhen was it put there? Before or after the data was stolen?
- jessaustin 8y agoFrom GP's link: I find that her email addresses have been included in that recent dump of 770 million accounts called "Collection#1". For background, see Troy Hunt's explanation for this data [0]. He certainly didn't add Ms. Sanchez's passwords to this. The MEGA uploader could have, one supposes, but that pushes the timeline back to early January. The idea that someone was sitting on all these creds (140M email addresses in this breach that HIBP has never seen before.), and then released them as a smokescreen for Ms. Sanchez's would be, let's say, conspiratorial. [0] https://www.troyhunt.com/the-773-million-record-collection-1-data-reach/ https://www.troyhunt.com/the-773-million-record-collection-1...
- doktrin 8y agoI thought Bezos' investigator had alluded to the leaks originating from Sanchez's brother? That also seems more likely to me than a nation state - in this particular case, at least.
- lucasverra 8y agonews flash : - https://www.nationalenquirer.com https://www.nationalenquirer.com is hosted in AWS - https://www.nationalenquirer.com https://www.nationalenquirer.com is down
- MattSayar 8y agoIt's up for me
- mtarnovan 8y agoI get a 403. Weird.
- lucasverra 8y agosame => https://drive.google.com/file/d/1du5rX4oW3PkfrDIwb4OVaLRHbX_lKepy/view?usp=drivesdk https://drive.google.com/file/d/1du5rX4oW3PkfrDIwb4OVaLRHbX_...
- ohitsdom 8y agoThis isn't being seriously alleged, as the source of this theory was a Roger Stone associate. https://twitter.com/lachlan/status/1093864755381571584 https://twitter.com/lachlan/status/1093864755381571584
- forgotAgain 8y agoFrom Reuters: "Inside the UAE’S Secret Hacking Team of American Mercenaries" https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-spying-raven https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-spyi...
- scottlocklin 8y agoCould be true. Could be whatever chat app he used too. But my Bayesian prior of how the world works is that someone had access to someone's phone (his or his GFs) and gave the photos to the Enquirer.
- 3327 8y agoWell, if Trump was stupid enough to have any remote knowledge of it or part in it - he is done. Esquirer will crack, Bezos has infinite funds, and determination, and is pissed. The truth will come out. Stay tuned.