5 ms·
As you can see, your first $6 / hour of tips do nothing but reduce your base pay. Whatever you get tipped above that amount is yours to keep. You had it right
by gamblor956 8y ago
As you can see, your first $6 / hour of tips do nothing but reduce your base pay. Whatever you get tipped above that amount is yours to keep.
You had it right the first time, but the first $6/hour of tips do not reduce your base pay, and are not considered garnishments since you are guaranteed a minimum no matter what. (And "garnish" does have a legal meaning in this context so that's definitely the wrong word to use here.)
It should be contextualized another way: the first $6/hour of tips offset the make-good wages the restaurant would have to pay if you hadn't earned those tips.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoWhat do you mean "the first time"? The amount of money you get is the same. The two scenarios are worded differently without being different. Except for the joy of financial engineering, there is no difference between "you make $8 / hour, and the first $6 / hour of your tips go to me instead of you" and "you make $8 / hour, and whatever tips you get are yours to keep, but the first $6 / hour of your tips lower your base wage by an equal amount". But you must conceive of it as either garnishing tips or eating into the base pay, because if you work one hour and get tipped $20, you only earn $22. If your tips weren't being garnished and also didn't reduce your base pay, you'd earn $28.
- gamblor956 8y agoAh you're basically misunderstanding what's going on. Tipped workers have a lower minimum wage. The standard minimum wage is relevant only if they don't reach that with tips. It's a fallback that was added to the law to protect the rare servers who don't make at least minimum wage from their tipped income. It's the exception, not the norm.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoTry the following: - Make up a scenario. - See who gets how much money. - Ask yourself what I would predict. - Then, and only then, tell me I'm misunderstanding something. And then tell me what it is.
- Dylan16807 8y agoWhat you're missing is "It's the exception, not the norm." Very few wait staff are in the range where the tips affect how much their employer pays, and they're definitely not supposed to be in that range. The base pay is not $8, because almost nobody has to be brought up to that. The base pay is $2, and none of that gets removed. That's not the case with most of these delivery companies. They have smaller numbers of tips and they're not a tip-based income. The base pay really is the bigger number, and the companies are subtracting from it. Or in short: You have the math right but your definition of "base pay" is wonky.
- dTal 8y ago>Tipped workers have a lower minimum wage Do they really though? The employer must guarantee that they earn the standard minimum wage, regardless of what happens with tips, so effectively their minimum wage is the same as everyone else's and all this stuff about "base pay" is a wordplay shell game. Either way, what's effectively happening is the customer is subsidizing somebody who their employer would otherwise have to pay, so it all amounts to the same thing: your tips up to a certain level are going to the employer, not the employee.
- gamblor956 8y agoThey really do. The legal tipped minimum wage is different from the standard minimum wage. The requirement that tipped workers make at least standard minimum wage is a backstop protection intended to apply to the (extremely rare) situation that a tipped worker does not actually make more than standard minimum wage. Going to repeat this again, for emphasis: tipped workers have always had lower base wages than non-tipped workers. The make-good requirement is a late addition to labor law that very rarely applies. The make-good requirement applies so rarely that a server who doesn't make at least standard minimum wage after tips will likely be let go for basic incompetence.