4 ms·
Explain my four-year-old hearing chords played on a piano by the teacher, and able to tell the notes that made up the chord. First 3-notes, 4, 5, 6 and he was s
by JoeAltmaier 8y ago
Explain my four-year-old hearing chords played on a piano by the teacher, and able to tell the notes that made up the chord. First 3-notes, 4, 5, 6 and he was still able to do it.
Sure the labels are learned. But the ability to hear all that is spread out over a bell-curve. The whole class could tell 1 note, 1/3 could tell 2, then 2 kids could tell 3, then just 1.
- dekhn 8y agoyes, and? I don't have perfect pitch, but with extensive training I have limited relative pitch. It's an acquired skill like anything else, and young kids exposed to music pick it up faster- with a distribution, like everything else.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoOh, and he has perfect pitch. Can tune stringed instruments without a reference, was employed to do so for some summers. It was something he could do, from a very young age. Not apparently learned. Not learned by most of his cohort at music school, so I'm guessing most likely something born with. If there is a distribution, then we have to task to explain that. Reasonable to call it genetic? Why not?
- dekhn 8y agoI don't know what you mean by "not apparently learned". Even with genetically inherited perfect pitch, the skill has to be "learned" (IE, presented with note labels). Nobody has the ability- without training- to tell you the frequency of a note. Genetic (in this case) doesn't mean "born with the ability", it means "predisposed towards greater ability after training"). Personally, I'd start with the strong observations like "People whose first language is tonal are more likely to have perfect pitch", while people whose ancestors spoke tonal languages, but were raised with a first language that isn't tonal, are less likely (and vice versa). That says to me "environmental differences" are as strong as genetic. All of this is covered in extensive (and relatively accurate) detail on the wikipedia page. if you want to argue with me further, I suggest getting a PhD in the field, or at least extensive experience with molecular biology, genetics, biophysics, experimental design, and scientific philosophy, as all those are necessary prerequisites for discussing complex traits that have both genetic and environmental components.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI guess I'm not making myself clear. The ability to learn this accurately is not the same for everyone. Those that can, are said to have 'perfect pitch'. What makes them different? Not just the learning - as suggested, maybe that's teachable (but probably not, look at all the advanced music students that never learn). But the speed and facility are not teachable - that came with the person. Which is about the same as said above I guess. And Really? Appeal to authority?
- dekhn 8y agoI wish I could answer your question with some level of authority, but nobody knows the answer. The general problem of how people transduce signals into information, why it's efficient for some people, and to what level people can escape genetic determinism is one of the prevailing questions in biological science. As for appeal to authority: completely appropriate in this case since it's a highly technical issue with a ton of prior knowledge that is both subtle and non-obvious. I don't really understand the idea that appeal to authority in this context is fallacious- as we are not having a formal logic argument, but arguing about extremely complex, messy, wet systems with complex feedback loops that lead to high non-intuitive behavior.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoThe trouble with appeal-to-authority is when its used to shut down discussion, e.g. 'before you say any more you have to be as smart as me' which isn't educational, helpful or honest.
- dekhn 8y agoI understand why some people don't like it. I don't mean it to shut down discussion but once I reach the pooint where hackers are presupposing a mechanism that isn't consistent with the modern understanding, I'm going to encourage people to learn to do the research on their own.
- jacquesm 8y ago