5 ms·
to learn assembly I wrote a "PC speaker clicker" that just strobed the click register and had a small timing loop to play A440. A person in the room spoke up w
by dekhn 8y ago
to learn assembly I wrote a "PC speaker clicker" that just strobed the click register and had a small timing loop to play A440.
A person in the room spoke up when I played it- "that's not A440, it's off slightly. Oh, and I have perfect pitch- it's about 439".
I had a small bug in my timing routine that made the pitch slightly lower, which I fixed.
- grenoire 8y agoI'm surprised that he did actually have perfect pitch.
- dekhn 8y agome too. I can't even hear any difference between 1hz intervals around 440.
- ttul 8y agoI sang in a children’s choir growing up. There were several kids with perfect pitch over the years. It’s an incredible skill; they really do get the pitch exactly right - even better than the piano.
- jacquesm 8y agoMakes you wonder what the difference is, genetically speaking. The one set of genes codes for a crystal oscillator and the other for resistors and capacitors or the biological equivalent.
- dekhn 8y agoThis is a really interesting area of research. I've been following roughly since the time I wrote the code I described above (at UCSF, a medical research institution). At the time, my genetics professor (Nelson Friemer) theorized it was primarily genetic (https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/07/090702170209.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/07/090702170209.h...) and even found some genetic associations. I don't think that's really super-important. For example, when he heard that perfect pitch was frequently found in children of musicians, his conclusion is that it was inherited genetically. I think, instead, children of musicians are exposed to pitches and their labels (notes) very early, during neural plasticity, and develop the mental associations, probably with some assist from genetics. The biophysics of audition are pretty interesting; see http://dailynexus.com/2017-08-24/hearing-a-biophysical-and-neurological-enigma/ http://dailynexus.com/2017-08-24/hearing-a-biophysical-and-n... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hair_cell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hair_cell One could imagine any number of genetic changes that could affect the ability of the physical system (these parts) as well as the neural parts to do this, but personally I think this is much more learned behavior, not genetically dominated.
- jacquesm 8y agoThe big question is: what is the reference?
- dekhn 8y agoreference to what? There is a collect of hair cells that vibrate in response to various pitches. When presented with enough training examples, the brain makes the association between those vibrations, and labels provided by others (that's where the pitch/note mapping comes from). For individual frequencies, I think most people with perfect pitch spend some time with pianos and tuning fork and eventually get a "feel" for what delta 1hz around 440 sounds like.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoExplain my four-year-old hearing chords played on a piano by the teacher, and able to tell the notes that made up the chord. First 3-notes, 4, 5, 6 and he was still able to do it. Sure the labels are learned. But the ability to hear all that is spread out over a bell-curve. The whole class could tell 1 note, 1/3 could tell 2, then 2 kids could tell 3, then just 1.
- dekhn 8y agoyes, and? I don't have perfect pitch, but with extensive training I have limited relative pitch. It's an acquired skill like anything else, and young kids exposed to music pick it up faster- with a distribution, like everything else.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoOh, and he has perfect pitch. Can tune stringed instruments without a reference, was employed to do so for some summers. It was something he could do, from a very young age. Not apparently learned. Not learned by most of his cohort at music school, so I'm guessing most likely something born with. If there is a distribution, then we have to task to explain that. Reasonable to call it genetic? Why not?