4 ms·
Facebook's statement is... interesting. > The Bundeskartellamt underestimates the fierce competition we face in Germany Which competition? The only viable soc
by mschuster91 8y ago
Facebook's statement is... interesting.
> The Bundeskartellamt underestimates the fierce competition we face in Germany
Which competition? The only viable social network in Germany that came close to Facebook was Lokalisten, which shuttered finally in 2016.
- thecatspaw 8y agoBND seems like it could compete with facebook
- adventured 8y agoFacebook's response is without question following Peter Thiel's monopolist argumentation position. If you're a monopolist, widen your pool of competition to include anything you possibly can. If your employees consume fruit at work, proclaim you're competing with Chiquita bananas (and have a tiny share of the fruit market). If your employees ever fly on planes, proclaim your position in jets is terribly weak next to Boeing and Airbus. They're not a social network, they're considerably trailing YouTube with Watch. They're not a social network, they're trailing Craigslist with Marketplace. They're not a social network, they're badly trailing Android and iOS in app marketplaces. They're not a social network, they're badly trailing Amazon and Google in smart speakers and home tech. And so on the lie goes.
- Deganta 8y agoDoes this argument really work? Nobody says that Facebook has a monpoly in everything they do. They say that they have a monopoly in a very specific area, which should be enough for antritrust lawsuits. I'm pretty sure that AT&T and Standard Oil also had branches that did not have a monopoly in their respective areas, but that didn't stop the splitting of the companies.
- adventured 8y agoMicrosoft aggressively deployed it in the 1990s with the US Government. It didn't work at all ultimately. Nobody outside of Microsoft's management bought into the premise (they either didn't actually buy into it either, or they were wildly delusional, hard to tell which it really was). Once the DOJ took the Microsoft case seriously, they cut through Microsoft's fluff like a buzzsaw. It doesn't work very well at all with a determined government, which will zero in on specific market abuses (rather than getting caught up in bullshit PR fluff). Primarily it's one part PR play with the public brand & image, and one part time delay. Facebook would love nothing more than to have an opportunity to burn years of time by being given a chance to argue round and round about all the competition they face. Microsoft laughably couldn't stop repeating how they were fighting for their right to innovate (which eg had next to nothing to do with their serious OEM abuses). Every other word out of Gates and Ballmer's mouths for years was a variation of innovation. They beat that drum to death, it made no difference. They tried playing the widen the competition pool card over and over again, that also made zero difference. No serious regulator will ever believe the competition everywhere premise. I generally don't believe it's aimed at actually convincing a serious regulator, either. The sharks that work for giants like Facebook know it's not an actual strong legal argument, which is why I believe it's one part stall tactic and one part public image support. There's a small chance it could cause some skepticism among less determined regulators as a fluke benefit.
- whyisthewhat 8y agoThe only thing I would add is that it serves as a convenient figleaf for regulators and policy advocates who are politically or ideologically friendly to monopolists, of whom there are no shortage in the US at least
- AJ007 8y agoThe other part of Peter Thiel's point is that if you aren't a monopoly, you pretend you are, so you can convince investors you are much more valuable.
- expertentipp 8y agoDomestic data hoarders and advertisers - extremely invasive and territorial. The difference is that none of them runs social networking website or mobile messenger app, thus without consumer facing facade many uninformed assume they don't exist. e.g. their media and retail oligopolies like to roll out their own ad, tracking, and loyalty programs to have full control of the data. They don't let anyone in and are trying to expand, clumsily, to other EU countries.
- close04 8y agoCare to provide some details? because FB considers YouTube, Twitter, and the likes as that competition but you may know more.
- expertentipp 8y agoAmericans are smarter - they provide this bait-facade of "usefulness", Germans are more direct and down-to-the-business e.g. there are billboards on the streets of German cities with "privacy campaigns" actively agitating against Facebook, country-wide hysteria against social networks (or even internet in general). Someone certainly pays for it - articles, billboards, etc are not a volunteer work.
- close04 8y agoI'm sure someone must pay. But I can make assumptions all by myself with little to no help. What I could really use are details, facts, evidence. So I'm forced to reiterate, care to provide some? I don't mean evidence that people want more privacy and someone is paying/putting up billboards advocating this. Do you have some evidence (anything) that these yet unnamed companies are behind a strategy to stain FB's image (as if it were needed) in order to have the privacy violation market all to the themselves? Can you at least name one of these companies? Or maybe a hint on why Facebook doesn't even acknowledge this enemy?
- expertentipp 8y ago
- cf141q5325 8y agoThey named Youtube, Snapchat and Twitter as their competition
- denzil_correa 8y agoWell, that statement is essentially a strawman. Even IF Facebook does face competition - it doesn't mean they should be allowed to violate privacy.
- F30 8y agoNot under anti-trust law (German "Kartellrecht"), where market concentration and competition are primary factors.
- duxup 8y agoI think most companies internally think of anything that takes a user away from their service or site, even unrelated as competition. Fortnite is the bogeyman for all entertainment and so forth. But yeah as for social network, nothing.