4 ms·
>On the other hand, fiat money is constantly being secretly manipulated. Crypto can be secretly manipulated in the exact same way fiat can. The only thing dif
by jayd16 8y ago
>On the other hand, fiat money is constantly being secretly manipulated.
Crypto can be secretly manipulated in the exact same way fiat can. The only thing different about crypto is that there's no central bank that can literally print money. Instead we get defacto authority with no legal framework in place.
- dragontamer 8y ago> The only thing different about crypto is that there's no central bank that can literally print money Satoshi's pile of ~1 Million bitcoins disagrees with you. The entire BTC economy innately trusts Satoshi to not ruin the fun for them. If Satoshi decides to liquidate his holdings of BTC, it would crash the market harder than the next 10-years worth of mining. Satoshi's pile of 1-million bitcoins acts as a centralized bank, whether he likes it or not. Satoshi realizes this fact, and that's why Satoshi has ensured that his BTC has never moved.
- jayd16 8y agoWe're saying the same thing. Satoshi is a defacto central bank. The main difference is the money is already printed but that fact is essentially irrelevant.
- blotter_paper 8y agoI don't see how that fact is irrelevant. In one case, an upper limit of how much currency can enter the marketplace is known. In the other, it can keep being printed indefinitely. That doesn't seem like a trivial difference. This is basic inflation/deflation we're talking about, and while deflation isn't popular among modern economists it certainly isn't seen as irrelevant. Satoshi has no magical powers, only a stash of coins that could have easily been mined by other early adopters.
- jayd16 8y agoI simply mean a large amount approaches infinity. In Satoshi's case he owns 5% of all bitcoin that will ever be and almost certainly much more in terms of what is in circulation. This amount of power is akin to that of a central bank for the purposes of this discussion.
- blotter_paper 8y agoUSD inflated 2.44% last year. Satoshi can dump his alleged 5% of the total supply once, and then he can't do it again. The fed can keep inflating at whatever rate they want year after year. That's the difference, and it's huge. The fed's power approaches infinity, but Satoshi's does not. Gold doesn't become inflationary just because the pope owns a lot of it.
- dragontamer 8y agoThere were 5-Million BTC in 2011, and there are now over 15-million BTC today. BTC has inflated 300% in the past 7ish years. There will be 657,000 BTC added to the system in the next year, or roughly 4.5%. Which means BTC is "inflating" more than USD right now (with your definition of 'inflation', which isn't very good IMO). The next halfening won't happen until 2020 or so.
- blotter_paper 8y agoThat's not my definition you're using! I wouldn't count a hypothetical Satoshi dump as inflation, nor do I count new coins mined as inflation. Again, think of Bitcoin as analogous to gold (and ignore the fact that we can technically make prohibitively expense gold now, as economists of the past were not considering modern alchemy when defining inflation). We don't claim that gold has inflated when more is mined, because it is understood that the gold mined already existed. The fact that there was hard-to-get gold underground has already been accounted for in the market valuation of gold. The fixed total number of bitcoins is what makes Bitcoin deflationary, even though more bitcoins are becoming available in the short term; the market knows this, and has theoretically accounted for it. This is more true of Bitcoin than the classic example of gold, as our gold estimates are just that and our Bitcoin estimates are perfect (barring breakdown of the network). Yes, the market is irrational and hasn't _really_ accounted for it, but don't tell the economists that! This is covered in intro macroeconomics, a currency/commodity isn't considered inflationary just because more becomes _available_, it's about whether or not there is a known finite supply. I'm not pulling this out of nowhere. Ask any economist if Bitcoin is deflationary.
- bduerst 8y agoFor all intents and purposes it's the same central authority powers. You can split hairs over hypothetical scenarios where Satoshi doesn't have as large a share in some future, but the fact is that now they have the same control as a central bank does over putting currency into circulation.
- blotter_paper 8y agoAgain, no. Satoshi can dump once, the fed inflates USD year after year at whatever rate they like. This is not the same power. Look at Venezuela; Satoshi can't do that. He can dump ~6% of current supply once (assuming high estimates of his holdings are correct), the IMF is estimating Venezuela's inflation at above 1,000,000% in 2018. That's totally different. This is the craziest modern example, of course, but USD could do the same at the whim of the fed (and they did increase supply by 2.44% last year, non-hypothetically). Satoshi holds no such power by any stretch of the imagination. There are legitimate criticisms of Bitcoin for you to make, but this isn't one of them. The supply is fixed. There is no "for all intents and purposes" disclaimer that can make your statement correct. This is basic economics, if you don't believe me find an economist to pick the brain of. They probably won't like Bitcoin, but they certainly won't argue that Satoshi is analogous to the fed.
- joe_the_user 8y agoSatoshi's pile of 1-million bitcoins acts as a centralized bank, whether he likes it or not. Satoshi realizes this fact, and that's why Satoshi has ensured that his BTC has never moved. Speculation on cause is kind of stretching it. Satosh's identity is still unknown. Maybe that bitcoin is lost entirely, maybe "Satoshi" is going to liquidate as soon as he/she gets out of prison or maybe something else.
- bduerst 8y agoAlso comes with the massive assumption that Satoshi still has control over the wallet, and hasn't, you know, lost the keys or anything: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-crypto-currencies-quadriga/millions-in-cryptocurrencies-frozen-after-canadian-founders-death-idUSKCN1PU025 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-crypto-currencies-quadrig...
- tim333 8y agoDepends how you liquidate. If they were sold gradually during a bull market it wouldn't effect things much.
- jondubois 8y agoBut a key difference is that nobody is forced to use a specific cryptocurrency and it's much easier to see if your cryptocurrency is being manipulated. If a currency isn't working for you; you should be able to choose a different one which does. As an investor, it would make things more interesting because you will no longer be able to just sit around and wait for the capital to come to you through the same reliable fiat channels (e.g. interest, corporate dividends, index funds, ...); you will have to keep moving your investments across cryptocurrencies to follow the value and talent. If any specific cryptocurrency becomes unfair, smart people will dump it for another one; the manipulated coin will lose its value. There are crooks in every country and it's not fair that you should be forced to share a currency with them just because you live in a country which happens to have a lot of them.
- jayd16 8y ago>it's much easier to see if your cryptocurrency is being manipulated. Specific transactions can be verified but that does not translate in to full transparency. Transactions can be obfuscated and laundered. A Swiss bank could set up a wallet to perform all BTC transactions through. And your not being forced to use fiat. If you were, investing in crypto wouldn't even be possible.
- yongjik 8y ago> If a currency isn't working for you; you should be able to choose a different one which does. Imagine an employer saying "This week I'm paying you by dollars, but I don't like being forced to deal with dollars, so if I decide dollars aren't working for us we'll switch to Euros next month. And then maybe Pound the month after that." I'm not sure how this is going to benefit cryptocurrency users.
- jondubois 8y agoIf conversion is easy and fast, then I wouldn't care what my employer pays me with. The onus is on me to figure out which currency is used by the smartest and most productive people on the planet because that's the one I want to hold onto in the long term.