10 ms·
It is that simple (in the sense of the parent's post): you need to know the specifics of why they were paying no taxes. If, as in the comment, they were carryi
by SilasX 8y ago
It is that simple (in the sense of the parent's post): you need to know the specifics of why they were paying no taxes. If, as in the comment, they were carrying over losses, then there's nothing really objectionable. You lost $10 million last year. You profited $10 million this year. Over a reasonable horizon, you weren't profitable.
Did they get a specific exemption against the public interest that no one else got? Great! Let's talk about that!
Did they deduct 100% of their costs for sham "IP licensing" from a foreign subsidiary? Great! Let's talk about that!
But you need to know the why before you conclude there's something objectionable going on.
Edit: More generally, every headline of this form comes with an implicit statement like "By my model, <company> should be regarded as having a profit of X dollars, but tax law views them as having a taxable profit of Y < X." That necessitates a good explanation of why you think X is the right value.
- anth_anm 8y ago> If, as in the comment, they were carrying over losses, then there's nothing really objectionable I find that objectionable.
- theartfuldodger 8y agoWhy? Profits should follow arbitrary calendar years?
- arkades 8y agoBecause private citizens aren’t given the same affordances. The double standard is objectionable.
- usaar333 8y agoYes they can. Carry-forward losses exist with capital gains losses as well as net operating losses from self-employment.
- gojomo 8y agoThey can't treat their living expenses exceeding income as deductions, no. But if: * their sole proprietorship loses money in one year, it can be carried forward to offset taxes the next year * they have net losses in investments, those can be carried-over to offset gains in other years * any LLCs in which they are members have allocated losses, those can be carried-over against profits in later years These are the ways a private individual engages in economic activity that are analogous to what a C-Corp does, and for these, the standard is essentially the same.
- dlp211 8y agoAll true, the objection comes from the limits placed on individuals that don't apply to businesses. Businesses are allowed to "use up" all of their losses, both current year and carried forward, in a single year. Individuals are forced to arbitrarily carry forward losses when they still had income/cap gains that could have been deducted against.
- theartfuldodger 8y agoInterestingly ( to me) I will be deducting losses specifically from Netflix this tax season and will have carryover in 2020. There are a handful of available carryovers and the concept of NOL is very similar to a private citizen as this discussed concern is to a business. Innovation and front heavy spending is very much improved do to this issue. It is a sound concept.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y ago>Over a reasonable horizon, you weren't profitable. The average worker isn't allowed to do that even when they lose money in a given year. Why is it so naturally assumed to be acceptable for a business to do it? Maybe the time is to just remove the loopholes in general from both business and personal income taxes.
- a-priori 8y agoI don't know about American taxes, but at least in Canada individuals can do this for capital gains / losses. If you have investments that produce losses one year, you can carry those losses forward to cancel out capital gains in following years and reduce your tax payable.
- lorenzhs 8y agoIn Germany, if you have less taxable income than tax deductions, you can carry that loss forward, too. It's a rare case, though, but it can save you several thousand when pursuing a second degree.
- a-priori 8y agoVery interesting. This feels like one small baby step away from a negative income tax scheme where you'd receive that difference immediately, rather than having to wait until you make more income in a later year.
- el_cujo 8y agoThis is how it works in America as well.
- scottlegrand2 8y agoI would be great with corporations deducting all the business losses they wish if only I had similar freedom deducting all of my business losses rather than an elaborate tax code that forces me to resort to tricks like tax-loss harvesting. Or TLDR: don't take away rights like this from corporations, give those same rights to individuals.
- MetalGuru 8y agoDo losses actually carry forward in full like you're describing? I was under the impression there was an annual limit in the amount you can deduct. For an individual, that limit is $3k.
- kelnos 8y agoNo, for individuals the limit on losses that you can deduct is the amount of your gains, plus $3k. If the entirety of your income comes from investments, you could certainly end up paying no tax if your capital losses cancel out your capital gains, regardless of the magnitude of each. The $3k you can deduct past that is a nice bonus. And even for individuals, losses over that $3k can be carried forward indefinitely to future years.
- dlp211 8y agoThere are losses that individuals can't take, but can carry forward due to the amount of income they make, notably real estate investments when the individual is not a real estate professional. Think about how messed up that is, DJT and his ilk can deduct and deprecate all the real estate that they own and operate and continually carry forward excesses, but I as an individual have to carry forward the loss until my income drops to some suitable level. I have no problem with carry forwards, but if you are going to limit the individual to the amount they can deduct in a year, that should apply to business as well. It's also possible to pay no taxes if you derive all of your income from investments every year as long as you don't exceed the allowed limit since we have a marginal capital gains structure that combos with our marginal income tax structure.
- prostoalex 8y ago$3,000 is the deduction limit against personal income. Deduction against capital gains is limitless.
- awakeasleep 8y agoYour argument is a form of 'this is too complicated for you to understand' .. aka bullshit. The average joe doesn't need to grok the whole tax code to know it's wrong when one of the most high profile profitable companies doesn't pay any income tax. That indicates the system is fucked. There isn't a technicality in the universe that will indicate that somehow our perception is wrong.
- SilasX 8y agoNo, it's the opposite. It's saying, "get the facts first", and I gave a few examples (some positive and some negative), at a high level of abstraction, of what would and wouldn't be objectionable. I completely agree that you shouldn't need to know the whole tax code to say, "deducting arbitrary figures for payments to a foreign subsidiary shouldn't be allowed and is shady". But "profits didn't cancel out recent losses, thus no taxable income" is not shady. All I'm saying is, you can't even have the discussion until you know what case you're talking about. Is that really controversial? Did it really sound like I was saying this is too complicated to understand? Is there a better way I could have said it?
- objektif 8y agoIt is really contreversial to have a defensive tone when it comes to corporate taxes. Tell me a year you made money and paid 0 taxes. Or anyone? Why cant we have a sceptical approach when the topic in question is large corps?
- smsm42 8y agoMost of people here do not rely 100% on investment income, I assume, thus such a situation would be impossible for them, since labor income tax does not allow to deduct this much. But I have successfully lowered my taxes at occasion where I incurred some substantial investment losses (the startup I owned stock in folded). It didn't make my tax to zero (and thank God, because this would mean I've lost as much as I make, I don't want this kind of losses) but it did reduce my taxes. > Why cant we have a sceptical approach when the topic in question is large corps? Sure we can, in fact we must. But skeptical approach means get the facts, verify them, then make decision. Not read the outline, feel outraged, reject any reasonable explanation because we must be skeptical about large corps. Having losses carried over from previous years is nothing wrong, and one part of being skeptical is being able to recognize there's no "there" there, and move on.
- jayess 8y agoSo many replies to your comment, but no one seems to be able to answer the question. Articles like these manufacture outrage with no detail whatsoever on why the company paid no income taxes.
- SilasX 8y agoI tried to dig out an answer, but the site was down and so was the Google cache!
- ksec 8y agoAgreed. Using Apple as example. From my observation, most people on the internet doesn't seems to care. There was an argument about Apple paying little tax in US. I said Apple is the largest tax payer in US and paid 20%+, then the topic changed to he is paying ~40%, why is Apple paying 20% only? There is Apple tax in France, there are even some saying Apple should pay tax in France, then paid Tax in Ireland, and pay Tax in US. There are some saying how can Apple not paying any VAT in France and UK? ( Have they been watching too much Fox News ? ) I mean seriously, unless your whole life have been working on any non business side of things, if any of the job involves calculating profits and sales would know none of these makes any sense. And yet we are in a world with people demanding company should pay more. Which is fair point, but what they are suggesting is ridiculous. I know many are concern about the lack of money for government spending, but as a counter point, do they realise how much money and inefficiency government have wasted in their bureaucracy, and their out of touch project which more than often leads to failure with sums that is unrealistic by any standards?