13 ms·
Notices have already been issued under Australia’s new encryption laws
- samcday 8y agoIf the idea was for Australia to lead by example on all the ways to NOT regulate an increasingly digital world, we're doing a bloody good job. I worked for Atlassian in Sydney. I know there's a pretty decent tech culture that is thriving in Sydney + Melbourne (and elsewhere, I'm sure). I really hope more of my colleagues find a passion for politics and get to a position where they can steer our clearly incompetent government in governance issues pertaining to technology. In the meantime, does anyone have a clear idea of how this Act will even work? Lets talk in specific terms for something like Signal. I'm assuming Signal has no legal footprint in Australia. How/can Australia compel Signal to allow Australian enforcement agencies to snoop on conversations? If they can't, won't one of the worst outcomes of this legislation be that any kind of technology company that needs to deal with encryption (which these days should be basically 100% of them) be forced to move overseas? How could a single Australian-based tech company have even the slightest scrap of credibility for data security when a law like this exists? Final note - is anyone from Fastmail around here? I'm a Fastmail customer and this has me extremely concerned.
- nicwilson 8y ago>I'm a Fastmail customer and this has me extremely concerned. IIRC Jeremy said its a swiss company with swiss servers, so, no problem.
- daurnimator 8y agoAre you thinking of Protonmail? Fastmail is an Australian company with US based servers.
- ardy42 8y ago> IIRC Jeremy said its a swiss company with swiss servers, so, no problem. Do you have a link for that statement?
- braddeicide 8y agoDoesn't matter, if they have an Australian employee they're compromised.
- jph00 8y agoNope I didn't say that - and I haven't been involved with fm for years.
- callahad 8y agoFastmail discussed the bill on their blog at https://fastmail.blog/2018/09/10/access-and-assistance-bill/ https://fastmail.blog/2018/09/10/access-and-assistance-bill/
- bscphil 8y agoSeems like a fair summary would be that since they don't offer any truly secure services (e.g. e2e encryption), there's nothing that this law could require them to subvert. Turning over an individual's account data pursuant to an Australian issued warrant was something they were already doing, and nothing about that has changed under the new law.
- kevin_b_er 8y agoSignal: The employee is required to intentionally alter the app to no longer provide security, such that some communication may be intercepted. They are not permitted to publicly disclose that they have done this. Unfortunately, this goes deeper. The law may be capable of compelling Google or Apple of Australia to force deploy to your phone a malicious version of the Signal app with the "technical assistance notice".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- akvadrako 8y agoIf they are ever forced to do that and it becomes public knowledge, I think it will finally be enough for a critical mass of security-conscious people to buy phones with user-controlled platforms where it becomes impossible. In a way this might be a blessing.
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoNo, they won't. They'll buy the newest Apple phone because it's 10 nanometers thinner and it's a status symbol. Apple Cloud was hacked and celebrity pictures were stolen and noone batted an eye.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoFiguring out people's easy passwords and password recovery methods isn't a weakness in iCloud, and shouldn't be counted as hacking iCloud. And if you were concerned with security, and had to buy a smartphone, what device is better than an iPhone?
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y ago> We didn't give random people loans in your name, your identity was stolen. When you shift responsibility from the provider to the customer, you play right into the security blame game.
- guitarbill 8y agoMeta-question: Obviously, the whole thing is rotten because of the secrecy. But is is better to do what Australia is doing, by making it a law which can at least be talked about, or doing it anyway, but covertly, like certain other five eyes countries (and beyond)? I don't really have an opinion or answer, just curious.
- zepto 8y agoWhat Australia is doing is worse, because the actions can’t be talked about. What the five eyes do is normal espionage. They often get away with it, but when they are uncovered their illegal actions aren’t covered by gag orders.
- braddeicide 8y agoThere's no reason to be concerned about fastmail like there's any kind of uncertainty, your account is comprised and you were given warning it was going to happen.
- rrggrr 8y agoHere's a brief of companies that could/might be impacted. I don't agree that server location is sufficient enough protection. Correct me if wrong, but can't the authorities compel the Aussie company's directors to hand over foreign server credentials? Xero Atlassian Canva Fastmail 99 Designs
- kevin_b_er 8y agoGood angle. But we're not just talking about headquartered companies. Cloudflare has datacenters in Brisbane, Melbourne, Perth, and Sydney and an office in Sydney. Could they be compelled to hand over your website's certificate that they have because they're the front end load balancing proxy for your website?? That way the police can man in the middle your website. Cloudflare would be gagged from telling you they gave away your private TLS certificate you entrusted them with.
- nybble41 8y agoSpin off Cloudflare Australia as an independent subcontractor of Cloudflare International. Give customers a choice of whether to enable Australian proxies for their site. Use distinct certificates for the proxies in each region, with short expiration times to limit the damage if a certificate falls into the wrong hands.
- komali2 8y agoMy understanding is an Australian cloudflare employee could be compelled to, yeah, hand over certificates, without telling their boss they did so.
- xucheng 8y agoBy this logic, there is no need to compel Cloudflare to handover the private TLS key. They can just compel any CA based in Australia to sign a fake cert. Or directly compelling OS vendors (Google, Apple, Microsoft,etc) to make government cert as a root CA.
- kevin_b_er 8y ago
- mark-r 8y ago“The legislation in no way compromises the security of any Australians’ digital communications.” Reminds me of the time someone tried to legislate pi=3. There's absolutely no way to give police a back door into encryption without giving criminals the same back door.
- deogeo 8y agoThat's working under the assumption that even the tiny scraps of privacy we have left shouldn't be safe from the government. In light of stuff like police helping blacklist union organizers (https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-43507728 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-43507728) or sharing data on protesters with the company they're protesting against (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victorian_Desalination_Plant#Sharing_of_private_information_with_private_consortia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victorian_Desalination_Plant#S...), that's a very poor assumption to make.
- Gaelan 8y ago> There's absolutely no way to give police a back door into encryption without giving criminals the same back door. This feels disingenuous to me. It would be fairly trivial, for example, to store a copy of all keys, encrypted with the government’s public key. Of course, there’s a million eats to go wrong, but that’s different from “mathematically impossible.”
- sprucely 8y agoBut the million ways to go wrong IS the problem. I may be appealing to authority here, but is it disingenuous when an overwhelming majority of encryption and security experts agree? https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/paloma/the-cybersecurity-202/2018/06/11/the-cybersecurity-202-we-surveyed-100-experts-a-majority-rejected-the-fbi-s-push-for-encryption-back-doors/5b1d39eb1b326b6391af094a/?utm_term=.cebc72f7c3b1 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/paloma/the-cyb... https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2018/05/ray_ozzies_encr.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2018/05/ray_ozzies_en... https://www.justsecurity.org/53316/criminalize-security-criminals-secure/ https://www.justsecurity.org/53316/criminalize-security-crim...
- hamilyon2 8y agoSo, is it time to distrust every ssl cert issued by Australian cert provider? Is there a list?
- lowpro 8y agoI'm not sure there are Australian cert providers... at least the government (gov.au) uses common ones such as Entrust and Digicert, and companies like Atlassian use Digicert.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kevin_b_er 8y agoYou would also need to distrust any ssl cert a multinational company's australians can access, as the law can compel and gag them to steal your ssl cert. All Australian residents and citizens, including potentially abroad, are now legislated to be untrustworthy when it comes to holding any cryptographic secrets or access to systems of your customers.
- gruez 8y agoIn light of what happened to symantec, wosign, and startcom, I would expect smart CAs to pull out of Australia, or at least spin off their Australian operations to a separate entity.
- jacques_chester 8y ago> including potentially abroad On my reading of the A&A bill there was no extra-territoriality clauses, so I think it only applies within Australia. However, I am not a lawyer and this is not legal advice.
- shakna 8y agoIt also appears to apply to Australian citizens living abroad, potentially making dual-citizens into covert actors.
- ChrisLok1 8y agoWe already in process of ending our Atlassian contracts, currently moving all our data out.
- generated 8y agoThis is short sighted. 1. The law applies to all tech companies who have users in Australia, regardless of where the company is incorporated. 2. Atlassian offers primarily self hosted products, to which this law does not apply.
- kstrauser 8y ago> 1. The law applies to all tech companies who have users in Australia, regardless of where the company is incorporated. Yes, but as someone not living in, working in, or traveling to Australia I don't really have to care. I don't own a company that makes crypto, but if I did, my reaction to this would be along the lines of "don't open a Sydney office but otherwise business as usual".
- brokenmachine 8y agoAlso you can't employ any Australians, because they are all covert government spies now.
- pmiller2 8y agoHow can Australia exert legal authority over a company that has no legal presence in the country and one Australian user?
- LiquidFlux 8y agoI'm not informed on the subject, but narrow-mindedly, GDPR and serving EU customers?
- nybble41 8y agoYeah, that has exactly the same problem with respect to jurisdiction. The only difference is that it's easier to write off Australia than the entire EU.
- victorNicollet 8y agoThe hotel room analogy is almost correct. Hotel rooms usually provide a small safe for which guests can pick the combination. There is also a secret backdoor combination or master key that lets hotel staff open the safe. This creates an obvious security hole : if the backdoor combination is easy to guess, or a copy of the master key falls into the hands of unscrupulous employees or ex-employees, then the contents of the safe can be stolen. As a guest, there is nothing you can do to reduce this risk. Now, imagine that a hotel found a solution where locked safes are destroyed and replaced at almost no cost to them, and could give up on the backdoor. Burglaries involving the backdoor would vanish, and although this slightly increases the risk of losing your belongings by forgetting your combination (since the hotel can no longer open the safes of forgetful guests), it's a net improvement in security. Ten years later, the hotel community has reached a consensus that safes-without-backdoors are the Right Thing to Do. The state then mandates that all hotels should be able to give access to the contents of those safes to the police. But they're not saying that hotels have to use a backdoor combination or master key, so they're not really asking anyone to reduce the security of their safes...
- test6554 8y agoAustralian tech companies need to release a program called UltraDecrypt that simply brute-force decrypts any message on their platforms given billions of years and sell it for $10M per license. Then when law enforcement claims they are not being cooperative, they can say they have a tool that meets their needs if they're patient.
- Klathmon 8y agoYou'd probably be charged with something and punished. Courts don't take to kindly to people trying to be cute with their demands. It's not like they are going to say "well they are technically right" and give up, they are going to just up the consequences or clarify the request until you comply in the way that everyone knows they want you to.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoDid Lavabit get additional court punishment for sending SSL keys in 4 pt font?
- Klathmon 8y agoThey were threatened with further charges unless they complied with them in electronic form, which is when the company was famously shuttered. Edit: And according to the wikipedia page [1] for Lavabit, he was successfully held in contempt of court for the printout move. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavabit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavabit
- carbocation 8y agoI feel like I must be misreading, because my first-pass interpretation is that companies would terminate all of their Australian citizen employees, and add terms to the remaining contracts saying that employees must notify them if they become an Australian citizen.
- brokenmachine 8y agoAs an Australian, I dearly hope all international companies actually do this. We are a testing ground for this insanity, the time to fight it is now. Australian citizens did not ask for this. All the "consultation" letters were ignored in favour of creating a police state.
- ohiovr 8y agoWould letsencrypt be compelled to issue certs for your domain to the Australian Gman?
- m-p-3 8y agoThis is where a political problem needs to be fought back where it hurts the government the most, threaten to get the hell out and see their corporate taxes income dwindle.
- brokenmachine 8y agoThe general point that I disagree with is the premise that there can be no such thing as a private conversation. Do you want a police state? Because secret surveillance of all citizens is how you end up with a police state.
- gorb314 8y agoI am not a cryptologist, not a lawyer, and only a marginally capable software engineer. But I think we've had the option to send personally encrypted end-to-end messages for a while now. (Open)PGP anyone? So instead of using Signal, or Whatsapp, or whatever and depending on their client-side-encryption (and possible server-side-decryption) of private messages, how about plain email using standalone user-encryption. Two things may come of this: Google will stop "interpreting" my email messages, and laws like these stop mattering very much. Of course, 5th amendment (and its siblings in other countries) still apply...