4 ms·
As we see STEM rise, if we look deep enough, the promotion of STEM also pushes down everything else not stem, recess, physical education, art, history, the very
by sitkack 8y ago
As we see STEM rise, if we look deep enough, the promotion of STEM also pushes down everything else not stem, recess, physical education, art, history, the very things that make us human(e). STEM is a hit on the humanities, learning those is now the domain of the 1%.
Forced STEM is a way to train the next generation of wage slaves. It is votec starting at the earliest possible age while being couched in a faux constructionist _.
- est31 8y agoIf the job prospects of history majors are teacher and cab driver, then it's not very attractive to many people for good reason. History is important, historians are important, but not everyone needs to study it. The skills only have limited demands on the job market and its dangerous to tell people to study history if they have meek prospects, especially in a place like the US where colleges aren't tuition free.
- harimau777 8y agoI realize that this is likely what you intended to communicate, but I would differentiate between the need to study a subject and the need to specialize in it as a career path. I agree that not everyone needs to become a historian but I think that everyone needs to study history.
- skybrian 8y agoUsing "wage slave" unironically for cushy office jobs betrays a pretty severe lack of empathy and historical perspective.
- therealx 8y agoThey're cushy office jobs now because the market isn't over flooded with talent.
- baybal2 8y ago> Forced STEM is a way to train the next generation of wage slaves. And at the same time, it is the only way the West can compete with China
- baybal2 8y agoChina can put real engineers with 6 year university education to work on assembly line, US can't do anything about that - it simply doesn't have so many of them physically. For as long as thinks continue that way, it will be only natural that US will continue losing out on manufacturing front.
- jholloway7 8y agoI'm sorry for the vitriol, but this is one of the most ignorant comments I've read on HN for a while. I read it three times and could only conclude your whole comment was just so you could spew the "couched in a faux constructionist" non sequitur at the end of it. STEM in physical education: Biomechanics, kinesiology, nutrition science, sports psychology, probability and statistics, equipment tech. STEM in art: physics, perspective, geometry, chemistry, music theory, acoustics, audio engineering, CAD, photoshop, Leonardo Da Vinci would like to have a word with you. STEM in history: agriculture, Gutenberg, Isaac Newton, Galileo, Copernicus, Alan Turing WWII, industrial revolution, manhattan project, Apollo, telecommunications Basically the entire tree of "advances in STEM" over the course of human civilization can be directly tied to salient events in art, sports and general history. STEM advances humanities and humanities advance STEM. If anything the STEM movement is about trying to get STEM back on par with how other fields are taught. It's not a zero sum where if STEM wins, then 'humanities' lose. They complement each other and both win.
- dorchadas 8y agoThat's definitely not true. Even at the high school level, where I teach, it's very much 'do STEM at the expense of humanities'. While it doesn't have to be a zero-sum game, it is and STEM gets pushed because it's seen as more 'practical' and better at getting you jobs.
- hydrox24 8y agoThe zero sum game is students' time. Not contribution to society. Whether it has to be a zero sum game is another matter, but you seem to have misunderstood the assertion of your parent comment.
- harimau777 8y agoI think that you might be understanding the poster's terminology differently than they intended. When people talk about physical education and art at the pre-college level they generally mean gym and the fine arts respectively. They generally do not mean the physical sciences or the mathematics behind the fine arts (although those are both very valuable things to study). As you point out, studying STEM could be complementary to the study of history and other humanities. However, that does not necessarily mean that it always works out that way.
- dalbasal 8y agoThe promotion of STEM and demotion of humanities is deeply linked to the promotion of college generally, to the majority of people. Going back a generation or two, most people didn't go to college. Most of those that did tended to be relatively wealthy, with better careers. Education proponents argues that education made people wealthy/successful. College was an investment, and the education paid for itself in later successes... Human capital theory. It turned out that lower-middle class kids who gave to college tend to make lower-middle adults. Earning potential increases somewhat, but nothing like human capital theory predicts. Re-thinking, it seems more that philosophy and history are/were upper class pursuits. They didn't make people wealthy. Wealthy people could afford it. It just does not make sense for most average people to study history. Its a luxury. STEM really means focus on employability. I agree that education is not just about jobs. But, the premise of "everyone go to college" policies is jobs. Hence the dissonance.
- james_s_tayler 8y agoI try to study it in my off hours. The more I do the more I think my goodness we can not afford not to study it. But then I wind up studying JavaScript because skills pay the bills.
- dorchadas 8y agoThat's what I've come to discover about the humanities as a whole. I was very much a STEM Lord going into college, but my Uni required a lot of electives outside the major, to try to cross pollinate. I ended up enjoying those much more, and started to realize that we can't focus solely on STEM to the exclusion of them because, well, STEM can't solve or answer everything and we're forgetting the past, leaving it doomed to be repeated.
- harimau777 8y agoI agree with you that articles advocating for increased focus on the humanities often fail to consider that historically university education in the humanities was only pursued by the wealthy elite. At the same time however, when I read books written by relatively average people from the early 1900s I notice that there are often many allusions to classical era mythology and history. This could just be a difference in the focus of the humanities that people are learning (e.g. people in the past were educated in a relatively greater understanding of hellenistic culture while modern people are educated in a relatively greater understanding of non-western cultures). However, is it possible that in the past primary and secondary schools gave people a grounding in the humanities even if they never studied them at university?
- mikeash 8y agoAre you implying that STEM is not part of what makes us human? I would say that technology and all the things that enable it are one of humanity’s most important and defining characteristics.