3 ms·
What value do you think your comment adds to the conversation? H.265 is a widely-used standard which millions of devices support and since it's older than AV1 a
by acdha 8y ago
What value do you think your comment adds to the conversation? H.265 is a widely-used standard which millions of devices support and since it's older than AV1 anyone who cares about, for example, iOS users has the choice of using either H.265 or H.264 but not AV1. Even if you're using Chrome or Firefox on a desktop, you often don't want AV1 unless you have a burly CPU, aren't running on battery, and don't mind hearing your CPU fans (a quick search will show this is true even for WebM because millions of people still use devices which have hardware H.264 but require CPU-based decoding for WebM). If that's not true for you, a high-quality open-source H.265 encoder is a great tool.
Here are the current support stats — note the distinct lack of a common format newer than MPEG-4 even before you consider hardware support:
https://caniuse.com/#feat=mpeg4 https://caniuse.com/#feat=mpeg4
https://caniuse.com/#feat=hevc https://caniuse.com/#feat=hevc
https://caniuse.com/#feat=webm https://caniuse.com/#feat=webm
https://caniuse.com/#feat=av1 https://caniuse.com/#feat=av1
- Dylan16807 8y agoA lot of your argument is based on H.264, which is not part of the question. H.265 is not extremely common and also hard to CPU decode.
- acdha 8y agoI’m aware of that but did you notice where I mentioned iOS and linked to https://caniuse.com/#feat=hevc https://caniuse.com/#feat=hevc at the bottom? That was why I mentioned the lack of a common option beyond MPEG-4 — iOS has H.265 support in hardware so if you want a newer codec that’s your only option for a fairly large group of people, especially in the United States, and it’s where battery life matters a great deal. https://www.scientiamobile.com/growing-support-of-hevc-or-h-265-video-on-mobile-devices/ https://www.scientiamobile.com/growing-support-of-hevc-or-h-... has it at 80% of iOS and 60% of Android, which is a LOT better than 0% for AV1, and might even allow only doing 2 formats if enough of the devices with WebM also support HEVC.
- clouddrover 8y agoI think you're better off going with VP9 as your next-gen codec for now rather than HEVC despite the lack of iOS support. That's what Twitch is doing, for example. They say VP9 is a particularly good fit for them because they're getting a 25% bitrate reduction over H.264 in live streaming, they don't want the licensing headaches of HEVC, and because most of their viewers are using Firefox or Chrome on the desktop. Apple joined the Alliance for Open Media so they'll be adding AV1 support eventually. It'd be good if they also added VP9 support, especially because some of their laptops already have hardware decoding for VP9 in the CPU. Most Android phones have VP9 support so iOS joining in would be great.
- ComputerGuru 8y agoFor personal media libraries, patents don’t matter while quality, size, and hardware support do. So HEVC > VP9.
- clouddrover 8y agoIt isn't a question of patents, it's a question of licensing. VP9 and AV1 patents are licensed under royalty-free terms and free for all use-cases. Royalty-free formats are better for the health of the internet and the computing industry generally. I'll always use royalty-free formats where I can. It's just simpler.
- ksec 8y ago>Apple joined the Alliance for Open Media so they'll be adding AV1 support eventually. They joined a organisation when their logo isn't even used. Compared to something the fully support and wants to move forwards with VVC [1] [1] https://www.mc-if.org https://www.mc-if.org
- clouddrover 8y agoApple joined AOMedia at the highest membership level. If Apple didn't care about AOM then it would have been simpler not to join at all.