4 ms·
"Beyond a reasonable doubt" accounts for only disclosing the five most incriminating factors out of fifteen. If you instead got the thousand most incriminating
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
"Beyond a reasonable doubt" accounts for only disclosing the five most incriminating factors out of fifteen.
If you instead got the thousand most incriminating factors out of millions, it looks like a damning mountain of evidence when it's really just the first page of the list of millions of factors sorted by how bad they look.
It completely destroys anyone's credibility scale because seeing a dozen one-in-a-million matches intuitively feels impossible to be a coincidence, but that's less than the result you get by random chance when you attempt to match fifteen million factors.
- marcosdumay 8y agoI don't think you'll find a persecutor willing to take a laundry list of low probability evidence and go after it, whatever the size of the list. Almost certainly, the longer you make the list, the less people you'll find willing to use it.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoIt's not about the length of the resulting list -- just the opposite. It's that you can take a list of a million and prune it to a thousand and suddenly everything bad happens with 1000 times the expected probability because you excluded the 999 things that didn't for every one that did. If you take the list of a million and prune it to ten it's even worse. You can find ten 1:100,000 probability events that occur randomly in a list of a million. It's this: https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/ Except a million tests instead of twenty.