9 ms·
There are two solutions: Part one, a more educated populace. Education will help those that can work in the "good jobs" get the good jobs. Part two, tax poli
by jedberg 8y ago
There are two solutions: Part one, a more educated populace. Education will help those that can work in the "good jobs" get the good jobs. Part two, tax policy. Wealth needs to be redistributed so that there are masses to buy the products that the wealthy are creating.
Edit: I just watched this post go up to 10 points, down to 3 and then back to 5. Clearly this is controversial. I find it interesting that wealth redistribution is this controversial. I'm curious as to why people would be against it. Is it really just "I worked hard for it why should I give it away" or something deeper?
- erwan 8y ago>Wealth needs to be redistributed It is not a zero-sum game. It would be more productive to facilitate wealth creation rather than devise new ways to forcibly take-away private property that offends you. Reducing the countless barriers to entry that stunt human ingenuity is where the real fight is. People can learn, and they are already (e.g Make/Lambda School) when provided with cost-effective training that delivers on investment. Wanting more of the same (tax + regulations) is not going to cut it now. We are past ridiculous levels (1:3 avg OCDE tax:gdp) and diminishing returns kicked in.
- dv_dt 8y ago> It is not a zero-sum game. I agree, but when it comes to government funding of programs to facilitate wealth creation, many act like it is zero sum.
- g9yuayon 8y agoI highly doubt that education reform will come by any time soon. Studying STEM is not natural to many kids, yet the reality is that people in the US have been living comfortably for so long that they would rather give up teaching tough subjects for so-called children's happiness, or shit like no kids left behind. As a result, it is the ordinary kids, which is the majority middle, who will hurt -- they think they learn something in high school and college, but they really don't.
- tlow 8y ago>Studying STEM is not natural to many kids That is purely a systemic problem, there's no reason that it couldn't be natural. Also there's no support for you argument, its mere opinion and unsubstantiated conjecture based upon false premises, but stated like fact.
- mpweiher 8y ago> That is purely a systemic problem That's a bold claim. Evidence?
- darawk 8y agoChina.
- echevil 8y agoProbably most east Asian countries? Likely India as well.
- darawk 8y agoYa, all east asian countries, you're right. China is interesting especially to me though because, just anecdotally, there seem to be an unusually high number of Chinese female STEM graduates. Not sure what's going on there, but they seem to have solved the gender gap in STEM somehow. Could just be i've encountered an unusual sample too, though.
- g9yuayon 8y agoEasy, just tell everyone that anyone can study STEM as long as they work hard. Do you know Noether, Marie Curie, Grace Hopper, Chien-Shiung Wu, and many more female scientists and engineers are household names? They are featured in mass media, in text books, and in our bedtime stories. Gender bias in STEM? That's a god damn first-world problem.
- Animats 8y agoWon't help. About half of the people in the US with a college diploma work at jobs which don't require college.
- jedberg 8y agoThat's what part two is for.
- maerF0x0 8y agoWhat if the jobs require higher IQs than 85? Suddenly we have 15% of the population entirely unemployable? Wealth redistribution is a choice of ethics. What if we start to create better technologies that augment the economic usefulness of the lowest IQ people?
- jedberg 8y agoThat's what the wealth redistribution is for. For the 15% that are unemployable.
- shard972 8y agoWith the USA seeing a decline in IQ and the IQ bar raising for tech jobs, It seems that percentage is going to be growing a lot more into the future.
- pkaye 8y agoMany people think IQ is meaningless and furthermore it is not used for hiring purposes.
- shard972 8y agoSome people think germ theory is meaningless. So what?
- twothumbsup 8y agoGerm theory has basis in science. IQ tests do not.
- shard972 8y agoSo why does the US army use it to both screen out recruits but to identify who should be elevated into the officer core if it's not based in science? Why is it that IQ after all these years has the best correlation with many positive results such as academic ability and job success? I'm not even sure if this a troll to be honest so i would like a bit more an argument than "it's not science cause i say so".
- diminoten 8y agoI've been preaching education to anyone who will listen. It's the skeleton key for every other issue, I dunno how else to put it. You can trace a direct line from each of the top 10 problems in the world to ignorance. People don't actually suck nearly as much as it seems, people are just missing information. We're not econs, but we'd act a lot more closely to that model if we were, on average, more educated.
- shard972 8y agoIsn't the first one basically "learn to code"?
- dominotw 8y agoYes its now grounds for ban on twitter :D
- shard972 8y agoIs basically my point. On one hand we can't expect journalists who I imagine are very Intelligent to get into programming but somehow we are just going to change our education system and everyone will just be coders? I feel like you have to subscribe to tabula rasa to think this is going to go off without a hitch.
- flukus 8y ago> Is basically my point. On one hand we can't expect journalists who I imagine are very Intelligent to get into programming Nobody seriously expected this to happen, it was an exercise in turning their own solution "all these laid off coal miners can learn to code" against them when they were laid off. Twitter now considers pointing out this hypocrisy to be harassment. I can see their point, it's kicking a person while they're down, but they were fine with undesirables like coal miners being kicked while they're down.
- zjs 8y agoI support both of those ideas, but I'm not sure I see how those solve the underlying problems highlighted by the article. We're going to continue to introduce technology to improve quality and enhance productivity. Will jobs continue to fall in industries that introduce technologies to enhance productivity? If so, education and wealth redistribution seem insufficient (albeit still necessary). (I haven't checked the linked paper to see if this is answered.)
- tossaccount123 8y agoeducation isn't the answer because no matter what you do a good chunk of the population simply isn't capable of high skilled jobs. The US military learned that below a certain IQ there's literally no job people can do that makes it worth the time to train them https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_100,000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_100,000
- ipnon 8y agoIf the average IQ of a STEM graduate is a standard deviation or more above average [0][1], then how does a more educated populace result in something besides the stratification we see today? STEM education can help a person get on the right side of the tech split, but the STEM education itself is already prohibitively difficult. [0] https://thetab.com/us/2017/04/10/which-major-has-highest-iq-64811 https://thetab.com/us/2017/04/10/which-major-has-highest-iq-... [1] http://www.randalolson.com/2014/06/25/average-iq-of-students-by-college-major-and-gender-ratio/ http://www.randalolson.com/2014/06/25/average-iq-of-students...
- jedberg 8y agoBecause providing a better base eduction lets those who are in that 1 SD above category actually use it. There are probably a lot of people right now who are 1 SD above but can't get the education they need to make use of it.
- sdenton4 8y agoEverything will be fine when everybody is above average... Historically, the economic promise has been that everyone who CAN get a job will just get a Different job when new technologies make their current jobs obsolete. Plow-pushers will become welders, for example. And the usual futurist's question is whether instead the low-skill workers are more like horses in the 1930's, soon to be completely useless. The interesting argument in the article is that, well, even if the low-skill workers aren't completely unemployed, they'll be pushed forever into low-productivity industries that are happy enough paying them serf's wages... Perhaps keeping them just busy enough to avoid open revolt. (perhaps.)
- jedberg 8y ago> Everything will be fine when everybody is above average... That's not at all what I said. What I said is that education opens the opportunity for those who have the innate ability.
- 8y ago
- dominotw 8y ago> Part one, a more educated populace. Education will help those that can work in the "good jobs" get the good jobs. https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/learn-to-code https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/learn-to-code
- Sytten 8y agoI agree with you. I think we will see the Universal Basic Income appearing sooner rather than later. The economy needs a recycling mechanism and if it can't be through wages than it must take another form.
- atemerev 8y agoWe won’t. Even for retirement schemes, there is not enough money; retirement age is rising, the future is bleak. UBI is basically a lifetime retirement scheme; it requires 10x more resources and completely unsustainable.
- mac01021 8y agoThat depends what you mean by "enough money". If more than half of the population makes at least double what they need to keep themselves from starvation, then you could argue there is enough money. In short, your disagreement with the GP is probably due to a disagreement about the lifestyle that UBI is supposed to afford its recipients. Those in power might determine that the bare minimum UBI to avoid violent revolution is something like $5000 per year.
- atemerev 8y agoStarvation is not a problem in the developed countries (and most of the developing world). Food is cheap. Housing, healthcare and education are the problems, but $5000 per year are not nearly enough for any of that.
- mac01021 8y agoIt's absolutely enough for housing if you squeeze in. Healthcare and education are problems, but I'm not sure they're enough to provoke a revolution when everyone is otherwise well-fed and sheltered from the elements.
- nopriorarrests 8y agoWhat I don't honestly understand is source of money for UBI appearing sooner rather than later. I mean, US is projected to have one trillion budget deficit for a second straight year - "US Deficit 2019: Treasury to Borrow $1 Trillion for 2nd Year - Bloomberg". Slap UBI on top of it and this is Greece trajectory.
- philwelch 8y agoEducation is part of the problem, though. What people need are marketable skills, and most of those aren’t taught in higher education. What we need to stop doing is putting young adults 5-6 figures in debt with no marketable skills.
- atemerev 8y ago“Redistribution” is inherently unfair; there is no “redistribution” except by force. Venezuela was the most recent in the vast row of examples of how redistribution works; probably not the last, as the idea keeps being pushed by some people for some reason, completely unimaginable to me.
- erik_seaberg 8y agoIt's unfair that you were born into a world of people who want your stuff. It's also unfair they were born into a world with no frontier they could homestead to make their own stuff.
- atemerev 8y agoThe entire world is a frontier. I was born in Siberia; I wouldn’t want to stay there, so when I was old enough, I saved some money and bought one way tickets first to Moscow, then to Europe.
- whateveracct 8y agoWhy is redistribution of wealthy any more unfair than the circumstances that gave rise to it in the first place? Nobody inherently deserves their wealth - it's largely a function of circumstance.
- atemerev 8y agoIt is my wealth that is going to be “redistributed”. I am a relatively well off software engineer; I was born in a poor family on the outskirts of a Siberian town. I learned to program all on my own, by visiting my friends with computers and taking programming books from the local library. It wasn’t a “function of circumstance” — it was a function of my interest and targeted activity. What is unfair here?
- jedberg 8y agoSounds like you landed in the lucky circumstance of having access to a computer and access to a library with programming books. You also got lucky with finding a job that let you save enough money to go somewhere else. Should we not do our best to afford that "luck" to everyone?
- TACIXAT 8y agoIsn't wealth redistribution via taxes treating the symptom and not the cause? We should look at the structures that allow massive wealth inequality to form in the first place. This could be a lot of things besides tax policy.
- bearmcbearsly 8y agoThat's what the entire article was about.
- TACIXAT 8y agoReally? I didn't see anything about about wealth distribution via taxes versus other means.
- mac01021 8y agoRight. The article was about the social structures that cause wealth disparity to come about in the first place. Maybe you meant, though, that we should be discussing plans to replace those with better social structures. That's fair, but I admit to having a hard time imagining any that are not ultimately equivalent to wealth redistribution.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoThis would seem to lead to a Harrison Bergeron sort of outcome, no? I mean, basic variation in genetic factors, geographic and political circumstances of your birthplace, these things directly lead to variation of productivity, which in turn leads to variation of wealth.
- mrweasel 8y ago>Wealth needs to be redistributed I'm still not convinced that it's possible to successfully tax the rich enough to ensure that the poor isn't poor. The redistribution (and taxation) always comes up as "the solution" to inequality. I think that's overestimating how rich the rich are, and underestimating the number of poor people. It's easier to make the rich poorer, and close the wealth cap that way, compared to making the poor richer. Sadly that's not going to help anyone.
- baroffoos 8y agoIs this backed up by any stats? Last I saw the stats on America showed the top % is unimaginably rich and the inequality is massively worse than other countries like Australia where the average person is much better off.
- mrweasel 8y agoNo, and I might very well be completely wrong. My reasoning is that some one like Jeff Bezos is worth $150 billion, if we take all his money (which we can't do, because most of his wealth isn't exactly in cash), then each American could receive something like $500. That's not really helpful, and we can only do that once, if we take ALL his money. Maybe I'm underestimating how many rich people the world has, and how much money they have. It just doesn't seem like did have enough to make much of a difference.
- baroffoos 8y agoThe $150 billion sitting in bezos bank account does very little for everyone. If it was distributed among the population of America, most of it would be spent very quickly and there would be huge benefits for everyone. Preventing hoarding would do a lot of good for society.
- rland 8y agoOn the contrary. Most of that money is the capital that makes up Amazon and its subsidiaries, which has consistently grown faster (created more wealth/benefit) than almost any other entity in our society. That's your neoliberal take. Personally, I'm a little dubious that wealth created is 1:1 with social benefit created. But to say that his bank account benefits nobody would be a misrepresentation.
- Shivetya 8y agothere is another solution, get government off the backs of the poor and middle class. from costs of simple government services to the the fees associated with occupational licensing it is not cheap being poor and trying to work. then throw in the ever fun new ways cities try to make money by trumping up trivial issues like declaring someone's home needs repair, a stack of firewood done "wrong", or a crack in a drive way, and fining them hundreds if not thousands of dollars. all fines against people who cannot afford to dispute the charge and may not even be able to pay it. Traffic fines starting over two hundred dollars for even the most minor infraction. or school systems where the number of non teaching positions are inflated all the while at the same time politicians are raising taxes to under the guise of improving education but its merely to pay for non teaching jobs. The idea that the "wealthy" are not paying sufficient taxes ignores the reality of how much taxes everyone is already paying. People tend to just focus in on the "income tax" and ignore all the fees and embedded taxes in every day living. the US has one of the most progressive tax systems in the world and when you look at who pays the bulk of the taxes its not even close. As a percentage the "wealthy" already pay many times percentage wise than other classes. The US governments own figures on taxes at federal, city, and state, levels shows this- it is not even disputable. Yet, when Congress recently passed a law to limit state and city deductions from the Federal taxes to TEN THOUSAND dollars who complained? The same supposed champions of the poor and why ? because their OWN wealthy people were having to pay more taxes. Simple truth, you could confiscate every billionaires fortune and not pay for our government or the proposals in the offing. however where you will find that wealth is the investments backing pensions and 401ks. you think that once they "nip" the wealthy they will stop? After all its already been stated by many in one party about the unfairness of 401K programs you can damn well bet they will get their wish.
- 0x445442 8y ago>> Is it really just "I worked hard for it why should I give it away" No it's more "I worked hard for it why should it be taken from me by force or fiat". I've found most folks who are well off (not living hand to mouth) are willing, and do give to charity. It's when some other group of people start demanding this behavior through governmental force when attitudes change.
- normal_man 8y agoActually lower income people give more to charity than well-off people.
- sol_remmy2 8y agoIf you exclude Christian lower income people, that no longer holds true.
- honkycat 8y agoYour point? Why would you exclude them because they are Christian?
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoInteresting. Still, it's unclear to me why that exclusion is a valid way of doing the analysis.
- greedo 8y agoPer capita or as a whole?
- Dumblydorr 8y agoI give to charity too, so what? They live and got lucky in the country they are then refusing to assist proportionally with their means. Most of them are not Bill Gates, while they toss their pocket change to some charities, they lobby to Congress for favorable laws and live an insular existence that doesn't go near the common man.
- Dumblydorr 8y agoWe already have wealth distribution: the rich get their lawyers to allow them to dodge taxes and jail time, just furthering their ability to gain more wealth, while the rest of us play by their trickle down rigged tax system.
- jeffdavis 8y agoOnce you start redistributing wealth, it turns into a grand 300-million-person argument over who gets what. Immigration arguments because each immigrant would be entitled to something, often more than they contribute for some period of time. Childbearing arguments, for essentially the same reasons as immigration. Arguments about drugs and other vice, becasue everyone would want to make sure you are contributing as much as you can, and many feel drugs prevent that. Arguments about education and career choices. There are no absolutes, but as long as people basically believe that they have what they create, then they will focus on creating and not worry about what other people create (or not). When they believe they have what they can get through the political process, they will focus on political fights. Fundamentally, freedom and large-scale socialism don't mix. In a socialist system, there are just too many other people who have a vested interest in what you do (and don't do). It may work in small countries or on short time scales, but these arguments eventually result in authoritarian policies.