5 ms·
None of the discussion I've seen here so far has raised what I think to be a much more important point: there should be an extra level of indirection between me
by lisper 8y ago
None of the discussion I've seen here so far has raised what I think to be a much more important point: there should be an extra level of indirection between me and my physical mailing address. In other words, there should be a DNS for physical mailing addresses. That way my publicly visible "host name" wouldn't reveal where I actually live (makes it harder for burglars to find me) and if I move I only have to update my real physical location in one place (my "name server") rather than with everyone who wants to send me mail. Also, publicly-facing logical addresses (the analogue to "host names") could be mnemonic, and one person could have multiple aliases. So you could, for example, send physical mail to (say) "Lisper@HN".
This way no one except delivery people would care what these addresses resolved to. They could be lat/long, traditional street addresses, X-codes, whatever.
- xen2xen1 8y agoBut physical addresses are physical address, they specify a place, not a person. We'd have to set up a paralell system, and expect the government to be able to fund and handle both... Yeah, they can't do either for the current system...
- lisper 8y agoDNS isn't run by the government. Why would this have to be?
- eloisant 8y agoYou still need an easy way to tell people how to get to your physical address to visit you.
- lisper 8y agoSure, but then it doesn't matter what format you give that information out in. You can just give them driving directions.
- gregknicholson 8y agoCongratulations! This is xkcd #783. There's no need to remove addresses from places that already have them, and a system like [Plus codes](https://plus.codes/ https://plus.codes/) could identify physical locations without an address.
- A2017U1 8y agoA Google maps link would likely save them time rather than telling them the actual address.
- gbear605 8y agoBut what if they want to use Waze or Bing Maps or Apple Maps or...?
- icebraining 8y agoYeah, using a Geo URI[1] would be a better option. And helpfully, Android already supports them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geo_URI_scheme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geo_URI_scheme
- ahje 8y agoHave we finally reached the point where people no longer know what a phone book is? :D
- albertgoeswoof 8y agoHow much would you pay for this? Would you also accept a small delay to receiving mail? With enough capital it would be fairly straightforward to provide a forwarding service for this. You could also have spam filters or reject mail from specific senders, provide scans of the outside of the letters, specific delivery dates etc. Given how we are ordering more and more things online nowadays this could be a very exciting opportunity.
- lisper 8y agoI don't want forwarding. If I move from California to New York I want mail sent to me from New York not to have to traverse the country twice to get to me.
- slightwinder 8y agoThat would only work if all post-services would work together. Otherwise it would still be relayed to your redirection-service first, where it receives a new address-label and gets send out again. I think those services exist in some countries, but not from postal services themself, so delivery-time is still rather slow.
- nybble41 8y ago> That would only work if all post-services would work together. That's the idea: the redirection would be handled by the carriers, not some third party. In place of the current system of (a) scan address; (b) route package; (c) deliver package the process would be (a) scan recipient ID; (b) translate ID to address; (c) route package; (d) deliver package. The address lookup should be completely automated and introduce no discernable additional latency in the mail delivery. It could even be implemented as a special case of the address normalization step carriers already perform.
- slightwinder 8y agoWhat I mean is, in many countries there all are third-parties, because there is no monopoly on postal services anymore. So they must cooperate in some way and share the redirection-database. And this means implementing this would be very very complicate and take a long time, because companies are not very eager for cooperation until some strong reason exists. And this feature, as nice as it would be to have, is not really a strong reason for cooperation. In the first place there is not even enough data to know whether the huge investment would be justified.
- samcday 8y agoI like your proposal. I was just thinking about this problem recently too. In an era where people are becoming more privacy conscious online, they can make reasoned decisions about how much of their data they shield from megacorp$ that are eager to vacuum it all up. But if you want to partake in the convenience of online commerce, how do you effectively shield yourself from providing your home address to dozens/hundreds of companies? I wonder if there would be a market for the service you're describing today. It seems you could achieve it in the current postal system. You sign up and are assigned a unique identifier, which you use as your "Name", then ship to a local address maintained by that service, who then forward it on. All you're doing in this case is just centralizing the trust from each individual online business to the reshipping service. Is that a reasonable first step?
- lisper 8y ago> Is that a reasonable first step? Sounds good to me. You know who is well positioned to do this? Netflix.
- samcday 8y agoIs Netflix the kind of company we want doing this though? I'd imagine it being some kind of non-profit organization that is funded by a combination of donations + fees for the reshipping service. Put differently, if we want to centralize all this sensitive information (people's residential address), would you want an organization beholden to shareholders and profit margins operating it?
- lisper 8y ago> Is Netflix the kind of company we want doing this though? Better them than Amazon, Google or FB. (Oh, the horror!) But I like the non-profit idea better.
- icebraining 8y agoWhy Netflix?
- vishnugupta 8y agoThis. I relocated a couple of times recently, and am about to relocate again. I too contemplated about a similar service. Personally I'm not too worried about the privacy aspect as much as about the pain of notifying every single service provider when I change my address. It does open up some interesting use cases. E.g., when I go on vacation then hold off delivery, if it's from Amazon then deliver it to such and such a post box etc. I'm not sure about the market size though.
- BrentOzar 8y ago> That way my publicly visible "host name" wouldn't reveal where I actually live (makes it harder for burglars to find me) and if I move I only have to update my real physical location in one place (my "name server") rather than with everyone who wants to send me mail. This part is done by mailbox companies like EarthClassMail.com. I've used them for years, and it's wonderfully convenient to have the same postal address despite moving all over the country. Plus, if you want, they'll open specific envelopes, deposit checks for you, scan stuff, etc. I love that because as a traveling consultant, I don't wanna wait until I get home to have checks go into my bank account. Drawbacks: there's a latency and an expense involved with forwarding packages. I tend to not use it for packages, just for regular postal mail. Anytime someone asks for an address, they get my EarthClassMail one, because I probably don't want whatever they're mailing me anyway.
- lisper 8y agoSee my response here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19075900 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19075900
- goldenkey 8y agoYou couldnt paste a single sentence?
- lisper 8y agoThat had nothing to do with it. I didn't want to bifurcate the same topic into two branches of the discussion tree.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jshowa3 8y agoI don't think it would be advisable to deliver mail from point A to B directly, physically. It would be too inefficient since mail has to be sorted and is often sent to intermediate facilities to do this.
- mvdwoord 8y agoCongratulations, you have figured out what a P.O. Box is. A bit out of fashion (at least in NL) but was the standard for exactly this. Or people who were expecting to move around quite a bit. My Dad used to have one (around the divorce of my mom), My Uncle had one, as he was abroad a lot and moved house a couple of times, and wanted a dutch address. etc etc. As for paper email, aren't there also services that open and scan your mail for you? Not exactly "DNS for physical mail" as you described but quite handy! As for the obfuscation part, if the delivery people know how to resolve... so will many others. ;)
- lisper 8y agoNo. A PO box is a physical location, it just happens not to be my home. If I move non-locally I have to change PO boxes.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lscotte 8y agoThere are mail services that do this - it's like a PO box, but not provided by the postal service and they will forward your mail to anywhere. These services are quite popular with RV folks and world sailors. Some will even scan your mail for you.
- imglorp 8y agoThat's still not name indirection, this is more like a 302, because your physical mail goes first to the company and then gets moved around.
- mbreese 8y agoBut the person who sent the mail doesn't know where it ends up. These services are exactly like what the parent was talking about -- someone sends a letter to a virtual address at the mail aggregator service, and the service then sends the letter on to your physical address. A 302 is like a letter that's been marked return to sender with a forwarding address. The original sender would then know the actual physical address.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yeahitslikethat 8y agoEarthclassmail.Com is a virtual mail box.
- kakarot 8y ago> That way my publicly visible "host name" wouldn't reveal where I actually live (makes it harder for burglars to find me) Someone has access to this database. And they're selling the data for a price inversely proportional to the exclusivity of their access. Increasingly it seems that if someone is selling data on the open market, this information is increasingly available to bad actors such as burglars. So it just seems like a very bad form of security by obfuscation. There are definitely things to be said about generally decoupling your physical location from your mailing address if you frequently move, however.
- dfxm12 8y agomakes it harder for burglars to find me How so? Or rather, what exactly do you mean here? Burglars don't want to find you personally. They're scoping out a property an determining if no one is home. They aren't looking though the yellow pages for potential victims remotely; they're driving around the neighborhood trying to get physical access.
- alistairSH 8y agoThis was my first thought. Put another way... If I'm the type of person whom criminals will target by name, address obfuscation isn't what I need. Instead, I need a comprehensive security system (likely including body guards). Think heads of state and other famous people. Joe Developer isn't being targeted by name. He just gets unlucky because he left his MacBook within sight of the window and didn't lock the back door.
- lisper 8y agoI write a blog. One of the most popular kinds of articles I used to post was travelogues, until I realized that I was pretty much advertising to the entire world that I was away from home. That wouldn't be so bad except for the fact that it is also trivial to find out where my home is.
- beatgammit 8y agoWhy not just post the travelogue after you return?
- ohithereyou 8y agoBecause that reduces the narcissistic supply
- lisper 8y agoFor the same reasons that newspapers don't publish week-old news.
- 8y ago
- whiddershins 8y agoWhat I think is interesting about this comment is it appears to be a novel enough idea that many of the replies quickly dismiss it without really seeming to grok it.
- freehunter 8y agoPeople are dismissing it because it already exists in multiple countries. In the US for example, you can get a PO Box and have the USPS forward that mail to your home address. There are also companies that will do this for you with variations on the service (a registered agent is one example, the company Mailboxes Etc also offers this service), which some are dismissing based on "yeah but then a third party is handling your mail". But if your country's post office won't do it then the only alternative is to have a third party handling your mail. This service exists, and people are dismissing the idea because it is not novel.
- lisper 8y agoWhat you are describing is not the same as what I am suggesting.
- freehunter 8y agoThe only difference is that you have to send mail to a normal post office address and not a "hostname". Other than that, virtual PO Boxes exist and fulfill your basic requirement of "no one knows my home address", even if some of the behind-the-scenes implementation details aren't exactly the same (latency etc). We're not discussing something new, we're discussing low-level implementation details of an existing idea. I'm not saying your dream is bad, which is why I didn't respond directly to you. What I'm saying is I don't think it's a novel/interesting idea for a startup to work on as I believe was being implied by the person I replied to. Even if it became a big business (which I doubt since even UPS/Fedex/Mailbox ETC don't have that many postal customers for their own services) it's just too easy for the national postal service to compete with if it was successful. I think it is a great idea for the postal service to do, but it would be very risky for a startup to do, even by modern startup standards. The existing postal system is a marvel of efficiency already.
- sickbeard 8y agoThis completely ignores the fact that delivery guys work efficiently when they deliver mail sequentially. It makes no sense to have some weird address resolution system when they need your physical address to plan their routes properly
- snuxoll 8y agoHere in the US it’s incredibly easy to find where anybody lives if they are registered to vote. You can plunk my name into the Idaho voter website and it will spit my address out, no fuss.
- JorgeGT 8y agoI find much more crazy that your party allegiance comes out, and that those records can be harvested by apps to harass your friends/family/employees etc.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoHuh, they don't have secret voting in Idaho? Isn't that federally required?
- snuxoll 8y agoYour vote is secret, but your registered party affiliation is not.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoDo you have to register an affiliation? What is the scope of that affiliation? Who holds the register? What is its stated purpose? Are you allowed to be in more than one party? Does it bind your vote in some way? It all sounds very strange. Now in the UK large party donors are publicly listed. And parties have memberships in private. I guess I should do some research!
- snuxoll 8y agoYou can register as “unaffiliated”, but depending on your state what options you have for voting in primaries depends on your affiliation. Some states only allow you to vote in the primary for your affiliated party, others let you pick one or the other regardless, some will only let you vote in one parties if you are affiliated but the other has no such restriction. The system is a giant clusterfuck of rules, but everyone just kind of works with it for now. Your affiliation is part of your voter registration, so it’s held by your Secretary of State’s office.
- corpMaverick 8y agoObligatory reference to the Fundamental theorem of software engineering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_theorem_of_software_engineering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_theorem_of_softwar...
- isalmon 8y agoThis. For the past 10 months I've been travelling constantly staying at hotels, AirBnb's etc and in a lot of cases not having the permanent physical address is very inconvenient. I've tried multiple solutions but none of them work well. Yes, there are companies that offer "virtual mailboxes", but I can't ship any packages to them.