6 ms·
Hacker facing an 8-year jail term for exposing vulnerabilities in Magyar Telekom
- friendly_chap 8y agoHungarian here (Magyar means Hungarian in our language). The guy was not sentenced yet, likely won't be, but given how incompetent everyone involved one can not be sure. Telekom does not want to press charges as far as I know, so despite their gross technical incompetence, at least their they have that going for them. Hungary recently had a bunch of ethical hackers getting into trouble, but fortunately the people are so outraged at the powers that be trying to jail them that they don't get harmed.
- doktrin 8y ago> The guy was not sentenced yet, likely won't be, but given how incompetent everyone involved one can not be sure. Does the public prosecutor in Hungary have a poor conviction rate? I know nothing about your country, but if I were facing a similar charge in the US I would be very concerned.
- friendly_chap 8y agoI don't know about that, but I think we don't have such a culture of prosecutors having conviction rates (might be wrong on this one I admit). But Hungary is a very tense country, it only needs a spark to blow up (last time internet tax triggered a massive massive protest), so I don't think the political elite wants to risk protests and outrage.
- htamas 8y agoThe public prosecutor actually has a unusually high conviction rate (can't cite a source right now for this), but there was a very similar scandal last year where a similarly young security enthusiast figured out he could buy public transport tickets for any price in the then recently launched web interface of the Budapest public transport company (BKK). He did this simply by editing the form post URL on the order page. BKK then tried to prosecute him but quickly dropped the case since there was a huge public outrage. The website and the related services has been down ever since the incident. So this is why people suspect they will drop the case soon again, but as an other commenter already said, they are incompetent and corrupt to the bones, so who knows?
- kowdermeister 8y ago> Does the public prosecutor in Hungary have a poor conviction rate? Not if you are a politician. In the last two terms of Fidesz 1 low figure guy was convicted. I find that ridiculous since we are the poster child of corruption in the EU. It is because the Chief Prosecutor[1] is a good old friend of Orban. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P%C3%A9ter_Polt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P%C3%A9ter_Polt
- pjc50 8y ago- Never do unsolicited pentesting - If you do, be very careful about how you report it; must be to a recognised bug bounty program - Especially don't do this in a repressive state
- ygkkojr6 8y agoHungary is a repressive state? My sides.
- lucideer 8y agoDid you read the article? > Hungary’s Prosecutor Office has indicted the white hat hacker > 'the Prosecutor’s Office is asking for a prison sentence' despite the fact that in the indictment files 'it is not clear what exactly has he done.' The files lack the place, time, and means of the committed crimes he is accused of, 'and in general, nothing that would be necessary to present the lawful accusation in detail'," The Prosecutor's Office is a state body, is it not?
- gtirloni 8y agoRegardless of this specific episode, it seems it's becoming a pattern in Hungary. https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/01/31/eu-leaders-drag-their-feet-hungary-sanctions https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/01/31/eu-leaders-drag-their-fe...
- ygkkojr6 8y agoHaving a corrupt public servant (if this is the case here) does not make a country a "repressive state". It's highly unlikely this guy will actually go to prison. weev, on the other hand, did go to prison. Is the US a "repressive state"? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev#AT&T_data_breach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev#AT&T_data_breach
- coldtea 8y ago>Is the US a "repressive state"? Well, it has the biggest incarceration rates per capita, and the biggest death penalty rates, of the whole world, and a horrible legal system (three strikes, for example, or the tons of people that went to jail for BS like marijuana). It has the top incidents of cops killing people in the western world. Heck, until the 70s it even have segregation laws. Then there's the circus that are internal politics (the same two parties alternating in power for a century, following a bizarro multi-step process as remote from the actual people's vote as possible, with gerrymandering on top, and fat pockets with millions in promotion needed to have any chance as a candidate). Oh, and legal lobbying. That said, they do have a decent rule of law, a legacy of respect for freedom of speech, and quite good representation at the state level. [Edit: added some counter-items for balance]
- kome 8y agoWhen in a country you reward unethical behavior and you punish ethical behavior you are going to the fall. This is outrageous and ridiculous. Magyar Telekom is a bunch of crooks anyway, why in western Europe phones plans are so much cheaper?
- friendly_chap 8y agoBecause Hungary is just a free for all market for every corrupt big corp and organisation that wants easy profits. Everything costs more than in Western Europe (except rents and services), yet people make 1/6th of the money. Hence why third of the working population left the country.
- ruc0la 8y agoSad but true, just came back from skiing and the food is in general cheaper in France. Also the quality is better.
- kome 8y agoI know, I wrote a couple of articles about Hungary for Jacobin, for those interested: - https://www.jacobinmag.com/2018/03/viktor-orban-hungary-fidesz-authoritarian-opposition https://www.jacobinmag.com/2018/03/viktor-orban-hungary-fide... - https://www.jacobinmag.com/2018/04/fidesz-viktor-orban-hungarian-elections https://www.jacobinmag.com/2018/04/fidesz-viktor-orban-hunga...
- LeonM 8y agoThis reminds me of the Vtech hacker story. Darknet diaries did an excellent podcast on it [0]. As someone having worked in pentesting, I have mixed feelings about this situation. Whitehat or not, the hacker knew that what he was doing was illegal. Of course this gives the hacker a dilemma, as not disclosing might result in a blackhat exploiting the same vuln. [0] https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/2/ https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/2/
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoThe hacker in this case, if they want to do the Right Thing but without any reward, is report it anonymously - they of all people should know how to hide their tracks. Creating a throwaway e-mail address through half a dozen proxies and/or TOR is relatively easy.
- Timpy 8y agoThe hacker did report it anonymously, there's no evidence that the hacker was caught from the email they reported the vulnerabilities from. They of all people should know how hard it is to remain completely untraceable.
- xyzzy123 8y agoDon’t give other people power over you would have to be the first rule. Oh gee, a “blackhat” exploits it. Moral dilemma! Who cares? You can’t control what other people will do on the internet and if it’s a target worth more than pennies of crypto cpu someone else has most likely done it already. 9/10 there’s like a dozen webshells on that box if there’s a good bug to be had. I srsly don’t get the hand wringing folks do. Shells are shells and you know what you be doing. But every year there are more summer children and I suppose we should look after them.
- jacquesm 8y agoThis is a better article with a better headline: https://portswigger.net/daily-swig/hungarian-ethical-hacker-faces-eight-year-prison-sentence https://portswigger.net/daily-swig/hungarian-ethical-hacker-...
- amingilani 8y ago> gets a jail term of 8 years The article says the prosecutor's recommending an 8-year jail term, but since the court hasn't decided on the case — how did the hacker "get" a jail term? Is the article wrong, or is the Hungarian legal system different from what I'm used to?
- friendly_chap 8y agoIt is just simply wrong.
- gota 8y agoI think the threat of prosecution in this case is already some form of damage. Even if he is ultimately not convicted, future whitehats will think twice about coming forward because this one was _threathned_ with prosecution, thinking "what if I don't get so lucky?"
- tomp 8y agoSounds like the same thing that happened to Aaron Swartz...
- chii 8y agoThe smart thing to do, if a company has no public vulnerability bounty program, is to sell the information on the blackmarket instead. This will incentivize all companies to start their bounty program, whilst still getting some cash reward.
- mirimir 8y agoI don't know about the "sell the information on the blackmarket" part. But uninvited pen-testing seems pretty risky. Maybe it'd be prudent to have an ~anonymous pseudonym for this stuff. And if you really care about reputation building, you could use an ~anonymous pseudonym plus the sha256 or sha512 hash of some string. If it all works out, you just share the string, and reap the credit.
- 8y ago
- hd4 8y agoWhenever I hear another case like this, I'm once again reminded of how the mainland Chinese deal with being witnesses to accidents or crimes taking place (as long as they aren't the victim), they simply walk on by as the "reward" for them is often not good, and in many cases they end up getting implicated. Maybe it's time for solo security researchers to stop being the nice guys. I'm not saying they should start behaving like blackhats, simply that self-preservation must come first and when you are faced with an industry who treats what I'd consider acts of generosity with contempt and legal action, then fuck them.
- aboutruby 8y agoArticle with sources: https://www.zdnet.com/article/white-hat-hacker-discloses-magyar-telekom-vulnerability-faces-jail/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/white-hat-hacker-discloses-mag... > the first vulnerability allowed the hacker to obtain an administrator password through a public-facing service. The second bug allowed him to "create a test user with administrative privileges." Translated source article with much more information: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Findex.hu%2Fbelfold%2F2017%2F07%2F26%2Ftelekom_t-systems_biztonsagi_res_nni_etikus_hekker_rendorseg_nni_orizetbe_vetel%2F https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https... > She browsed and found a user guide in a PDF file on the Telekom website that contained the IP address of a DNS server. Performed a routine scan for this IP address and then surprised to find that it was relatively easy to get an administrator password from here.
- thecleaner 8y agoWhy would you set a precedent for not reporting vulnerabilities ? Are they stupid ? This just means "next time you find something, exploit it or just sell it to someone".
- oriol11 8y agoMany people in this thread trying to find something to attack hungarian right-wing politicians with and unfortunately there's nothing
- hiperlink 8y agoSome details that as it appeared (in Hungarian) on the Civil Liberties Union blog ( jelenti.blog.hu/2019/01/25/igy_kert_bortont_etikus_hacker_vedencunkre_az_ugyesz ): (it was translated to English by me, sorry for any mistakes): - he was invited to visit Telekom's office (the expenses was on him), and wanted to give them the details - he was not convinced by the meeting that they'll solve it (close the doors): tried again, successfully (yep, that's a bit grey hat). There are several issues not with the hacking, according to the Hungarian Civil Liberties Union: - the prosecutors used a way too generic accusation which missed several important details, like [regarding the crime] when, how, etc. - the accusation claimed that the hack was done by using the Internet (seriously). - they (the prosecutors) offered a deal of "admit the crime == free to leave" but when the guy denied they asked for more prison. - the prosecutor stated: "we are not IT people but we know from the media (!) that with Internet and certain competence he could have hidden more of his digital footprints". And the prosecutors didn't asked for expert advisory for more than one an a half year long. - they asked for 8 years because the hacker should have been able to disturb a public interest service, though the company claimed that this server/service was not affected any of their customers.