8 ms·
Out-Of-Office Messages Are a Security Risk
- kazinator 8y ago'Don't record "we're on vacation"' on you home phone answering machine is ancient knowledge/advice.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoIndeed - who has an answering machine these days?
- kiwijamo 8y agoMost people have voicemail which is pretty much the same thing.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoIn general, touche. For this context, there's a meaningful difference: voicemail, unlike an answering machine, is accessible from anywhere, so there's no reason to set a "we're out of town" message.
- duxup 8y agoThis reads like something someone logiced out in their head but has no basis in any information that indicates if any of this is a real risk.
- chias 8y agoOr you just check the box that says "only send to people at my organization".
- kop316 8y agoI'm glad I wasn't the only person who thought that. Not only that, my work email is very much decoupled from my personal email.
- adrianmonk 8y agoOr? That's one of the strategies that the article states for managing the risk: > Set the autoresponse to the smallest group possible. In many cases you can narrow it down to coworkers, and/or have a different message for people inside your organization than outside your organization.
- sm4rk0 8y agoWhat if you are working mainly with customers? BTW, the article says: > Set the autoresponse to the smallest group possible. In many cases you can narrow it down to coworkers, and/or have a different message for people inside your organization than outside your organization.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bigiain 8y agoI think the context of the blog post, "the lonely sysadmin", means "working mainly with customers" isn't its target audience. Bikeshedding for a moment, I suspect the right response for people "working mostly with customers" is for the CRM to automatically re-route known-customer and cold-call emails to someone else on the "working mostly with customer" team, instead of first up telling customers or leads "Sorry, Bob's away for 2 weeks", which is _never_ going to be the message you want to be sending there...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- heavenlyblue 8y agoOr, you could have a system that only responds this way to e-mails to which you had already responded in the past.
- throwawaymath 8y agoBut why? At that point I might as well turn off the feature...I can't know everyone who will try to get in touch with me while I'm out of the office. If I could, I'd just tell those people ahead of time. If someone tries to reach me for something unanticipated and I've never responded to them before, they won't receive a notification. This "threat" is a fugazzi. Honestly I can't believe this hit the front page of HN. What a ridiculous "security risk."
- arachnids 8y agohttps://twitter.com/natashenka/status/974822101067612161 https://twitter.com/natashenka/status/974822101067612161
- O_H_E 8y agoNext time a little comment would go a long way confronting with HN guidelines.
- arkadiyt 8y agoAs always with security the first thing to ask is "What is your threat model?" This person's threat model seems to be people who email him for a legitimate business reason, but see that he's away & take the opportunity to attack him? I just don't buy it - I think there is nothing wrong with always setting an autoresponder.
- markovbot 8y agoI think the point is that autoresponders will autorespond to legitimate business emails as well as phishing/scam/whatever other emails.
- kovrik 8y agoSo the attacker gets autoresponse. What's next? What is the attack vector here? UPD: also, I guess any attacker could just assume that you're Out of Office at night time.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoEDIT: To be clear, I don't think this is a serious threat whatsoever, and went through the exercise as an explanation. Go easy on my comments, just having fun thinking it through. Impersonate the person out of town to escalate to their privilege level. Imposter: "My password isn't working, can you help me reset it?" Yes, this is unlikely to to work in smaller orgs where you know people face to face. It is more likely to work as the org scales up in size (think enterprises with their own helpdesk). Once you have email and/or other federated access, you have a toehold. Bonus points if you've cloned their work cell SIM or have rerouted SIP for their desk phone to keep them out of the loop. I have seen weaker phishing attacks on financial/accounting staff who have the authority to move millions of dollars of corporate funds. EDIT: > Whom the would-be attackers send this email to? Phishing target > Do they send this email from their own email address? Throw away address or spoofed address from a familiar-to-the-business domain. > Is there an assumption that sysadmin/support team will blindly reset a password on someone else's request? This is one assumption. > How do attackers bypass corporate VPN? VPN access might not be required to obtain the level of access desired. Do all of your SaaS providers require 2FA? Your business bank accounts?
- tptacek 8y agoStuff like this is what keeps organizations from taking corpsec guidance seriously. Whatever the infinitesimal risk you accept by setting an autoresponder, it's dwarfed by the risk of convincing the rest of your team that you're a crank, and that what you have to say about phishing and email attachments isn't to be taken seriously.
- clubm8 8y agomy current job lets you set the autoresponder to only autorespond to people in the org. how is that such a bad risk?
- throwawaymath 8y agoIt's not a risk. That's a useful feature, but not because there are any security implications.
- Moodles 8y agoI agree absolutely. It's similar to previous companies I've worked at that do phishing test emails for all their employees (usually at 9am on a Monday). There's little evidence it works, it is security theater and generally harms productivity. Knowing when not to bother people about security can be really helpful.
- bplankers 8y agoFollowed immediately by HR sending an unsigned email about critical deadlines for benefits or something, telling you to click a link and/or a PDF attachment.
- kovrik 8y agoSo the real issue here is not emails or autoresponders, but lack of IT security knowledge among employees. Hence, do (mandatory) trainings or something.
- 8y ago
- dana123 8y agoOut of office? Its an invitation to a thief with the address attached in the signature.
- Haydos585x2 8y agoIs it? If I leave for a week is it assumed all of my coworkers also leave, our doors unlock and alarms are off? Maybe that's a risk for a single person working in a coworking space. Probably less so for companies that have >1 employee.
- joegahona 8y ago> Don’t tell people anything more than they need to know. Does everybody really need to know where you’ve gone and how long? Probably not. You’re just gone. Set some expectations around response time, though. That's a borderline contradiction.
- bplankers 8y agoTrue -- fixed. Thanks.
- ta2987 8y agoThis is a joke, right?
- nradov 8y agoMicrosoft Outlook allows separate settings for internal versus external out-of-office messages. There's no real security risk in telling my work colleagues where I am.
- city41 8y agoGoogle allows you to limit our of office messages to within the company as well.
- _asummers 8y agoI fail to see how being out of office and not responding to work email has any relevance to a person not recognizing when their bank accounts are being zeroed. I also fail to see the vector by which someone being out of office gives an attacker access to their bank accounts.
- Cyclone_ 8y agoImportant to keep in mind that security is always balanced with convenience. Individuals need to just judge how much "risk" they want
- willart4food 8y agoEven worse: Social media posts of traveling/vacation.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- graybored 8y agoQ "hey did you get my email? im following up. that thing X needs to be done and they are asking me why not" A "well, i was out of office. jamaica is amazing... have you been" Q "No, uhm, so the thing is that we are going to lose 5 bajillion dollars if this is not done by 2 pm" A "jerk chicken. its just like my mind opened up to a whole new way of seeing the world.... " Q "Right so.. .. will we be able to have that paper by noon maybe? Then I can get it signed and we can rush it back to the.." A "no, sorry, it takes 3 days to send it through Central, then West has to backsearch the kumquats, its not something i really have control over" Q ".... was your out of office not working? i couldnt see it.. i mean i thought you were there..." A "no, thats a security risk. i wouldnt want us to lose money due to some scammer" Q "what.. is that some new IT policy? i dont remember seeing that..." A "no, no, i read about it on this site for experts in computer stuff, its called Hacker News, you should check it out"
- scarface74 8y agoI haven’t seen any mention of his other point. “If you’re gone be gone.” I don’t respond to emails on vacation or after I get off of work. Not even meeting invites. If I happen to be working late trying to figure out something, I make it a point not to let anyone know. I don’t want to set the expectation that I’m always reachable. I have a project manager and a QA person who will send me messages on our Slack channel. They ask me did I see it I tell them when I’m home I’m home. One exception is that I will answer an email to our offshore team, but even then I take the local developers and manager off of the email list.
- lazylizard 8y ago2 cents on the topic. Potentially. Auto responders let spammers knows its a live mail account. It can also become a backscatter problem.