3 ms·
Yeah, it is also interesting how they categorize the activities... apparently reading a book doesn’t count as “avoiding boredom”, but playing a video game does.
by joe_the_user 8y ago
Yeah, it is also interesting how they categorize the activities... apparently reading a book doesn’t count as “avoiding boredom”, but playing a video game does... why?
- Why? Because a video game move forward at it's speed, setting, since it keeps things going regardless, it's own agenda. A book only moves forward at the speed of a child's own thinking. There's always an opportunity to stop and think when reading a book.
- IggleSniggle 8y agoEvery game I played as a kid moved at my speed because they were turn based or puzzle based, with the exception of WarCraft. Even many games today that are popular with kids, like Minecraft, can move at real-time speed but still be designed to be self-paced. In Minecraft, there’s always an opportunity to stop and think.
- ThalesX 8y agoI’ve never played Minecraft but it is my understanding that you have some sort of zombies that come nighfall. If these zombies catch you without shelter, they would presumably kill you. While this is a simple mechanic, I imagine even this small element of gameplay would turn a player towards thinking about survival rather than taking the opportunity to stop and think.
- solipsism 8y agoIt's clear that your college course in game design is of less value, in the context of this conversation, than having actually done lots of gaming. Minecraft has a Creative Mode where all you do is build. Or explore. Or whatever you want, at your own pace. It's incredibly popular -- spend some time on YouTube looking up people's creations. Let's remember the context. This is the quote we're talking about: Because a video game move forward at it's speed, setting, since it keeps things going regardless, it's own agenda. A book only moves forward at the speed of a child's own thinking. There are games that push you through like watching a movie. But even the most linear games let you make choices. Some games are slow, some are fast, some require quick thinking, some require slow calculated thinking. Some involve creativity, some involve math. Talking about games as if they're just push you through some rigid narrative like a movie is just incredibly ignorant.
- cortesoft 8y agoIt really depends on the type of game you play. There are a TON of open ended 'sand box' type games that don't do any of those things (City Builders, MineCraft, Factorio, etc).
- PavlovsCat 8y agoThere's also even more "tons" of games that do them.
- cortesoft 8y agoSure, which is why my point was that you can't treat all video games as the same.
- solipsism 8y agoBecause a video game move forward at it's speed, setting, since it keeps things going regardless, it's own agenda. I feel like maybe you've not done much gaming? This sounds like Tipper Gore telling us about how heavy metal music inspires devil worship.
- ThalesX 8y agoI took a college course in game design, one of the key components of said topic is ‘flow’. You want to keep the player in a state where it’s neither too hard nor too easy for them to continue playing. Make it too hard and the player loses interest. Make it too easy, the same behavior can be observed. If you want a game, you want to keep the player in a state of flow, if you can’t do that, the game would presumably not be well received by the players, thus not really a good game. You achieve flow through gameplay, and if you add gameplay to any medium, does it really keep a neutral agenda? The game needs to push you in one way or the other, else it’s not really a game.
- solipsism 8y agoAny game design course worth its salt would cover Myst. Tell me, in what way does Myst force an agenda in a way that a book does not?
- ThalesX 8y agoThe course did not cover Myst. Also, you make assumptions, such as the one that Myst was released when I took my game design class...
- kurtisc 8y agoLike a book that you don't want to put down?
- dvdkon 8y agoAs a young kid I didn't play any action games (especially first-person shooters) at first, because I didn't have the skill to play them properly, and instead I played games from other genres, like point-and-click adventures. I think your concern is unfounded.