3 ms·
> Google wouldn’t say what factors go into that score, other than that Google observes what a bunch of “good traffic” on a site looks like A few days ago, I si
by hedora 8y ago
> Google wouldn’t say what factors go into that score, other than that Google observes what a bunch of “good traffic” on a site looks like
A few days ago, I signed up for some service on a new-ish laptop, and it made me pass the storefront captcha three separate times.
This is yet another example of the social credit score being implemented in the US; in this case punishing users for opting out of continuous tracking (which will in turn be used for price discrimination or worse).
The good news is that this is almost certainly going to lead to a massive backlash as it becomes more common.
- Cacti 8y agoWhile I see your point, social credit is not tracking, it is tracking with legal, economic, and political consequences. Given that the consequences to you of opting out of this tracking are little more than a minor inconvenience of your time, comparing it to the nightmare that is the social credit system is laughable. And, I would add, you're in part trivializing the horrendous impact of the social credit system by making this comparison, because it gives others the impression that this is merely a difference of degree, rather than of substance. It allows people to make arguments like "Oh, the US credit score is just like China's social credit score, so the social credit system can't be that bad." Yeah, NO. You don't get denied freedom of movement between cities or states because you owe a few dollars, you don't have your passport revoked because you don't use Google cookies, you're not forced to sit in the back of the bus because of something vaguely political you posted on twitter, you don't get denied the ability to send your kids to certain schools because you rolled a stop sign. The social credit system is not a _tracking system_, it is a _legal system_ (made possible by surveilance), and while the US may one day be there, to suggest they are anywhere even on the same planet yet is laughable. Your average person in the US still, even after decades of abuse, has innumerably more rights than your average Chinese citizen.
- bennofs 8y ago> ... little more than a minor inconvenience of your time This is not entirely correct. I have seen recaptchas that simply deny access without giving any option to solve them when browsing with Tor. The message says something like: automated systems detected unusual activity, try again later
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sbierwagen 8y agohttp://jwmason.org/slackwire/on-money-debt-trust-and-central-banking/ http://jwmason.org/slackwire/on-money-debt-trust-and-central... >People get very excited about China’s social credit system, a sort of generalization of the “permanent record” we use to intimidate schoolchildren. And ok, it does sound kind of dystopian. If your rating is too low, you aren’t allowed to fly on a plane. Think about that — a number assigned to every person, adjusted based on somebody’s judgement of your pro-social or anti-social behavior. If your number is too low, you can’t on a plane. If it’s really low, you can’t even get on a bus. Could you imagine a system like that in the US? >Except, of course, that we have exactly this system already. The number is called a bank account. The difference is simply that we have so naturalized the system that “how much money you have” seems like simply a fact about you, rather than a judgement imposed by society.
- marcosdumay 8y agoA bank account is a system where the entire society decides how much it's worth. Your government does not control the contents of your bank account.
- sbierwagen 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation