10 ms·
Police stop people for covering their faces from facial recognition camera
- pcurve 8y agoguy told them to p* off and then they gave him the £90 public order fine for swearing,” Ms Carlo added. “He was really angry.” Didn’t realize this was enforced. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/8546253/80-fine-for-swearing-in-public.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/854625...
- smaili 8y agoIs there a formal definition of what words are considered “swearing” or is it at the discretion of the officer?
- viraptor 8y agoI don't think a list of specific words would be useful. Otherwise you could wish someone asphyxiation due to a foreign body erect in their throat and claim it's not swearing, technically.
- cortic 8y agoIts not swearing though. You want people locked up for saying "please officer stop bothering us" cause its analogous with 'piss off'? We have to decide whether expressing a (legal but unfriendly) sentiment is illegal, or only some wordings of a (legal but unfriendly) sentiment are illegal. Actually we don't have to decide, and the police will be quite happy, its a catch-all law; they get to arrest anyone they don't like and the public get to live in a legal grey area where they are only safe if they grovel and plead, its a minefield, tell me again why can't we have freedom of speech?
- DanBC 8y agoThe law is pretty clear. >A section 5 offence comprises two elements: > A person must (a) use threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour, or disorderly behaviour, or (b) display any writing, sign or other visible representation which is threatening, abusive or insulting; and > The words or behaviour, or writing, sign of other visible representation must be within the hearing or sight of a person likely to be caused harassment, alarm or distress thereby. This is all intepreted by the courts and they do push back against police misuse of the act.
- cortic 8y agoThreatening, abusive, harassment even alarm are all superfluous words to make insulting and distressed look better, really, to answer my own question; why can't we have freedom of speech? Cause we are a society distressingly terrified of being insulted.
- DanBC 8y agoIt's at the discretion of a judge if the person declines the on-the-spot fine. Judges waver a bit on this. Here's a blog post talking about the offence, and about a 2011 case: https://www.6kbw.com/publications/articles/section-5-of-the-public-order-act-1986-the-impact-of-harvey-v-dpp https://www.6kbw.com/publications/articles/section-5-of-the-... I think, but I'm not sure, that the offence isn't in the word that is used, but in how the word is used. I think if he'd said "I'm not fucking doing that" he'd have been ok, but if he says "fuck off, I'm not doing that" he isn't ok. But I'm not sure about this. It is a bit worrying that police so frequently use public order offences and I wish they'd reduce the use of them.
- jdietrich 8y agoSection 5 of the Public Order Act 1986 makes it an offence to use "threatening or abusive words or behaviour, or disorderly behaviour" in a public place. Interpretation of the precise meaning of those words is a matter for the courts; this has historically been interpreted quite liberally, but Harvey v DPP established the clear distinction between words that are potentially abusive and words that actually caused harassment, alarm or distress. Broadly speaking, you're OK to swear in front of a police officer, but you'll get nicked if you swear at a police officer, which strikes me as a reasonable compromise between liberty and civility. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1986/64/section/5 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1986/64/section/5 http://www.mondaq.com/uk/x/175956/Public+Order/Section+5+Of+The+Public+Order+Act+1986+The+Impact+Of+Harvey+v+DPP http://www.mondaq.com/uk/x/175956/Public+Order/Section+5+Of+...
- balfirevic 8y agoWhat about swearing at another person who is not a police officer? The law sounds like it prohibits that too.
- jdietrich 8y agoIt is a defence for the accused to prove— that he had no reason to believe that there was any person within hearing or sight who was likely to be caused harassment, alarm or distress, or [...] that his conduct was reasonable. The police aren't going to get involved if you use robust language at 10pm in a pub. They may well get involved if you start screaming obscenities in the supermarket.
- chippy 8y agoI think the guidance (if not the law) to the police is that they have to tell the potential offender not to use those words, or "don't swear at me" first, and if they still continue then they can be nicked. So they have to know that what they are doing is abusive first. In other words you can swear at the police but only once!
- weavie 8y agoI had a friend who was loitering at night. When an officer approached asking him what he was doing, my friend replied something to the effect of 'none of your fucking business'. The policeman warned my friend that if he swore at him again he would be arrested. My friend replied 'what, so if I say fuck again you are going to arrest me?' He spent the night in the cells.
- acct1771 8y agoV for Vendetta's due for a watch, I reckon.
- ndnxhs 8y agoI feel like there may be a need in the future to come up with trendy facial coverings. Might be useful to combine them with practical features like partical filters. Its also insane how you can be fined for swearing. Sounds like the police where harrasing some random guy and they expressed frustration in a non violent and ordinary way.
- baloki 8y agoThere was that face painting thing from a couple of years back, don’t know how effective it was though: https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/07/makeup/374929/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/07/makeu...
- viraptor 8y agoThe makeup ideas are already out there: https://cvdazzle.com/ https://cvdazzle.com/
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoThe ideas there appear to consist of using the hair, or attached fake hair, as a mask; or attaching fragments of a mask (particular reflective pieces) to the skin. They seem mostly very obviously designed as masks.
- clouddrover 8y agoI think the simpler approach is to put the police back on the leash. There are no real technical solutions to problems with the law. The law needs to be changed to stop police acting this way.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoUK govt have been slowly chipping away at freedoms we took for granted for decades. The Daily Mail is constantly campaigning to "do something" over some trivial thing or another. Putting the police back on the leash seems unlikely, to say the least.
- eveningcoffee 8y agoI do not believe that there is a technical solution for this political problem.
- PunchTornado 8y agoalthough there are some legitimate concerns about privacy, the tradeoff here seems worth it. if it were expanded to everywhere in London I believe we will catch criminals quicker.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- throwaway_1235 8y agoI think the communists said it best: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_idiot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_idiot
- nichos 8y ago"Those Who Sacrifice Liberty For Security Deserve Neither." -Benjamin Franklin
- evgen 8y agoIf you are going to throw out the quote, please learn the actual correct quote: "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." If fact, it would probably serve you well to learn that actual context of the quote as well (hint: it is not about the conflict between government power and individual liberty...)
- quaice 8y ago"Those Who Sacrifice Liberty For Security Deserve Neither." -nichos Better?
- nyberg 8y agoAt the cost of privacy? Wouldn't that make a huge part of the population "criminals"? They hardly teach law in UK schools meaning most of the population may be unaware of some of the smaller offences which are usually not much of an issue. It could also be used to wrongly place you at a scene where you had nothing to do with it.
- NeedMoreTea 8y ago> The force had put out a statement saying “anyone who declines to be scanned will not necessarily be viewed as suspicious” Though you'll be stopped, asked for ID (not compulsory in the UK), and fined if you decline. That sounds like being viewed as suspicious to me. It's a shame it sounds like he didn't decline the fixed penalty to get a court case. We're overdue for some civil disobedience.
- robjan 8y agoYou don't get fined for failing to produce ID but you can be fined for swearing at the police, which is what happened in this case. If he politely refused to show ID, there is nothing the police can do unless they have reasonable suspicion that the guy was committing a crime
- Simon_says 8y ago> fined for swearing at the police Punished for speech?
- robjan 8y agoAll speech isn't equal. Nobody has the right to use threatening or intimidating language
- jdietrich 8y agoPolice in England and Wales do have the powers to compel someone to remove a disguise, but only under specific circumstances under Section 60AA of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994. It is not clear that in these circumstances they had the power to do so, although there is nothing stopping them from simply asking someone to remove a mask. This man was fined for a separate offence under Section 5 of the Public Order Act 1986, due to his decision to swear at a police officer. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1994/33/section/60AA https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1994/33/section/60AA https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1986/64/section/5 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1986/64/section/5 It is worth noting that this trial is being conducted in the vicinity of the Westfield centre in Stratford, which has seen a number of serious violent incidents in recent years. It lies in something of a no-mans-land between the territories of various local gangs, creating a natural point of friction. There have been at least two incidents where a gang fight caused mass panic, one of which involved an acid attack. I am opposed to facial recognition technology on principle, but this seems like the most justifiable use-case; unless something is done, there's a very real risk of a mass casualty incident in the near future.
- nerdponx 8y agoThe problem is that it is a slippery slope. How do we, as a society, reward just uses of this technology and penalize, or make impossible, unjust uses of it?
- Tharkun 8y agoIn Belgium, covering your face in public has been illegal for at least as long as I've been alive. It's not usually strictly enforced (e.g. scarves in winter are fine), but it's nevertheless the law. When I was maybe 6 years old, I was dressed up as a Ninja Turtle, and got reprimanded by the police because the outfit included a mask.
- dingo_bat 8y agoWhy do you need to cover your face in public though? How would you feel if a masked person approached you on the street, asking directions or something? I'd be uncomfortable. There's something inherently suspicious about trying to hide your face.
- 0db532a0 8y ago“anyone who declines to be scanned will not necessarily be viewed as suspicious” So the police demanded to see his identification while having no grounds for suspecting that the guy had committed, or was about to commit a crime. There are two actual situations which come to mind where the man could have been legally compelled to provide ID: a designated area under the Terrorism Act, and a traffic stop. Neither of those situations apply here. If were in the same situation as this man, I might not be able to hold myself from telling them to piss off too.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoYou see someone, they notice a sign "police: cameras being used for facial recognition", one person turns away and immediately seeks to conceal their identity ... I'm sure people will come up with lots of creative reasons why the person covered up but the most likely is because they knew themselves to be a criminal the police would care about. As you consider you would get in the same situation I'm curious why you would cover up? Aside from that, I thought police were using facial recognition in public cctv already. So, I suspect the sign works rather like the "pickpockets in this area" signs that /pickpockets/ put up; they encourage people to reveal themselves. tl;dr is there a reason to cover up except hiding criminality?
- saagarjha 8y ago> is there a reason to cover up except hiding criminality This is a pretty standard “nothing to hide” argument.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoAnd? One sees it a lot in our town, some groups when they walk past police pull hoods down over their faces, scarves up, turn their faces away -- we have a lot of drug selling, these people match the look of those you see dealing/running (deliveries); or those who do the organised shoplifting. Whilst the rest of us may have lots to hide, our physical appearance isn't one of those things because we don't expect to be subjects of active investigations. Maybe that'll change?
- m3nu 8y agoIn Austria it's also illegal to cover your face in public. The only exceptions are cold weather, job, traditional costumes. Here is a great infographic about it. As can be seen, the law was originally against muslim women. But if it works equally well to support facial recognition – awesome. https://media.diepresse.com/images/uploads_1152/6/3/6/5289526/22-s10-Vermummungsverbot-PW_1506004077588230.jpg https://media.diepresse.com/images/uploads_1152/6/3/6/528952... (edit: forgot some exceptions)
- a3_nm 8y agoSame thing in France: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_ban_on_face_covering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_ban_on_face_covering
- known 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burqa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burqa is a religious tradition
- yowlingcat 8y agoWell that's one kind of a...sardonic response. I'm imagining a dystopia where people wear Burqas in order to evade facial recognition. The more I think about it, the more I wonder if facial recognition is sine qua non conceptually haram. Will there be some such standoff one day between Wahhabists and proto-centrist, pro-surveillance warhawks? What an odd world we live in.
- deogeo 8y agoWe can't stop omnipresent surveillance, because if someone chooses to put cameras on their store-front that's their business, but apparently we can stop people trying to avoid this surveillance.
- jaclaz 8y agoIn Italy there is a Law that prevents from having face/head covered in public that dates back to the terrorism years (1970's). http://www.edizionieuropee.it/LAW/HTML/46/zn81_03_001.html#_ART0005 http://www.edizionieuropee.it/LAW/HTML/46/zn81_03_001.html#_... It is rarely (or never) actually enforced, as it prohibits specifically to wear "in public places or in places open to the public" (unless there are specific reasons) helmets (including motorcycle ones) and "any other means that may make difficult recognising the person", which would include scarfs. hoods and similar.
- mhb 8y agoIt would be great to tell the anti-vaxxers that facial recognition cameras cause autism. Two problems solved!
- rahuldottech 8y agoArgh c'mon. This is just getting increasingly dystopian and Orwellian. I don't like this.
- webmobdev 8y agoIncidents like these just confirm my suspicion that the real reason UK exited EU was to complete their political experiments on spying on their citizens (both offline and online) - EU privacy laws might have proven a hurdle here.
- jradd 8y agoWhen are we going to find a clever trick like the "License plate SQL injection" command [1] to drop database upon scanning the malicious text superimposed on a license plate. Obviously sql injection wont work, but perhaps some sort of sunglasses, makeup, lipstick, jewelry, or hat could severely confuse the neural net's recognition algorithm, similarly to the way certain colors of faces would confuse emotion detection in camera's a while back. edit: Don't know if this is authentic or not, but apparently there is a clothing line in Berlin that features patterns [2] meant to confuse these systems. [1]:https://hackaday.com/2014/04/04/sql-injection-fools-speed-traps-and-clears-your-record/ https://hackaday.com/2014/04/04/sql-injection-fools-speed-tr... [2]: https://static.independent.co.uk/s3fs-public/thumbnails/image/2017/01/05/16/hyperface.jpg https://static.independent.co.uk/s3fs-public/thumbnails/imag...
- acct1771 8y agohttps://cvdazzle.com/ https://cvdazzle.com/
- clubm8 8y ago>“The guy told them to p* off and then they gave him the £90 public order fine for swearing,” Ms Carlo added. “He was really angry.” The fine was not for covering his face. It was for swearing. People often forget that the UK is a monarchy and does not have rights like free speech.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoActually we do. Under both common law, and statute via the Human Rights Act. What does being a monarchy have to do with it? Say anything you damn well like unless it has been proscribed by Statute. Examples include inciting racial hatred or as here the provisions of this public order law.
- clubm8 8y ago>Actually we do. Under both common law, and statute via the Human Rights Act. Then why was a man fined for telling an officer to piss off for invading his privacy?
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoIt's one of the situations that have been proscribed. In this case by the Public Order Act 1986. Personally I think this provision in law an overreach, but the general point stands. Say anything you like unless it's been specifically prohibited.
- clubm8 8y ago> It's one of the situations that have been proscribed. In this case by the Public Order Act 1986. You just claimed you have free speech. Now you're citing a specific law making it illegal to not be deferential enough to police. These two points conflict.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoI am aware of NO nation on earth that has unconstrained free speech, including the USA. I believe the famous canonical example in a US context is shouting fire in a crowded theatre, and therefore speech opposing the draft. I see no conflict whatsoever.
- sys_64738 8y agoThere's a reason Airstrip One was the UK.