12 ms·
The Zipper Rule on German Roads
- ojbyrne 8y agoExcellent book that mentions this as well as other counterintuitive facts about driving: https://www.amazon.com/Traffic-Drive-What-Says-About/dp/0307264785/ref=asc_df_0307264785_nodl/ https://www.amazon.com/Traffic-Drive-What-Says-About/dp/0307...
- sowbug 8y agoTom Vanderbilt's Traffic: Why We Drive the Way We Do (and What It Says About Us) contains the same conclusion that late merging leads to less congestion because of fuller utilization of available lanes. Related reasoning supports the London Underground's Holborn Station experiment to encourage escalator users to stand on both sides, rather than the customary stand-to-the-right, walk-to-the-left. https://www.amazon.com/dp/0307277194 https://www.amazon.com/dp/0307277194 https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/13/world/europe/a-london-subway-experiment-please-dont-walk-up-the-escalator.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/13/world/europe/a-london-sub...
- fuckyah 8y agoI'm trying to do this here, but most Americans just don't get it. f
- astrodust 8y agoThe stand right, walk left tradition here usually works well, and it's not like the left is empty for a lack of walkers. Maybe it's cultural or depends on how eager to walk people are as to utilization factors.
- kaikai 8y agothe stations where they encouraged people to stand on both sides were so far underground that almost no one chose to walk up. In the case of the Bay Area the “walking” side is often fully utilized and it wouldn’t make sense to stand on both sides.
- benzible 8y agoBART now discourages "stand right, walk left" because it leads to "'uneven wear' on the escalator's gears, which can lead to more breakdowns and need for repair." https://sfist.com/2017/01/16/bart_says_actually_standing_on_the/ https://sfist.com/2017/01/16/bart_says_actually_standing_on_...
- blattimwind 8y ago"The infrastructural humiliation of America"
- vinay427 8y agoMaintenance problems aside, I'm usually surprised at how consistently people follow the stand-right "rule." Typically, everyone ahead of me followed it in my experience with BART.
- dbaupp 8y agoStanding is denser than walking, so the throughput is greater (at the cost of latency, for those who would walk). I believe the station only encouraged the break in tradition at peak times, when there are significant numbers of people waiting to get on.
- jrbancel 8y ago> Standing is denser than walking, so the throughput is greater Doesn't this depend on the walking/standing density ratio and walking speed/escalator speed ratio? Let say the walking density is 1/2 of the standing density. If the walkers walk at the speed of the escalator (i.e. their speed relative to the ground is 2x the speed of the escalator), then the throughput is the same.
- frosted-flakes 8y agoHolborn's escalators are over 23 metres tall, as tall as a six or seven storey building. Very few people will walk up the entire escalator, essentially limiting utilisation to 50%.
- eevilspock 8y ago> Standing is denser than walking, so the throughput is greater Optimal Tip-to-Tip Efficiency is well studied mathematically. Here's the authoritative paper: https://www.scribd.com/doc/228831637/Optimal-Tip-to-Tip-Efficiency https://www.scribd.com/doc/228831637/Optimal-Tip-to-Tip-Effi...
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoI really feel like that could have used more illustrations.
- labster 8y agoDoesn't seem to be cultural. It was replicated in Japan: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18735288 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18735288 There are other issues than eagerness to walk, like physical disabilities and collision avoidance. Ultimately two-speed traffic only works better if you're far from congestion, I believe.
- grabbag 8y agoWe do this in the US in many places. The difference is we don't need a law for every common sense rule. And for some road configurations, strict adherence to the rule wouldn't make sense.
- aquabeagle 8y agoAlternating merging yes, but many people probably don't wait until the last possible opportunity to do so. Some merge as soon as they can and think late-mergers are trying to cut ahead.
- mrep 8y agoThat's because a lot of people like me don't/didn't know about the zipper merge and asscoiate it with 1 lane exits where assholes try and merge into the backed up exit lane after flying by everyone else in the other non queued lanes and thus blocking other lanes.
- mark-r 8y agoThere's no worse feeling than realizing the backed up traffic in the right lane that you've been buzzing by was waiting for the same exit you need. I hate being "that guy" but sometimes ignorance catches you unaware.
- mrep 8y agoTotally, that's why I let people in at the start of the queue and get more aggressive about not letting in people the further I get into the exit lane queue. I still let in people but the further into the queue I get, the less permissive I am because if you fucked up, then accept the fact that you will have to miss your exit and reroute back to your destination and hopefully you won't be that asshole next time and enter the queue early.
- pkamb 8y agoThen drive to the next exit...
- FTA 8y agoI try to follow the zipper rule when getting on the freeway. The problem I run into quite often in CA (and the thing that frustrates me the most in urban driving) is when people behind me on a highway on-ramp cut across the solid white line to "get ahead". That then forces me to have to slow down while they pass so I don't ram them from the side. If you factor in other through-way cars already in the lane, this can really congest merging and you get major backups in the rightmost lane. A similar event comes to mind when you come across someone sitting in the left lane going under the speed limit but completely unaware or bother for the people passing them. So I guess my point is, while these are great in theory, they don't really work in practice without buy in from the herd (I use herd as this problem can be framed in a similar light as vaccinations and herd immunity).
- ken 8y agoYes, this is one of those concepts which works much better for everyone, if everyone else drives like a German driver. In the US, when you get to the end of the merge region, most people in the continuation lane will blast by at full speed, leaving no room to get over. I have to sit at the end of my lane, stopped, until I see a gap, and then floor it. That's worse for safety, fuel efficiency, wear and tear on my drivetrain, my own transportation time, and overall road throughput (everyone blocked behind me). This is a "boil the oceans" type solution. All you have to do is convince everyone to do it. Here, we can't even get people to stop blocking the box. The SPD is making short YouTube videos with "PRO TIPS" like "Bus lanes are for buses" [1] and "Don't stop in the street" [2]. The average driver is not at the point of thinking about higher level strategy like merge location yet. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s_62iDA5Z-s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s_62iDA5Z-s [2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S3dUj6-Kx5k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S3dUj6-Kx5k
- frosted-flakes 8y agoMerging onto a freeway from an on-ramp is different, and zipper merge doesn't usually apply. There's a reason the merge zone is 300-500 metres long (where space permits), and depending on the region, clearly marked with a dashed line. It's up to you to match the speed of traffic, then signal your intention to merge before merging into a gap in traffic. Some on-ramps even have metering lights to space out incoming vehicles to make this process smooth. The only time other vehicles should have to change their speed is in heavy traffic, when a gap might not exist.
- loeg 8y agoThis is also the rule in the US, isn't it? Maybe just Washington? http://mynorthwest.com/474290/washington-traffic-law-reminders/ http://mynorthwest.com/474290/washington-traffic-law-reminde...
- banana_giraffe 8y agoThe article mentions Washington and Minnesota (and other unspecified states) are trying to encourage it. I certainly see it sometimes. I also see people preventing it sometimes by straddling both lanes.
- mwfunk 8y agoLane straddling doesn't prevent people merging via the zipper rule. Rather, it prevents people already on the road from moving over to the merging lane, shooting ahead of a bunch of people, then merging again (slowing down everyone else by adding to the merging traffic). It's one of those behaviors where whatever convenience that person gets is greatly outweighed by the cumulative cost to everyone else. Actually lane straddling doesn't even work to prevent someone from using the zipper rule. It prevents people from passing other people on the right (nobody should be passing anyone on the right most of the time anyway). But it doesn't prevent someone from merging into the other lane when the time comes. As long as you're pacing yourself vs. the speed of the traffic in the lane you want to merge into, everything's fine. Using the zipper rule doesn't mean you race ahead of everyone before merging, if anything it means waiting a little bit longer and maybe even merging behind a car you would otherwise be tempted to merge in front of.
- loeg 8y agoStraddling prior to zipper merge at the last moment is absolutely intended to prevent proper zippering, which you would describe as "shooting ahead on the right."
- mwfunk 8y agoMaybe I'm wrong, but my understanding is that proper zippering is simply waiting until the lane ends to merge. You align the right side of your car with the curb and let it weave you into the lane at its own pace. It doesn't necessarily involve speeding ahead to get to that point, although certainly lots of people do that. It minimizes the jostling and speeding up and slowing down that people do to try to actively find a place to fit in. When traffic is at its peak, it approaches its ideal state: the on-ramp is fully occupied with cars (no space wasted), and everyone's driving at basically the same constant speed up to the merge point, where everyone neatly and cleanly merges, alternating lanes. But if traffic is not at its peak, zippering doesn't require you to race ahead to merge point. It wouldn't hurt anyone if you did that, of course. Same for everyone else waiting to merge. But there really are lots of people (where I drive at least) who are already on the road/freeway/whatever, who will move onto the (about to end) merging lane, race up to the end of it and force themselves back on the road, a few cars ahead. I've seen so many bad traffic jams made so much worse by people doing this. It makes a bad situation so much worse for everyone. Those are the people the straddlers are guarding against, not the well-mannered zipperers trying to do the right thing.
- numlock86 8y agoThis sounds good in theory, but it works less than one out of four times. (no negativity bias included) There's always someone not following the rules, which in human nature automatically grants every observer to do the same. Following local news right now it seems people aren't even capable of "Rettungsgasse" (leaving a corridor for emergency vehicle access in traffic jams) anymore, a concept also encoded in law here. Sincerely, a German who's on the Autobahn on almost daily basis.
- baxtr 8y agoStrange. I see it working in practice 80% of the time... I’m on the road a lot, too. “Rettungsgasse” is something that regained popularity in the last years due to strong media push.
- User23 8y agoIt always irritates me when I see people refusing to yield the right-of-way to rescue vehicles.
- CalRobert 8y agoFor what it's worth, foreigners driving there may not be aware of the rule. I tried as hard as I could to be a conscientous, informed road user before my first trip to Europe (studied signs, rules of the road, etc.) but still got an angry motorcycle cop whacking my mirror in France because I thought emergency vehicles would pass on the shoulder and had moved over to allow this, not in this Rettungsgasse (or the French equivalent)
- danieldk 8y agoWhat makes it worse is that the rules differ, even in EU countries. In Germany you have to make a 'Rettungsgasse' when there is a traffic jam, whereas e.g. in The Netherlands, emergency services use the 'vluchtstrook' (outermost lanes not used for traffic) in such cases.
- 8y ago
- scurvy 8y agoOr just ride a motorcycle and do whatever you want wherever you want whenever you want. ;)
- nycidiot 8y agoThis is interesting, because merging in New York is an extremely aggressive and hostile activity on the surface, but with the equally high noise floor of ambient, surly stink eyes, each individual instance of road rage’s signal to noise ratio achieves a normalization that leaves all participants within the cloud-like traffic mob in a state of mutually unhappy compromise. To reduce this concept to four succinct words: Yeah, fuck you too... In the outer tri-state area, and among tourists, this can, and does boil over into real animosity in the surrounding smaller towns and suburbs, where heavy police activity usually muscles up against aggressive city driving tactics, to keep the peace, and establish normitive boundaries to clue the unititiated in on the fact that they’s outside city limits, and it doesn’t fly in other counties. But to elaborate, city merging means maintaining sub-six-inch proximity to adjacent vehicles in slow moving traffic. This is done to acheive a number of effects, from preventing pedestrian induced gridlock/deadlock at crosswalks, to nosing in on corners, such that a wedge forces surounding vehicles apart, by way of slow-motion chicken. It requires an extremely accurate sense of vehicle volume and the bounding box definition of your car’s footprint/shadow in the lane. This manner of merging also plays into the fact that most professional drivers, from taxi cabs to box trucks, will yield, because they kind of get paid by the hour. The only wrinkles to this driving style are Wall Street Lambos, McLarens and such, and the occasional motocycle. More often than not, these exceptions will often appear within proximity before you register their presence, and typically outmaneuver you, before you have a chance to assert position, even if you do see them coming.
- gorpy7 8y agoIn many cases the lanes weren’t designed for zipper merging or drivers “zipper merge” at inappropriate places. Zipper merge is great! But not all merging is to be a zipper merge- this is constantly abused, and perhaps justified in the minds of offenders under the guise of the zip. A lane, such as an entrance lane, that terminates is a good time to zipper merge. But many many times, in Minnesota, people use any lane that allows them to cut to the front of the line. Regardless if that causes a massive slowdown as they leave the relatively free flowing lane and “zipper merge” - match speed of the slow lane. Articles would do well to mention the finer points before ushering us to 10% gains... maybe.
- EricE 8y agoThe "merge when you can" mentality that has predominated in the US is the major cause of this. If people would just go down to the merge point and then merge there wouldn't be an issue. It only leads to the perception of "cutting" when more idiots merge well before the natural merge point then logically where the lanes pinch back down.
- jmkd 8y agoGlad to see lane design mentioned, it's a key component. In most zipper merge opportunities there is a predominant lane and another lane that is ending, leading to the idea of a 'right' and a 'wrong' lane which precludes intuitive zipper merging. If lane design (even just the markings) were such that both lanes were equal prior to the merge, zipping together would seem the most natural thing to do whether signposted or not.
- pkamb 8y agoTo encourage this behavior, why not put a stoplight in the middle of the road at the merge point? Just like the ramp meters that limit cars entering the freeway. But instead a dual light that encourages zipper merging via offsetting green signals for each lane.
- rtkwe 8y agoA full stoplight requires a full stop which defeats a lot of the benefits of a proper zipper merge where traffic just keeps flowing with no stops. In a more general sense on a highway any time a car comes to a full stop you have the chance to create a phantom traffic jam as the stop travels back along the incoming stream of cars. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5005afd7e4b0a6953320bf3f/t/57c6ceb69de4bb8747981006/1472646990392/?format=750w https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5005afd7e4b0a6953320b...
- marcus_holmes 8y agoAs an Australian driver: hahahahhahahhahahah you got Buckley's, mate. No f_ing way am I letting you in. Get f_ed As an English driver: <extreme tutting> get to the back of the queue like everyone else! As a Cambodian driver: we are all stuck in a sea of motos, and being on time for anything is unimportant. Of course you may merge into my lane.
- lysp 8y agoAs an Australian driver I like to use what I call the "Robin Hood Rule" - steal from the rich, give to the poor. What that means is if someone tries to push their way in, I will block them off. If someone is stuck and trying to get out of a side road / park, I will always let them in.
- leetcrew 8y agoI think this is a dangerous approach, as the more aggressive drivers are more willing to play chicken and risk a collision. of course I follow the same rule myself.
- kweks 8y agoOr in Paris: give way to cars that are more dented than yours.
- captainpete 8y agoKiwis have this rule, signs saying "Take this tip: merge like a zip!" (think of it said in a happy kiwi accent). Driving in Australia without the rule, merging gets personal quickly.
- EricE 8y agoI can't believe this is even debatable. Near my house there are a couple of lights where the road opens up to two lanes before the light, then after the light narrows back down to one lane. Obviously people should zipper off before the light to load both lanes evenly and get as many people through the light before it cycles. Then after the light everyone should go forward and re-merge back into a single lane again. Yet people will stubbornly pile into the left lane before the light leaving the right mostly empty then play games blocking people from merging in after the light. Well, that's when they actually move through the light in a timely manner if not distracted from texting while stopped at the light :/
- mhdhn 8y agoMaybe they feel the right lane is only for people turning right?
- seattle_spring 8y agoThen it would be a right turn only lane...
- pnutjam 8y agoYes, we have roundabouts where this happens. I also see this at the interstate on-ramp by my office. There is a long lane, often backup up past a stop light and then it goes to 2 lanes for about 50 yards before the light that lets you turn left onto the interstate. Nobody ever turns from the rightmost lane, everyone stays in the left lane. When I use the right lane and pass people I get angry reactions, people trying to block me from merging back in, and a couple times people cursing at me and following my car. Luckily I'm a big guy who's not easily scared.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- henrikschroder 8y agoSweden has the same laws, but everyone still merges early because some sense of "fairness" kicks in, and people don't understand that they're making any queuing worse by not utilizing all available road surfaces. I've stopped caring about other people's sense of fairness in these situations, and I always use the empty lane and merge late. The law is on my side, and people can glare and honk as much as they like. I just saved five-ten minutes of not queuing, they could too if they all learned to drive correctly.
- Angostura 8y agoAs a Brit, I always merge early due to the sense of fairness. However, this is strongly enforced by the nature of road signs, which show, say 500m ahead, a diagram with an arrow on the right merging to the left. All it would take would be a consistent change of sign showing merging in turn at lane-merge to change this behaviour
- lorenzhs 8y agoThis is the sign for a zipper merge in Germany: https://www.swr.de/-/id=22217882/property=gallery/pubVersion=1/d6vtby/r.jpg https://www.swr.de/-/id=22217882/property=gallery/pubVersion... (the text says "zipper merge, no sooner than in 400m"). But we also have the arrow sign you describe, albeit with the same text as the other one: http://www.steine-und-erden.net/se501/reissver.gif http://www.steine-und-erden.net/se501/reissver.gif. It would be interesting to conduct a study on whether there is a change in behaviour depending on which sign is used.
- Angostura 8y agoThat would be perfect. The odd thing is that you do see very occasional zip-merge signs in the UK, which tend to reinforce the idea that zip-merge should any be used in exceptional circumstance.
- slantyyz 8y agoAs someone who lives in Ontario, Canada, I merge early as a defensive/safety measure. People here will follow each other incredibly closely, even at high speeds, and quite often they won't slow down to let you in if you're trying to merge.
- User23 8y agoI independently rediscovered this driving in Southern California. It's the obvious fair and efficient solution for two lanes merging. What most Americans have a hard time understanding is that German driving school, or Fahrschule, requires the student to master these "advanced" techniques. Unlike in the USA where if you can operate the throttle and the brakes you're good to go.
- gregopet 8y agoIt's not just drivers who don't let someone from the empty lane 'cut in' - there are those that stop completely and let in 3 or 4 'poor sods who were stuck on the wrong lane'. This breaks the system just as badly! The trick is to merge 1-1 as fluently as possible or you've broken everything.
- tluyben2 8y agoI can see the comment in the post about the UK; I am used to this practice in a lot of EU countries I go; in the UK however, they don’t do this and the amount of roadrage there is quite staggering. I do not drive there but when I am in taxis/Ubers, the amount of honking, cutting in, swearing, (racial) insults and flipping the bird I have not seen in other countries. Ofcourse mostly in/around large cities but I have seen it in tiny villages too; enough anyway for me (YMMV) to think it is not an anomaly. Not sure where all that anger comes from but I am happy that a hardly ever saw it in other countries where I drive or take a taxi.
- jacquesm 8y agoTry driving in Bucharest or Athens for a bit and the UK will seem positively polite.
- tluyben2 8y agoI drove in Bucharest a few months ago; I did not notice this. But might well be as this is all anecdotal anyway; I have been in the UK many times, I have been in Bucharest once (I did not like it compared to other cities in RO).
- chkaloon 8y agoI've never actually seen this work in practice, so maybe i'm missing something: Isn't the overall flow of traffic defined by the speed of traffic within the narrow section? E.g. if the speed limit and actual speed of traffic in the one- lane construction zone is 45mph, how people merge prior to that point should be irrelevant. The same number of cars are going to get through at the same rate.
- pintxo 8y agoFrom my experience, the speed is most often lower at the merging zone then in the following stretch of road. So overall througput could be improved by a more strict merging regime.
- viraptor 8y agoThere are a few other things in play: You get less of the wave-like behaviour from 2 lanes merging. That means fewer start/stops. If the line is long enough, it may also reach the previous intersection - with two lanes it gets much shorter, avoiding blocking other directions.
- ykevinator 8y agoIt's sort of a nice thing that people choose nice over efficient.
- seattle_spring 8y agoNo it's not, and often being "nice" instead of doing the correct and predictable thing while driving is extremely dangerous.
- 6nf 8y agoNew Zealand has some 'Merge like a zip' signs. I've not seen them in Australia but people do know the rule. They just don't follow it all the time.
- will_brown 8y agoI personally have never seen more efficiency on the road than Manila. Merging is just on an entirely different level in the Philippines. I would recommend going of course (not just to observe their driving) but there is no shortage of YouTube videos of traffic/Driving in Manila.
- FabHK 8y agoOr other countries in SEA, for that matter. The way to cross the road, as a pedestrian, in Cambodia is this: Close your eyes and, with one hand raised, walk across the road at a steady speed. Traffic will flow smoothly around you. Any attempt to avoid traffic by walking faster/slower will confuse everyone and lead to accidents.
- arjunvpaul 8y agoFor people who prefer videos - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cX0I8OdK7Tk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cX0I8OdK7Tk
- sametmax 8y agoI don't get it: why not just put all the cars on one lane then ?
- skocznymroczny 8y agoIn a case of a highway it might not be as beneficial, but imagine a city with lots of road intersections. If you put cars on two lanes and merge, you have half as long line of cars. In case of one lane scenario, the cars might block the previous intersection for other cars.
- sametmax 8y agoIn a city, you won't have this problems, as traffic will jam at the first road work it encounter anway. Besides, how do ones plan to make all those people collaborate ? It all seems very theorical and not that useful.
- nmeofthestate 8y agoNo, it's the opposite. In a highway/motorway situation with more queuing space it's not such an issue. In urban situations where queuing space is limited, using both lanes is more important, as longer tail backs will cause problems with junctions further back on the route.
- close04 8y agoThe drivers should know to leave just enough space in front of them for the car on the other lane to merge. Having to stop for a merge makes everything slower. It takes longer to accelerate so longer to clear the jam. Ideally one lane slows down and leaves some spaces between the cars, and the other one merges 1 to 1 without anyone ever having to brake to a full stop. And I see this working every day since where I live the rule applies. Of course there will always be the occasional smart guy who rides in the ass of the car in front in order to not let anyone pass and save 1-2 seconds at the price of causing everyone behind him 10 times the delay. This forces the cars trying to merge to come to a full stop, then forces some of the cars on the other lane to fully stop in order for the merging cars to be able to accelerate and merge.
- danieldk 8y agoThis is not really specific to Germany. Zipping is also used in e.g. in The Netherlands and Belgium. It's been required by law in Belgium since 2014 and has been campaigned in The Netherlands since 1989 (apparently). Also, having lived in Germany for five years and having been in 'Stau' for many times, Germans are also not terribly good/efficient at it. Typical problems: people switch to the lane that is supposed to zip when traffic is going faster, which is obviously counterproductive; and not leaving openings for people to zip. It's probably still better, but it would be far more effective if all drivers would actually cooperate.
- christoph-heiss 8y agoPretty much the rule in Austria too.
- bebna 8y agoStau is a bad example for most cases, but yes you will always get some who think they know better, even if they had to learn in the driving school that lane jumping makes it just slower for everyone.
- pnutjam 8y agoI think your wrong. You should switch to the faster lane, zipping should make both lanes the same when optimized.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoIn my experience, zipping as described here - when getting onto the highway - isn't done properly in NL. People still try and force themselves onto the highway or other lane as soon as possible. My colleague called it "eerste blokjesangst". Just keep going for a bit further, use the whole road, and make sure you're matching speed with the rest of traffic, instead of making them (unknowingly) slow down to let you in. Also keep in mind you ARE allowed to overtake slower traffic on the on-ramp, so if there's a truck there, just pass it on the right, then merge.
- nf05papsjfVbc 8y ago
- wil421 8y agoI’ve heard of the zipper merge in the US too, many cities and states recommend it. I much prefer the zipper merge and I’ve always done it before I knew the name. Some states are even putting up signs about it. Minnesota[1]. Other states[2]. My home town[3]. [1]https://www.dot.state.mn.us/zippermerge/ https://www.dot.state.mn.us/zippermerge/ [2]https://www.fleetowner.com/driver-management-resource-center/magic-and-mystery-zipper-merge https://www.fleetowner.com/driver-management-resource-center... [3]https://www.ajc.com/news/local/gridlock-guy-transportation-officials-urge-use-zipper-merge/BaKOEqwrhAD0597B5fSssM/ https://www.ajc.com/news/local/gridlock-guy-transportation-o...
- slantyyz 8y agoI think the problem with adoption has less to do with the theory of zipper merging working than local culture and traffic enforcement. I live in Ontario, Canada, and despite of our reputation for politeness, we have some of the worst/most selfish drivers anywhere. Part of this is because there doesn't appear (anecdotally) to be a lot of traffic enforcement, so people now push the limits as much as possible, whether it be texting while driving, running red lights, tailgating or merging improperly. The only way I could see this work where I live is if there's strict enforcement to ensure it happens, otherwise you'll see behaviours like people not letting in mergers, or a second car trying to squeeze in after the legit merger.
- NickBusey 8y agoThis has seemed so obvious to me forever, but I remember two instances very clearly that illustrate how much people generally hate it in the US. Once, (in Pennsylvania) there was construction coming up, with maybe still half a mile until the actual cones to merge. This one guy in a massive truck didn't like that people were using both lanes so he straddles his truck across both lanes causing no one to be able to pass on either side. Second, (in Colorado) there were signs that construction was coming up in a few miles, and the right lane would be closed. So, I was riding in the right lane, passing a massive line of cars in the left lane, getting flipped off the whole time, only to find out there was no closed lane. The signs just hadn't been taken down yet. So I was being flipped the bird because I was using a lane that was fully open. I think people just don't like feeling that other people are "getting ahead of them", in life in general, and especially in traffic.
- jimhefferon 8y agoWhere I live there is a very strong culture of politeness and kindness in driving. For instance, I often see (and do it myself) that someone has let a person in who is trying to pull out of a hard-to-leave business driveway, with no hope of reward, just out of a sense that other people have helped you out in the past so now it is your turn. In a recent construction on my way to work they put in two lanes where there was one, which must merge within a hundred yards to get over a narrow bridge. Filling both lanes and zipping would increase the capacity at that location, no doubt. But few drivers do it. Are others worried, as I am, that it would be part of a change in the overall driving culture, normalizing cutting ahead? That is, could zipping be a local optimization that leads to a global suboptimization, an overall decrease in how reasonable it is to drive around here?
- ojhughes 8y agoWow where is this place where drivers are courteous? It is the polar opposite in the UK, many drivers are selfish, aggressive and ignorant, especially around London & South East.
- jimhefferon 8y agoVermont USA
- dark_ph0enix 8y agoInteresting, cause living in the South East I mostly find drivers that are quite polite on the roads (giving way, respecting crossings, stopping traffic to allow you to merge into the main road, etc). I suppose it's a matter of expectations. Originally from Portugal so I'm used to seeing far worse people driving on the road.
- simonh 8y agoThat's not my feeling, I live in SE London and it's not that bad. There's just a lot of traffic, which makes it difficult and people can be pushy, but when I'm coming off a side road into a queue of traffic I'm usually let in OK and see the same courtesy given to others. Conversely my mother lives near Worcester, and up there some of the drivers are insane. Nipping the wrong way round a roundabout, dashing across junctions on red. It's like they don't understand the concept of other traffic or sometimes even have actual control over the vehicle. Not everyone obviously, but enough to make my hair stand on end more than just once or twice.
- Zardoz84 8y agoI never listen that this is a law here (Spain) or mandatory. But is what usually people done here.
- shiven 8y agoOnce self driving vehicles are the norm, such rules would become default.
- IshKebab 8y agoIn the UK I had someone almost try to crash into me when continued along a totally empty lane 200 yards before the merge point, while everyone else was queueing in one lane. So stupid. I actually think that roadworks people could fix this fairly simply though without requiring people to think. Instead of closing one lane and keeping the other open, close half of each lane - create a new single middle lane, then people won't be able to queue in the "right" lane. After everyone is in single file you can shift them wherever you want. Here's what I mean: https://imgur.com/a/rCw4vJ7 https://imgur.com/a/rCw4vJ7
- epanchin 8y agoI’ve also experienced this. I have also found that often on the motorway the lane isn’t really closed, so I have no intention of changing my behaviour.
- gvurrdon 8y agoBased on your description of the scenario I'd think the driver in question considered you a "queue jumper", and their fury at what they perceived as your objectionable driving would cause them to act unsafely. I see similar things from time to time on a road I use frequently. In cases where it's very busy and both lanes fill up then merging in turn tends to happen quite well, but when there's only moderate traffic and it's queuing in one lane then events such as that you describe may occur. Perhaps some signs saying "queue in both lanes" and "merge in turn" at the appropriate points on the road might improve things.
- sureaboutthis 8y agoSomewhat related, I wish people would learn that, when turning right or left onto a two or more lane road, you are to turn into the lane nearest you and never the far lane. This way, a car facing you can turn onto the same road at the same time.
- tssva 8y agoA US driver and it may not be the law but the zipper move is certainly the norm in my area. Again an article making a generalization about the US without recognizing how large it is and the vast differing cultural norms and laws between states and regions.
- gojomo 8y agoYour point about recognizing US regional variation would be stronger if you also identified the “my area” where you imply local practices may be better than other areas.
- noxToken 8y agoI've also had the pleasure of driving in multiple states. The zipper merges seems to be true everywhere that I've been. Even the purportedly terrible Orange County and LA drivers user zipper merging. The one thing that I have noticed is that people are more likely to do early merges and zipper merges together. Well, not the same person, but I may see it in the same area. The early mergers usually don't block traffic waiting for opening. It's usually that they see the gap in traffic and take it immediately.
- bagacrap 8y agoSouthern California drivers certainly aren't terrible, and if that's a reputation they carry among outsiders it's probably because they're more aggressive (efficient) and leave less space than those from parts of the country where real traffic doesn't exist.
- noxToken 8y agoThey absolutely aren't terrible. I do think some SoCal drivers can be a little over aggressive to the point where it is unsafe, and this tends happens with multiple lane changes to make an exit. No matter where you go, you'll have adrenaline junkies in coupes and on bikes weaving around cars, distracted drivers, rubberneckers, and fender-benders that refuse to move to the shoulder.
- alkonaut 8y agoI'm living temporarily in spain and notice something similar: they basically don't use the inner lane in roundabouts. So people go 3/4 of a lap on the outside lane which can be clogged while the inside is empty.
- dark_ph0enix 8y agoExactly the same problem in Portugal. People tend to stick to the outside lane as they feel that if they go on the inside lanes they won't have the opportunity to move to the outer lane when they are near their intended exit due to other cars being on the outer lane. IMO this stems from lack of education (driving lessons are not adequate) and the fact that everyone's looking after themselves (i.e not respect for other road users (which also explains the ludicrous speeds on the roads, road rage, queues, etc))
- oneeyedpigeon 8y agoI hate roundabouts, at least partly for this reason. Whenever I'm taking anything other than the first exit, I'm moving round just praying that no-one's going to join or drive up alongside me... (And don't get me started on driving lessons. Here, in the UK, they're an absolute joke!)
- sjwright 8y agoHence why spiral roundabouts exist. They effectively solve this problem. (And replace them with a bunch of others, but hey.) http://r-m-t.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2014/06/spirial-roundabout2.jpg http://r-m-t.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2014/06/spiri...
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoThere's some of those in NL as well; I haven't learned any rules of those, so I can't be sure I can leave the roundabout on my exit if I'm in the inner lane, or if there's someone doing more than one exit on the outer / rightmost lane, making me cut them off. This has caused me to shit a number of bricks in the UK, where two-lane roundabouts are a lot more common.
- Gasp0de 8y agoI get why zipping vs. early merging causes shorter traffic jams, but I don't get why it would be more efficient in terms of speed. If 50 cars can pass the bottleneck per minute, 1000 cars will always take 20 minutes, no matter if they cue in one or two lanes? Wether a jam is 1 or 2km in length only matters if there is an exit blocked by it, right?
- afaikilt 8y agoThe length of that q is halved, imho traffic issues are caused by one bottlenecks tailback into a junction or similar and creating a bottleneck elsewhere. its like bandwidth. you are keeping twice the bandwidth up until the last possible moment, meaning the bottle neck is going to be "fed" as efficiently as possible with half the chance of causing a knock on effect elsewhere. but this is not just a german thing.. in the UK there is a curved arrow sign on the road where one lane ends meaning "merge in turn" you will also see signs saying: "use both lanes" and "merge in turn" (but as text) which are all the same thing. you will often see it say after a junction or roundabout where maybe 200m later the road goes from two to one lanes. encouraging you not to just queue right through the previous junction and block that up too.
- stetrain 8y agoIt can help move traffic up to unblock exits further behind, which reduces congestion for those not actually travelling through the bottleneck. Once example I see often that is more length sensitive is dual left turn onto a highway onramp that merges to one lane before entering the highway. If people use both lanes equally all the way to the merge point you can fit more cars through each turn light cycle and then the merging process continues even when the light has changed. Often people merge early and leave room in one lane, which leaves some cars stuck on the other side of the traffic light who could have made it through.
- lqet 8y agoBecause a longer traffic jam propagates through the entire road network, possibly blocking earlier exits, making the entire network less efficient. I am German and can confirm that the zipper rule is holy here, but people often have problems following it, especially unexperienced drivers afraid of merging. Very often, there are additional signs to remind drivers of the rule [1][2][3]. [1] https://www.schilder-versand.com/assets/gfx/product/300x300/hinweistafel-rei%C3%9Fverschluss-variante-2-13925.jpg https://www.schilder-versand.com/assets/gfx/product/300x300/... [2] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/e/eb/Hinweiszeichen_23c.svg/800px-Hinweiszeichen_23c.svg.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/e/eb/Hi... [3] https://www.schilder-versand.com/assets/gfx/product/300x300/hinweistafel-rei%C3%9Fverschluss-variante-1-13924.jpg https://www.schilder-versand.com/assets/gfx/product/300x300/...
- ivanhoe 8y agoThis rule exists in many European countries, but afaik it only applies to situations when the lane is blocked or stops there, so all cars have to move into one lane. It's totally OK however to not let into the lane people who're using an empty lane on purpose to pass by others and jump the queue. If the car has the road in front of it to continue moving, so they don't need to switch the lanes, you don't have to let them in.
- lixtra 8y agoLeaving a blocked lane early reduces the storage capacity of the road. In slow traffic/traffic jams the rule is to use all lanes possible until very close to the blockage. If you break that rule the jam becomes longer and could affect a crossing upstream. Jumping the queue counters this negative effect and is the correct behavior (in slow traffic).
- floofy222 8y ago> t's totally OK however to not let into the lane people who're using an empty lane on purpose to pass by others and jump the queue In Germany, this behavior is explicitly forbidden by the law. If there is a merge, one car of each lane has to go through the merge each time. That is, if you are at the end of the lane that gets merged, and you let one car pass, then you have the right to go and merge next. The next car in the other lane must yield, if they don't and there is a crash, it's 100% their fault. This is so that the lanes that merge get used to their maximum capacity. If the intent were for cars to merge earlier, they would just have made these lanes shorter.
- ivanhoe 8y agoAbsolutely, but only if there's a merge of lanes. If this is just the empty lane that people use to get to the front of the queue, like when there's a traffic jam to enter the highway and some cars are trying to cut the line, then you don't have to let them. I'm aware that this is not a common problem in normal countries like Germany where drivers generally behave well, but if you ever find yourself waiting in a line somewhere in Italy or say in Balkans, you'll often see cars trying to push past you by cutting the queue using empty and service lanes.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Allower 8y agoAs a 13 year old this was obvious to me. Wtf is wrong with human beings? American's in particular are extra retarded
- bauc 8y agoIt's funny that the article states it doesn't happen in the UK, but according to the highway code you are are supposed to. Many people seem disagree with that and like to queue but should read their highway code https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/advice/driving-advice/zip-merging/ https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/advice/driving-advice/zip-mergin...
- ChrisRR 8y agoThat's what I was confused about. The article says we don't do it in the UK but then describes what we call "merge in turn"
- bauc 8y agoYes, but I can believe people not seeing it being applied. A lot of people don't like it for whatever reason. Only ignoring it seems to create (or worsen) the problem in the first place
- tomatocracy 8y agoAt least on motorways, this is because more often than not you will be going too fast to do this safely by the time you run out of lane. Most drivers will be conditioned by that experience to expect it unless they can see evidence to the contrary. This is also why the signs indicating lane closures will usually be half a mile or more before the actual closure. When the traffic is slow moving to start with people do tend to merge in turn.
- toastermoster 8y agoI've always thought this would be best. I recently saw signs instructing people to wait to merge in Duluth MN when I was visiting for work. People weren't abiding by the signs though and continued to behave in the normal random way they typically do when merging.
- seniorsassycat 8y agoIf the culture is early merge and you choose to late merge you will be skipping the line and people will resent you for it. If I see an opertunity to late merge I will often choose to stay in the late merge lane, but match speed with the traffic in the early merge lane, then zipper when I have to. People notice that I haven't cut anyone off or skipped the line, and people usually fill in behind me and I'm able to transform an early merge queue into a late merge queue. You shouldn't late merge if it blocks a thruway. If a single lane highway has a backed up exit ramp then exiters should join the queue as soon as possible instead of late merging and blocking the highway.
- mark-r 8y agoI see a lot of talk of fairness to justify the urge to merge early. This is ironic since zipper merge is the fairest of all, if you can only get everybody to adhere to it. Nobody can get ahead if both lanes are full and moving at the same speed.