9 ms·
Forget privacy: you're terrible at targeting anyway
- buboard 8y agoWhat a wonderful article. I like the part where you don't need to rely on too much data to be good at something. Same goes for science in general. You dont need a million of experiments to do something great, you need ingenuity.
- anonytrary 8y agoIngenuity gets you from 0% to 90%. Millions of dollars and little experiments gets you from 90% to 99%. All of the money in the world won't get you from 99% to 100%.
- endofcapital 8y agoThe only social networking I do anymore is twitter. The list of the thousand people I follow is so intimate, I feel like just flipping through that would reveal everything about me and be a huge violation of privacy. But even on this platform I've spent almost 10 years curating the perfect feed on, the one that should know absolutely everything about me, I still get served endless garbage ads for junk food and pickup trucks. I can't think of two products I care about less. Amazon is a similar story, they seem convinced that I'm a woman despite having some pretty detailed purchase history going back to 1998 suggesting otherwise. The targeting algorithm is often wrong, they just don't seem to know it be willing to admit it.
- AnimalMuppet 8y ago> The targeting algorithm is often wrong, they just don't seem to know it be willing to admit it. It doesn't matter if their targeting algorithm is wrong. It just has to be 1) better than random and 2) not significantly worse than anyone else's. In fact, even that isn't necessary. It just has to be perceived as those two things by those who are willing to give Google or Amazon money to try to improve their chances of selling you stuff.
- mhb 8y agoWouldn't Google and Amazon rather have more money for effectively targeted ads?
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoIt's a continuum. Better targeted ads are worth more than less-well-targeted ads. They do the best they can, and they keep trying to get better. Their targeting may be lousy, but it's still good enough for them to get paid.
- meditate 8y agoI think it's a common misconception that "the algorithm" is responsible for this, when what is actually happening is that an advertiser is bidding on the wrong users and effectively buying bad ads.
- pdkl95 8y agoI think it's a common misconception that "targeted" advertising in any way involves the ad viewer's interests. Showing you only ads for things you are interested in was never a goal. The advertiser targets who should see the ad, which may or may not match what the viewer's interests. Advertising junk food and pickup trucks to someone that "can't think of two products I care about less" isn't an error. It's an attempt to make you care (if possible), and reinforce the brand so their name is familiar= if opinions change about junk food or pickup trucks in the future.
- abrichr 8y agoFascinating, thank you! Where can I read more about this?
- justapassenger 8y agoGoogle “purchase funnel”. It’s 101 in ads business.
- ffilipa 8y agoMore like the advertisers who could cater to a person’s interest are not able to locate the individual. Because the platform knows ads can be creepy, and will result in user disengagement. Facebook often accurately targets people, and the result is terrified users. So, the answer is other platforms have taken note, and are providing cover for users, to retain them. This augments the return on ad spend, but only slightly, since ads actually aren’t very effective in practice. Ads are simply signage, nothing more. They don’t actually change behavior, but only reorganize behavior that usually would have happened anyway, so that the existing outcomes possibly land in the finite set of buckets differently. Thus ad platforms only need to target so vigorously, and with that, it becomes obvious that targeting can be made less acurate, and buyers of ad space would never know. So you can quickly see that Facebook’s game is absolute overkill, and other players likely underkill by a margin, with much improvement to their platform reputation.
- nameisu 8y agoamazon knows you are getting a sex change
- barbecue_sauce 8y agoEvery time I get a Spanish-language ad on Spotify or YouTube, I take solace in the fact that the algorithms have not yet won.
- nraynaud 8y agoI get spanish language from the credit card machine at the supermarket, it’s written in the card that it is French.
- manigandham 8y ago95% of ads are not using targeting based on your personal interests. Advertisers don't just upload ads and let them go. They add the targeting themselves and start wide open so that they can optimize after seeing the actual performance amongst different groups and cohorts. Far cheaper and more effective. Ad networks might add their own algorithms but they definitely aren't going to stop advertisers from spending money otherwise.
- Mirioron 8y agoAre you sure that it's the algorithm that's wrong or could it instead be that the people who buy ads target the wrong categories? If I want to target 18-25 year old males with make-up products then no algorithm is going to save me from myself.
- futurix 8y agoYour example might be seen as an advertiser trying to capture a nascent market (which it actually seems to be).
- nitwit005 8y agoSimple test: Google "wedding ring", click the top 10 links and browse around each a bit. You'll see the ads on a lot of the web change. I'm sure if your Twitter feed was full of automotive posts you'd see car ads. It's probably full of stuff no advertiser cares about, like your love of old British railway cars, so instead you get generic ads about spicy nacho cheese.
- hakfoo 8y ago>It's probably full of stuff no advertiser cares about, like your love of old British railway cars As a railway enthusiast myself, I would say that's actually an opportunity for very effective targeted marketing: * There are loads of specialized reference and historic books and video on the subject. * The crossover interest to model railways, a hobby involving many high-margin purchases, is very high. * Many enthusiasts literally plan their vacations around preservation railways and museums. Everyone from the tourist-railpass sellers to full-fledged package tour operators should be targeting them. If that interest is not well advertised to, it's either because they're doing a poor job identifying the interest and routing it to advertisers, or they've done a terrible job of fostering ad buyers in those verticals.
- nitwit005 8y agoWhile, yes, it's theoretically possible, there must exist some company paying Twitter to sell one of those products, and who wants it specifically targeted to the group.
- intopieces 8y agoThe last time I was on Facebook (2015) I accidentally logged on without an ad-blocker. The best it could come up with was a package discount on gay scuba diving. I admit I was intrigued, but I did not click, simply because I could not discern what the product actually was.
- fiddlerwoaroof 8y agoInteresting, Facebook ads are the only ones I’ve ever clicked through and then purchased the advertised item.
- westmeal 8y agoNow I've heard everything
- StavrosK 8y agoWhat is happening? Are we tacking sexual orientation onto random activities now? What's next? Bisexual solitaire? Straight geology? Drag racing?
- viraptor 8y agoMaybe they are advertising that as a meeting / dating activity specifically. We've got lots of themed speed-dating events already which have the sexual orientation tacked onto them implicitly. You'd just expect the default for "gardening speed dating" to be straight.
- nraynaud 8y agoNope, couple activities for gay men only. Because men have a higher salary and gays probably have no kids. Now you have a high chance of big money target with a clear differentiator.
- flomo 8y agoHad a similar experience a few years ago. I cleared cookies and visited YouTube a couple days later. It showed me an advert for an oven starring Florence Henderson (Brady Bunch mom), who died not long afterwards. Google has all this data on me, but you take away their cookies once in a while, and they think you are a housewife.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoHonestly, Instagram is pretty spot on with their ads for me. I've always taken pride, like I think most tech nerds of being "ad resistant." However I've probably bought more stuff as a direct result of ad exposure on Instagram (3 things in three years) than in the entirety of the 25 years I've been on the internet.
- qazwse_ 8y agoSame for me. It may be because Instagram lends itself to "life style" follows? In my case, I'm interested in climbing, and because brands actually post interesting content, I'll follow them. Do this over a few categories of interests and it may result in Instagram having a better understanding of my interests/things I'll care about.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI have never bought anything from an ad. One time I saw an ad for something that seemed very relevant but I had already clicked on the next link and when I navigated back the site showed something different :-(
- manigandham 8y agoThose are not the only ads that exist, nor do you need to click on them to be influenced. Everyone who thinks this way is usually incredibly susceptible to advertising, you just don't see it.
- maxxxxx 8y agoAgreed. Just seeing or hearing a brand name repeatedly makes it more trustworthy.
- tzs 8y agoThat happens a lot with me. I'll be reading a multi-page article at a site, get to the bottom of the page, click the button or link to go to the next page, and only then, since I'm not busy reading the page content anymore, notice the ad. Just as I'm realizing that it is something I'm quite interested in and want to click it for more information, the next page loads and I've lost the ad. It's quite annoying.
- j0e1 8y agoUser data has become a currency that has intrinsic value without having to prove itself in any way. Not sure how long this is going to last but I suspect as long as there is this feeling of 'potential' in tracked data, it is always going to sell. On the other hand, the existence of pervasive tracking especially those done unethically, exposes people to a new attack surface that not only malicious (in the traditional sense) actors but govts. are prone to exploiting.
- jiveturkey 8y ago> This is, by the way, the dirty secret of the machine learning movement: almost everything produced by ML could have been produced, more cheaply, using a very dumb heuristic you coded up by hand lol, too true
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoThe point of ad targeting isn't to generate relevant ads. It's so the advertising platform can put you in a more expensive targeting cohort, increasing the revenue from serving the ad. The "optimal" bid for serving you an ad to your cohort is proportional to the product of expected relevance and the revenue per conversion. If a programming placement firm makes $100 per lead (after various filter steps) on your targeting info, and a witty t-shirt makes $10, your cohort has to convert ten times as often on t-shirts to match the recruiting firm's ad bids.
- zozbot123 8y agoThis seems fallacious. The whole reason for that "more expensive targeting cohort" becoming available after tracking is its increased relevance. Otherwise, everyone would be getting the $100 ad in the first place-- the $10 ad would simply be uncompetitive!
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoI'm not saying relevance is meaningless. I'm saying it's scaled by the profitability of a conversion as well. This business logic works on traditional non-targeted ads as well, like on broadcast TV. For example, do you remember seeing ads along the lines of "if you or a loved one has been diagnosed with mesothelioma, call the law offices of such and so"? Mesothelioma affects less than 30 people per million. Why run an ad that so few people care about? Because the payoff is so high for reaching the people that do care, and the higher the payoff, the less people have to care for the ad campaign to be worthwhile.
- yellowapple 8y agoA-fucking-men. YouTube's recommendations are effectively worthless to me because they're full of garbage I'll never watch instead of videos actually relevant to the one I'm watching (no, YouTube, just because I watched an antivax conspiracy video because it was linked on reddit and I want to laugh at it doesn't mean it's something I want to watch every day after watching entirely-unrelated things). On another note: "But everyone sucks, except Pandora." No, they suck, too. Thumb-up one song and it'll commandeer the station. Half the songs are live recordings (and I haven't checked if they finally added the option to exclude them, but given that it hadn't been added many years after the original feature suggestion by the time I switched to Spotify, I don't have high hopes); thumbing down said live recordings doesn't actually stop them from showing up (in fact, my "fuck this, I'm switching to Spotify" moment was when Pandora queued up three live recordings in a row, all of which I thumbed down, then on the fourth in a row wouldn't let me thumb it down because I had too many "skips" today). Fuck Pandora. Spotify's radio feature is just as good (which ain't saying much, but it doesn't bombard me with live recordings, so that's a start), and of course Spotify supports use-cases besides procedurally-generated radio stations. Way more useful.
- _bxg1 8y agoI've used Pandora for nearly a decade. For half of that time, I've also kept a subscription to an on-demand music streaming service. But I always kept using Pandora for the auto-stations.
- doublekill 8y agoAdvertising was not made for OP. It was made for people who do not see the difference between ads and search results. It was made for people who impulse buy to improve their mood. For people who care about pictures, not stats. Personalization tech for ad tech is top of the line. Really pushing that part of ML forward. It drives the internet with billions worth of profit. Ad tech companies can know more about you than intelligence agencies, and sometimes they are one and the same. Targeting is changing how people vote. It is influencing social mobility. It can turn startups into money printing machines. It is not something you can debunk in a single blogpost, just because it does not apply to you. You are the vocal minority.
- prophesi 8y agoI wouldn't say OP is a vocal minority; certainly you've heard your non-techie friends talk about the ridiculous recommendations these algorithms have wrought. I'd like to think that this is the majority, and the minority who can't tell an ad from their search query would make those impulse purchases even without ML. You're just swapping out their random impulse purchase with a different impulse purchase, and neither side knows why they met. The key point in this blog post, I think, is the ineptitude of ML algorithms.
- princeofwands 8y ago> the ineptitude of ML algorithms. Computer vision can show greater-than-estimated-human-performance, while still failing hilariously unhuman once in a while. People remember the 1 in a 1000 wonky recommendation that made them do a double-take. Recommendation engines work best for the mean and stereotypical person. That way, you can use information of similar profitable people to effectively recommend. Facebook, for instance, got mined for "suckers". If you are scummy, you want a list of gullible people who click the most stupidest, poorly designed, and shady ads. Ad tech knows where they are and delivers them on a silver platter. Going back 2 decades to serving ads without ML would kill a business. You don't think they thoroughly test a new recommendation engine and see relevant stats go up before they deploy it? You don't think they can serve you more relevant ads when they know you are a 17 year old male vs. a 42 year old woman? Both the data gathering and the algorithms have improved year over year. To say ad tech personalization is terrible, is akin to complaining we don't have AGI.
- ltr_ 8y agoI'm poor so no ad is for me. plus I have an ad block in every browser. also I'm kind of ad blind
- _bxg1 8y agoWeirdly comforting.
- andrewflnr 8y agoIt's a long series of epic burns somehow delivered in a calm style. It offers peaceful resignation with a world of insanity. Or something like that. I see what you mean, though.
- _bxg1 8y agoI meant because it suggests an eventual end to the world of insanity, when all the emperors realize they don't have any clothes
- andrewflnr 8y agoOk, I guess I didn't see what you mean. :)
- manigandham 8y ago1. Targeting is rarely as sophisticated as you think. Many campaigns are run wide and cheap (all users in a region, maybe some particular hours, etc). It's easier to optimize after this initial run based on actual performance rather than trying to figure out the exact people who would respond. 2. Some companies are also taking ad auction bidding in-house and running their own algorithms with their 1st party data, like upselling their own customers. This doesn't need any relevance matching since they know exactly who they're going after. 3. Targeting is not free. There is a continuum of price vs precision and high precision is rarely worth the costs, especially if the product itself cannot support those margins. Again this is why optimizing after a wide start is better than targeting upfront, and also why if you're trying to reach a very narrow audience it's easier to just send them email, or even direct mail. 4. People only notice the bad ads, not the good ones which they like or are influenced by. This is no different than complaining about bad CGI in movies when your average sitcom is 50% artificial but nobody notices because it just works. 5. Recommending movies as entertainment with cost in a subscription plan is nothing like finding relevant ads on the internet. 6. The adtech industry has 2 of the most valuable companies in the world and generates petabytes of data and billions in profit proving how well ads work. A random blog post by an outsider who has no idea how the industry works but claims it's all broken in direct contradiction to the data just comes across the same as a flat-earth conspiracy theorist.
- ghthor 8y agoI think it's a little harsh to relate this to someone who thinks the earth is flat.
- askafriend 8y agoNo, I think it's actually pretty spot on. A flat earth makes sense if you only spent 5 minutes thinking about it and have no background in or exposure to basic science. Similar to this blog post. It makes sense if you read it, think about it for 5 minutes, and have no background in the advertising industry or the dynamics of effective/efficient advertising. Not to mention that advertising and content recommendation engines for a paid service are each wildly different in their underlying dynamics and economics. But who cares about nuance anyway.
- jtms 8y agoOP is my spirit animal
- rjf72 8y agoA major issue this does not consider is that ads which are too accurate are often deemed 'creepy'. Turns out there was some recent research on this topic [1]. In another thread on digital advertising a user shared an anecdote of a company that met with poor response after targeting locals who were pregnant with new baby related promotions. But after masking the promotion in a packet of otherwise unrelated offers, it met with much better results. Another thing here is that this information isn't going anywhere. All the information that you give up to companies can be exploited at their whim and to whatever end they choose. In this regard I think Cambridge Analytica was a really great thing. They were, all things considered, probably a very small player. But for people to realize that their personal information could be used for more than to try to sell them crap was an important lesson. There are also things like the NSA who are now hoovering up immense amounts of information, facilitated by participating companies including Apple, Microsoft, and Google. Recent issues should show the problem here. The NSA is not immune to hiring people they should not (from their perspective) hire. Their secret tools get leaked. They themselves get hacked. And now there is this immense trove of potentially sensitive information that they're sitting on. That data is going to eventually end up in the wrong hands. It's also not out of the question that the NSA themselves eventually end up being the wrong hands. Without invoking Godwin's law here, it should suffice to say that bad people can get into positions of power and do very bad things. Pair this with profiles on everybody in the nation, and increasingly even the world, and it opens the door to some really catastrophic scenarios in the future. So no, don't forget privacy. [1] - https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/04/150408171201.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/04/150408171201.h...
- 3xblah 8y agoIf I understand this correctly he is saying that much of the private information collected is actually not needed in order to achieve the desired outcome ("everybody wins"). He points out that tracking companies pay websites to allow them to collect this information, but (through examples) he argues that companies do not actually need the information that is being collected. This begs some questions: Do these tracking companies remain solvent? Who is buying the information they collect? Are the buyers happy with the product/service? Is their usage of the data effective or just experimental? I am willing to bet those tracking companies are operating based solely on investments, not licensing/sales of the data. That is, their future is uncertain. We cannot put the genie back in the bottle. Whether or not the data works for the purposes it was collected, copies of the data will still exist. If the tracking companies fail, who gets the data then? An ongoing effort will continue in trying to find a use for all this collected personal information by whomever shall come into possession of it. How do you all think that will turn out? Should there be more regulation on how that data can be used? BTW, another nice bit of work from this author which only got two points when it was posted on HN a few weeks ago: https://redo.readthedocs.io/en/latest/cookbook/container/ https://redo.readthedocs.io/en/latest/cookbook/container/
- aquarin 8y agoI am guessing the targeting can be done better. The problem is, there is more products supply than eyes demand. As a result, the companies have to push down the throat products, even if they don’t match users' preferences.
- cortic 8y ago>Let's be clear: the best targeted ads I will ever see are the ones I get from a search engine when it serves an ad for exactly the thing I was searching for....I don't know anybody who complains about this sort of ad. This has actually nerfed search engines in my lifetime. It used to be a crawler returned as much as it could and you could search through the results; Now i get to only search through the big players who pay for their rankings. >Never give positive feedback to an AI. Funny; i wonder how Google profiling handles me occasionally using Google as a spell check.
- ilovetux 8y ago> using Google as a spell check. I do that all the time!
- arkitaip 8y agoSame here. I sometimes use incognito mode if the spellchecking is... off pattern.
- cortic 8y agoI sometimes blank on words that sound the same, like typing through when i mean threw, and of course google won't correct it unless its in context, so i type something like 'i through a bomb' which corrects to threw, i know I'm on a watch list somewhere.
- lordnacho 8y agoI've noticed this with recommendations, too. Something about it seems off. I'll watch a documentary about World War II, and then next thing you know it's recommending another 50 hours of Hitler and Nazi stuff. Or other war documentaries. Medium is similar, too. I read a couple of articles about cryptocurrency, and then there's nothing but crypto articles. I ended up having to actively find a bunch of stuff to follow to get some variety. I thought one of the key ideas in stats and ML was intelligent sampling? That would suggest you should sometimes throw in something the person hasn't expressed interest in, just to see if maybe you're on a local minimum. But I rarely see that. I often wonder if it would be smarter for Netflix to just hire a guy who watches a lot of content, and he can just tell you what's similar to what.
- kgwxd 8y ago"Targeted ads" is just a euphemism for "tracking". The not-so-threatening term allows the practice to exist in the first place. It may have been the initial plan, and the promise made some people a lot of money, but ads are no longer the primary goal or the only way the data is monetized. We should be using the term "trackers" when talking about targeted ads, it's more accurate and sounds scarier.
- nsnfkdjsnbf 8y agoSo when Zuckerberg says users want targeted ads, he actually meant users like being tracked.
- kgwxd 8y agoWell, really he's just spewing bullshit to avoid directly stating Facbook tracks people all over the internet and will monetize the collected data in any way possible.
- smsm42 8y ago> the job of most modern recommendation algorithms is to return the closest thing to porn that is still Safe For Work Loved this part. About 99% accurate for "read this next" suggestions I've seen.