4 ms·
Canada recently made a trade deal with the EU as well. Our country (Canada) hasn't been pushing harder enough for this IMO, considering how greatly we benefitt
by dmix 8y ago
Canada recently made a trade deal with the EU as well.
Our country (Canada) hasn't been pushing harder enough for this IMO, considering how greatly we benefitted from NAFTA it should have been our top policy objective for the last couple decades.
Modern countries would rather get lost in decades long mega-deals with 1000 conditions for every political crony connection / special-interest group ever than get an actual real "free trade" deal done.
There are still so many things that are ridiculously expensive in Canada for no rational (long term) benefit to either party assuming it was a real market. When you could drive an hour south to the US and get countless things for 25% cheaper (clothes, shoes, cars, etc) not to mention the lack of access to media (streaming sites) and sports blackout contracts.
- annapurna 8y ago>There are still so many things that are ridiculously expensive in Canada for no rational (long term) benefit to either party assuming it was a real market. I cannot find the link but no surprises when there was a report (from one of the EU organizations) that we pay the highest cell phone fees.
- dmix 8y agoThe high cellphone + ISP fees in Canada are a result of the monopoly the ~2-3 telecom companies were given by government a few decades back to "accelerate" broadband and mobile infrastructure development. The only positive tradeoff we've gotten out of decades of paying 25-50% more per month than most countries is that our networks have been cutting edge. We got 3g, 4g, etc before almost everyone. But I don't attribute this to the gov, their investment was long ago, but rather the competence of executives being smart enough to maintain their monopoly without falling into the trap of falling behind as many monopolies do before being trumped by economic progress/tech (ie, see the taxi monopoly lack of tech investment before Uber/Lyft), and via the massive margins they get out of their monopoly pricing providing plenty of capital investment to prevent any sort of competition.
- matt4077 8y agoI doubt there are many countries with more than two or three competing networks. There may be a few more resellers, or even several dozens. But it’s just uneconomical to build the hardware five times over. In any case, a FTA is not going to change it.
- dmix 8y agoSo how does that explain the high cost of our networks vs other countries? I'm not convinced a regulated oligopoly is the only positive option. If anything it's only positive for: a) the private friends of government who profited when the business was kept 100% Canadian b) the intelligence agencies who were given plenty of access. Most of the ownership capital went to a small group of millionaires and billionaires. Meanwhile the jobs/network/other taxable services would still exist in Canada regardless of the nationality of the original investors. Plus the wireless networks continue to be very closely controlled in these companies favour. They only recently allowed a single competitor into the marketplace in Canada, Freedom Mobile, and they have the best pricing with tons of data. The main monopolies still have nothing comparable price-wise - their only edge remains their network investment which will diminish over time absent more gov intervention. But even getting Freedom Mobile, which had plenty of foreign investors, to be a thing was a huge controversial, challenging, multi-year deal, which was extremely risky for its investors because the Canadian regulatory agencies were very close to nipping the deal under extreme political pressure from the entrenched companies. How exactly do we as citizens benefit from this?
- IfOnlyYouKnew 8y agoI don’t know.. Maybe Canada requires these networks to serve even the rural parts of the country? That would seem to be expensive. Or they charged extremely high license fees. Those work like a tax, making the specific service more expensive, but allowing for government services or lowering your other taxes. In any case, it seems like you are maybe focusing too much on conspiratorial explanations like corruption and sourveillance. I know it’s easy and somewhat satisfying to immediately assume bad faith, but if you always assume the worst, that is what you will end up with. Because if honest politicians trying to balance the complex and competing interests of a modern society somewhat fairly, and then get spit in the face whenever they meet someone in the streets, soon you will have driven out the honest ones, or their will to remain honest. Because why bother, when the reaction is completely disconnected from your accruing, anyway?
- sonnyblarney 8y ago80% of CDN exports go to the US and so a deal with the EU won't be creating that much value. We trade a lot with China otherwise. "There are still so many things that are ridiculously expensive in Canada for no rational (long term) benefit to either party assuming it was a real market" This is because Canada has what some might describe as an inefficient economy, ruled by a small cabal of oligarchic players. We have maybe 6-7 banks nationally, each with a different coloured logo, but with the exact same services! There are other reasons of course. Also, Canadian national policy has always been about 'peace and stability' over market ambitions, so 'somewhat higher pr ices might literally be the price we pay for that.
- xxpor 8y ago>80% of CDN exports go to the US and so a deal with the EU won't be creating that much value Yeah, but what about after the deal? It makes sense that pre-free trade, there wouldn't be as much business.
- jammygit 8y agoCanada is sort-of not allowed to enter into trade deals without the USAs permission now... so its hard now. I'm worried about Canada being so easy to bully lately. I think the best defence is to get stronger economically, but all our tech talent is going south (Note: kicked out of NAFTA if WD 'disobey') https://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/canada-usmca-1.4845494 https://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/canada-usmca-1.4845494