3 ms·
> It's not clear that even reputed newspapers like NYTimes/WaPo produce quality content consistently. Example: Washington Post pushed the "Covington boys surro
by nailer 8y ago
> It's not clear that even reputed newspapers like NYTimes/WaPo produce quality content consistently.
Example: Washington Post pushed the "Covington boys surround and intimidate native man" narrative that's been completely shattered by about 200 hours of video footage in the last week, and led to Twitter disabling the account that spread it, refutations (oddly enough from the NYT) and various apologies from those who came after the child on question.
- Dylan16807 8y agoExample: The narrative in many news outlets that the Covington students were doing nothing wrong. Quote: "It’s not rape if you enjoy it." for example why that's not right.
- nailer 8y agoDo you know what whataboutism is?
- Dylan16807 8y agoIn many cases it's the same news organizations getting the story wrong both ways. It's a very interesting case study in bias. (and the power of PR firms) Also I don't see how it's whataboutism when I'm agreeing with the general thesis.
- nailer 8y agoCool. I thought you were saying that it's OK to lie about bad people but you're not. Totally support reporting on anything that happened (and yes a kid said this) Edit: it's not me modding you down, I think your second post was quite reasonable. I wish HN didn't downvote civil discussion like this.
- TarpitCarnivore 8y agoThat story is a perfect example of perception of a situation and how people view it in many ways. While you say the narrative is wrong, many feel the narrative was right.
- nailer 8y agoNo. Not at all. Either the children surrounded the man and one boy stood threateningly close (as the Washington Post reorted at https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/01/20/it-was-getting-ugly-native-american-drummer-speaks-maga-hat-wearing-teens-who-surrounded-him/?noredirect=on https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/01/20/it-was-gett...), or this did not happen. As it turns out (Bari Weiss at the NYT viewed over 200 hours of footage) this did not happen. The man moved into the middle of the boys and stood very close to one of them. You can watch this from multiple angles and multiple cameras on YouTube and confirm this for yourself. David Brooks in the NYT also has an excellent summary: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/21/opinion/covington-march-for-life.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/21/opinion/covington-march-f... Reality is not a matter of perception.
- TarpitCarnivore 8y agoI am not disputing the moments before and during. There is no doubt the events going on were a powder keg of problems waiting to tip off. However my comment was about how that actual scene can be viewed differently by people, and is exactly what is happening. This is not a matter of scientific facts being disputed, it's an interpretation of a real life event that took place. Too many people, the scene of 30-40 boys yelling and acting how they did invoked a sense of fear and intimidation to them. Too many others, it was just 'boys being boys'. The other reason people are so miffed over this is because of the actual people in it and the narrative. For one, a boys family had the means to hire a PR firm to help with the ordeal (again, a place of privilege). And two, there is so much hand wringing over this boy and this event, but for some reason when many young men have been shot or hurt by cops it's often met with negative depictions of the person hurt. You can call this whataboutism all you want, but that's the reality of it. Why in this instance where a boy and his group of friends, that are clearing acting up and provoking others (not even touching the negative nature of their hats), are given a free ride as 'boys being boys' but yet we chastise people who get in trouble with cops? Aren't those same people "just being boys"?
- nailer 8y ago> I am not disputing the moments before and during. You mentioned a fact was a matter of people interpreting a narrative. "While you say the narrative is wrong, many feel the narrative was right." That is not how facts work. > There is no doubt the events going on were a powder keg of problems waiting to tip off. Nobody is discussing whether there were "many problems". We are debating whether children surrounded and intimidated an old man as reported by the Washington Post. We are doing so because WaPo was cited as an example of 'real news'. That did not happen. WaPo was wrong. > This is not a matter of scientific facts being disputed Do you think the boys surrounded and intimated the old man? You keep discussing unrelated issues without specifically answering whether you believe this happened or did not happen.